Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

Posts

More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#1

More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

david weaver

Not that this really proves anything, other than exactly what's shown in the pictures.

(Brian offered me space to post these pictures, but it's still easier for me to use the postimage site - I'm a bit tired - apologies if you don't want a Russian bride).

Total width of the photo represents about 2 1/2 hundredths of an inch.

Another picture of the Iles chisel that had the bubbles. I seem to have sharpened most of them out and can't find any of the big ones. Maybe it's just a spot thing:

https://s1.postimg.org/5it8b0ebof/Iles_Chisel.jpg

After additional rehoning - fewer bubbles. Presume this is washita based on the lines (edit, a look at a larger picture and I can tell this was a translucent arkansas):

https://s1.postimg.org/5q97km9c9b/Iles_Chisel_-_Rehoned.jpg

Footprint UK chisel (these are now Chinese made, i believe). Red acetate handle, delicate beveled sides. Really a nice chisel. No bubbles at the edge, but is that one at the top? I didn't rehone this, so there's a little damage at the edge:

https://s1.postimg.org/8zl2vg1epr/Footprint_Chisel.jpg

I think tracked down a japanese chisel (not an expensive one, this one was one I got directly from japan in a set of ten for $80 (does that make it an $8 chisel?). This is after chopping a plane mortise. You can feel the damage at the edge and just barely see it with the naked eye:

https://s1.postimg.org/5jvihj2cj3/Japanese_Chisel_After_Mortise.jpg

No bubbles. Then what I normally do with these (since the mortising is a pretty rough process and a fairly large volume of wood) is 15 strokes or so on the washita. The edge isn't perfect after that, but it'll do another mortise and come back the same as above, and you can do this indefinitely.

https://s1.postimg.org/8q0j8t3ci7/Japanese_chisel_after_mortise_-_15_swipes_washita.jpg

Digging out some more modern stuff, an LN A2 iron honed on the washita (I wanted to see if I could see evidence of carbides not being cut. I can't, they're probably too small, anyway)

https://s1.postimg.org/9bmy99vy5b/LN_A2_-_washita.jpg

Bubbles (up the bevel and not at the edge those at the edge *do* look like large chunks....carbides?)!!

Patrick speculated that the washita may be pulling out carbides, I don't know is that's true or not. Maybe it is? I figure the voids are probably around a thousandth. I can't see them on the iron with the naked eye. So, I honed further with a trans stone:

https://s1.postimg.org/19oi8u4f5b/LN_A2_-_trans_ark_honing.jpg

Though it doesn't look that special, if you look at the evenness of the edge, you can see that it's very even. I planed with this later and the shavings were less than a half thousandth. I'd speculate they were around 3 ten thousandths of an inch. As much grief as oilstones are given for not sharpening A2, I'm not really seeing it. This sharpening process is much less time than the jigged "charlesworth method" that I started with on waterstones:

Moving on - "Wiley's knife", the fallknaven knife referred to elsewhere here. Don Ho approves!!

https://s1.postimg.org/7e731ggb73/USB2_3_M_UE301000054_20171023164724.jpg

This is the factory edge. Quite interesting - a very steep tiny microbevel at the very edge (you can tell that it's steep because it disappears in darkness when the bevel itself is at the right angle to reflect), and it's nicely sharp out of the box.

That may lead some to wonder if V11 also has these voids. i didn't rehone this iron, and am not sure what I used last, but it wasn't a synthetic stone or it wouldn't look like this.

https://s1.postimg.org/1wr8rt78vz/PM_V11.jpg

No bubbles on this sample. I'm not surprised by that. Very different post-honed look

And lastly, because so far, it appears that the modern stuff that's not forged japanese stuff contributes bubbles, I tracked down my oldest functional iron. A butcher iron that is probably from 1820 or so (guessing based on the maker of the plane).

https://s1.postimg.org/9ieoocxxhb/Butcher_-_Early_1800s.jpg

(pardon the dark marks, I think that's fuzz or junk from wiping the oil off of the iron with my jeans).

No bubbles, though I did find some areas of prior corrosion that looked a bit like the voids in the above pictures. None of the above items have had any rust, though.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#2

Fascinating. When I ask my wife

Chuck Nickerson

for a microscope for Christmas, I won't mention your name.

