Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

First Smashed Marking Knife

Posts

First Smashed Marking Knife

#1

First Smashed Marking Knife

david weaver

I got a coffee can forge for Christmas. It's the kind of thing I would normally waste a bunch of time to build, but people build them cheap.

In keeping with the talk about plain steel, I figured the first thing I'd do would be to smash the end of a file and sharpen it, more or less, with a plan to leave a rough handle that I can wrap.

And then sharpen it and see if it worked out.

(I already had a good anvil to pein infill planes).

It didn't spread out as much or as easily as I figured, and I didn't do high tech tempering - I quenched it and then immediately tempered it to straw waving it back and forth through the torch flame and put it in the quench quickly as soon as it got there, and then blued the tang.

It takes an incredibly fine edge, given that I have no clue what it is (the steel) other than to assume it's somewhere between W and O steels (ultimately, who cares?).

https://s17.postimg.org/xqcoebpvj/20171227_082006.jpg

https://s17.postimg.org/88u9uoq4v/20171227_082851.jpg

https://s17.postimg.org/9mlwq3rzz/Still_Cap232.jpg

It'll be a while before I figure out how to make anything accurately (unless it's just sawn, filed and ground out of flat stock), but I know what I'll make my marking knives out of from now on.

If the quality of the edge hadn't turned out so good, I wouldn't have posted this at all.

After all of the SGPS screwing around, finally finding that a buffer will give it a fine edge (at the cost of a thin edge, somewhat), file steel just hand grinds off of the IM 313, a quick buff and then a reset of the edge (I don't want that rounding on this knife), a bit of work on an arkansas and scrap wood loaded with compound.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#2

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

Brian Holcombe

Cool! Glad to see, I think you will enjoy that forge.

You might next think of something like a Burr King type grinder. A big serrated rubber wheel and platten are much nicer to do heavy grinding work or profile grinding than a hard wheel grinder.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#3

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

david weaver

Not that it matters, but I had my terms mixed up. Mine is a paint can, and there's room for a second torch in it, so it should be good for about 6 inches of heat, but it's not that even (so practically less).

You're right about the grinder. I either have to get a better belt grinder (I have a 1x42 kalamazoo) or get really used to filing things. I'm not opposed to the latter, it's predictable, and for a slow-head like me, it gives me a lot of time to look at the work and think, and it feels good to do heavy filing sometimes.

The trick with grinders is finding one reasonable, and then, for me, figuring out where I'd put it.

I'm still surprised at the feel of the file knife. Maybe I didn't get it fully hardened, but it's very compliant on the stones, and I subjected it to beveling, notching, whittling on dried wood and it sort of has that no real damage thing going that we find in carbon steel. I recall george once saying that a lot of the low-cost files are not high carbon steel through and through, and perhaps that could be the case in some of the good ones, too (where the surface is carburized with something like a case-hardening treatment so that the top layer is hard and below is not, without having to use silver steel drill rod, etc, for the blanks.

I don't think I'll be "smithing" much, but I'll smash the used files as a way to avoid some of the grinding.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#4

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

Jim Matthews

Are you taking any advance orders?

I would like to buy your second Kanna.

Kudos

PS - What is necessary to ventilate a forge that size?

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#5

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

david weaver

Kanna....well, I just bought a Nakano iron off of ebay for $45, and I got two vintage kamaji-backed 72mm irons off of the japanese proxy auctions for about $60 each (including a decent dai that just needs refitting).

I don't think there will be any kanna! Not that I could make one to begin with, other than filing out a piece of rikizai.

No ventilation needed for that kind of forge, it's just a small insulation wrapped can so that you can heat small items. My other method of heat treatment is a giant weed torch, which is difficult to get close to due to the level of heat - this is just a way to be able to do small stuff in the garage without adding a lot of overhead.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#6

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, won't you please post pics of your coffee can forge? I plan to build one (in a couple of weeks when I am back in Perth) to build a few more travisher blades. To date, for heat treating, my method has been very inefficient - using a couple of torches and trying to enclose the heat with bricks. Quick and dirty. It works but it takes a long time to get an even red glow. Time to build a small forge.

Incidentally, tempering the blades is easier in the oven: 1 hour at 425 degrees creates a very good edge for O1 steel that is around 2.5mm thick. I have been very impressed with the curved blade I recently made for a travisher.

