Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Posts

Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#1

Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Jason Ingoe

For those that were looking to buy a Dan's Translucent Ark, 55% right now 8x2x1/2 boxed stone ($49.99) and several other sizes at Sierra Trading Post

https://www.sierratradingpost.com/dans-whetstone~b~1631/

Jason

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#2

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

David Weaver

A superb piece of rock. Even if these are seconds, they are better than other peoples' firsts.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#3

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

I just ordered the one Jason pointed to. What should I expect? Can you locate this stone within a Sigma sequence, for example? Or is it a different animal altogether and can only be compared to natural stones? I have some Japanese natural stones, which I use, but don’t know what they are.

The only Arkansas stone I have is the black hard stone that came with the Hand America kit, with strop and CrO 0.5u powder.

Wiley

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#4

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Patrick Chase

Unlike waterstones, Arks are hard enough that the surface roughness of the stone influences the finish that it creates. The Dan's translucent stones come finely lapped, which means that they leave a pretty good finish out of the box. They have a smoother out-of-box surface than the Nortons Arks, which are similar quality stones IMO but need to be "worked in" a bit before they'll leave an equally refined edge.

I'd say that my Dan's translucent cuts a bit more coarsely than the Sigma 6K, but more finely than the Sigma 2K (which I have but seldom use). IMO it's a very serviceable edge that leaves a good surface, but it benefits from refinement (with CrO compound for example) if you're trying for every last bit of sharpness.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#5

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think there is some overlap between black Arkansas and a translucent. The greater difference between stones of this type is the care with which they were finished. The quality of the sharpening is dependent on how well the stone is polished. I would not wait around for the stone to break in; my black stone is 1.000 inches thick after 42 years.

When I have gone to Woodworking in America or other hand tool events I have often seen tools sharpened with Shapton 16000 or green wax bar. I get about the same quality or better from my soft Arkansas stone.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#6

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Hank Knight

Hi, Wiley.

I've tried lots of different sharpening media over the years and have ended up where I started with oil stones. I use two: a norton combination coarse crystolon/fine india and a translucent arkansas stone. I finish with a leather strop loaded with green compound. The translucent arkansas produces a very serviceable edge, not polished like I got from an 8,000 Norton water stone, but very good nonetheless. I would place it between a 4,000 and an 8,000 Norton water stone. The strop puts the last touch on the edge and can be returned to multiple times for renewal before going back to the stone. I have no experience with Sigma stones, so Warren is your man there. I hope my reference to Nortons is helpful.

Merry Christmas.

Hank

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#7

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

david weaver

If they can't better every soft arkansas stone in the world with either of those two options, then something is wrong.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#8

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

david weaver

Hi Wiley - this stone will be different than any you've used, unless the black stone that hand america sold was from halls or dan's. Nobody else really has a good black stone, and dan's is better than halls.

I can't really put it at a specific spot in sigma's lineup, because the trans ark is dependent on:

* the hardness of the object being sharpened

* the density of the trans (dan's is very consistent - 2.7 specific gravity, or just a hair below that is the actual density of a novaculite particle, and dan's stones are generally mid 2.6s - both the black and trans are about the same).

* how well conditioned the surface of the stone is

* your sharpening technique

I think you'll find that the the stone likes carbon steel in the high 50s to low 60s range. Below that, and it can cut aggressively and the edge will show that. Above the low 60s, it can still finish wonderfully, but it won't cut much.

It will show up well lapped and a good bit of the way toward its ultimate fineness. I would use it as is and never do anything else to it (no lapping, etc, which will ruin the surface treatment that dan's does). It will continue to get get finer and slower cutting, which is what you want.

The bias you mentioned the other day is how you'll want to use it - biasing toward the area of the blade that you want to polish, and as you mentioned prior - it's good policy to make sure the edge is in as good of shape as possible at the end of the prior step.

Light mineral or WD40 are my choices of lubricant. You can also use ballistol or smith's honing solution. You can try the stone with nothing but a tiny film to more than that and see what you like.

When the surface gets loaded, if it does, it only needs a drop or two of lubricant, and it will be clean (no need to do anything else).