I now want to do this with my blades and sharpening routine.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#3

Re: Fascinating. When I ask my wife

david weaver

I have to admit that I thought it wouldn't be helpful at all (aside from the comment below about razors), but I've seen a bunch of stuff that I didn't expect to see.

I flip razors on etsy from time to time, as well as natural stones. What I really wanted was to be able to confirm that the razors were set and sharper than the person who gets them will have ever seen (it's not quite as simple as it is for tools, and it's also the point where you separate good razors from razors that aren't that great so that you don't get a bad rep).

Instead, I've seen all kinds of odd things. The only thing i don't like about it is that it pretty much focuses on one thing, and if what you're looking at isn't reflective, it doesn't see much. You can tell by the picture of the veritas blade that I couldn't get it to appear at the proper angle, so the photo is dark.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#4

bridger

Re: Fascinating. When I ask my wife

Bridger

When I started honing razors I bought a $25 usb scope via eBay. It is fussy to get a good shot with. The base it comes with is useless. However once you work through those issues it can be a useful tool for imaging edges.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#5

Re: Fascinating. When I ask my wife

david weaver

It definitely is. Those scopes are pretty much all the same, and I used one for a while. You can get quite good with one and there's no fixturing issues because you can just put the scope on whatever you're looking at.

But they're not quite strong enough and clear enough to get the last little bit of resolution that you need to be able to tell a defective razor from a decent one.

They will, however, tell you absolutely everything else you'd need to know for a sharp edge on anything else, and for tools, they are a multiple of what's really needed in terms of magnification. Mine cost $11, but the stand was junk (probably why it was so cheap), so I just use it by hand.


I just took this picture of the 2 on a ruler with mine. The focus isn't great, so I reduce the picture size instead. For $11, it's awfully good, though, and it supplies its own light.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#6

Modern vs. Modern Vintage

david weaver

I didn't have the big scope set up, so I took a couple of pictures with the small scope.

This is the fallknaven knife first, after grinding some of the shoulder off with a silicon carbide stone and then sharpening with arkansas stones.


It looks like the last bevel is really steep, but it's not. I sharpen knives with oilstones like this, rounding the shoulder (but not steep rounding, just a product of hand honing), then a tiny bit of fine work with the final stone and then a leather strop.

A view of another section (it's hard to get a good picture with this scope because you have the scope in your hand and focus at high magnification depends on the scope pretty much touching whatever it's looking at, so all of the operation has to happen with one hand - holding the scope still on something that's not held down, turning the focus wheel at the same time with the same hand, and then using the other hand to tell the computer to catch an image)....anyway..another section. What this results in is a sharp edge (and this shaves hair easily, even though it's powder stainless), but a hair here or there will get missed.


And here's a tidioute. This is 1095, which is an awful lot like vintage steel. I'm sure you can get bump imported 1095, but I doubt tidioute is using cheap stuff because the blades are so small. This is a new knife (I didn't have my daily carrier handy), so I didn't hone it to remove the shoulder. Not sure what they use to sharpen these at the factory but the bevel is both very well polished and very steep. It equates to an edge that doesn't feel that sharp.

Note also that despite the very high magnification (probably 100x), the finish above the bevel is very fine. The entire bevel is finished that well. As I've been gushing already, I don't think they make much money per knife, their level of fit and finish is so far above everything else without being amatuerish like a big wide convex grind that you'd see on a benchmade knife or some other giant hunk of metal.

No bubbles on this.

I have run into these things at random so far, the bubbles on this, the bubbles in the AI chisels, the possible carbides being removed from the A2 from LN. So far, no japanese chisel and no vintage steel has had any bubbles in it.


Though there's nothing advanced about 1095, I've seen several technophile knife user reviews where the reviewer has bought a GEC 1095 knife and remarked how well the knife cut and how it cut far longer than they'd expect 1095 to. There's no magic going on, these blades are just appropriately hard (I think they told george they shoot for 60 or 61 or something, and I haven't seen that on any other 1095 knives, even though some claim it. Other 1095 knives that I've had sharpen very easily and quickly on oilstones, which is a tip off that they're not close to 61).

I'm still sticking to my comment that the japanese steel is the best quality I've ever seen, the good vintage stuff is between, and the modern stuff is lacking.

When I get the scope set back up, I'll get some more irons in it.

