Re: Tempering and HT
David weaver
I should clarify, I got a second torch for the paint can yesterday, so I know it will heat an iron.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Tempering and HT
David weaver
I should clarify, I got a second torch for the paint can yesterday, so I know it will heat an iron.
Re: Danger, Will Robinson
David weaver
I'd use either a refractory cement mix or big temp refractory blanket. The lower the mass, the better.
Re: "Two-brick mini forge"...
John in NM
For what its worth, I've never known this forum to be strangely fussy about linking to other forums. That's something I associate with SMC. Moderation here is generally pretty light and always quite reasonable, so go ahead and post the link.
What to look for... *LINK*
John in NM
Soft refractory fire brick. It will work far better & safer than concrete or clay brick, and is vastly cheaper than hard refractory brick. It will slowly break down under propane temps, but I've seen people get years of casual use out of a soft brick forge (they had them at a couple shops I worked for years ago).
The link is just an ebay auction, first thing that google barfed up.... I've not much time to look for better suppliers this morning, but the link should provide a general idea of cost & appearance.
https://www.ebay.com/i/200945542607?chn=ps
Re: Tempering temps
steve voigt
Derek, it depends on the type of steel and the application, but for something like an O1 rabbet iron, 400-425 F, for about an hour. The hour is not necessary though; as long as the steel is heated all the way through it will be fine. I used to temper on the stove top, but the oven is more consistent if you can control the temperature variations, as we discussed.
With something like 1084 or 1095, the tempering temps need to be a little hotter, say around 450. Floats, which I make out of O1, are hotter still, around 550 (this results in a harder float than the ones LN sells, but I like them that way, and they can still be filed just fine).
Re: What to look for...
David weaver
I've got two types, one light and one not, but both are refractory. If you have a lot of heat and are going to run the forge for a while, both types are ok, but for one iron or knife, the blankets and low mass bricks are better because they heat almost right away.
Hardware stores usually have firebrick for fireplaces.
Thanks Steve
Re: Danger, Will Robinson *LINK*
steve voigt
Derek, I have limited experience with propane and refractories, so take this with a grain of, uh, sand.
Cheap homemade refractories work fine with solid fuel, but propane is a whole different ball game, because the average temp can easily be 1000 F higher than with a solid fuel forge.
There are lots of recipes on the web for homemade refractories used with propane. They will probably work, but they will be less efficient, and will need more frequent repair or rebuild, than the proper materials that are specifically made for forges. As with anything else, you get what you pay for. By all means go for it, just be aware of what you're getting in to.
If you decide you want better materials, get some Inswool and Satanite. Your forge will heat faster and the lining will last much longer. I'll link below to a place in the U.S. that sells small quantities of all that stuff. Also, there's a place in Australia that sells a rather pricey kit, but the savings in shipping might be worth it: https://www.artisansupplies.com.au/product/forge-refractory-kit/
forge supplies
Re: First Smashed Marking Knife
William Duffield
I got my soft refractory fire bricks from Sheffield Pottery.
https://www.sheffield-pottery.com/SOFT-BRICKS-Insulating-Firebrick-s/372.htm
I need to reduce the size of my file photos of my furnace and the process I used to build it, but in the meantime, I have some pics of a heat treating furnace that Bob in NJ built from my descriptions.




The big hole is easily drilled in the bricks with a hole saw (e.g., one used for installing lock sets in doors), and the small hole for the torch nozzle with a spade bit. Clamp two bricks together, drill as deep as you can with the hole saw. Take the bricks apart, and knock out the half cores with a cold chisel. Clamp them back together and drill the hole deeper. Repeat until it is deep enough to enclose your blades.
Re: First Smashed Marking Knife
William Duffield
Shipping for soft bricks is less than hard bricks, they are much easier to drill holes in, and they don't suck up as much heat from the torch.
The springs in Bob's last pic are to keep the fragile bricks from crumbling when they heat up and expand.
Clamp two bricks together and drill with a hole saw. This one is probably not wide enough for a #8 blade, and for sure not for my 3" slick. A smaller chamber heats small blades more quickly and with less gas.

When the hole saw bottoms out, take it apart and break out the cores. You don't need the cold chisel. A big screwdriver will work.

When you have the chamber deep enough, drill another hole for the torch nozzle, tangent to the wall of the chamber and near the bottom.

Find some hardware to clamp your furnace together, and locate it someplace fireproof. This one is on a concrete block in front of a Unisaw table.

Light the torch and stick it in the hole.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
That does look easy, William. Many thanks.
Regards from Cape Town
Derek
No Knives?
david weaver
Albeit, I didn't expect anyone to be impressed by my small knife, and fortunately, the discussion about it's composition was limited, and we didn't get into a fight about whether or not it's medium carbon core or not (all I can say is that it will cut cardboard, whittle wood, bevel the end of a tenon, etc, without taking any damage).
But I'm surprised how far the forge talk went, or that we got into the weeds with the oven stuff, etc (yes, it's important to check temp and consistency of the kitchen oven if you use that, and don't quench in motor oil if you're going to temper in your wife's favorite baking space).
I didn't think this discussion would go toward forge talk (wasn't my intention, but I guess people have a lot of thoughts on forges, and I just wanted an indoor cheap option - perhaps maybe a pair of longer tongs for my 500k btu outdoor burner, too).
Anyway, I'm surprised that in all of this talk, nobody has anything they've smashed with a hammer on the cheap and thought they'd share. Konobu has nothing to worry about in terms of me and kiridashi, but the rough little knife works really well and sharpens like a dream.
Re: Danger, Will Robinson
TomD
That is what I have, Koawool and satinite. The only downside is if you do a lot of work with flux, as it can eat right through that stuff, but many people use a lot of flux, so there are many work arounds out there.
Re: No Knives?
TomD
"but the rough little knife works really well and sharpens like a dream."
I am sure that is true, but it does help that one made it oneself as there is less reason to be critical. And I don't mean that in a cynical way. A lot of the point of what we do is that we make the stuff we want. There is a long list of ways in which the home made tool will be better for one, so even if it lacked a point here or there in raw edge holding (which is mainly a huge issue because it is one of the few things that is at least theoretically quantifiable), a win on everything else more than makes up for it.
Re: Forge
TomD 


This is my little forge, the key component of which is the Hybridburner.com burner. Runs off a propane BBQ type supply and regulator.
This was also my first welding project, so it looks rough and I never bothered to grind it.
This forge was designed with the option of doing swords, however I never have, and it has everything wrong if you want to do anything else. But even though not great, it works well enough that I haven't changed it, except to add a carry handle.
This forge is insanely stout, and the advantage to that are that it is easy to mount heavier burners, or to support heavy workpieces on the rests, but it is simply supporting koawool battens, so there isn't any reason to have a super sturdy shell, for what the forge does.
I like my forge but for a lot of things it is easier to use an oxy torch, or for that mater an electric heat treating oven. The propane units are best for actual hammer and anvil work.
Re: No Knives?
david weaver
you're right, it's not so much that I'm not critical of what I'm making, it's that on something like this on the first iteration, i'm pleased if something turns out good at all.
This little knife is capable of shaving below the nose (that'll make sense to anyone who shaves with a straight razor).
I have another knife I'm about to post, and the steel isn't as good, even though my effort was much greater.
I'm not as obsessed with edge holding as some are, either, at least to a reasonable level - I just don't much like edges that fail unexpectedly or give up a bunch of little chips.