If you find that you want it to have more mass, I'd find an inexpensive soft arkansas or piece of slate the same size, make sure the ark is oil free on the glue surface, and glue the two together to make it more similar to a full thickness arkansas stone.

I would say that on the fine end of things with ideal steel, you should get an edge similar to the SP 13k in sharpness, but the quality of the edge will be different in feel. If you have softer steel (which often shows up in pocket knives) or lap the stone, then the edge will be well below that.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#9

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Patrick Chase

AFAIK Warren's only waterstone is a mid-grit King, and he isn't a fan of waterstones for polishing in general.

The Sigma 6K leaves a similar or finer finish than the Norton 8K in my experience. Your observation that the Dan's Ark falls between the Norton 4K and 8K is therefore basically consistent with my remark that it falls between the Sigma 2K and 6K (and closer to the latter).

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#10

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I will not deny that there is often something wrong. I visited Brent Beach's site this evening for the first time in many years. He claims that sharpening a plane iron full bevel like I do takes 1 hour and 31 minutes, and quotes the figures to prove it. I pity him if he actually has done full bevel sharpening enough times to establish an average figure in that range. I am usually under 1 minute and 31 seconds.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#11

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

david weaver

He's not really open to learning about the craft side of things (things that rely on craftsman's sense, subtlety and touch).

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#12

Re: My apologies

Hank Knight

Patrick,

It was your post I should have referenced; not Warren's. Warren didn't compare a translucent arkansas stone to any Sigma stone. My apologies.

Hank

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#13

Can we please stop talking about Brent's "data"?

Patrick Chase

I'd say Brent's problems go far beyond not being willing to learn the craft. Some of his results are just ridiculous.

Consider for example his conclusions about Shaptons here: http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/jig%20faq%2006.html#ab12. Shapton has their problems but as you yourself have pointed out, grading/consistency isn't one of them. Their polishers do not leave rogue scratches of the sort that he claims. Shapton stones are a bit coarser than average at any given grit #, but that's an entirely different and far less problematic issue. Their "#30000" would be "20000" in Imanishi or Sigma's rating systems, for example.

His accusation that Leonard Lee misrepresented the "green compound" results in his book is similarly charming, and has caused many gullible woodworkers to go off the deep end as recently happened in another forum.

Brent's pages strike me as the work of somebody who has predetermined conclusions (not to mention a few axes to grind), and won't let "facts" or "objective reality" get in the way of his story. As a result I don't trust his micrographs. His credibility is our only guarantee that those images show what he claims, and some of his representations are so blatantly false that I consider his entire body of results to be worthless.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#14

I have to admit...

david weaver

..that I still really like his pictures of wear, because they match what I've felt, and I am too lazy (or perhaps just too unwilling to use my shop time), even as curious as I am, to duplicate them myself.

That's the one thing that I like to refer to on his pages - those pictures. They don't tell a beginner the clearance pattern or the thickness of the edge, but the smooth wear vs. the chippy lets you infer that.

I'm pretty sure I've read most of the rest of his page (but probably nearing 8 or 10 years ago now) and most of it has been discharged from my mind. About 4 years ago, I encouraged him to learn about the double iron because he had some incorrect conclusions about it, and he was polite, but dismissive.

I wish he'd wear test V11, because it's a huge hole in his pictures to not have that shown.

You can tell that I could care less about the length of the wear bevel to some extent (his numerical decider), though it's also useful - just not as useful without a discussion of the condition of the bevel itself (the thickness of the edge presenting itself to the wood).

The sharpening pages are dangerous territory for a beginner - they might think all of that stuff is necessary.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#15

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Brian Holcombe

This is not a scientific test, but I thought I’ll mention;

For Kez this past year I decided to use a Sigma 13k to finish my edge following the logic that the extremely hard super white steel was not being effectively sharpened by natural stones. I took many shavings in practice, then switched back to a natural stone (Nakayama). I bested that of the Sigma with the natural stone, so long as I polished the edge and back first with the Sigma.

I’d speculate that on the right steels the black ark will make a nicer edge both more durable and possibly sharper.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#16

Patrick, thank you! Very helpful!


Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#17

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thank you, Warren. I didn’t realize finish was so important on an Arkansas stone. Do you never regrade or renew the surface, once it’s how you want it?

