Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

Posts

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#26

Re: Managing the stone

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Stones for chisels and stones for plane blades? If a stone is maintained with a camber for a plane, what do you do for chisels ... unless you camber them as well? What am I missing here?

I would also assume that a flat bevel benefits from a flat stone. Otherwise it is more sensible to hollow grind and ride the curves. I am missing something again?

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#27

Re: Managing the stone

Brian Holcombe

I think you guys are reading way into this, which doesn't surprise me for a sharpening thread. I can only speak for myself, but I'm talking about a very light hollow. Basically enough that I simply don't need to flatten the stone or think about flattening the stone, but not so much that it would only touch the outside edges on my flatter irons.

I'm not trying intentionally to make it more hollow when I use it, just maintaining what it is.

I have chisels 2" wide, sometimes a light hollow makes it easier to polish them out all the way to the edges. I'll argue that a chisel need not be perfectly flat and it has zero effect on the work. I make this argument because I know how truly difficult it is to have a super flat bevel, making one annually for kezurou-kai. So wether you know it or not, most of you likely have a minute camber on all of your blades.

So I'm not intentionally cambering my chisels, nor making a level of camber which would be noticeable to anyone really, just easing the stone enough that I can work the full bevel without turning a 5 minute job into a 30 minute job.

As mentioned I have a separate stone for backs, and

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#28

Re: Call me a boor ...

Brian Holcombe

Part of the trouble here is that we're drawing from different experiences. I maintain my synthetic stones for flatness, pretty routinely. However when I progress to the finish stone, which is a Japanese natural finish stone, I have one for bevels which is maintained all about itself.

Jnat finishers for tools are similar in hardness to Arkansas stones and so they don't actually dish that easily. It takes me probably 10 sharpenings with dedicated attempts to really dish it to the point that it is barely noticeable. Compared with a synthetic which dishes by looking at it.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#29

All saying the same thing

Patrick Chase

I think we (at least Warren, David, you, and I) turn out to have all been saying more or less the same thing in different ways:

1. There's no such thing as a perfectly flat stone

2. There's no point in trying to keep your stone any flatter than your straightest iron profile requires (ignoring back-flattening - like you I use separate media for that)

3. Good technique can allow you to achieve (2) with minimal flattening or none at all (again ignoring back-flattening and special cases like Kez).

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#30

Re: rubbing stones together

AlanWS

"...two will inevitably lead to convex and concave surfaces."

True, but it is very predictable. As a 7th grader I learned how to do it to within 1/4 wavelength of light, or a precision of about 10 millionths of an inch. Lots of people have done this by hand while making telescopes.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#31

Not so predictable with sharpening stones

Patrick Chase

Rubbing two objects together only produces predictable shape if they have fairly simple and well-understood material properties, like glass.

Neither of those descriptors applies to common sharpening stones.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#32

Re: Not so predictable with sharpening stones

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I probably started this rubbing stones discussion with a single sentence on Wednesday morning, 1/3/2018.

In 1967 I was taught to rub two stones together to help with flatness.

At that time I already knew that two stones were not enough for flatness. That is why I said help with flatness. Even just working with just two stones is helpful because stones tend to wear in similar patterns, especially hollow along the length, which can be markedly improved by rubbing them together. And if one can use more than half the brain and do the rubbing in a judicious way with real discernment, improvement can be made even if starting with awkward stones.

This is much more the spirit of the historical work that John asked about originally. Today's attitude is more of paint by number scheme that some one can lay down for all time, so that the worker can do the job without thinking (while watching tv).

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#33

Re: Not so predictable with sharpening stones

Greg Forster

...if three stones are better than two, would four or five

stones be even better?

After all this is a sharpening thread; let us leave no

stone unturned

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#34

Re: Not so predictable with sharpening stones

Patrick Chase

In theory 3 stones is enough to achieve perfect flatness, but there's an important caveat: The proof behind that assumes they're all made of the same material.

In practice 3 stones of the same "family" (for example 3 medium waterstones, 3 Arks, etc) is good enough for any real use.

Warren is right about what a skilled practitioner can achieve with 2 plates. I was replying to the post that claimed you could easily achieve sub-1/4-wave errors, not claiming that rubbing plates together was insufficient for mere woodworking.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#35

Re: Not so predictable with sharpening stones

AlanWS

Yes, of course you need something like glass (or metal, as demonstrated by Isaac Newton) to get to ridiculous levels of precision that nobody is arguing would be helpful for sharpening stones.

Even in the case of glass, what is predictable is not so much what curve you'll get initially, but how to correct the inevitable flaws you measure and monitor by testing. Glass is particularly helpful because of what you learn from reflected or transmitted images, and when you put two almost matching surfaces together, you can see interference bands that clue you into precise differences between the surfaces.

I think you can tell if a stone is flat enough with a straightedge. If you look to see where you want to remove material to make stones flatter before abrading them, the difference between flat and spherical is unlikely to be a problem.

If you mindlessly rub two (or three) stones together, you will wind up in a similar situation as you would if you mindlessly planed away stock to make a surface flat: it might eventually work, but you will get there faster and easier if you think about what you are doing.

To me, one of the main advantages of sharpening by hand rather than with a guide is the ability to maintain a fairly flat stone simply by avoiding dished areas.