Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

Posts

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#26

Re: Cliff Stamp

david weaver

Not intended to slight anything anyone has made. I know most folks who make knives are almost obligated to make them out of something unusual.

White/Blue rikizai makes a really really nice low-cost slicing knife, but it doesn't get much regard. Same reason as others in my esoteric run ons - it's really sharp, it's plenty tough for its hardness if an experienced user is using it and it sharpens relatively easily.

This is my first foray into really examining sharpness with these knives, and using the same stones and then a strop. I thought they would all end up in the same place to start and am surprised that some of them will shed bits and pieces to linen and leather. The buck deserves a little more attention, but as it is, the shoulder needs to be relieved, and it will get less total angle instead of more once that's done, and that probably won't help. It could be something as simple as it not liking the al-ox that's in the dursol, though. That's fairly harsh on horse butt, but not a bad choice for rudimentary finishing on a stainless knife. Anything finer is too slow, anything more coarse is potentially big trouble.

My first shot is always a mid-range (inexpensive, mid range in terms of grit) slurried japanese finisher that's got a hard surface and a bit of particle release. It's the easiest way to keep a knife in shape, but this one is a bit far off in geometry to go right to that because it's not cut that quickly by it (indicating pretty good hardness for a brand of knives that gets knocked from time to time).

At any rate, store it and use it sparingly? stainless. Use it all the time? Still carbon steel. Powdered is perhaps an interesting alternative, but a lateral move at base so far for functional use. Crediting Wiley for talking about things we actually do with knives (cutting boxes, stripping wire, etc), the one stone thing with the wharncliffe in carbon steel...really tough to beat. Same thing with japanese knives. If I were allowed to keep my blue 2 santoku out, once a month on something like a suita for three minutes and no steeling, and no anything else. No gadgets, no gimmicks and no..."eh...kind of sharp".

re: the razor talk, most wild custom razors are made by knife makers because they see it as a way to increase their market. As warren would probably suggest, those makers don't get enough experience with the old stuff before they set out making all kinds of oddball stuff. The person I talked to had some custom razors in tow that they'd never used themselves, and I'm sure they sold them. No slight to the makers, they're trying to do something creative, but it's not a great place for freelancing. The super makers know enough not to dash in. I can think of a super maker....george :). I asked george if he'd like to fiddle around and try to make me a razor after describing what I'd found in my best (spinework, a bit of weight, great proportions, a super delicate grind), and George said "no...it would take too long to get good at it. Too specialized". Smart man, he is! I know he could do beautiful classy hand filed or die-made spine work. But there's a lot he could do that he hasn't.

And since I'm indulging myself, I still get a chuckle out of the richmond addict powder metal knife that's NLA (it was sort of a plain single bevel chef's knife that was $400 - not necessarily out of line for a knife that would've been perfect). "It's really expensive, and it's really hard to sharpen and chips easily, but it's a great knife!!".

Takeshi Kuroda sold me my blue steel tanaka santoku for $65. My wife cut her fingernail off without noticing that she did that, and I took it away from her and she quickly banned it from the kitchen. No blood was shed so no real foul. I use it to scare guests on special occasions when they boast about how sharp their knives are when they sharpen them. it is sheer pleasure to use slicing vegetables, but it always gives guests a little pucker that I'm sure they'd work around if they just spend 3 minutes getting used to it. So far, nobody has.

This has been an interesting departure where I've mostly posted my thoughts out loud - something kind of rude :) But the metallurgical scope has opened up all kinds of interesting looks back at stuff I'd shelved. And a reminder that i need to unload some of it before I forget about it again.

And, once again, Warren was right. So were all of those nutty craftsmen in japan who insist that efficient sharpening and carbon steel are the pinnacle.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#27

Re: Cliff Stamp

Brian Holcombe

I'm always tempted to pickup a general purpose and fairly inexpensive Japanese kitchen knife, given such limited use as it will get currently I hesitate. A Chinese cleaver would be very regularly used in my house but I've found two varieties of those and the low end are just terribly bad.

I take no offense of course, it's been a very long time since I've made a knife and I always did want to try exotic materials. I still have a small pile of exotic woods that I picked up for that purpose and a few pieces of steel.

