Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Posts

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#26

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

david weaver

It's not important, but I don't think they're renge. Sometimes they are described as such in listings, but renge are usually darker, smaller/tighter and more intense.

More like nashiji (pear skin), but that's often pear skin color.

I'll never know all of the different stones, colorations, etc. I often see things from experienced dealers that aren't correct. I just went looking at a pattern page to see if there was a name for the pink nashiji, but i couldn't find any. I did, though, see Fujibato stating that kuro (black) renge comes only from Narutaki and is ultra rare. It's definitely rare, but there have been several ohira mine stamps on buyee with kuro renge. I missed out on one at $975 last year - I don't buy many stones for myself any longer, but that one was huge and ultra rare, a bright white suita covered with blue and black renge, and with a super dark iron flower.

I think dealer is important, but it does at least double the price, and I've gotten some good stuff from dealers, and some stuff that's ho hum but being described as great. It's the curse of having seen too much. I don't have the stomach to be a "real" dealer.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#27

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! This is why I defer to yourself or So. :D

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#28

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Hank,

Kayoko only told me that Yataiki instructed her what to look for, and she hoped she picked right. I showed a photo a few years back to So, and he was complimentary, saying ‘you don’t see stones like that anymore.’ Perhaps he was being nice, but I consistently found So to be more direct and honest than nice, though he has well-bred ways.

Wiley

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#29

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones


Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#30

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

david weaver

I should be clear about why "it doesn't matter".

I've found some stones with renge and goma that don't cut that fast, I've had kiita stones that were hard and fine (they're usually on the coarse side for the price) and I had an okudo suita with those dots like wiley's, and they didn't look like "real" renge, but it was brash and fast cutting.

I ran into the fastest cutting suita I've ever seen recently, and it's plain white with no renge. It replaces my next fastest stone that had renge.

It's all a guess until the stone goes under a tool.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#31

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones


Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#32

Toxic JNats?

Patrick Chase

Please do tell. What's the toxic agent and are these actually at all common?

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#33

Re: Toxic JNats?

Brian Holcombe

Basically just means a line of sand in the stone.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#34

Re: Toxic JNats?

david weaver

Large foreign particle in the middle of a stone. Sometimes, they are loose in a crack, and sometimes they are actually in the stone itself, embedded in the matrix.

It drops the price of a stone if there is a toxic line (which can be managed), and most of them don't make it to market (none over here that I'm aware of), but this picture of a stone used by shigefusa (they hand finish their knives, something not common these days) is pretty heavy endorsement to just remove the line itself. They took some extra, but they're finishing knives, so that line will never be a problem like it might be with chisels.

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-gxBEP4eq4SM/TbIiAPl69fI/AAAAAAAAA-s/kOKbyIQfRLE/s1600/P4150234.jpg

When toxic particles are embedded in a stone matrix and just look like shiny points here and there, they are impossible to deal with.

There are other flaws that behave like them - stones with fragile surfaces (these are common) where the top corner of a chisel profile scratches a line, and with the scratch comes particles in gloms. They are not toxic themselves, but as shards together, they can do damage. A stone like this will finish a razor without issue if it's fine enough, but it will scratch up the bevel of a knife and put little nicks in the edge. They can be used with tools with a technique adjustment, but they usually have crappy feel.

This last type occurs sometimes in high quality stamped stones. I'd say of all of the stones that I import, probably a third have a fragile surface, and a tenth to the point they're unusable for anything other than razors (and they're usually too coarse to finish them). One of the reason that suita are desirable and expensive is that they exhibit this a lot less.

anyway...I'm sure there are others, but the "shiny points" and the toxic lines with particles in them (sometimes loose, sometimes not) are the two I've seen the most.

There's all kinds of foreign stuff in japanese stones that we don't see much in oilstones, etc.

I just went out to one of fujibato's old guides. He calls the lines Kane-Suji and the dots Harike. I have one stone with the latter - it's annoying, because it looks like a great stone, and it's huge. It scratches everything up, and you wouldn't expect it when look it at.

I also have several stones that have obvious metallic deposits in them, but they just make for shiny dots that do no damage. You just never know.

(the stones that I have with toxic bits came directly from japanese wholesale listings. I'm sure they said something about them, but google translate didn't hook me up. I did learn that if the word chisel shows up in a stone listing, it means that you'll have to chisel out toxic particles, not that the stone has been chiseled by hand on the back or that it's good for chisels).

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#35

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

Hank Knight

Thank you for the information. It is very helpful. The kanji printed on my stone has long since worn away, but I found a photo I took of it when it was new:

[url=https://postimages.org/][/url]

I can't decypher it, but it looks similar to the printing on the stone you linked.

