Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

Posts

Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#1

Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello All,

Question - with all the recent discussions of diamond plates and how they can be used to flatten stones, both natural and manmade, what items and/or techniques were historically employed to maintain a flat waterstone? Before the late 20th century advent of "affordable" diamond plates. Or open the question more widely and ask how were natural Washita or Belgian honing stones kept truly flat? Was there particular sharpening techniques used that evenly abraded the entire surface, thus maintaining flatness? Was stone flatness less an issue then, or were there other methods to keep the sharpening media truly flat? Rubbing two or three stones together until all were flat? Were reference flats available 200 years ago (I think not!)?...

Thanks,

John

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#2

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones.

Patrick Chase

I believe that for Japanese waterstones the traditional solution was a Nagura stone.

You can also flatten most any stone (water or otherwise) by lapping with loose grit on a flat substrate, and it's still necessary to do so with very coarse stones. I flatten Crystolons and stones like the Sigma #120 that way, for example.

Diamond plates use electroplated nickel bonds to affix the diamonds to the steel substrate. If the abrasive particles on the stone stick out far enough to reach those Nickel bonds then the stone will "gently exfoliate" the diamond plate in very short order. That's why you generally want to use a diamond plate that much lower grit than the stone being flattened, such that the diamonds are large enough to keep the stone's abrasive particles away from the Nickel bonds.

Paving stones also work, though I don't think that's very traditional :-).

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#3

In western use

ian neuhaus

I don't think waterstones were "flat" till late in the 20th century.

Before then western waterstones were typically large (2 to 6 ft diameter) discs lubricated with water. I'm not sure how these stones were kept flat across their width -- perhaps it was by using the whole with when sharpening.

I think there is a picture of these stones in use at Theirs in Leonard Lee's book.

On the other hand, a lot of old Oil stones are found slightly dished in the wild.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#4

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones.

David Charlesworth

Patrick,

The traditional method I read about for oilstones, is silver sand and water on a York paving stone!

David Charlesworth

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#5

Re: In western use

Jim Matthews

I can't speak to methods prior to the 20th century.

The old timers in woodcutting country North Carolina used cinder blocks or a worn concrete step to flatten their coarsest stone, and that to flatten the finer stone.

Most carried a file and single stone to keep both their axe and pocket knife sharp.

Stropping was done on denim, canvas or an open palm.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#6

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones.

david weaver

Most of the stones that I've gotten that look used but not disused are reasonably close to flat, but not perfectly flat. I have flattened most of them, but only once, and the single stone that I use most of the time hasn't been flattened in four years or so and is still flat.

Couple of things - random thoughts:

* you can keep any stone flat in use with technique, obviously ditching the guide helps

* if an end or edge starts to get a little bit high, then sharpening overlapping the edge will bring it back. that's good technique, anyway - at least for keeping stones flat

* if a stone is swayed in its length but not much in its width, it's not that hard to use. You work the bevel on the stone length-wise, and you work the back on the ends. it would be harder to flatten an iron on a stone like that, but flattening work is better done on coarse material and not on stones

* softer stones like kings are pretty easy to keep flat without ever lapping, but some of the modern stones don't do that well if they are not lapped from time to time

* the oilstones that have a lot of sway are probably stones that were used heavily with laminated steel. hardened steel does little to pull particles loose from most oilstones (except turkish stones), but wrought iron will pull particles off of a washita and keep the stone semi fresh.

* we have some idea that modern stones should be good at tool prep and maintenance sharpening. The two should be separate. Preparing a new tool is the only area where even with good technique, an out of flat stone is a pain to use. The best stones - especially on the coarser side, pale in comparison to a fresh run of 80 grit PSA roll on a lap. Economically, they are behind, too. Tool prep and poor sharpening and tool use technique has led to the notion that stones should cut "fast", or as fast as possible, but that probably breeds more poor tool sharpening. Point being, we don't really need the flat stones for anything but tool prep, and we should be doing the tool prep on something else, anyway. Prep on stones leads people like Chris Schwartz to write errant blog posts asserting that it's less expensive to buy lie nielsen tools than it is prepare vintage tools.

