Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Dovetail - why does this happen?

Posts

Dovetail - why does this happen?

#1

Dovetail - why does this happen?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

What am I doing wrong that I sometimes end up with these little gaps that the red arrows are pointing to.

Just so you know how I do this...

What I do is:

Cut the tails

Put blue tape on the pin board

Put the pin board in the vise

Lay the tail board on the pin board supported on the other end with a plane

Mark out the tails with a knife

Peel off the tape where the tails go

cut/chop it out

This picture is right off the saw; no paring or fiddling to get it to fit.

Admittedly I am rushing this little project and being a little sloppy.

When you lay the tail board onto the pin board, should there be an ever-so-slight gap between the boards (on the inside of the boards). I think that is what I am messing up somehow.

Thanks in advance.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#2

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Joe, the simplest possible cause is that the baselines are not vertical. Check all of them for square.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#3

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks Derek.

I think I understand. You mean from font to back, right?

I use one of those Veritas wheel marking gauges.

I'll have to double check squareness front to back.

Thanks!

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#4

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

david weaver

Could be several reasons, but I'd suspect that tightness is the main culprit (but I wouldn't go nutty - a little extra glue and those are handsome - they're quite handsome as they are).

* So, tightness in the tails (to keep them seated)

* check the squareness of the pin board and make sure that the gap isn't tight at the back (which would prevent it from seating at the front).

Check the corners and make sure they're not tight at the corners and a little rounded. I work a tiny bit extra into the corners - not injuriously so, but to make sure there's nothing there.

But most of the time, if I am banging out a drawer, I think mine look less good than those, and I feel good doing them that way, because it's quick.

I'd split half of my time improving the fit (if you're looking for them to be show) and the other half experimenting with how to make them look good when the fit isn't perfect).

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#5

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

John Pappas

My theory....when you cut the pins you probably sawed on the knife line. You have to leave the line. If the pins were a tad fatter, the pin board would be wedged back into the baseline. That is how I diagnosed it when I had a similar result.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#6

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

Brian Holcombe

I suspect the same as John.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#7

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

roger lance

Joe.....there are numerous causes of dovetails not going together tightly.....sawing away too much material (sawing away the line).....leaving some material in the corners that stop the parts from coming together.....problems with the layout and marking.....

One potential problem that has not been mentioned has to do with your use of the chisel. When removing waste, it is tempting to remove a large portion of the waste at once.....if you are placing your chisel into your marked line and there is a significant amount of waste material left to remove, the chisel can be forced backward into and beyond your line as the chisel is meeting resistance from the waste as it is being tapped into your boards. This is one reason people use a fret saw to remove the bulk of the waste before chiseling. I've seen people sneak-up on the base line with their chisel by removing no more than a 1/2 mm or so of material until reaching the line. This helps to eliminate a gap in this area of a dovetail joint.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#8

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Agree, plus the chisel is backing up and taking out the baseline mark.

Here’s the main thing: when you mark the pins board down thru the tails, the entire mark is live wood and belongs in the socket. So when you saw, you want to leave the entire mark on the pins board. To put it another way, don’t split the line on the pins board, you want to just shave the line.

Second, referring to the photo, when chopping to the baseline on the tails board, the chisel is backing up across the baseline.

Beyond that, check whether the baseline mark is being preserved on both sides of the tails board.

David’s right—you can make this join work, especially if you use hide glue.

Wiley

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#9

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen? +1

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Agree here, looks like a case of trying to take too much at once with the chisel, and driving it past the mark from the wedging action. On pine I've seen the chisel driven easily 1/16" towards the baseline while chopping...

One of the reasons why I saw (most of) the waste...

DC

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#10

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The problem with your dovetails is not in the chopping. One can see quite clearly from your pictures that the bottom of the pin socket lines up very neatly with your scribe lines; a nice job of chopping actually. And one can see that tips of the pins protrude from the outside of the dovetails by the same amount as the gap.

If you put just a single dovetail joint together and bend the two boards together so they do not meet at 90 degrees you will get this same gap appearance. So make sure your carcass is square. You can also get this effect if the end of the board is not square to the face of the board and the inside scribe lines are referenced off the end. There is definitely something inside the joint that is keeping the pins away from the bottom of the sockets. Try putting your square inside a pin socket.

