Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

About designing and making

Posts

About designing and making

#1

Ellis Walentine

About designing and making

Ellis Walentine

Recently I received a query from an author who is about to be writing a book on furniture design. I thought you folks might want to weigh in on what would make such a book useful to you:

"In an ideal world, a working drawing (or 'shop drawing') is the dividing line between the design stage and the making stage of a piece of work. There is no shortage of books and articles on the making of a piece of furniture, but there is far less published about the design phase, from the initial conception to the working drawing. In a book about design, what would further your understanding of the process or be of help in designing a project?"

What think?

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: About designing and making

#2

Re: About designing and making

Brian Holcombe

I have some thoughts on the subject:

I do a fair amount of prototyping new designs, the process is not always so straightforward that the paper or rendered work becomes reality. I do work in that fashion but not always so I will comment on the times when I do not work in that fashion:

Chairs: As I venture further down the rabbit hole of chair making I find that drawings are near useless to me. The chair I designed and built on the blog is one example and I'm currently working on a dining chair, neither of which started as anything more than a very basic back of the napkin sketch.

Once I have an established idea, I worked from ergonomic measurements and adjusted until it was right and about the proportion I was looking for. I do this in steps quite often, not completing the design phases of good portions of a project until it is right in front of me.

The dining chair I designed recently, the back was a block of wood clamped onto it for probably two months while I stared at it and drew lines all over it until I could commit to something.

I work in this process often, the Butler's desk, for instance I did not design a great deal of it until I was well into the project. The desk stay wasn't designed until the entire project was nearly completed, it put much pressure on me to get it right and I enjoy that kind of pressure to some extent. I think a bit of pressure actually helps creative process, it provides boundaries and influences problem solving both of which are critical aspects of design.

Re: About designing and making

#3

Re: About designing and making

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ellis

A book on design is an interesting concept. I am curious to know whether the author is considering that the content is about original ideas and creating an original design, or about taking an existing concept and laying out its proportions in a pleasing manner. The latter seems to be more achievable - George Walker has written in this area. The former seems more formidable - what can be done to release and direct the creative juices? Any thoughts where the author is coming from?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: About designing and making

#4

bridger

Re: About designing and making

Bridger

I can divide my designs into two camps: stuff I do for myself and stuff I do for clients. Just because I need to represent to the client just what it is that they are spending their money on those designs tend to be more developed before I cut any wood. I'd imagine that projects involving larger teams would require proportionally more developed designs.

I always start with function. Once that is determined I find form and finish that complement the environment it will occupy.

Re: About designing and making

#5

Re: About designing and making

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I haven't made many pieces of furniture, so I may be speaking from utter ignorance; weighing the value of this comment should take that into account.

I've yet to do a drawing any more complicated than a few quick lines on a piece of paper; and, often, it's been in my head. I know there are many folks who won't pick up a saw until they've completed a drawing from which they can confidently develop measurements; but, just as many people try to avoid calculations, relying on direct measurement ("fit and cut") instead, I think there are designs, and people, that don't demand drawings.

Mockups are another method of understanding whether a design works. When I made the coffee table that sits in our living room, years ago, I determined the correct dimensions for the oval top by making samples from thin MDF and sitting them on milk crates, until I found the dimensions that looked right. The first one was too thin; the second worked.

I think there may be a direct relationship between the complexity of the piece and the importance of drawings: more complicated, more need for a drawing.

Some incoherent thoughts on a Monday morning...

Re: About designing and making

#6

Re: About designing and making

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Depends on whether the book will be about how to do the drawings themselves, from sketches to software, or whether it is a book about design itself. If it’s to be a how-to draw and render, I wouldn’t be interested, but if it is a book about design, I would find the following of interest:

1. A few plates illustrating Period-correct moldings, ornaments, feet, legs, pulls, inlay and banding styles.

2. A few style plates, illustrating examples of chests, desks, secretaries, bookcases, end tables, etc from different periods.

3. Typical drawings of carcase internals and how they are secured front, back or sides, for example, according to whether the carcase will have legs or slab sides.

4. Discuss how design affects assembly—for example, what is the order of march on cases with many internal pieces.

5. Chapter on foot styles and how the feet are joined to the carcase or base.

Wiley

Re: About designing and making

#7

Re: About designing and making

Oskar

I'm pretty green, and haven't completed many furniture projects. One thing comes to mind (which might be obvious and boring for more experienced makers).

When planning a project I usually spend a lot of time thinking and worrying about wood dimensions. Questions like: How skinny can a chair leg be, and still be strong enough or allow for strong enough joinery? How thick must a table top be? And the seat of a stool? If an oak table is so and so thick, how much thicker must my pine table be? What about the sides of a chest? Or the shelves of a book case?

Usually I can copy dimensions from other furniture, but when building something I don't own I have to guess. Most of the time I find it easy to see or feel when a design is to clumsy or heavy but I'm often insecure when erring in the other direction, like "will this hold up/be strong enough".

Often enough, when seeing plans for furniture these dimensions are given. But I'd like to understand them and not just go for 3/4 shelves, because the wood you buy is 3/4''.

