Follow up
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
All this is so personal.
I am not an experienced designer, so am cautious about this topic. I have been building for a few decades, but not many pieces since I only get into the shop on weekends. Two big projects and several small ones each year ... not enough to lend weight to being A Designer. Still, I think about design all the time. I do not wish to copy others. Borrow perhaps, but add something different, inspired. I believe many here share the same passion.
My style of choice could be called modern or contemporary. What attracts me is the emphasis on line and form, away from boxes, looking for the sweep, a curve ... something sensual to the eye, and to caress with the fingers.
Beauty lies in the eye of the beholder, so I do not expect others to share the same view as myself. Lines emphasised with fine, almost invisible mouldings, or without any at all. Minimalism is for me where there is just enough to create the form. Ornamentation comes from selection of the timber - colours, shading, figure - and their alignment, but done without detracting from the form. Design and planing of the way grain and figure flows forms an important part of a piece. Conversely, while I do work with some very figured woods, I also admire pieces - such as Windsor chairs - which are painted to focus attention on their form.
Design must also incorporate joinery. Traditional joinery has stood the test of time, and I am a big fan. Where possible, I want to use all the joinery of the past in pieces that are of the future. And yet, there are machines, such as the Domino, that offer a way to build designs that could not be done in the olde ways. There are machines, such as bandsaws, that permit the resawing of boards to form laminated curves. This is a hand tool forum, and we hear the argument that power tools cannot create the delicate details that hand tools can (I believe this to be true); still, without power tools, we can limit our imagination to what can be done with hand tools.
Design depends on the ability to visualise. In the absence of visualisation skills, one might create a model, or play with parts until the shape consolidates. I mull over designs in my head. I cannot imagine how this can be done in CAD, and am so envious of those that do. I keep telling myself that the images are limited by the computer program
Designs evolve, small modifications can excite me as the design comes together. Eventually I make a drawing to scale, using 3mm MDF sheets, cut out parts and glue them on. I have never made a scaled model, and probably never shall as I lack both the patience and the skill. In my imagination I see what needs to be done, and the MDF drawings - really a giant story stick - guides the process. The advantage of being an amateur means that they can be modified at any point.
Enough rambling for now.
Regards from Perth
Derek