When I was first in business I did a lot of dovetail work, drawers and carcasses, for other woodworkers. I insisted that they cut everything slightly oversize so I could adjust the stock preparation. They would have been upset to know how much of my time was spent in this truing up, but this preparation paid dividends in the ease of joint making and the final appearance.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#11

sawing next to a line

Joseph Piotrowski

i just can;t do it! lol. my eye track right to that line and then so does the saw. so what i do when i transfer the line to the pin board i offset it by the thickness of my saw kerf and knife in the line. now i saw right down the line but now my pins, if anything are a little too snug. but that is easy to fix.

i picked that tip up from one of the youtube videos, like maybe rob crossman? i also make a small shoulder on the tails that help square up joint. somehitng i saw in FWW recently.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#13

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I think I understand. You mean from font to back, right?

Hi Joe

The square you need to check is inside the socket. I answered quickly, but Warren did a good job of explaining my exact thoughts ...

"There is definitely something inside the joint that is keeping the pins away from the bottom of the sockets. Try putting your square inside a pin socket."

There is nothing obvious from the outside that will explain why the pins are held out from the baseline. I do not consider that the sides are cut too tightly to "squeeze" them away - it is possible to see a slight gap at the sides. Ergo, there is an obstruction at the baseline, and this is propping the pins up. Remove the obstruction(s). It may be a convex surface at the baseline, which is common - that is what you use the square to check for.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#14

Re: sawing next to a line

steve voigt

Joseph, I understand your difficulty of not cutting into the line--it seems almost human nature, if there's a line, to want to cut into it. At the same time, cutting to the correct side of the line is actually a pretty important skill, and well worth learning. There are always going to be situations where you're either working right to the line (and not removing it), or removing the line entirely. In the long run, it's going to be faster and simpler to be able to adapt to whichever situation is required, without the need for jigs or additional steps. I watched the Cosman video you posted; my thought is that laying out dovetails is complicated and time consuming enough without introducing additional steps and complications, all to avoid having to think while we cut.

Looping this back to the original post, it's clear from Joe's picture that the main problem is cutting to the wrong side of the line, as Brian and others have said. It may also be true that the sockets are not vertical, but I think the baseline is the main issue.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#15

Re: sawing next to a line

Joseph Piotrowski

i agree its a great skill to have. but since it s hobby, sometimes you have to pick your battles. i'm not a young guy any more and there are limits of time involved.

i don't do everything like he does but, i tell you, making a shoulder and offsetting the kerf is the way i taught myself. now its a matter of process and really nothing but an extra minute is required.

maybe if i was making 20 drawers/carcass a day, i be concerned with speed.

the hardest rule is to remember the offset simple as lefty righty, righty lefty. i.e. offset left side, scribe right side.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#16

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks all for taking the time to respond to my question(s).

I don't do tons of DT's but I don't recall this specific problem.

Reading the responses made a light bulb go off though. I knife the line on the pin board, then (cheat) and use my bandsaw to cut away the wast very close to the knife line. Then I pare away even closer to the knife line, then lastly put the chisel into the knife line for one final paring away. I'm aware of how the chisel can move the line. That's probably the crux of the problem.

I have one more box to go. I'll do it this weekend. I'll keep your suggestions in mind.

Oh, and yes, I will be using hide glue and the boxes I've made so far, although not perfect DT's will be good enough.

Thanks!

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#17

Re: sawing next to a line

Brian Holcombe

Joe,

If I can be frank with you, don't be so quick to disqualify good advice. :D Learning the technique properly will do you well wether you cut one dovetail or 100. It's important because it is a staple technique of woodworking.

Dovetailing is one joint but the techniques involved can be applied to everything. if you cut a mortise and tenon you need to know to cut next to the line. If you plan around your saw kerf in each instance you'll confuse yourself and make either joints that are much too tight or firewood.