I'm surprised that fallknaven would not check something like this. This is a utility type knife, so it's no big deal, but it's the kind of thing both the steelmaker and knife maker should catch on QC. It is, though, a hard knife and it holds its burr with vigor, so I'm sure it will wear well. In good 440C, though, the knife would cost a third as much, and could potentially be better. The knife, with plastic handles and hex screw fixturing is essentially $1 worth of knife and a lot of $s worth of laminated powder metallurgy. But the powder isn't delivering what it should as far as quality goes.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#7

The other

david weaver

This is the other tidioute, my daily carry around knife.

There is actually bubbling on the surface of this one as you go up the side of the blade, but.....

...wait for it...

...it's only because this knife has actually gotten some light surface rust a few times and after you buff it off, it pretty much looks like what's on the fallknaven knife. No such thing once you work the bevel, though - the simple steel is pure at the edge, and at proper hardness, plenty durable.


This is a functional edge from a cheap japanese finisher, and it's shiny at the very edge after stropping due to the burnishing by the leather. I never sharpen with anything else other than a slurried finisher - just one freehand bevel. In terms of sharpness, it's a silent shaver from both sides. If you miss a patch shaving in the morning, you can take care of it with this while you're walking around the house.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#8

Re: The other

Brian Holcombe

David, out of curiosity do you have any knives made of ATS-34?

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#9

Re: The other

david weaver

No. I'm not really too much of a knife enthusiast. I did get a 154CM knife by chance a long time ago when I was just looking for a "made in USA" folder and ran into a buck "hunter" on clearance.

I didn't hunt down the composition charts, but see a knife site that says it's a lot like ATS34 (actually, it sharpens well enough that I thought it was a carbon steel).

And, I have VG10 in a chef's knife and like it a lot - like really a lot. I see that it's not that well regarded by people who believe you need wootz to cut a marshmallow, but it's a lot like the tsunesaburo irons - rikizai and really good and really easy to care for - sharpens on anything.

Those accurate thoughts? (VG 10, 154CM sort of being the same?).

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#10

Re: The other

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I sharpen kitchen knives, butcher knives, hunting knives and the like, as a courtesy to the neighbors. I have done several ATS-34 knives. The steel is much crisper than other stainless steels, not nearly so gummy on the stone. I use older carbon knives for myself, but ATS-34 is not horrible like other high chrome steels.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#11

Re: 154CM

david weaver

Though I haven't used ATS 34, I saw a website that said that 154 CM and ATS 34 are the same steel.

I didn't even know the knife that I have is a stainless grade (the one in 154CM).

VG 10 is only a little behind (but sharpens well on oilstones and strops nicely).

I sharpen kitchen knives for people in the neighborhood and my wife's friends, but it's uncommon for me to get anything as good as ATS 34. Henckels international, etc, is the kind of thing I'm used to seeing, but I'm not running a business like you are, so my exposure is a lot less.

(Lots of posts while I was looking that say 440C, 154CM and ATS 34 (and VG 10) make a low durability knife and are out of date. I can't imagine that anyone who knows how to sharpen anything without getting out some kind of robotic contraption would ever have that thought).

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#12

Picture of 154CM

david weaver

With the small scope.


Nothing untoward on the edge other than some aspects of the blade itself (geometry - the shoulder is close to the back of the knife and the actual edge itself is concave a bit along its lines - both of those would need to be addressed in the long term). I have seen far worse, though - there is a notch for relief, so it's not immediately "unsharpenable" like some knives are (when I sharpen knives for people, the hard shoulder kitchen knives that are beat up at the back of the edge are always a pain - I usually grind the shoulder, but some people get offended by that. I have no clue how someone would use a knife like that, though.

Anyway, the look of this knife is found here:

http://www.budk.com/Buck-Rosewood-Folding-Alpha-Hunter-Knife-2349

This is a US made knife, though, with rosewood clad handles, liner lock, relatively large and a button to open. As I recall, it was $45 or $50.

http://www.budk.com/Buck-Rosewood-Folding-Alpha-Hunter-Knife-2349

Not classic style, but again, there's far worse out there

It could be sharper, but I'm sure my dad never used a hunting knife as sharp as this one is at this point (he sharpened a camillus survival knife with a mid grit silicon carbide stone and that's it). We ate an awful lot of deer meat when I was a kid, so the urge to sharpen is not because it needs it. I did find a washita stone in my dad's gun cabinet, though, and we cleaned it off and now he sharpens his knives properly - and he no longer hunts.

