Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Prototypes for the stools

Posts

Prototypes for the stools

#1

Prototypes for the stools

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The stool is 26" high, and the seat is 14 1/2" wide and 12" deep. Eventually, the three counter stools planned for the kitchen will have a Black Walnut seat and Hard Maple legs.

The prototype is incomplete - missing the stretchers. These are planned to span between the legs, in other words, there will be three stretches (ala Esherick). They are not added in these photos since I was experimenting with the number of legs (and there is a limit to the number of holes one can drill before everything just looks like Swiss cheese!).

The model was made from Radiata Pine. That is OK-ish for the seat, but a word of warning - it is horrible for legs. The wood is soft like tissue paper and fragile. I would have liked the legs to be a snitch thinner. That will be possible with the Maple.

The seat received 8 tapered mortices: 5 at the front and 3 at the rear. I played around with the placement of legs - 2 at the front and 2 at the rear, legs in line and legs wider at the front, 1 leg at the front and 1 leg at the rear. At the end it came down to four legs vs 3 legs.

I showed the four-legged version to my wife first ...




Then I showed her the three-legged version ...




What do you think she preferred?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#2

Re: Prototypes for the stools

roger lance

4 legged.....

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#3

Re: Prototypes for the stools

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

3 legged :)

Wiley

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#4

Leg placement

Patrick Chase

Do you have room to move the rear leg of the 3-legged configuration back a bit, perhaps the same distance from the edge of the seat as the rear legs in the 4-legged design?

The reason I ask is because the zone of stability (the set of places that people can rest their weight without tipping) seems perilously small with the rear leg tucked under like that. For example it looks to me as though somebody could tip it over by shifting their weight directly over either of the holes for the 4-leg configuration.

More generally, of you draw diagonals on the floor between the front legs and the rear, then those define the places where users can rest their weight and not tip over. I think that if you do that you'll see that a fair bit of each of the rear seat corner is outside of those diagonals, meaning that if a user somehow manages to center their weight on those parts of the seat then over they go. It's unavoidable to have some exposure like that in a 3-legged design, but this seems to be too much to me.

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#5

Ellis Walentine

Re: Prototypes for the stools

Ellis Walentine

Interesting question, Derek. Of course I can't guess how your wife feels about this, but tipping points have interested me ever since I built my first cobbler's bench over 50 years ago. I've observed that splaying the legs of a piece of furniture makes it much more difficult to tip. In the case of this stool exercise, each of the legs individually is angled outward at perhaps a 10 degree angle, which looks like a pretty reliable angle to prevent tipping. But, on a three-legged stool, there's some three-dimensional geometry going on that makes the net angle between the plane of any two legs and the floor less than the individual leg angles, so the resistance to tipping might be less than you expect. Clearly, a working prototype would be the most empirical way to assure yourself that your chosen configuration is viable.

Ellis

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#6

Re: Prototypes for the stools

david weaver

Much prefer the look of the three-legged stool. If I missed which your wife prefers, my apologies, but hopefully it's the three-legged version.

I'd build that one, and if it proves to be dangerous, you could always build four-legged versions.

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#7

Re: Prototypes for the stools

Philip Duffy

Derek, May I offer the thought that creating a pommel in the front and scooping the "cheeks" of the seat would enhance the comfort of the lady? The rear leg design is more traditional and very stable but the leg might be offered an additional 1-2 degree additional angle so as to put the weight of the passenger more at ease against a counter/bar?

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#8

Re: Prototypes for the stools

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, May I offer the thought that creating a pommel in the front and scooping the "cheeks" of the seat would enhance the comfort of the lady? The rear leg design is more traditional and very stable but the leg might be offered an additional 1-2 degree additional angle so as to put the weight of the passenger more at ease against a counter/bar?

Hi Philip

Why does a pommel make the seat more comfortable? I've spent some time thinking about this and playing with shapes. I have seen many, many pictures of seats, and many have pommels. I begin to wonder whether they were added because others add them ... or whether there is a real reason to do so.

This is a new area for me, and I am trying not to re-invent the wheel. Just trying to separate out what is tried-and-true and what is not. So, how did the pommel originate? Is it the result of excavating for the thighs? That is, by craving away the area for thighs on a Windsor, the centre section automatically forms a pommel. If so, the more important design element is a curve for the thigh. In this area I carved a lower section (the surface of the seat is a more complex set of hollows that is seen in the photos). That opens the door to removing some clutter. On a small area, such as a stool seat, I find the pommel very busy. Larger Windsor chairs are another matter.

With regard the comment that "the rear leg is more traditional", I am not sure whether you are referring to one or two legs. Can you say more about this?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#9

Re: Prototypes for the stools

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ellis, you have a very good eye. The legs at the front are indeed splayed and raked at 10 degrees. The rear leg is more than that.

I took photos of the drilling and reaming, but could not find them at the time of posting, and so omitted discussion of this at this time. I will find and post them as it includes a comparison of the 6 degree (closer to 7 degree in my case) reamer I made based on the one of Pete Galbert, and the 12 degree reamer made by Veritas.

The experimentation of 3- vs 4- legs, and their splay/rake is all about form and function together. It would be so much easier if I could simply sign up for and attend a chair and stool making workshop, but there is nothing like this around these parts.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#10

Re: Prototypes for the stools

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

My wife prefers the 3-legged version as it has a sleeker line. The 4-leg version I showed was an attempt to create this look by placing the rear legs closer together than the front legs (or the front legs wider apart than the rear legs). The 3 legs still carried the day. So three legs it is. It seems pretty stable, but now I shall finish the prototype stool and test it for real.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Prototypes for the stools

#11

Re: Prototypes for the stools

david weaver

3 legged stools were common in my childhood (because nobody throws anything away where I came from, and they also figure safety is half device-related and half user-related).

I often remember being told "that's a three legged stool - sit on it and don't tip it", and never fell off of one. I have managed to tip a 5-footed desk chair, though :\

Looks win out if there isn't a huge reason for them not to, and 3 legged stools just look far better. Your wife has a good eye!

A four-legged stool looks amish to me (I say that because the Amish often make something that looks almost like a style, but it's compromised for safety or comfort. The last guy I bought from before I started woodworking would absolutely not leave a square corner on a table. Every edge was broken and every corner rounded for safety - I'm sure he saw or heard of safety issues and it was his thing).

At any rate, it's nice to see an "it just is" (a 3 legged stool just looks better) win out.