I very much doubt that modern files are hardened all the way through. I would search out worn out vintage files. They could be had very cheaply. (Or do you think they are any different from the modern versions?).

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#7

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

David weaver

Derek - it's this one.

https://m.ebay.com/itm/Forge-Coffee-Can-Propane-Gas-Forge-Blacksmith-Forge-Knife-Making-By-CGR-Customs/232317898107?hash=item361739cd7b:g:pkAAAOSw9idaFSIR

Sorry for the long link.

It's just a paint can lined with refractory blanket and bolts for feet, but it works surprisingly well.

An iron would preheat sitting in the bottom, and if a second torch doesn't manage to burn it out, it'll easily heat an iron to critical.

Agree on the o1, it's extremely forgiving, and almost difficult to make a bad iron with it if the stock is quality. I usually temper in the oven, but on small stuff like this, I'm often too lazy.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#8

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

Brian Holcombe

For small items it is certainly more economical to use files, in fact they may be indispensable even with a grinder given that all of my best Japanese tools are filed by hand. That said I think it makes a lot of sense on a lamination but less so when dealing with solid tool steel.

I’ve fixed a few chisels with fine precision files, it’s a good amount of work but I assume much like woodwork that experience and proper choices cut the time down considerably. Much like doing all the planing with a fine set #4 vs hogging off the bulk with a jack.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#9

File composition

Patrick Chase

It would not surprise me at all if modern "good" files were face-hardened.

Embrittlement/fragility is a real problem for tools that hard, and a soft "core" would actually be quite advantageous in several respects.

If you do go the filing route, I suggest looking into Vallorbe Valtitan and Corradi Corrinox files. They're both Rc72 and can cut tools into the low Rc60s. I once used a Corrinox to reshape the side bevels of an ~Rc60 bench chisel and it worked perfectlu (I mostly did it for kicks, but also to achieve a thinner side edge than I felt comfortable doing on my belt).

The Corrinox ones in particular can be had decently priced on Corradi's Italian e-commerce site, provided you buy enough to amortize the shipping.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#10

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife *LINK*

David Bassett

Derek, I've been collecting links since Don Weber made a forge sound feasible in the special features to his "Build a Viking Tool Chest" DVD. Pop Wood published the video publicly. (Link attached, I hope.)

Also, I booked marked a build article for a smaller simpler propane oven that'd work for heat treating moulding plane irons. It's title was "Two-brick mini forge" in the Metalworking sub-forum of a different board.

Both should give you some more ideas. I think your "best" is going to be based on the materials you have readily available. (Turns out new refractory bricks aren't cheap in my area. Don Weber either had some on hand, has a local supply at a much different price, or just didn't add up all his costs. Pop Wood did up the cost estimate when they posted the video, so maybe some of all three.)


Propane Forge

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#11

Re: "Two-brick mini forge"...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello David,

Thanks for the Don Weber video link. Very informative. Certainly easy to make that forge!

You also wrote about a "..."Two-brick mini forge" in the Metalworking sub-forum of a different board"...

Might you give us the link to that site?

Thanks,

John

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#12

Re: "Two-brick mini forge"...

David Bassett

Sorry, I know many sites are sensitive about links to other sites and I can't find a doc permitting it here. (OTOH- it is a wood working site Derek also frequents.)

I will note when I use exactly that string, including quotes, it is the top site my favor search engine lists, with several other links that look interesting following.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#13

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks David. I have seen the various plans for that one on Youtube. It makes sense to make my own, given that the costs of a ready-made one would be excessive when one adds in shipping.

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#14

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks David. I like the idea of bricks - I wonder whether house bricks or 2" thick fired clay driveway pavers could do duty? Anyone here have an opinion. I used the latter for my recent "forge", however they were more of a rest for the steel that built into a forge, per se.

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#15

I wouldn't do that...

Patrick Chase

IIRC conventional bricks have melting points lower than the austenitization temperatures of common tool steels.

Concrete doesn't melt but tends to crack and disintegrate at such temperatures.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#16

Two problems with conventional bricks

David weaver

If they have moisture, they can crumble or break when heated. Btdt

They're massive and cold until you expend a lot of energy to heat them.