Sawing next to the line is one of the most important aspects of joinery and it separates the enjoyment of making good work quickly from the tedium of making handwork very slowly and possibly messy.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#18

Re: sawing next to a line

Joseph Piotrowski

you can be frank or Fred or who ever you like :)

i'm not saying to dismiss this advice and to not learn it ever.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#19

Re: sawing next to a line

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)



i just can;t do it! lol. my eye track right to that line and then so does the saw. so what i do when i transfer the line to the pin board i offset it by the thickness of my saw kerf and knife in the line. now i saw right down the line but now my pins, if anything are a little too snug. but that is easy to fix.

i picked that tip up from one of the youtube videos, like maybe rob crossman? i also make a small shoulder on the tails that help square up joint. somehitng i saw in FWW recently.

Hi Joe

I am going to be blunt - that method that Rob uses to offset is a load of unnecessary bollocks, and it is probably making the process harder for you.

Sawing to a line is the fundamental skill in woodworking, whether you use a hand- or power saw. There is no difference between these. One might argue that hand saws require more hand skills, which is true, but dovetails require so little wood to saw. A go-for-it-attitude is more important. And in this regard, the less complex the task, the easier it is to get on with it all.

The one area where I appear to complicate matters more is in transfering the tails to the pin board. To do this, I use blue tape, and this is simply because it makes everything easy to see. My aging eyes (I'll be 68 next month) need all the help they can get, especially with dark woods.

The blue tape makes the lines jump out at you once they are marked. You can peel away the waste areas, and there is no confusion where to cut.

The process of transfering the marks requires a sharp knife. It needs to be a single bevel type, as it will be pressed against the socket wall and cut alongside the wall. The finer the knife bevel, the closer the line is cut to the socket wall. I like the double- bevel Stanley knife that Sellers advocates, but for general use - never for slim dovetails! It simply cannot be angled to cut against the socket wall. The best knives to use are the type sold by Lee Valley (cheap as chips), Blue Spruce, and Chris Vesper. Or make your own.

Do not offset the marks. Just transfer board to board. The boards must not move. With the blue tape method you only need a light cut, and one slice along the tape (unlike marking directly onto bare wood).

Saw against the side of the tape. That's all there is to it.

I would never dream of deliberately leaving waste to pare away with a chisel. The more actions you include in the dovetailing process, the more chances there will be of screwing things up.

Finally, ensure that the baseline is flat and vertical. This process actually starts before you cut any lines. It starts with preparation of the boards themselves. The sides must be parallel, and the ends must be square. If they are not, you cannot mark square, and then you cannot pare square. Check the sockets at the baseline with a small square. You can even deliberately chisel a slight hollow in the socket wall at that spot. A hump here will prevent the two parts mating tightly.

Here are links to articles I have written on through- and half blind dovetails:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/HalfBlindDovetailswithBlueTape.html

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/ThroughDovetails3.html


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#20

bridger

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

Bridger

Is your pinboard cupped?

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#21

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

North of the Border

What is that dark line on the tail board? Is it a pencil line (if so why a pencil line there?) or a scribed line (from the marking gauge)?

If it is a gauge line, then it is VERY clear on my screen that you have chiselled (pared or chopped) BEYOND the line on the part marked by the first red arrow. Even if the two boards were at right angle (check that too as Warren pointed out), the gap would still be there.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#22

Re: sawing next to a line

Patrick Chase

Wait, he's laterally offsetting the tail board by the kerf thickness and then transferring with a small saw to create kerfs on the pin board?

Just when I thought I'd seen it all...

That seems like an awfully time-consuming way to avoid practicing sawing next to the line. I suspect that the "invested time breakeven point" is on the order of 10 drawers total, i.e. that's how long it would take you to recoup your investment in learning the technique that others here are suggesting.

Re: Dovetail - why does this happen?

#23

Re: sawing next to a line

Patrick Chase

Derek wrote:

> The one area where I appear to complicate matters more is in transfering the

> tails to the pin board. To do this, I use blue tape, and this is simply because it

> makes everything easy to see. My aging eyes (I'll be 68 next month) need all

> the help they can get, especially with dark woods.

I think the key thing here is that all the practice in the world isn't going to fix your eyes, so there really is no more efficient alternative to be had given your physiological constraints. Blue tape makes unambiguous sense in this context IMO.

I think that the question of whether to learn to saw next to a line is very different. It's really no harder than splitting it once you've got the hang of it, so other than the learning curve there's no constraint forcing Joe to stay where he is.