Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

One down ...

Posts

One down ...

#1

One down ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

So now i am interested in building Windsor chairs, starting with three bar stools for the kitchen bench. First I need the tools. I decided to make a few, starting with this travisher ...

Thanks to Pete Galbert (for the supporting emails) and Claire Minahan (for the video and emails). Claire has a video building Pete's design. She makes and sells these now. The video was made a few years ago, before the design was updated with a brass sole (rather, it used an ebony sole, which necessitated a slightly wider body). I chose to built it with the brass sole, which is where the extra emails came in.

The blade is O1, bent, heat-treated and tempered in my shop. The timber is She-oak.

Front ...


Back ...


Sole and blade ...


I tried it across pine grain ...


It was hard to stop :)


It works the same on hard maple. Forward pressure = light shavings. Back pressure = heavy shavings.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One down ...

#2

Re: One down ...

roger lance

What a great looking tool.....you never fail to impress me.....your capabilities just keep growing.....I'm amazed.

Re: One down ...

#3

Re: One down ...

steve voigt

That looks great, Derek. The she-oak is stunning. What radius is the sole?

I made one a few years ago, before the video existed. I wish I'd had it! Probably would have saved me a bunch of time. I did pick up the video last week at 50% off, since I'd like to make another with a larger radius--the current version has a 3" radius.

Have fun with your new tool!

Re: One down ...

#4

Re: One down ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

Claire's video was a big help in shaping the blade and then sawing the escapement. I then went hunting for anyone who had built a travisher with a brass mouth. Zip. I came across your blog. It is impressive that you made your travisher without as much to guide you as I had.

The blade in this travisher is as per the "standard" travisher, that is, 3 3/4" radius. It is actually the second blade I made - the first was bent inside a form based on the curve from the plan Claire sent. I did not take into account the spring back. I think it would do for a 12" radius! :)

I plan to make another, with a 5 1/2" radius, for smoothing out. But tomorrow I will build a 6 degree reamer, which will in turn be used to make a tapered tenon cutter. I have a bit of spring steel for the reamer and will use an old plane blade for the tenon cutter.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One down ...

#6

Re: One down ...

David weaver

Outstanding, Derek. Can't disagree with your comment about it just feeling right to make your own tools.

As my son says, "it do!"

Re: One down ...

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: One down ...

Jack Guzman from Maine

Nicely done Derek. I have been using a poorly built one but I have one of Claire's travishers on back order. I didn't know that video of hers existed til now.

I look forward to your progress in the windsor world. Please post your results,your work is always informative to look at as well as pleasing to see.---Jack

Re: One down ...

#8

Re: One down ...

Patrick Chase

That is a beautiful tool.

Out of curiosity what was your bending process for the iron? Did you heat it and hammer over a form or something like that?

FWIW the "springback radius" can be calculated fairly easily from the thickness and temperature. If the temperature is unknown then you sort of have to wing it.

Re: One down ...

#9

Re: Thanks Roger. You are always far too kind! 

roger lance

Too kind??.....were it so. I'm impressed with getting the two metal plates to confirm to that curve.....I'm guessing that those screws are helping those plates to curve as wanted. I made a panel gauge and used a piece of brass for the registration face.....the stuff deformed on me when I cut that piece from a brass plate....had a time getting it back to flat.

Got those CBN wheels installed.....


You influence a lot of us in many ways.....

Best wishes for the holidays.....are you off to South Africa??

Re: One down ...

#10

Iron-bending

Patrick Chase

While he may have been able to use the screws to hold the brass in a bent state, that wouldn't work for hardened O1 of that thickness. It's way too brittle for that.

You have to hit the profile pretty accurately while working in the annealed state, before hardening.

Re: One down ...

#11

Re: Formula

steve voigt

"FWIW the "springback radius" can be calculated fairly easily from the thickness and temperature. If the temperature is unknown then you sort of have to wing it."

Patrick, do you happen to have the formula, or could you point me to a source? I need to make a cold-bending form to use in a press, and some math would be super helpful.

Re: One down ...

#12

Re: Formula

Patrick Chase

http://www.custompartnet.com/calculator/bending-springback

I haven't looked at the math underlying that site, but it passes some rough sanity-checks (for example the springback for a small element at the surface of the metal should be reasonably close to yield_strength/elastic_modulus, and it is).

For a large radius like what Derek did the K-factor is 0.5. Wikipedia has a reasonable treatment here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bending_(metalworking)#K-factor. The "remarkable variation" that they mention only comes into play when the radius is a small multiple of the thickness or when it's nonhomogeneous (face-hardened one one side, for example). For a normalized steel with R > 10*thickness it's exactly 0.5 as far as you'll ever be able to tell.

Temperature mostly comes into play when it gets hot enough to change the yield strength, so I'm not talking about variations in room temperature there :-)

Re: One down ...

#13

Re: Formula

steve voigt

Thanks Patrick. Small problem: this'll be a sharp bend radius on the order of .020"-.035" or thereabouts. Is K still 0.5?

