Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Use of walnut for bench top?...

Posts

Use of walnut for bench top?...

#1

Use of walnut for bench top?...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello All,

I might have a source for some mostly clear ~4" thick walnut for making my Roubo bench top. The base is assembled and in place in my shop.

The walnut is ~7 years old, and is still in log form, but without the bark. I know a sawyer who would cut it for me. It would have to air dry more fully when cut up. I would like to use three pieces dowelled (not glued) together to get the width for the top. Makes the pieces just about maneuverable.

Question - is there some good reason not to use walnut for a bench top? It's reasonably heavy, local to me, available, looks nice, etc. Reasons for or against its use?

John

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#2

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

Tony - Memphis

Wow! Sounds good to me! I would love to look down at some walnut as I worked. Beats the stained hard board I work on!

Pictures!

Tony

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#3

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

roger lance

I'm agin' it: 1.) its soft and would get beat up....dented easily....etc. (some will favor this as it will be softer than most work pieces and take the abuse....not the work piece....I still don't buy this argument). 2.) its dark....makes things harder to see.....you want things brighter not dark and subdued for a working area.

Know that you may be making the last and only workbench you will ever make for yourself.....take your time.....use the best materials including hardware that you can afford.

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#4

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

david weaver

Dark, that's it. It's more stable than most stuff used for a bench, and if the darkness is a problem, you can bleach the surface.

if it's inexpensive, go for it, unless it's nice enough that it should be saved for something else. You can figure that out once you've sawed the log.

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#5

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

Paul in NJ

If you don't feel like it needs a higher use, go ahead. There is probably going to be a surplus with thousand cankers disease. You could always bleach to make it lighter. If you put the bench by a sunlit window it will lighten pretty quick. A plus is that walnut is pretty stable when drying. All that I have air dried had very little twist or cup.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#6

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi John,

As I recall, your shop is washed in sunlight all around, through large windows. If I’m remembering right, the walnut won’t darken the work area. I’d go for it, cause yours will be unique, like your bows.

Wiley

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Use it!

Jack Guzman from Maine

I would love to have a walnut benchtop. Easy to reflatten after a few years of abuse. Great to look at in your shop. I can't think of any downsides to a walnut top. ---Jack

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#8

Too dark.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi John

For about 20 years I worked on a bench I built out of dark Jarrah. It was OK, and I was used to it, but about 5 years ago I replaced it. The current bench has a top from European Oak. The difference (to my aging eyes) is truly night and day. The old dark top would soak up the light. The light top provides good visibility even when the light is less.

My suggestion is to use your Walnut for the base, and build a light top from something else. I like this colour combination, which is what I have ... Jarrah base and Oak top.

Photo below taken shortly after my bench was completed ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#9

Re: Too dark.

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Derek,

Good advice but the base is already done and in place in my shop. Just need to make and fit the top. Famous last words: "Just"...

The base has 3.5"x7.5" cherry legs on 8' centers (the cherry has bug damage but I oriented it so it can't be seen), ash stretchers 2.5"x7" front and back and locust side stretchers. When done, the bottom shelf will be white oak flooring pieces over plywood. Huge (think timber framing) mortise and tenon joints with drawbored pins of rived black locust. There are two wooden screw legs vises on the right and left front legs. Chops are of white oak. Can you say overbuilt? I got tennis elbow from building this behemoth. It is the largest and heaviest thing I've ever built!

John

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#10

Black Walnut

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Black walnut has a pretty good range of hardness and density in our area. I would take a gouge to the end grain or something to get an idea how crisp it is. The lightest stuff isn't much harder than poplar.

Also if the darkness is a concern, it will lighten up faster with no finish, which might be preferable anyway.

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#11

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

Brian Holcombe

I have a walnut chair so bleached that it looks like maple, it’ll lighten up quickly. Looking forward to seeing how the bench turns out.

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#12

yes!

Joseph Piotrowski

while i toil away on my $129 harbor freight bench to learn what i don't know.. i spent the last year researching benches. buying books, learning who builds them and what people actually use.

basically the only thing i have not seen used is basswood. there are only 2 kinds of benches. ones that are fine woodworking and ones you pound on.

i have seen some that are works of art that just floor me at how nice they are and i see 2x4 benches being used by craftsman. even a few store bought ones pop up in pictures.

so basically it comes down to your preference. i have noting against all the walnut, hard maple and cherry benches I've seen. if you want to feel inspired by your bench, 2x4 are not for you. if you plan to abuse it, screw things to it, etc. fancy wood isn't required.

my personal take:

i want to get the cheapest, flattest, thickest most stable wood i can get. it will work! i'm happy to build a 2x pine bench top but if i see some cheap walnut like you describing, i'm all over it! i'm actually considering a popular top because i saw some 12/4 12"wide boards. that would be great for a split top.. no glue ups, i could flatted it on day and have a bench!

i believe shop fixtures should be cheap and fast to make. money is finite and id rather make stuff with the best wood i can find, not my bench. now if you'll excuse me, ill go make a post about a premium chisel i didn't need to buy but did :)

p.s how cheap ?

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#13

that is too...

Joseph Piotrowski

pretty to be a workshop!

nice bench! and cabinets and everything i see :)

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#14

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

TomD

I would be on the use it side of things. Hard vs Soft, is normally also on the slick vs sticky, rebound vs dead inverse side of things, so you get and you loose in about equal proportions. Really what stops a bench top being mauled is whether you take reasonable care, the rest doesn't mater. On damage to your work, soft is more likely to hold grit that may mar it. Another thing where you don't worry about it, just work with what you have.

On light, while I defer to Derek's experience to some extent. I don't personally want glare off my bench. I would consider it a benefit that the light does not bounce up. But I haven't been there.

I fell in love with Roubo's before some of you were born, but I fail to see any advantage to them, and since Bench Craft got into the game even the cost advantage has spiraled out of control. I would do something more robust, like traditional heavy breadboards if I were trying to piece a top. My third bench has a two piece top, and I hardware bonded 1/2" studs into the endgrain, so that when they were installed, all that showed was an acorn nut. Super stout instant disassembly and reassembly, not that one does, but no chasing captured nuts makes me sleep better at night. Unless you have something substantial piecing the timbers, I would worry.

I got a big jolt from seeing some Japanese carpenters who had plane blocks that were not finished on the bottom. I had believed the thing about the blocks being soaked in Tung oil and allowed to harden off, but no, they left the bottoms exposed so they could tune them (a wag might say so they would have to tune them). But if you want to go for the snob appeal that comes from being more open technically, you might consider leaving the top surface unfinished (or get some trophy pics first). Then you can touch it up with a plane to refresh the surface, and to allow the higher frictional coefficient to help you out. This could also fit into your process of drying, though there might be some risk with the dovetails.

I cut a piece of 4 inch beech for a 5th bench. I don't have a place for one, though with the kids moving out, I may put one in front of the TV (what do you think about the new coffee table?). Anyway, the thing I noticed was that the weight stabilized in my unheated shop in under a year. There is some deal about how beech dries extraordinarily fast due to transverse pores. I guess!

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#15

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

Gregory v Forster


attch is a drawing I made of a Walnut workbench from Chickering and Sons piano factory. When I saw it, about 2010, it was located at the lobby of a corporate office in Rochester, NY.

I believe it came out of the auctions of Aeolian Piano Works (East Rochester, NY)

in the early 1970s. I remember going to these with my Dad; though I don't recall this bench and I had little interest in woodworking at that time.

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

#16

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Use of walnut for bench top?...

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Hi John,

I think Walnut is excellent, the look will be yours alone and I know under your skilled hands it will develop into a classic...

Take care, Jim