Only a small part of a forge gets hot enough for trouble, and that's easy enough to insulate against, but heating a bunch of bricks is a problem if you're going to harden only one item.

A quick blanket type forge pretty much heats while you're getting your stuff together.

I did learn that the torch igniter won't stand the heat, so small manual ignition torches are so good idea.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#17

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

David weaver

Definitely make it. It's only about 20 bucks of materials. I was a bit lazy when I bought this, but kids put pressure on my time. I have enough materials to build a second one, or extend the length of this one.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#18

Re: File composition

David weaver

I'm good for files. I like the simonds black max multi cut for stock removal, and only file annealed and spring steel, so no need for the specialty super hard files. George has mentioned those, though.

There's a clearance place here that sells the multi cut files for $8 (including a decent handle). They're really superb for draw filing, sort of a hybrid between single and double cut, and with a bit of flex, so you can file a flat surface with them.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#19

Re: Danger, Will Robinson

steve voigt

Derek, you need to be very careful with bricks in a propane forge. Especially if you're not sure of the brick's composition. If there is moisture trapped in the brick, it can explode, with serious injury or death the likely result. This is mainly a risk with concrete, but still…

Aside from that, Patrick and David are right that regular bricks can melt, crumble, or degrade very quickly in a propane forge (less of an issue with solid fuels). So, I strongly advise using firebrick--made for the purpose--next to the flame. There are two types of firebrick, hard and soft, and you want soft. In a larger forge, it's no problem to surround the firebrick with conventional brick, since the latter won't be exposed to direct flame.

There's a forum called iforgeiron which has a tremendous amount of info on forge building. Worth a look, though as with any forum you have to sift through a lot of nonsense.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#20

Re: Tempering and HT *LINK*

steve voigt

I'll second Derek's recommendation on tempering in the kitchen oven. One problem with that is that there can be heat spikes and uneven heat distribution. Two things really help. First, put some heavy cast iron pans on the bottom rack to act as a heat sink--this will help smooth out temperature fluctuations.

Second, and this was a real game changer for me, put the blades or whatever you're tempering on an insulated cookie sheet (thanks to the missus for that suggestion). These have an air pocket between two sheets of steel, and further protect your work from heat spikes. I get incredibly consistent results doing this.

Speaking of game changers, I recently started using a "muffle pipe" for heat treating. It pretty much eliminates scale and decarb, and makes heat treating large pieces much more practical. It's probably not an option for smaller forges, but for a medium size forge it's great. See link below.


muffle pipe

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#21

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

steve voigt

That's a nice little forge, Dave. It will serve you well for molding plane irons, small bench chisels, and other similarly sized work. I suspect it will whet your appetite for something larger eventually, but that's how most things work, right? In the mean time, you'll get a lot done with that rig. Have fun!

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#22

Re: Danger, Will Robinson

Patrick Chase

To Steve's point about explosions: IIRC bricks don't typically do that because their manufacturing (firing) process drives off most of the retained moisture. It's certainly known to happen with concrete though. When I said "disintegration" in my previous post I should have noted that the motive force for that is moisture, and that if there's enough moisture and/or heat then it can happen VERY rapidly.

PS - I'm not a masonry expert by any stretch. Caveat emptor, all advice is worth what you paid, etc. With that said, unless you *are* one I strongly urge sticking to fire bricks.

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#23

Re: Tempering and HT

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Yep, Steve ... baking tray and aluminium foil.

Incidentally, what temperature do you use, and for how long (assuming that the average blade is about 2" wide and 1/8" thick).

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#24

Re: Danger, Will Robinson

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

That is why I asked - I suspected as much.

My preference at present, based on the Youtube presentations, is a mix of plaster of paris and builder's sand into a steel container, as per David's forge. These are easiest to obtain. Any thoughts?

Regards from Cape Town

Derek

Re: First Smashed Marking Knife

#25

Re: Tempering and HT

David weaver

"Air bake"

I mapped the areas of the one per George's suggestion and temper on convection, but the lure of the quick temper in the shop is strong with small items.

I think I can do a 2" iron with the paint can, but if not, I can use the outdoor setup that I already have, but it's 500k btu and a bit hard to stay close to.