Anyway, this is a knife too nice for me to use in the shop, which is bizarre to say. It's four times the size of the fallknaven knife and a little more than half the cost (but it'd be probably equal in cost now if it wasn't on clearance). I plan to keep the fallknaven knife in the shop. From what I recall, also, this buck knife is not fully hardened if VG10 knives are a reference point.

Another thing rare about it is that it represents a time when I found a bargain at cabelas (which is near the in laws)...That's something I rarely find.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#13

Re: The other

Patrick Chase

154CM and ATS-34 are pretty similar. You can safely think of both as "440C plus Molybdenum".

VG10 is a somewhat different beast. Much less Molybdenum, but with some Cobalt and Vanadium added.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#14

Steel obsession

Patrick Chase

w.r.t. people claiming that these steels are "obsolete", there are always folks on fora who get waaaay too carried away about having the latest and greatest.

I think it's easy to lose sight of the true magnitude of improvement from newer steels. ATS-34 is good stuff. Yes, you can do "better" for some definitions thereof these days, but the gains are fairly marginal in the larger picture.

Also, everything looks good right after honing, provided the person doing the honing is competent.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#15

Re: Steel obsession

david weaver

Yep, I agree with that, and with all steels.

You can make anything look great off of the stones - stuff that's loose still stays in place. Some of it, though, yields a little bit even to the strop - and more than just a bit of a shiny edge.

Unfortunately, some razors are like that, too - edge looks OK, but doesn't stand up to a strop. Never have been able to solve one of those.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#16

Re: The other

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Warren, David and Patrick.

I've actually made a few knives from ATS-34 but it's been so long I can't remember if it's a steel I really enjoyed but I remember it being preferable to some of the more extreme alloyed steels like BG-42.

I used 440c at the time as well but had a bit of an exotics obsession so I also had used D2 (awful) and BG42 which truly holds a dull edge forever.

I was mostly curious if it would have those bubbles under the scope and I'm glad to see the comparable steel does not.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#17

Re: The other

david weaver

Well, so far the bubble count:

* Iles chisels - and not all of them. May have just been a defective spot. The bubbles first discovered were not uniform in shape and some took up a very large part of the scope view. Perhaps almost a hundredth

* the fallknaven (I'm sure I'm spelling that wrong at least half the time) knife - probably just a defective batch or low QC. V11 doesn't have those bubbles. The knife will work fine for what I like (much like wiley's list - pretty much anything at hand) and I won't have to subject my prized tidioutes to the shop and rust potential.

* LN A2 - could be carbides

I doubt we'll see anything from crucible, carpenter/latrobe or hitachi like that, though.

I'll really "get after" the buck knife later and see what the maximum potential of the 154CM is after a strop (as mentioned in another post - everything looks great off of the stones and compound, but the strop will take a little off of lesser steels and hard tempered razors - or razors that are flat out defective). Just a little line and very few gap disturbances is the mark of a good steel in razors. On knives, well, I don't know if the angle is gradual enough to matter. It's easy to make an edge on a chisel that looks as good as my best razor edges, but the angle is almost twice as steep, so the effect on a hanging hair is much different!!)

Thanks for the discussion. I had sort of set this knife aside (I gather sypderco and benchmade are the preferred knives for low and mid-cost knives, but I don't love either of them and buck reminds me of my childhood when every brass and rosewood knife engendered the question "is that a real buck knife or a cheapie"?). I see also that benchmade specifies a fairly wide range of not very hard for a lot of the exotic steels. If you're going to put S30V in something and then make it 58 hardness, I don't really get it.

re: the 440C, I have read a little that part of the issue with it is that it's so rewarding to skill and care in the making and heating and tempering. That can be a good thing in the hands of the right smith, but not so great overall. My chinese stockman from boker is 440C, and it's not cheese soft, but it's definitely not hard! Not sure what GEC uses for stainless, probably 440C, but would guess that by tradition, it'd be a touch soft to sharpen on natural stones.

(a knife by friodur made at the same quality level that they make their razors would be just lovely).