Wiley

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#18

Thank you, Hank and Patrick, for the

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

grit approximation. Two people agree!! :O

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#19

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks, David. A great rundown. I’ll find the lightest oil I have that’s not camellia oil. Maybe the WD-40. Will send a photo when it gets here.

Will do some testing starting with a C&W iron—I think they’re in the Rc58-59 sweet spot you mentioned. Not quite as hard as a Hock O1. Brian (below)talks about an interesting thing with his Japanese blades—he got his best edge off his Nakayama, but after first polishing with Sigma 13K. I’ll see if I can replicate his results on steels from C&W up through white #1and Mr. Kanda’s blue steel.

Will post a few Japanese natural stones below—interested in your commentary.

Wiley

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#20

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thank you, Brian. I’ll see if I can replicate your experience, working between this translucent and a Sigma 13K. Will test on irons of increasing hardness.

When I sharpen, I always check for final sharpness on whether the iron slides through the edge of the LATimes—will have to see if that’s an adequate test to separate the effects of these stones.

Your info is very interesting!

Wiley

P.S.

Here are some Japanese natural stones I use. Interested in any commentary you may have—I only know the type of one of the three stones, the tomae.

The album:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/albums/72157689864241771

The two smaller stones left and right were gifts from Scott Nehring. The one on the right is a tomae, but the marked one on the left he only said ‘tell me what you think of it.’ Of the two, the tomae is fast cutting and somewhat coarser than the marked stone. The marked stone can make a very keen edge on O1 and Japanese white and blue, but I’ve never tested it against graded stones like Sigma, so have no comparison.

The marked stone:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/38389550975/in/album-72157689864241771/

The larger yellow stone. This was selected by Kayoko Kuroiwa from a collectiion owned by a friend of Yataiki the saw-maker (now deceased):

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/38389550985/in/album-72157689864241771/

Close-up of the larger stone. This is my finest-cutting natural stone. Notice the red specks:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/38389551055/in/album-72157689864241771/

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#21

bridger

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

bridger

thanks for the heads up. a pretty good deal for a stone I've been wanting to add to the kit.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#22

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

david weaver

re: Brian's mention - the natural stones will make varying grooves in the super hard white steel. I remember Stan Covington saying that the kez guys in japan were working up through 30k shapton, and then using something slightly more coarse to relieve the "tension" at the edge, or something like that.

The stone should work ideally with Larry's irons at that hardness. My favorite thing to do with them is bias the finish stone at the edge (to your advantage) with stiff pressure, and then alternate back and forth (bevel and back) with lighter pressure until any burr or foil is completely thinned. A low/mid pressure strop on a clean and oiled strop and the edge has good geometry and good durability without the transient initial sharpness that synthetics seem to have.

re: the stones, I have probably passed through about 150 stones now (japanese naturals). The tomae stones are really variable. Some are fine and slow, some are mid speed and on the coarse side (the green tomae that come from imanishi and that hida sold are generally of the latter type). I'm not an expert on layers - tomae and the deep suita strata seem to be the most consistent for woodworking. Your spotted fine stone, I've seen those light red dots, but I'm not sure what they're called. The black dots are goma.

The karasu pattern stone looks like shoubu with the light colored lines (they are common on shoubu stones), but those lines do appear elsewhere. Like Tomae, karasu pattern stones are all over the board. For a while, there was a rumor that are were hard and superfine, but I think razor purchasers found out that wasn't true.

Because of that, I can't say much about the stones other than to defer to you on what they're like to use. As long as a stone isn't scratchy or toxic, you can always make good use of it. If it's coarser and faster, then it'll make a good prefinisher in a two step finishing process. If it's really slow, but not scratchy, then it'll do well following a prefinisher, but maybe not on its own.

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#23

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

Hank Knight

Wylie,

I have the same stone from Kayoko. It is also my finest cutting stone and it puts an incredible edge on my Japanese chisels. Oddly, it doesn't seem to do much for my western chisels. Kayoko called it a " honyama" stone. I don't know if that's the type or grade of the stone of if it refers to where the stone was quarried. It is my understanding that Kayoko had was, and perhaps still is, allowed to select stones for her customers from Yataiki's friend's very large collection of natural Japanese stones. I trusted her judgment and swallowed hard when I wrote her the check, but I was rewarded with a very fine stone.

