Three-leg bar stool
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Question: for a three-leg bar Windsor style stool, would you place the single leg at the front or rear, and why?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Three-leg bar stool
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Question: for a three-leg bar Windsor style stool, would you place the single leg at the front or rear, and why?
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Three-leg bar stool
Jack Guzman from Maine
I would think you would want two legs in the back for stability. Your legs help the front leg maintain stability. Peter Galbert's "perch" is designed with the single leg in front but that is not a bar stool. So I'm not sure if that applies.---Jack
Design elements
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I've been pondering a bar stool design and its leg orientation for the past few months now. For some years I have been keen to build Windsor chairs, and I recently began thinking that a way to start would be to build three Windsor stools - the stools are the last part needed to complete the kitchen I began at the start of last year.
Pete Galbert's perch stool would make sense if I was building a stool for the workshop.

This version is made by an Australian chairmaker, Glen Rundell ...

This looks very ergonomic as it aids in maintaining a straight back. However, I want three bar stools for the kitchen, where one is inclined to slouch a little, and I do not think that the perch stool will work there. I like the look of three- as opposed to four legs, but this complicates the design in as much as how best to position the legs.
Pete also has built stools with four legs, and of course they are beautiful ...

Of four-legged bar stools, mention must be made of Curtis Buchanan, who is a hero of mine and a doyen of chairmakers. As far as I know, he has not made any three-legged bar stools ...

The granddaddy of the modern three-legged stool (in my opinion) is Wharton Esherick, who made the most beautiful stools. He brought together great skills as an artist (his training) and passion for woodworking into sculptural furnituremaker, and really was instrumental in help launch the era of studio furniture. I love the free-flowing lines and seat that appeared to have no specific side - however, on closer examination, they force two legs to the front.

These stools have a irreverence that appeals to me, and I love the free form design. No one is the same as another.

My favourite image ...

Eshertick's is a design that also appeals as often the stools in our kitchen are pulled away from the breakfast bar and someone will sit on their rear (the kitchen opens into the livingroom).
Everyone was influenced by Esherick.
Here is an example by another Australian, Bern Chandley ...

Nakashima's Mira bar stool ..