This, the "construction" or "mechanics" part of designing furniture would be interesting for me in such a book.

Re: About designing and making

#8

Re: About designing and making

Josko Catipovic

Why does a Krenov cabinet stand out amongst hundreds of his students'? It's really his incredible eye for proportion and yes, beauty. It's only on closer look that shape is seen as beautifully coupled to execution and wood choice.

To me, that is the essence of design. It's an artform, perhaps trained for and refined in art schools. It's a quality I'd very much like to have, but seems to escape me in most pieces I design. I look back and wish the stiles were just a bit wider, or narrower, and this little thing, perhaps just a little more that way. I've built series of project t prototypes, each one learning from previous, and yes, on good days, they do converge towards something more pleasint to the eye. But I have a long way to go.

I would love to learn how to be a better designer, that is decide on piece sizing and proportioning in advance of the first build. I've done it enough to be able to fully appreciate the gift (of design ability) that some folks have and try to work towards some vestige of it. A book on how to help in this process would be invaluable.

Re: About designing and making

#9

Re: About designing and making

roger lance

I think you are hitting on something that is very important here and little discussed.....that is, when a piece is designed and a prototype is made, is that the end of it or are other improved versions made of the original design??

I generally only make prototypes....one offs.....and invariably, I feel that I could make improvements on a piece if I were to make another.....but, I rarely ever do.

I think a lot of the premier designers we hold high are makers who made numerous versions of their designs.....and made improvement upon improvement along the way.

I believe that it would be extremely rare to have the first design be the gold standard of a piece.

Re: About designing and making

#10

Re: making something really good...

david weaver

..on the first shot is an awfully tall order, especially if it has to be original enough that it's not attached to lifting established elements off of something else.

I think there's a big disconnect between what we do as hobby or small hire woodworkers and what it's like to be someone who makes magazine pieces.

I didn't comment on this thread because the constraints are too vague. Someone who owns a shop and has profit needs will have an entirely different view than someone who is designing a piece for their wife (Derek's lingerie chest comes to mind). Then, there's materials limitations, the size of the piece (and whether or not it can be moved fully assembled), the aesthetic constraints, etc.

Re: About designing and making

#11

Re: making something really good...

Brian Holcombe

The first shot is quite tough, I think that is one of the big reasons why guys like Krenov, Maloof and Nakashima were so skilled in this area. They made their same designs quite often, often enough to discard what they did not like about them and enhance what they did.

The first version of my art frame is quite lacking in detail that the more recent iterations provide. That's the benefit of making the same piece a few hundred times.

Re: About designing and making

#12

Follow up

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

All this is so personal.

I am not an experienced designer, so am cautious about this topic. I have been building for a few decades, but not many pieces since I only get into the shop on weekends. Two big projects and several small ones each year ... not enough to lend weight to being A Designer. Still, I think about design all the time. I do not wish to copy others. Borrow perhaps, but add something different, inspired. I believe many here share the same passion.

My style of choice could be called modern or contemporary. What attracts me is the emphasis on line and form, away from boxes, looking for the sweep, a curve ... something sensual to the eye, and to caress with the fingers.

Beauty lies in the eye of the beholder, so I do not expect others to share the same view as myself. Lines emphasised with fine, almost invisible mouldings, or without any at all. Minimalism is for me where there is just enough to create the form. Ornamentation comes from selection of the timber - colours, shading, figure - and their alignment, but done without detracting from the form. Design and planing of the way grain and figure flows forms an important part of a piece. Conversely, while I do work with some very figured woods, I also admire pieces - such as Windsor chairs - which are painted to focus attention on their form.

Design must also incorporate joinery. Traditional joinery has stood the test of time, and I am a big fan. Where possible, I want to use all the joinery of the past in pieces that are of the future. And yet, there are machines, such as the Domino, that offer a way to build designs that could not be done in the olde ways. There are machines, such as bandsaws, that permit the resawing of boards to form laminated curves. This is a hand tool forum, and we hear the argument that power tools cannot create the delicate details that hand tools can (I believe this to be true); still, without power tools, we can limit our imagination to what can be done with hand tools.

Design depends on the ability to visualise. In the absence of visualisation skills, one might create a model, or play with parts until the shape consolidates. I mull over designs in my head. I cannot imagine how this can be done in CAD, and am so envious of those that do. I keep telling myself that the images are limited by the computer program :) Designs evolve, small modifications can excite me as the design comes together. Eventually I make a drawing to scale, using 3mm MDF sheets, cut out parts and glue them on. I have never made a scaled model, and probably never shall as I lack both the patience and the skill. In my imagination I see what needs to be done, and the MDF drawings - really a giant story stick - guides the process. The advantage of being an amateur means that they can be modified at any point.

Enough rambling for now.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: About designing and making

#13

Re: making something really good...

david weaver

I think we get a misconception that the great creators just spring something out of their mind, stand over it and ponder a little bit, and there is a bit of that angelic sound when they're finished.

Then out pops a perfect project with no mistakes in it and no future design improvements.