For at time comparison note, I get cheap beat up japanese chisels from the proxy auctions sometimes. They're usually in fairly tough shape, including the backs. I don't do any ura work on them, I just flatten them brute force, go over the whole chisel with a deburring wheel, hone them and oil the handles. The last set of 11 chisels that I got took 45 minutes to have flat, and half of them honed - I set the others aside until I have a reason to finish honing them behind setting up the primary bevel on a coarse stone. 95% of that work is on materials that I'd never use for maintenance sharpening (a crystolon stone and a run of PSA paper).

As far as flattening them goes, loose sand, or George mentioned that at wmsbg, he found that arkansas stones flattened easily on a sandstone grinding wheel. Holtzappfel mentions workmen often truing turkish stones, which I can see, especially if laminated steel is used - but I don't remember if the text mentioned how the stones were trued. Probably loose sand, corundum or rubbing on a coarse stone.

I've maybe bought 200 stones now. I'm sure some of them were last used by skilled users, and none of them were flat by modern woodworking standards, but I'm sure at least some of them were used to do fine work.

When I use the better of those stones for a while before flattening them, I don't notice much difference in the sharpness of the tools that are honed on them.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#7

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones. *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In 1967 I was taught to rub two stones together to help with flatness. I have also used grit on glass and cement block. I doubt glass is a historic method; most glass was far from flat and even wavy glass was quite expensive. As David mentioned, however, the most important thing is using the stone so as to avoid gouging the stone in the first place. Running the tool down the center, avoiding the edges of the stone is a sure way to create a hollow.

For a plane iron on a water stone, I typically use maybe 100 back and forth strokes per sharpening and I flatten the stone only after thousands of sharpenings. The idea is to manage the stone, not abuse it. Overhang the edge and use as much of the length as you possibly can. For sharpening gouges and small chisels, which are naturally hard on a stone, use separate stones or the underside of the stone.

Historically, I think both water stones and oil stones predate the iron age. Both are discussed in the first century, the 10th century, etc. In the 18th century there were rub stones (usually flat pieces of sandstone) rag stones (finer water stones), and oil stones. Fine water stones were used for razors, not as much for woodworking tools.

Stephen Sheppard presented excerpts from an early 19th century paper on sharpening stones on this forum:


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/archives_handtools.pl/bid/3001/md/read/id/443118/sbj/tuesday-night-hand-tool-chat-sharpening-stones/

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#8

Managing it..

david weaver

Managing it is a good way to put it.

When I was a beginner, it seemed like fiddling, because I was fighting sharpening technique at the same time.

Now, managing the stone rewards you in a better stone (one that isn't lapped and brash) and time saved sharpening by the fact that you're never fiddling with the surface of the stone with lapping materials, etc.

Just sharpen, and that's it. Management of the stone is part of sharpening and doesn't add any time.

Recently on here, this kind of stuff was described as being quaint. There's nothing quaint about it, it's being sensible.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#9

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones.

JOE MOHNIKE

One thing I have done in the past, which others may not recommend, which is understandable, is to use a steel plate that is flat, and apply valve grinding compound on it and rub the stone on it until flat. you can use coarse and then fine to improve the surface. Works better (faster) depending on what type of stone you are flattening,

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#10

Re: Managing it..

Brian Holcombe

I follow a similar approach for most of my stones, of managing them from either almost flat to a preferable level of dish depending on what their purpose is. This is the typical approach, from what I understand, with carpenters and other tool users in Japan.

I do take a modern approach with one stone and keep it scientifically flat :D I typically use it only for backs and because I'm exceptionally particular about the ura.

Natural stones dont dish so quickly, so maintaining them is only slightly more difficult than maintaining a natural oil stone.

In traditional method I don't believe the nagura stone is used to flatten, but instead used to modify the character of the stone by effecting the slurry or creating additional slurry.

I believe rubbing two stones together or three stones is the way to flatten.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#11

Re: Managing it..