I have spent the past 6 weeks (including a 2 week break overseas) gearing up by building tools (I'll post these separately). It's time to finalise the design and get on with it!
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Three-leg bar stool
Patrick Chase
I'd put the single leg in the back.
My intuition is that the worst direction to fall in terms of both potential for injury and inability to use other limbs or furniture to self-arrest is straight back. Putting the single leg in the back prevents that in two respects: First, it makes the stool most stable in that direction. Second and more important IMO, it makes it near-impossible for absent-minded ADHD sufferers like me to idly rock the stool backwards. If you have two legs in the back then it's very easy to do so, and that's a bad thing.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
Jim Matthews
Lower stools for fiber spinning tend to have one leg in the "front" but they're knee-high - essentially squatting.
The downside of this is having a single leg intrude into traffic around the bar.
If users lean on a high bar surface, and a footrail is provided, one forward leg would be adequate.
Users will naturally seek out a place to put their feet.
Spinning stools aren't designed for drunks
Patrick Chase
The reason I brought up trying to tip the stool backwards is both because that's the sort of thing I'd try to do sober, and because it's the sort of thing drunks do :-).
This is a *bar* stool after all.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
Philip Duffy
Authentic Windsor Stools that I have seen and replicated have the single leg in the back. They are comfortable when the seat is carved/shaped to fit ones bottom correctly. The leg in the rear also allows the user to slide up close to the bar.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Philip and Patrick
I've come to the same conclusion that the front must have two legs. This is where a foot rest is needed, and that there is more likely to be a tipping forward than a tipping backward with a high stool.
Note - while they are called "bar stools", they are for use in a kitchen, where the counters are not as high as a bar.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Three-leg bar stool
roger lance
Derek.....beyond the ability to always have all three legs in contact with the floor, I don't see much advantage in a 3 legged stool over a 4 legged.
I liked the images you posted of stools (which you removed).....I suppose there are design, looks elements (studio furniture) examples that have an appeal.....but, there are also 4 legged examples that are attractive, stylish, and comfortable as well.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
William Duffield
No pictures of stools were removed. They are in a post by Derek in the thread on the Messages forum.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
roger lance
You might be correct.....seems like I saw it that way after awakening at 4 am and taking a quick look here before getting back to bed.
Derek has posted the same grouping of stools above under "Design elements".....
Either way, I'll try not to make too many important decisions at 4 am.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Roger
I posted the same thread on both forums as some only visit one ( I did not visit Messages until a year ago, saying on the Hand Tools forum exclusively up until then).
My last post there included a link to a video ...
http://www.pbs.org/video/woodwrights-shop-staked-furniture/
... which is by Roy Underhill and Chris Schwarz at the WoodWright's Shop. This deals with stability issues, and it demonstrates that the tipping point of legs on a chair. Based on this, I would say that it makes little difference, in regard to stability, whether one uses 3 or 4 legs.
3 legs just appeals to my sense of aesthetic. I do plan to knock up a prototype before using any of the nice Walnut I have.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Three-leg bar stool
roger lance
Derek.....Intuition tells me....the more legs....the more stable.
But, this is not why you are choosing 3 legs.....its aesthetics. I do believe that you will be getting a higher level of reaction from people visiting your home when they see the 3 legged stools over the more common 4 legged type.
From a comfort perspective, I'd rather be sitting on a stool with back and side supports on which my arms could rest. But, this is drifting into a chair verses a stool.
It might be fun to set up a little experiment to see how long people average sitting in a stool as I've described verses a 3 legged "studio furniture" version. Sorta reminiscent of college days testing this theory over that.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
Brian Holcombe
Considering the number of makers who are making three legged stools and the historical designs, I’d venture a guess that they can be made plenty stable. I also prefer a back for sitting in a dinner type situation but not really for aesthetics or for a bar where one might pull up for a drink or for appetizers.
I have stools with four legs, they do not lack in aesthetic, but if I made a set I think that I’d go right to three legged designs just as Derek has.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
roger lance
I'm confident that a 3 legged stool has adequate stability. I think that the real design consideration here is the expected duration of time that people will be sitting on the stools.
The longer a person might be expected to be sitting.....the more comfort considerations (a back, arm rests, etc) become important. The shorter the expected sit.....the less important.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Roger, our counter stools are rarely used for eating meals. Mainly they are used when having a quick snack, a place to sit while chatting with the cook, or reading the newspaper.
The existing stools are from Ikea, purchased 20+ years ago. From the entrance hall, there is a large open plan with living room and kitchen. The stools are the first items seen .. ugh!
Here is the nearly completed kitchen (in Hard Maple) and current stools ...

Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Three-leg bar stool
roger lance
Derek.....I know you have given great thought to this.....done a lot of research.....and you know how these stools will be used in your home. Someone has to play the devil.....the contrarian.....and give some opposition.....some alternative views.
Like everyone else, I'm looking forward to watching this build.....and I know the end product will be most attractive.
That being said and knowing you're a car guy, my Corvette sorta fits this discussion.....high on style.....low on comfort. Great for short trips.....but, a long journey requires frequent stops.....

Off topic (very)
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
That being said and knowing you're a car guy, my Corvette sorta fits this discussion.....high on style.....low on comfort. Great for short trips.....but, a long journey requires frequent stops.....
Hi Roger
My wife would kill for that red - she's always wanted one ... it is a ladies car, yes?
I'm kidding - that is a beautiful car. 
My favourite was the '57 Corvette.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Off topic (very)
roger lance
A Vette is suitable for a bloke, a shela, or an old man scratching off items on his bucket list.... 
Re: Off topic (very)
roger lance
Just curious, did you watch a TV show called "Route 66" back in the 50's - 60's that featured two guys riding across America in that '57 Corvette??
Always thought that was a real smart ploy on the part of Chevrolet to plant a seed in the minds of the young to one day have a Vette.
Re: Off topic (very)
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
It rings a bell.
I like that era. I once owned a '57 Porsche 356A. Sold it about 8 or 9 years ago after 12 years restoring it. It was costing more than I could justify, and still needed a new gearbox. Parts are very expensive to ship to Perth, and mechanics with an understand (and the correct tools) for old cars were impossible to find.