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#18

Re: follow up picture

david weaver


Probably more improvement available, but it does let a little more go to the strop (bigger pieces - leaving some tooth) than carbon steel does.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#19

S30V at Rc58

Patrick Chase

Using a steel like S30V at lower hardness actually makes a LOT of sense, if the maker's objective is high toughness with decent edge life.

The overall hardness is principally a property of the iron matrix. S30V contains a fair bit of Vanadium Carbide (Rc>90) no matter how it's hardened, and those carbides provide a lot of wear resistance even if/when the surrounding matrix is fairly soft. By tempering to a lower hardness the maker therefore achieves good toughness while retaining good wear resistance.

That's actually the *entire* point of high-alloy, high-carbide steels like S30V (or PM-V11, or HAP-40, or A2, or D2, etc etc). Their heterogeneity allows otherwise impossible combinations of toughness and wear resistance precisely because they don't sacrifice as much when used a bit softer.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#20

Re: follow up picture

Patrick Chase

Yep, that's going to be a fairly "chunky" steel.

Do you happen to have a comparable shot (same edge angle and sharpening method) of PM-V11? I can't remember what you've posted along those lines. Both it and 154CM can be broadly described as "440C-like" steels, though they diverge from 440C in rather different ways.

Note that edge angle is a critical variable when looking at carbide chipout like this.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#21

Re: follow up picture

David weaver

Edge angle is probably about 35 degrees, maybe 40, compared to the razor edges I'm used to looking at at less than half.

This would actually be a better knife with zwillings cryo 440 at razor hardness, which isnt the same as their knives.

I can't tell of the knife is dropping those carbide when being stropped on dursol and then chrome ox, or if it's giving those up to the linen and strop. Maybe a little of both.

I haven't driven v11 up through a razor process, but I'll give it a go. It tolerates oilstones without odd failures just fine.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#22

Re: S30V at Rc58

david weaver

I don't disagree with any of that. The floats that LN makes out of S7 are another good example of really good toughness and not chisel-like edge holding.

But what I'm whining about (and that's all it is) is that you take some of these steels and you make them 58 hardness, and then they drop their initial edge and they really don't hold that keenness. I guess that's not the point of them, but then they fail in real life cutting tasks compared to something like GECs 1095.

I saw several more reviews of Tidioute knives where people did a cut test in something like cardboard and found the 1095 to match high numbers of what they had with other knives that were alloyed. Except the profile of the tidioute knife is better for something like that (slicing), because it's thinner, and I'm sure that has something to do with being able to drive it into relative dullness - but on top of that, the initial edge is better as is most of the wear profile until it's really dull.

All of the heavily alloyed knives that I've run across just give up that initial edge, and the only steel I've seen that really keeps it is high tungsten steel (T1, perhaps or something else similar to old high speed steel - almost impossible to find and to my knowledge, not rust free). T1 will actually sharpen nicely on natural stones, but if you do a test on something really abrasive, it probably won't hang with the high chromium and high molybdenum steels (or are the V series vanadium? I'll admit I haven't looked...they must be, because something comes to mind...that in a second).

At any rate, the failing of good carbon steel blades for cutting and slicing (which is most of what we do) is two fold:

1) when they're offered, they're usually not hard enough. Ontario specs 55-58. 55 is a good hardness for a machete, but it won't hold a fine edge. I suppose if you're selling knives to people who abuse them, then that's what you do. I'm sure they have a reason, because tidioute is going 60-61, but perhaps it wouldn't tolerate a 12 year-old trying to cut a bridge cable and may fail spectacularly

2) they rust. This is actually pretty easy to keep ahead of in a knife that you look at more than once per week, but not so much for one that you might store somewhere and look at it once per year.

So, anyway, it's the resistance to sharpening stones combined with the desire to give away that initial edge that I don't like about the really wear resistant steels. AT 58 hardness, they're probably eminently sharpenable by a wide range of waterstones. At 64, they would not be. Probably the vanadium carbide steels are only easily sharpened by CBN and diamond, anyway.

But, man, all other than the friodur razor stuff seems to be really lacking. I have a henckel's chef knife that's intended to be steeled and says "ice hardened". It doesn't match their older razors in terms of quality, and i'm not sure why. And that's hardness aside - it chips a little.

The fast refresh, the tolerance to a strop and keeping that uniform initial edge is really the top of the heap. But it doesn't allow for all kinds of things that don't enter my head, like saltwater (a need claimed more often than actually needed, I'm sure), disuse, inability to sharpen, etc.