Patrick Chase

Managing the sharpening medium is just good common sense regardless of what sort it is. It's as valid and useful for sandpaper, PSA films, and cast-iron laps as it is for the most traditional natural stone.

If you don't distribute the load as you describe then you're just wasting abrasive, whether by the need to flatten excessively (in the case of friable stones) or by wearing out patches prematurely (in others).

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#12

Re: Managing it..

david weaver

I agree (using the whole surface just makes sense. When a spot gets a bit high, using it just makes sense if the user has the skill).

However, guru instructions often involve constant flattening of stones, or admonition of anyone who suggests that you can get decent results by "managing" as we're discussing, vs. chasing exact flatness.

Cosman's demonstration of stone prep comes to mind - it's fairly severe.

Discussion of all of this stuff is fairly painful, because a beginner who hasn't had a few hundred cycles under their belt isn't going to understand the idea of hanging a flat (or straight) object off of a surface that isn't perfect and still having a flat (or striaight - if desired) object when you're done. Especially if their iron or chisel is imprisoned in a guide. Even then, if flattening of the back happens while a chisel or iron is still in a guide, anything with reasonable width should overlap the ends of the stone a little bit when flattening.

(pardon if my posts are a bit disorganized - the migraine fairy is visiting).

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#13

Re: Managing it..

david weaver

It's hard to tell how nagura were used historically, but they're not similar to the rectangular sticks that come with a king stone, and I don't get the sense that they were ever actually used to flatten stones.

I think stones were rubbed together (in threes) if they needed flattening, and the nagura has always been a method to generate a slurry and speed cutting on slow or too-fine stones. Or, in the case of a substandard (super hard) stone, provide an external abrasive source since the stone isn't releasing any.

Nagura use is a lot more methodological in preparing a razor (where a slow base stone is desirable and you can control the grit progression using graded natural nagura - which are not remotely similar to the rectangular bars!).

I can't think of any nagura that I've handled that would actually be effective at keeping a stone flat, and many aren't effective at freshening the surface of a stone - they're intentionally softer than the base stone. Hard or scratchy versions are discarded as ungraded junk (or in my case, I found one at rockler 10 years ago for ten bucks - definitely a natural mikawa nagura - and definitely set aside or thrown out by any of the well known graders like asano).

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#14

Re: Managing it..

Patrick Chase

There is no such thing as perfect flatness, merely larger or smaller flatness tolerances. Even if you could get your stone perfectly flat, it starts to minutely deviate the instant you use it. The only practical exceptions are diamond plates.

As a practical matter any given flatness error tolerance will allow you to confidently do a certain amount of work before you have to check and possibly re-flatten. Good, uniform technique is simply a (potentially very very large) multiplier on that amount of work. It's really a pretty simple concept when you view it that way, and I don't see why anybody would find it debatable.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#15

Re: Managing the stone

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Managing the stone is more complicated than just evening out the wear. You want to manage the stone and the camber at the same time. We usually like a hollow in the stone roughly matching the camber on the plane iron. After all, we want uniformity on the edge of the plane iron. The two curvatures, stone and iron, cannot be a perfect match because the arcs on our various irons don't match exactly, but there is no point in having the stone flatter than any of the irons.

We don't just mindlessly rub away at the stone; concentration, knowing where the stone is cutting, where the stone is wearing, how fast these are occurring and such, is very important. Sharpening is an art.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#16

Re: Managing it..

david weaver

None of my stones are perfectly flat to start with - no hone that I use to flatten them is perfectly. Warren is correct, it's a collection of small things that you pick up while working (if you're willing to think while you're doing it).

I don't anticipate flattening anything at any point on any of my stones. The ones that are close to flat are used only with razors (which will never threaten their flatness). I flatten them once when they're new to me so that they start in a familiar place (plus, it makes them easier to resell), but generally go back to the same stone for most sharpening work.

