Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones *LINK*
david weaver
Hi Hank - those are ohira tomae that either originated directly from Ohira or from Imanishi (who distributes a huge number of natural stones), who distributes a lot of ohira stones. It's possible to get stones directly from the mine if you're a big enough dealer, or if you want to chase the really expensive stuff (which isn't really ever worth the price - by really expensive, I mean stones with four figure prices).
The reason that the stone seems very fine with your japanese tools, but not with the western tools, is that those are sort of a middle of the road finisher. They rely on the hardness of the japanese steel to produce a fine edge, but can penetrate softer chisels more deeply.
You can improve the results you get from them with a couple of tricks:
1) bare leather strop lightly after you use one
2) work an edge lightly on an area of clear stone without slurry, back and forth a little, and then strop
3) let a spot on the stone get slightly dry and then burnish the edge on it
Honyama means that it was an original mountain stone. Until recently, most of them sold in the US say Ippon Sen on them, also, which means they are select or highest grade (even stones with no cracks or toxic particles), no voids underneath, sit flat, etc. None of these things are a given, so those stones have been graded to ensure that they're free of those.
They are favored by dealers because they can still be gotten in volume (either the mine is still open, or they have a ton of stock) at a relatively low price. Probably about $150 for a type 30 stone, perhaps a little less, and then resold or flipped for a reasonable profit while maintaining supply. Same with Atagoyama, they're still out in numbers, and now there are some off-main-mountain mines producing a lot of stones (iwatani, takashima, wakasa, etc).
They are now coming to the US through other channels and are relatively less expensive. For a while, Hida was selling them for about $400 type 30 size and something close to $800 for the type 24. there is someone on ebay (I suspect the former owner of Japan woodworker, who was always looking to make a huge margin) selling type 24 atagoyama stones for $800+ (they probably cost less than $200 at the dealer level in japan, because I can get them for $230 or so off of the japanese auction sites - they also originate from imanishi).
All that said, the Ohira tomae are decent stones, they're usually stable (mine delaminated - one of the ones from Hida, but that just happens sometimes, even when there are no visible cracks on a new stone and it's better just to repair and keep going than worry about it) and they're relatively predictable from stone to stone, so they're attractive for people to flip - or were. Now that they're showing up here for the price on the attached link (that is a japanese market imanishi stamp - no english, but it's imanishi), it's probably a little less attractive to sell them.
I've got some objection to what the explanation of the stone is in the ebay auction (they're not good for razors, they're not rare, etc) but given the price for the stone, that's not so bad. I don't favor so much Hida's selling them at $400 (I subsequently resold mine to someone for $150 - the most I could get for it, and it delaminated on them, to my horror), but we live and learn.
While the ohira tomae is sort of the king 6000 of the naturals, there's really no good suggestion that I have for anyone to go up the ladder to something finer, as the hand-picking dealers like So and others really charge a mint (or mint squared) for what they're selling. It's the economic reality of being a dealer if you're going to make any money, I guess. And, the stones are variable, so as much as a dealer would like to tell a buyer that they're getting the best (a common line), they're really left trying to find a fit for most of the stuff they're selling.
I flip stones on Etsy (but I wouldn't suggest anyone buy from me. I'd rather link people to the Japanese proxy bidding sites and help people pick something on their own), and I do relatively often get people who learn that the stones are not all the same, and they usually write telling me that I should do them a favor and sell them my best ("1 in 20") stone at cost (my term for those is 1 in 20. one in 20 stones is something special. Another 5 are really good, 5 more are good, 5 OK, and 4 outright junk), or they'll buy nothing - because they've already been had by one of the other well known dealers. I'm OK with the latter.
Linky