I tend to agree with George on the razors, I also imagine it takes some time to really find your bearings as a maker. In fact this might be a good break from plane making for yourself.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#28

Re: Cliff Stamp

david weaver

I'd love to make razors, but have no clue how long it would take to get good at it, and i'm not sure how one would heat treat them reliably. I think manufacturing has for a long time used a molten lead setup to heat and an oil quench, as well as wet grinding wheels (some of the current boutique makers use abrasive paper, but I haven't seen any who really make something that competes with a very good vintage razor in terms of geometry).

The fear about getting good at it instead of just making a bunch comes from the fact that Dovo says they can't find enough people able to do it and willing to continue doing it (despite the amount of equipment).

But it has the very attractive trait of being dependent on hand and eye and subtlety, as well as rewarding repetition (which planemaking does, too, though you can take some of the hand and eye out of planemaking as you get further toward manufacturing - I guess - I'll never get that far).

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#29

Re: 154CM repeat

david weaver

Boxing something up tonight and decided that while I was downstairs, I'd work at this knife with a different regimen since it was so close.

Diamond ("6500 grit" dry on a charnley)

Then a japanese barber hone that just isn't quite up to razor work

Then green chrome ox pigment

Light leather


You can see the grooves from the diamond. This edge appears to be polished to the naked eye

The one thing to notice is that the very edge is even, but I think given the unevenness and deep grooves just back from the edge, it would release stuff.

Much sharper than prior, though. Time wise? The tidioute gets every bit as sharp as this in a matter of a minute. Total time on this edge from the state a tidioute comes in is at least 5 times as long, and in all honesty, it's a bit shy of where the tidioute is off of a slurried japanese stone. I'd dread resharpening it on a routine basis. A sloppier regimen would be fine, but this is neat work in terms of evenness of the bevel. I've got most of the original factory issue problematic geometry erased.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#30

Re: 154CM repeat

Brian Holcombe

That is a very nice looking edge!

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#31

Re: it takes a good eye

david weaver

...to see that there's even a finished edge on that knife, anywhere :)

To call that finished bevel economical would be a bit of an understatement! I'd love to have that knife hardness tested, but it's harder than I thought it would be. Even a friodur razor will yield to a slurried japanese barber hone pretty easily, but this thing is pretty resistant.

I can stuff it away now and maybe give it as a present to some hunter in the future since it was cheap. I used to hunt, but I'm too lazy and impatient (my version of hunting is more like a natural walk with a rifle).

Regular use of a knife like this, and I'd probably set up a paper wheel with al-ox compound on it. It just doesn't make sense to me at this point over a carbon steel knife.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#32

Re: 154CM repeat

Patrick Chase

6500 grit is about 2 um depending on whose numbering system you use.

As you say that's a bit too coarse for diamond because of the deep, "crisp" scratches they leave. I usually go to 0.5 um on diamonds for that reason, whereas I think that 1 um is perfectly fine for AlOxide. SiOxide can safely be even more coarse than that IMO.

As Brian says that is a very nice and uniform edge. I think it's a good example of "maxing out" the media, by which I mean that it's been thoroughly worked with nothing missed, and there probably isn't anything you could do to improve it without using finer abrasives.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#33

Re: strength for the carbides...

david weaver

..would be improved if the extremely tiny refined edge (which is the product of a japanese barber hone and then light stropping on chrome ox and leather) was increased in size.

That would slow down the ever annoying instant shed of the edge carbides a bit.

But to be realistic, I have felt the sharpness of the knife that my father used to skin and gut enough animals to feed any of us for a quarter of our lives, and except for a new knife, it was never better than medium crystolon.

So, we're just playing.

What's annoying about this is in the prior version, I subjected the edge to 3 micron aluminum oxide (fresh dursol) and it couldn't hold its carbides with that.

In the old days, I'd have traded this knife with a local guy who had a camillus air force knife sans blood groove :\

Actually, that is the knife my dad used to do most of his animal cleaning, and even on an old silicon carbide stone, it was quite nice. He also had an older stainless knife, and I can still see/visualize the wire edge that was on it from the same silicon carbide stone. Don't remember the brand, but it wasn't generic. The camillus knife of vietnam vintage was really nice.

(and no clue about the quality of the diamonds in terms of consistency, but they're on an oilstone now and it, too, could release a particle here and there that would make the deeper grooves shown.