(cutting to the chase, I'd like to come up with a faster way to bend cap irons. A form and a press seems to be the way to go.)

Re: One down ...

#14

Re: Formula

Patrick Chase

Depends on the thickness, but unless it's 0.01" or less (which I find doubtful) then no, K won't be anywhere near 0.5.

Why are you trying for a bend that tight in a cap iron? Are you trying to create the initial "breaking profile" by bending? If so then I suspect that you'll have trouble controlling the dimensions well enough for that to work, and that you'd do better bending a loose radius and then post-machining the "fine features" at the leading edge.

There's basically no bending moment on the leading edge of the cap iron, so you can thin it quite a bit by machining without sacrificing overall stiffness/preload.

Re: One down ...

#15

Re: Formula

steve voigt

Patrick,

The radius I'm referring to is the arris of the piece of metal I'm bending the cap iron against. It is a pretty sharp bend, but I'm probably wrong about the radius.

I'll send you an email. No need to continue hijacking Derek's thread. Apologies, Derek!

Re: One down ...

#16

Re: Thanks Roger. You are always far too kind!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

How are you liking the CBN wheels?!

The brass and steel was curved to fit the wooden sole. It does so without the aid of screws to hold it to shape. I will show you in a while - will post pictures of the whole process.

And yes, off to Cape Town at Christmas. I have been doing this trip for 35 years now. Oz (we lived in Sydney, and then moved to Perth 29 years ago). My mum is still going strong at 94. My dad passed away a couple of years ago. He was nearly 101. Lynndys parents are also both in Cape Town. It is a beautiful city.

Keeping the beer cold for you in Perth :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One down ...

#17

A photo essay of blade making and fitting

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am being careful what I post here. Claire builds and sells these planes, and I would not wish to reproduce her methods or plans since they are her livelihood. I chose to modify the travisher in the video and update the design to match the latest one. To do so, I examined many photos on the 'web - almost all were by Claire, since it seems that few, if any, have built this version. I have suggested to Claire that she makes a new video ... although the current video is very worthwhile. What I will do, is post a few pictures of the processes that I needed to do that take her video a step further.

I started with 1" wide x 2.4mm thick O1 steel. You may make out my scratched marking ...


The cut out blank(this is already quite different from the video) ...


The jig to cold bend the blade ...


In compression ...


This is how much springback there was ...


This was the second blade I made. The first was bent around a template of the final shape, and with the springback was far from the desired curve. The second time around I was ready for this and just bent it enough to fit ... got a little lucky ..

How it fits ...


For heat treating I made up a small oven with some scrap stainless steel and bricks. The MAPP gas was only just hot enough to get it to the desired red.


... and then it went into the oven. Luckily my wife was busy baking Christmas cakes. I made sure she first sampled the brandy ... :D


This is the completed blade. Interestingly, when the steel is bent, it becomes concave along its length, which is like adding a hollow grind. This makes it easier to hone the back of the blade.


This is the jig for grinding the hollow. When the steel was flat I ground a shallow bevel - just enough that I could register the wheel on the centre of the bevel as I was after 30 degrees. (The eagle eye will note that the white Norton wheel is back - a rounded edge is needed to grind the inside curve).


The brass mouth was made in the same manner.

This is resulting hollow grind ...


.. and angle ...


Fitting the blade and brass mouth: the basic shape o the travisher has been cut out on the bandsaw. The fit between sole and blade is a little off ...


After rasps, files and scraping ...


Now with bolts ...


... into inserts ...


Mark off the area where the throat will be cut, and saw the waste for easy removal ..


Chisel it away ...


Clean up with rasps and scrapers ..


Now to prepare the brass mouth: the toe needs to be tapered at 6 degrees. The reason for this is to allow for a varying blade angle - if you rock the travisher back, it will take a deeper cut. Rock it forward to take a fine cut.

The disk sander is set up at 6 degrees off vertical ..


I masked off the area not to grind (I did not want to grind over the bolt holes), and tapered the mouth up to the edge of the mouth ...


Once done, all was screwed back together. Now we have a working travisher ... or should have ... so a test cut ...


And that's where we came in ..


Oh .. that is Rock Oak, and not She Oak.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One down ...

#18

Re: Thanks Roger. You are always far too kind!

roger lance

I just got the CBN wheels.....so, I'm very inexperienced with them.....but, I can see why others say they will probably never go back to the old friable wheels (except for an unusual sharpening/shaping job).

Best wishes to you and yours.

Re: One down ...

#19

My Snell & Atherton shaves

Chuck Nickerson

and Stanley dowel machine will thank you for this information.

It's time to start bending metal!

Re: One down ...

#20

Re: A photo essay of blade making and fitting

Patrick Chase

That's a very nice and precisely done bit of metalwork.

The white wheels are almost ideal for that sort of one-off application, since the friable binder makes them quick and easy to dress them to shape. I have one dressed with a semicircular profile (i.e. rounded all the way across instead of just the corners) for that sort of work, and for shaping larger hollows.