Kayoko told me it was a Honyama Awase stone. It's probably the same common stone you described, but I wanted to throw in this additional bit of information. I paid about double the $200 range you mentioned and it seemed a lot at the time. But knowing nothing about Japanese natural stones, I relied on Kayoko and am not disappointed. She has always been a straight shooter with me and I am very satisfied with my stone. If she made a few bucks in my stone, I don't begrudge her that.

The information about technique for using this stone with my Western chisels is interesting. I'll try it, but I doubt I will make much use of it. Several years ago, I decided yyto simplify my sharpening regimen. I settled on a Norton combination crystalon/fine India stone followed by a vary fine translucent Arkansas stone and finishing with a leather strop charged with Lee Valley's green crayon for my Western chisels and irons. This will probably draw raised eyebrows from many of the sharpening gurus, but it suits me well. I still use water stones for my Japanese edges and finish with the natural stone I pictured above. I am very happy with the edges I get finishing with this stone.

Thanks again for your information.

Hank

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#36

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

david weaver

I paid about the same as you, and for an almost identical stone (I got mine from Hida, and Hida may have had their own earlier because I know they bought stones from imanishi, but I heard they bought the rest of the stock from someone else to continue to sell - it may have been from the person who sold your stone to you).

That was just the going rate at the time, and I don't think there was any proxy auction or other sellers who were interested in selling the stones for less. Alex (the japan stone, blade at the time) was selling some vintage maruka stones for huge dollars, and So was selling at the very top end of the price range for a given stone.

Naturally, that has brought a lot more sellers into the market. The green Ohira stones and the Atagoyama stones (giant stones that are a bit finer, but also a bit slower to go with that if the fineness his higher) are still out there in numbers, obviously.

They do all work well when the steel is very hard, and Fujibato mentioned in one of his old guides that steel hardness should be 62 or greater to get the most out of finish stones in general.

I hope I don't seem too harsh. I think the US market just wasn't served very well for a long time, and it probably still isn't, whereas you could go find a stack of imanishi's stones at a knife shop in Japan and really get what you're looking for.

In terms of the stamps, I believe the one on the left side says Ippon-sen, and the one on the right has kanji for honyama, and I believe some of the rest indicates the mine (Ohira) and though I haven't gone to track down the rest, it probably specifies that the stone is a finishing stone.

There was a short golden era not long ago where you could get what are sold as $3k stones here for about a quarter of that on the japanese proxy sites, but the resellers have found them, so that's pretty much over. For the same $400, you can get a nice suita stone now of about the same size as those tomae, but it's not really a game changer (it's a little faster, but it wouldn't change your routine or have you making more - and there's a bit of risk buying proxy auctions that Kayako saves you from taking).

And still, even the average tomae stones are a delight to use.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#37

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

Hank Knight

Thanks, David. That kinda closes the circle of my infirmation gap. I appreciate it.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#38

bridger

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Bridger

Quote:

It will show up well lapped and a good bit of the way toward its ultimate fineness. I would use it as is and never do anything else to it (no lapping, etc, which will ruin the surface treatment that dan's does). It will continue to get get finer and slower cutting, which is what you want.

Quote/

Mine came. The lapping is pretty coarse looking compared to other translucent and surgical black stones I have, and it cuts like it too. It'll leave an edge that just shaves arm hair according to the little I have done with it so far. I expect that it will settle in quite a bit finer.

I have had good results waking those stones up by using them as nagura with my Norton waterstones. The finest waterstones will definitely leave the trans arks too smooth for my purposes.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#39

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

David weaver

I wonder why they didn't surface lap them at Dan's.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#40

bridger

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Bridger

It looks hand lapped, like it was done (nicely) with fairly coarse sandpaper. It works fine, just a little more aggressive than I was expecting.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#41

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

david weaver

Yeah, that's unusual. I wonder if they didn't finish them because they were seconds for Sierra trading co. The first Dan's stone I ever had was a second, and it was fully finished lapped (and from Sierra trading co.).

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#42

bridger

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Bridger

I'll see if my cell phone camera can capture it with low raking light.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#43

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

Bridger is no doubt ahead of me, as I know almost nothing about Arkansas stones. That said, mine arrived today and my reaction was ‘smooth as a baby’s hiney’. Both top and bottom faces. But I don’t know what I should be looking for.

Only tried it briefly on one iron; got interrupted. Initial impression would place its effective grit size at maybe 4K to 5K in a waterstone series. But that’s very preliminary, and you have said these stones will cut finer over time. More later.

Wiley

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#44

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

david weaver

Sounds like yours was lapped. I'd expect a little finer as time goes on (the lapping from the factory is good, but it'll still settle in more), and then you might develop some nuance to get more or less.

Of course, steel hardness will determine a lot, too.

Good clean bare leather strop is a must.