Hank

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#24

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones

Brian Holcombe

That yellow stone is very nice looking. The dots are referred to as renge and usually indicate faster cutting. Nice that it is a full sized stone as well, without knowing anything about the origins of that stone (which mine) that one stands out. I know yellow color is generally more sought after.

I’m not much an authority on these stones, I just use them. I generally rely on So Yamashita or David for real info on the stones so I can’t offer deep insights :D

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal

#25

Re: Dan's Translucent Ark Deal—+photos of stones *LINK*

david weaver

Hi Hank - those are ohira tomae that either originated directly from Ohira or from Imanishi (who distributes a huge number of natural stones), who distributes a lot of ohira stones. It's possible to get stones directly from the mine if you're a big enough dealer, or if you want to chase the really expensive stuff (which isn't really ever worth the price - by really expensive, I mean stones with four figure prices).

The reason that the stone seems very fine with your japanese tools, but not with the western tools, is that those are sort of a middle of the road finisher. They rely on the hardness of the japanese steel to produce a fine edge, but can penetrate softer chisels more deeply.

You can improve the results you get from them with a couple of tricks:

1) bare leather strop lightly after you use one

2) work an edge lightly on an area of clear stone without slurry, back and forth a little, and then strop

3) let a spot on the stone get slightly dry and then burnish the edge on it

Honyama means that it was an original mountain stone. Until recently, most of them sold in the US say Ippon Sen on them, also, which means they are select or highest grade (even stones with no cracks or toxic particles), no voids underneath, sit flat, etc. None of these things are a given, so those stones have been graded to ensure that they're free of those.

They are favored by dealers because they can still be gotten in volume (either the mine is still open, or they have a ton of stock) at a relatively low price. Probably about $150 for a type 30 stone, perhaps a little less, and then resold or flipped for a reasonable profit while maintaining supply. Same with Atagoyama, they're still out in numbers, and now there are some off-main-mountain mines producing a lot of stones (iwatani, takashima, wakasa, etc).

They are now coming to the US through other channels and are relatively less expensive. For a while, Hida was selling them for about $400 type 30 size and something close to $800 for the type 24. there is someone on ebay (I suspect the former owner of Japan woodworker, who was always looking to make a huge margin) selling type 24 atagoyama stones for $800+ (they probably cost less than $200 at the dealer level in japan, because I can get them for $230 or so off of the japanese auction sites - they also originate from imanishi).

All that said, the Ohira tomae are decent stones, they're usually stable (mine delaminated - one of the ones from Hida, but that just happens sometimes, even when there are no visible cracks on a new stone and it's better just to repair and keep going than worry about it) and they're relatively predictable from stone to stone, so they're attractive for people to flip - or were. Now that they're showing up here for the price on the attached link (that is a japanese market imanishi stamp - no english, but it's imanishi), it's probably a little less attractive to sell them.

I've got some objection to what the explanation of the stone is in the ebay auction (they're not good for razors, they're not rare, etc) but given the price for the stone, that's not so bad. I don't favor so much Hida's selling them at $400 (I subsequently resold mine to someone for $150 - the most I could get for it, and it delaminated on them, to my horror), but we live and learn.

While the ohira tomae is sort of the king 6000 of the naturals, there's really no good suggestion that I have for anyone to go up the ladder to something finer, as the hand-picking dealers like So and others really charge a mint (or mint squared) for what they're selling. It's the economic reality of being a dealer if you're going to make any money, I guess. And, the stones are variable, so as much as a dealer would like to tell a buyer that they're getting the best (a common line), they're really left trying to find a fit for most of the stuff they're selling.

I flip stones on Etsy (but I wouldn't suggest anyone buy from me. I'd rather link people to the Japanese proxy bidding sites and help people pick something on their own), and I do relatively often get people who learn that the stones are not all the same, and they usually write telling me that I should do them a favor and sell them my best ("1 in 20") stone at cost (my term for those is 1 in 20. one in 20 stones is something special. Another 5 are really good, 5 more are good, 5 OK, and 4 outright junk), or they'll buy nothing - because they've already been had by one of the other well known dealers. I'm OK with the latter.


Linky