Re: Toxic JNats?
david weaver
Large foreign particle in the middle of a stone. Sometimes, they are loose in a crack, and sometimes they are actually in the stone itself, embedded in the matrix.
It drops the price of a stone if there is a toxic line (which can be managed), and most of them don't make it to market (none over here that I'm aware of), but this picture of a stone used by shigefusa (they hand finish their knives, something not common these days) is pretty heavy endorsement to just remove the line itself. They took some extra, but they're finishing knives, so that line will never be a problem like it might be with chisels.
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-gxBEP4eq4SM/TbIiAPl69fI/AAAAAAAAA-s/kOKbyIQfRLE/s1600/P4150234.jpg
When toxic particles are embedded in a stone matrix and just look like shiny points here and there, they are impossible to deal with.
There are other flaws that behave like them - stones with fragile surfaces (these are common) where the top corner of a chisel profile scratches a line, and with the scratch comes particles in gloms. They are not toxic themselves, but as shards together, they can do damage. A stone like this will finish a razor without issue if it's fine enough, but it will scratch up the bevel of a knife and put little nicks in the edge. They can be used with tools with a technique adjustment, but they usually have crappy feel.
This last type occurs sometimes in high quality stamped stones. I'd say of all of the stones that I import, probably a third have a fragile surface, and a tenth to the point they're unusable for anything other than razors (and they're usually too coarse to finish them). One of the reason that suita are desirable and expensive is that they exhibit this a lot less.
anyway...I'm sure there are others, but the "shiny points" and the toxic lines with particles in them (sometimes loose, sometimes not) are the two I've seen the most.
There's all kinds of foreign stuff in japanese stones that we don't see much in oilstones, etc.
I just went out to one of fujibato's old guides. He calls the lines Kane-Suji and the dots Harike. I have one stone with the latter - it's annoying, because it looks like a great stone, and it's huge. It scratches everything up, and you wouldn't expect it when look it at.
I also have several stones that have obvious metallic deposits in them, but they just make for shiny dots that do no damage. You just never know.
(the stones that I have with toxic bits came directly from japanese wholesale listings. I'm sure they said something about them, but google translate didn't hook me up. I did learn that if the word chisel shows up in a stone listing, it means that you'll have to chisel out toxic particles, not that the stone has been chiseled by hand on the back or that it's good for chisels).