I like the softer 1095 knives about as much as the ones with big carbides. They're just missing it. Kabar stockman as a reference point - probably mid 50s hardness. George had a hard one and recommended it to me, and I bought a used one that was a bit of a basket case due to prior rust. It just wasn't hard enough to hold a good edge, and it took a tooth off of natural stones because they have an even battle with 60-62 hardness, but they cut 55 or so deeply.

Back to my story. Quite often, people send me messages on the straight razor board looking for free advice in oddball cases. One of them is a guy who's just about driving me nuts right now, because he bought a thousand dollar stone from alex gilmore (I suspect it's a fast stone that requires a specific technique to sharpen a razor) and he's trying to figure out how to use it. I sell cheap razor stones on etsy (not plugging here, this crowd isn't my target) to try to set up new shavers with a tested stone that doesn't cost four figures or even low-mid 3 figures when it really should be $75-$125, etc. I tell all of these people (with razors) to buy a well ground vintage razor, find one straight and either buy a stone like I'm selling from me or someone else. I don't even care if they buy from me. This guy has literally sent me about 125 emails asking about technique. I'm sure one of my tested stones would solve his problem, but he's reluctant because he bought a fast (and fast means more coarse in the world of natural stones) kiita bench stone. I don't want him to buy from me to make a profit, I want him to buy from me to stop sending me questions!!! Simple steel and a simple stone - rub them together and shave for a while. That leads in to this...

Another person on that site who is a moderator sent me a message. He offers to sharpen peoples razors for a fee. Someone sent him an S30V very heavy custom razor. Both of those are non starters:

* There's no virtue in really heavy razors. That equates to a large bevel and is counter to what you want in ease of sharpening. Heavy is done with custom razor makers because they don't have the skill that european cutlers worked so hard to perfect (and later, japanese cutlers trying to improve on western razors) - the double hollow with a very fine singing grind. You strop it, it rings. The heavy ones sound like rubbing a pet rock on a pair of fruit of the looms. Nothing.

* S30V apparently doesn't take an edge from anything that people use for razors.

I'm guessing this guy spent several hours screwing around trying to get something out of the S30V, and each time he stropped it, it probably gave up whatever he achieved to the linen and leather (and wasn't that good to start). I gave him a talk about the carbides and abrasives, told him to find diamond powder or solution if he'd bought some in the past, and the said he'd dig (and eventually found something). Then I told him to sharpen the razor with the finest diamond compound that he has, strop it very lightly, test shave with it and if it's OK, ship it and tell the buyer that if he likes buying $500 massive razors for display, that's OK, but they're not going to be very good shavers unless they're made of something people would've made razors from 100 years ago. I told the sharpener to skip using anything natural on it (escher hones are popular finishers with razor people, for example), and people don't necessarily like that because with razors, especially, predictable and consistent is important. But si02 and vanadium carbides, no point.

He did that, sent me a message of "phew" and then that was it. If the customer of his had bought a $30 vintage zwilling carbon steel razor, he could've shaved with it for a lifetime, rubbed it on a stone twice a year and subjected it to linen once per week and leather daily.

I feel kind of the same way about the "good" 1095 pocket knives. If you can rub it on a stone a little bit, and buff off budding corrosion, nothing else is as good. But it has to be hardened fully to be "good", and it usually isn't. thus my constant gushing about GEC, and the tidioute sub brand wall street knife (which is a lockback, and given as sharp as they get, a lock back is appreciated).

If I had a sailboat that I stored at a marina and used twice a year and just wanted to put a knife under the dash, I'd have different considerations. Just about everything else folks do with knives (splitting wood, etc), I generally have better tools for, and as many times as I've been in the woods (grew up in the woods) and made a fire, it was always a whole lot easier to start with small sticks and work to large and split nothing.

Very long winded way of saying, yes, I recognized the virtue of the carbides, but they take away the two best things on a good knife - that instant sharpening that you get with a wharncliffe lockback (for example), and the ability of the knife to hold that initial edge and fail uniformly once it does (rather than letting go of hunks).