I made a good bit on the sale and bought a used Boxster S. That is my therapy - driving with the top down, through the vineyards and forests down south!
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Off topic (very)
roger lance
When I was just out of high school, I bought an ole 1961 MGA and would go for drives along Lake Michigan.....there was this stretch of winding 2 lane blacktop that was lined with very large oak trees.....almost making a tunnel.....and late at night, I'd have that road to myself.....the sound of the exhaust reverberating on that stretch was great.....even for that little 4 banger.
Tools for carving a seat
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
In the spirit of offering information to others who are also looking to take their first steps carving seats, I have a run down of the tools I have used so far. Not all of these tools are necessary, but as I am learning to carve a seat, I am interested in the tools that make this happen.
It is also hoped that others, especially those with experience, will comment on the tools - which they find useful and which not.
I shall return to discuss my experience of marking drilling and tapering the legs at a later time. That deserves a topic to itself.
In the background I am making a prototype three-leg counter stool in Radiata Pine (construction timber - dry and a little brittle ... but the smell when cut is strong!). The seat is 12" deep and 15" wide. The blank is 1 3/4" thick.

Roughing out with the Ray Iles scorp: this is the only scorp I have used, so I cannot make comparisons with others. Apparently - I read somewhere - that Pete Galbert came across a vintage scorp which he loved, and sent it off to Ray Iles as a model. This is the result. To a newbie like myself, this was well-balanced and easy to sharpen - it came beautifully hollow ground and pretty sharp to start. It was easy to keep sharp with a strop. I liked the handles and the blades continuous curve (I've seen some, like Two Cherries, which are a curved square). It surprised me how it was possible to use this to make precise cuts, both thick and fine.
The Veritas Pull Shave is an alternative to the scorp, however I did not find it as aggressive. Instead it was more like a jack plane than a scrub - capable of removing waste but not cut as deeply as the scorp. I like using if after the scorp to refine the surface. It offered more control than the scorp. I am comfortable using drawknives, but someone who is not may prefer it to the scorp.

I managed to find two cobbler (shoemaker) shaves of differing radii. These came with blades that were nearly worn out. They were reground and sharpened up. The handles were cut off as they were limiting the angles they could be used at. These shaves really surprised me. Dark horses. They managed to get into tight angles ...

The LN round bottomed spokeshave was used later at the front of the seat. This is a reliable, old friend.
These are two travishers I built. One has a radius of 5 1/2", and the other a radius of 11". The latter is to remove the hollows left by the 5 1/2", or where a flatter surface is needed. To be blunt, the 11" is overkill. I have seen Pete Galbert used just the one (5 1/2") travisher (made by Claire Minihan), and do so immediately after the scorp. As mentioned earlier, I am feeling my way ... and anyway I made them. It was just a little more time.
Rock Oak and Jarrah ...


It was very satisfying to find these two planes working well.

Lastly, the surface was finished with a scraper. This is one I made from the rear end of an O1 1/8" thick plane blade. It is prepared very simply, hollow grinding to create a fine wire at the edges.
Re: Three-leg bar stool
#24
Re: Off topic (very)
Patrick Chase
Derek wrote:
> I made a good bit on the sale and bought a used Boxster S.
Ooh, a Porsche that actually has its engine in the right place. Nice!
Now if only they would admit that their mid-engine platform truly is superior and offer their best engines for the Cayman...