Just about everything in the world has been the result of incremental improvement, and if we can drop our egos for just a second and allow ourselves to make something that we know we'll be able to improve the next time, we're better off. Our 10th piece is better, too. And you get the superbly satisfying feeling (especially if you're working by hand) of being able to work in rhythm with something you've already done a few times.

I guess if you made five of something and the fifth was great, someone on a forum would probably instantly tell you that they couldn't imagine building five of the same thing.

Re: About designing and making

#14

Re: making something really good...

Brian Holcombe

Absolutely, I feel very much that is a misconception. My wife and I went to Maloof's home and studio and participated in a tour led by the fellow who worked with him for something like 45 years. The tour is something I felt to be very honest about his progression as an artist and maker, some of the failures along with obvious successes.

I like to build the same projects over and over again (to some extent :D) for that reason. My client for the dovetailed bench detailed earlier in the year encouraged me to explore my options for improving the work. I've made a few of them now and that most recent one is considerably nicer than the first. The first is in my workshop.

I think learning what does and doesn't work in real terms, for each project, is perhaps the most insightful thing in design. When the design is abstract its actually quite difficult to make it very fine, but as the design becomes a real set of parameters it's far easier, IMO, to refine it.

Re: About designing and making

#15

Re: making something really good...

Josko Catipovic

Absolutely! I'm on my 8th sea chest right now, and loving the (2 yr) journey. It took a few to get size, angles and proportions right, then tills and drawers, then inlay...

It's been a wonderful journey with no end in sight. Only problem is I don't quite know what to do with all the sea chests. I like too much just looking at them and remembering the progression of thought and design that took me each step of the way.

At some point, the trick will be to take lessons learned from the seachests and incorporate them into the next furniture journey. I suppose that's how we all learn and get better.

While we're at it, I'd like to touch on speed and workflow. Long time ago, I got to watch Tage Frid work, and was awed by his speed and precision. So I get a lot of satisfaction of doing something well AND efficiently. As I progress through a sequence of similar pieces, it's a lot of fun to see my efficiency increase. There's also the part of not being afraid of the next crux move, the ability to dive into a tricky part without worry about 'what if's.

Not sure where speed and efficiency juxtaposes with design, but in my mind, they're quite related.

Re: About designing and making

#16

visual appeal is more than a mater of proportions

ian neuhaus

In an ideal world, a working drawing (or 'shop drawing') is the dividing line between the design stage and the making stage of a piece of work. There is no shortage of books and articles on the making of a piece of furniture, but there is far less published about the design phase, from the initial conception to the working drawing. In a book about design, what would further your understanding of the process or be of help in designing a project?

What do I think?

"Design" is the process of getting from an idea or nominated need to a rod or shop drawing.

Design includes the selection of the most appropriate joinery for the article. I know of only one reference which describes the joints most commonly used for different pieces of furniture.

Design is much more than selecting pleasing proportions and dimensions.

and design also includes ergonomics -- matching the users' stature and limitations to the purpose of the piece. Perhaps the simplest example of this is selecting an appropriate height for your workbench.

But perhaps the most important aspect of design is matching the visual and structural properties of wood species to the project. When to use something like white or red oak as opposed to cherry or maple. I'm sure we can all think of pieces constructed of white or red oak which which would look quite bland in maple or cherry.

perhaps bringing all the "design rules" into one place would be very useful.

Re: About designing and making

#17

One can alter a design,

Chuck Nickerson

either aesthetically or structurally, so something can be quicker to make. Doing so could sacrifice original aesthetic or structural intent. My guess is that part of being a great is finding the balance point.

As I gain technical skill my aesthetic vision is more completely realized on each piece.

(I'm using aesthetic instead of artistic so some people won't stop reading.)

Re: About designing and making

#18

Re: One can alter a design,

Brian Holcombe

I tend to agree. I often find that excellent design tends to consider efficiencies in its make. By that I don't necessarily mean that it should be simple or should be especially fast but that it should not consume to excess and that it should take the material properties into great consideration.

It's hard to describe, but when I look at things like excellent Sashimono it becomes clear to me that these are actually the result of aesthetic and efficient process coming together.

I suppose that is why items like the windsor chair remain very popular, even built traditionally, in a modern environment.

A windsor chair, in my eyes, is a marvel of engineering. It uses the properties of wood to its every advantage. It's also very lean in terms of design, they're not especially ornate.

Re: About designing and making

#19

Re: One can alter a design,

Patrick Chase

Brian wrote:

> I tend to agree. I often find that excellent design tends to consider efficiencies in

> its make. By that I don't necessarily mean that it should be simple or should be

> especially fast but that it should not consume to excess and that it should take

> the material properties into great consideration.

Oh come on, it's the Trump era. Get with the times, man. What you need to make is the furniture equivalent of a golden elevator.

Re: About designing and making

#20

Re: One can alter a design,

Brian Holcombe

Hah! It’s never too late to start gilding?

Re: About designing and making

#21

Clint Searl

Re: About designing and making

Clint Searl

Design considerations: Function – Dimensions – Features - Proportions – Scale – Style – Materials - Construction