(V11 wouldn't make a good razor steel, just a hunch. That's also going through my head as I mention these properties. Not because it doesn't sharpen finely, but it probably doesn't when you get to that level of sharpness and that acuteness of angle - but because it really holds onto its wire edge. It's not a "dry" steel - a term that's been used on here quite a bit).

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#23

Re: S30V at Rc58

david weaver

Vanadium comment - I looked at the alloy (S30V), and it does have a fair amount of vanadium in it, but a lot of chromium and molybdenum.

That's enough knife searching for me. After finding that people, in all seriousness, make knives and sell them for high dollars with the name (and claimed purpose) of counterterrorism knives, and then go into goofy explanations about carbide precipitation, etc. (do the terrorists care if the knife releases a few carbides?).

I found one post that I really pretty much agree with, apparently a bladesmith that's been in business for a long time, and expects his customers to cut with the knives and be able to sharpen them. Quoted:

I suppose that if dropping your blades on the concrete is something you want to do......but I don't think its very viable, simply because its rather unrealistic.

If anyone ever came to me with a damaged knife and told me they had intentionally dropped it that way, I would tell them that they are on their own.

I personally think that all of the "testing" you see and/or hear about, like stabbing a car hood, slashing a 55 gallon drum, or bashing a concrete block, is about like trying ice skating uphill....its counter productive to common sense, and pretty ridiculous.

A knife is a cutting tool....its not a prybar, its not a screwdriver, nor is it a can opener. The primary function of a knife is to cut, hold the edge reasonably well, be easy to resharpen for the owner (this is something that many knifemakers seem to miss), and withstand the "abuses" that it encounters while being used for its intended function.

OK, now that my rant it over, I do think its important to test the blades that you make, but it is also important to test them in a realistic manner.

Dropping a blade, point down, on the concrete isn't something that a blade would normally encounter during use...and if someone where to do it intentionally, that constitutes abuse in my opinion. I've handled and tested my fair share of blades that boasted of their ability to cut through a car hood or smash a concrete block, and without exception, none of them were even close to being what I would consider an acceptable cutting implements. In order to endure/survive that type of abuse, the edges are super obtuse, the blades overly thick and heavy, and the grinds utilized are often counter productive to a cutting tool.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#24

Cliff Stamp

david weaver

I don't really know who cliff stamp is, but I got a comment from him on youtube at one point, because I asked if people thought a quarter inch convex grind knife that weighs almost a pound was a good thing to slice tomatoes with.

Brief conversation, I told him I ventured into the knife videos after watching something else, but the car wreck rubbernecking thing caused me to watch a few videos of people trying to cut the lip on a 55 gallon drum, as well as punching through sheet metal, etc.

I told cliff that I wasn't impressed with knives that are hard to sharpen but that lose their edge, and then tracked down his page. He had a large amount of testing that he'd done where he found that for one reason or another, a lot of the modern knives didn't deliver what their alloys should have (either the metal was low quality, the heat treating was low quality or the manufacturing after heat treat had rendered the knives a failure). They remained really difficult to sharpen.

As he described, few people actually use the knives they bought so such things can be sold and carried for a long time without anyone being wiser for it.

In my separate post re: S30V and counterterrorist knives, I sort of get the point if someone is actually walking around with a rifle and they carry their knives much and use them almost none. Though, not sure why they need to be S30V - the cheapest stainless at saw temper would be fine.

As for my buck knife that I was prepared to call a win for modern CPM154, I'll give it rust resistance, because I'm sure it has that. Aside from that, it's inferior to a knife made of the same steel as the butcher iron pictured in the pictures thread. And that's too bad. The natural order of conclusion so far YSS products (revise that to be of the simpler types since hitachi apparently makes all kinds of powder goods now) > good vintage steel > modern steel.

Re: More Pictures - Modern Vs. Vintage

#25

Re: Cliff Stamp

Brian Holcombe

Thanks for your comments above!

Wrt knife usage, I agree infact very few of the knives I've made for myself have gotten much use.

I'd venture a guess that kitchen knives are truly the knives that are really used. Even my super delicate sushi knife gets more real and practical use than any of the custom Bowie knives I've made.

The most serious ametuer chef that I know of gives preference to vintage English made carbon steel blades, without much concern at all for patina. Second to that he prefers carbon steel Japanese blades.

Survival type knives always seem to go the direction of comparing fact sheets, but knives like the ka-bar are just 1095 and tempered to 56-58.