I think I'm done with these topics for a while. The discussion isn't advancing here - it should go in the direction of greater subtlety, but we're talking about whether or not a stone is perfectly flat (or a plane frog, etc..whatever it is). It's completely pointless.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#17

rubbing stones together

David Charlesworth

I would like to point out that rubbing two stones together does not produce flatness. (Except if one is flat diamond).

One must get three surfaces to agree to get flatness.

two will inevitably lead to convex and concave surfaces.

David Charlesworth

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#18

Re: rubbing 3 stones together, origin... *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

An excellent point. I wondered when this three surface flattening method was discovered and found this in Wikipedia:

"The importance of the high-precision surface plate was first recognised by Henry Maudslay around 1800. He originated the systems of scraping a cast-iron plate to flatness, rubbing marking blue between pairs of plates to highlight imperfections, and of working plates in sets of three to guarantee flatness by avoiding matching concave and convex pairs"...

Thus, what we would consider a modern true reference flat surface is an early 19th century concept and practice.

John


https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surface_plate

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#19

Call me a boor ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... but my idea of "managing" a stone is to work the surface evenly and keep it as flat as I can. However, I am not obsessing - the stones I use (Sigma or Spyderco) do not go out of flat easily, and I will use a diamond stone to flatten the surface after a while.

Since the bevels of my chisels and planes are hollow ground, perfect flatness is not important when honing the bevel. However it is important for the back of the blade. Actually, I can get away with an uneven stone for the back as well, but it is nice to make this predictable.

I do not see the relevance of a hollow in the stones to create a camber on the plane blades. I prefer to add the camber by working the edges of the blade. Cambers vary per plane, and I prefer to have the autonomy here to decide how much I want.

My stones last a long time even with the flattening. Even so, they are consumables, and not so precious.

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#20

Re: a couple links

steve voigt

I may have posted this before…here's a classic reference on precision surfaces. The three plate method is described very clearly.

https://pearl-hifi.com/06_Lit_Archive/15_Mfrs_Publications/Moore_Tools/Foundations_of_Mechanical_Accuracy.pdf

Also, this page on scraping has a very nice bibliography:

http://www.circuitousroot.com/artifice/machine-shop/surface-finishing/hand-scraping/index.html#ward-2011

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#21

Re: Call me a boor ...

Brian Holcombe

Working flat bevels evenly by hand is different than working a hollow grind. It’s easier to get to the extremes of something like 70mm blade if the stone is slightly hollow. Otherwise I would need to work about 1/4” of blade on the far edge of the stone.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#22

Re: Managing the stone

Patrick Chase

Warren, in previous posts you've mentioned that the irons for your various planes have different amounts of camber depending on their use. I'm therefore curious about how you maintain "a hollow in the stone roughly matching the camber on the plane iron".

Do you have a different set of stones for every plane? Multiple carefully calibrated hollows in a single stone?

It seems easier to me to just keep the stones reasonably flat and deal with camber by working each tool side to side by an amount that appropriate to its use. Perhaps that approach isn't sufficiently "artistic", though. It certainly doesn't sound like something an artiste would say :-).

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#23

Re: Call me a boor ...

Patrick Chase

As is probably obvious from my reply to Warren, I agree with Derek here. I don't see the point of "stone Feng Shui".

It just has to be flat enough that it doesn't prevent you from achieving the straightest profiles you need.

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#24

Re: Managing the stone

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You certainly did not read my post very carefully. I mentioned that the stone could not match all the various arcs on a set of five planes or so. However, I hope you can see that it is advantageous to have arc in the stone because it fits the bevel profile better. So there is no point in having the stone flatter than any of your bevels. Why fight the stone more than necessary?

Re: Query regarding historical use of waterstones...

#25

Re: Managing the stone

Patrick Chase

You're right, I mis-parsed that sentence (last one in first para).

Having the stone's camber match the "flattest" iron will certainly speed up honing on that one iron. It won't do anything for the others, though, as the stone and the irons will still meet at a single point (as is always the case when the iron is more heavily cambered than the stone).

Still, your point is well-taken - flattening the stone beyond what's needed for your least-rounded iron is a waste of time. You'll get no argument here.