Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

Posts

Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#1

Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

david weaver

Talking about the Fallkniven knife with the powder steel blade.

I found one on ebay for $76 new, and received it over the weekend.

The powder steel is interesting, and they put the tiniest microbevel on the knife and it actually arrives sharp - and it's hard, too. I accidentally forgot that it was stainless (I remembered it being powder carbon steel for some reason) and sharpened in on the washita, and it took quite a nice edge.

I put it under the metallurgical scope before sharpening it, just to see how it looked. It, too, has "modern bubbles" in the steel, but who cares? It's an interesting little very light weight knife with a dandy blade on it.

I don't think it will unseat the Tidoute Wall Street for pocket space, though.

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#2

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

Thought you was gonna wait til Christmas! That’s what I told myself: I’ll just wait til Christmas like David. But then I saw one offered by an Amazon affiliate—the bone-handled model—like new—for $5. I jumped on it, knowing it was too good to be real. Sure enough, the seller realized before the knife got out the door that some nitwit had mispriced it. Then he had to sit down and write a cock and bull story about why he was cancelling the sale. I decided it was for the best, because I had begun to gloat about it, and the evil eye was sure to take note.

Meantime, I had ordered the Wharncliffe bladed knife that Joe Shelton recommended, the Case Seahorse, the stag-handled model. It arrived, and was quite sharp as delivered. The thing is, this Case knife is an art object. Amazingly beautiful. So far, I can’t bring myself to put the final hone on the blade.

Still gonna get the Fallkniven bone handle. Christmas. David and I can use them to cut electrical cord to length and scrape solder off and such.

Meantime, it’s our 50th anniversary year, so I’m mostly showering my wife with stuff.

That’s it for now.

Wiley

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#3

C'mon, use it in the garden too! 


Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#4

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

david weaver

Congratulations on your 50th!

I didn't know there was a bone handled fallkniven!! that's OK, this knife will probably exist in my shop. There are lots of time when you're making a plane where you just need something that's sharp to do a little bit of scraping, and a small knife is just the thing.

I was going to offer you my second Wall Street knife, but sometimes I feel a bit awkward about things like that. Buying the case sort of heads that one off at the pass, and Case still makes good knives that in my experience walk and talk the way they should.

re: the amazon folks, I believe amazon offers those vendors (the ones who made a mistake) an out. An honest vendor would just admit that it was a keypunch mistake or a listing mistake and apologize.

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#5

Bone handled Fallkniven

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

It’s the TK3 model, in jigged bone. Same cutting steel as yours, with blade a little longer at 3”. They run between $250 and $300, and most dealers are stock-out right now, though you can find them at the higher prices. It’s ridiculous—who needs a $300 pocket knife??!!

https://www.fallkniven.com/en/knife/tk3/

Well.....

Wiley

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#6

Re: Bone handled Fallkniven

david weaver

At that price, I'm a plastic handle buyer!!

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#7

Re: Question For you Wiley

david weaver

I went out and looked up the case that you mentioned.

What's your opinion of its walk and talk? When I went through a rash of stockman knives (I think I probably bought 8 to find the best one or two i wanted to keep), everyone told me that case knives were old news and no good. I bought puma, two queen knives, an older schrade (old timer or something?) and two bokers - oh, and an old kabar on George Wilson's suggestion.

Only the case had good walk and talk - the blades rubbed a little, but I don't care about that (it was $33 and everything else was perfect). The puma was OK (reasonably hard blade but extremely hard opening - not safe with something as sharp as a knife should be), the small queen was nice even though the steel was a commodity stainless and soft. I thought the D2 queen was a real disappointment - it was loose and the ability of the steel to have a decent cutting edge was very poor (you can sharpen it to really sharp, but as soon as you cut something, the edge goes). As much positive press as they were given as being a better than case knife, it definitely was not that.

The great eastern cutlery knives are like a better version of Case. George turned me on to them at the time (the wharncliffe #99) - i didn't want to spend $95 on a pocket knife, but he said "I couldn't make a better knife for $1,500". The trouble is that they often make a run of something like that and then you either see it again several years later or not at all, and then resellers drive price of anything desirable but out of production way up.

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#8

Re: Question For you Wiley

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

I will post a couple photos of the Case Seahorse, once Flickr gets online (they go offline sometimes). It’s very beautiful and my pictures don’t come close to doing it justice. But photos help.

That said, this Case knife talks but doesn’t walk, unlike the older Case’s. Knife fora say the ‘surgical stainless’ is Latrobe 420HC. The HC stands for high carbon, but Latrobe says 420HC is 0.46% C, which limits its hardenability to the upper 50’s. The knife people, who always sound like they know what they’re talking about, say that Paul Bos, when he was at Buck, did wonders with 420HC, in part by cryo-ing it, thereby converting all the carbon to martensite before tempering. Don’t know whether Case is doing something similar. Your Fallkniven, with the cutting edge of true high carbon stainless, is at 62 (according to Fallkniven).

Blade opening is not hard, but is reassuringly a bit stiff—I prefer this. The three blades—and you’ll see this in the photos if I can ever get them up—are polished to a mirror finish. No grinding marks at all, except on the bevel. The knife comes quite sharp from the factory, will slide through Post-It’s, but not the LA Times—will require a little polishing for that.

I would say overall, that Case has produced a work of art that will serve well as a gentleman’s knife. I’m glad I have it; it’s the one I’d like my son to have, as opposed to the abused knives I’m inclined to keep in my pocket.

Would love to hear the take of Joe Shelton or Patrick on this knife. My opinions are based on zero experience actually using the knife, and I could be dead wrong limiting it to ‘gentleman’s knife’ status. It may be much more than that.

Wiley

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#10

Re: Couple photos

david weaver

I think it looks great, wiley.

If you ever want to try one of the tidioute lock back wall streets (wharncliffe), let me know. They are a brand, in general, to pick an example from at some point......at least as long as they continue to go as they are now and don't lose focus.

Like the stag on the knife you pictured. Has a good look but not so deep on the dark part that it's absurd.

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#12

Re: Couple photos

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

I’ve been looking for Tidioute or Northfield with Wharncliffe. Finally found this one in stock at KnivesShipFree. The second blade, same length, is a Wharncliffe:

https://www.knivesshipfree.com/great-eastern-cutlery-48-northfield-un-x-ld-improved-trapper-sambar-stag-26/

It’s on its way. Thank you very much for the inspiration on Great Eastern!

Wiley

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#13

Re: Couple photos

david weaver

That looks like a fantastic knife, Wiley. Beautifully made. I love the bevel work they did on the spine.

What I like most about their knives is that they are not only beautifully made and tight, but they put details on a knife that's a little over $100 that just aren't on any other knives that are anywhere close in the price range.

I really do like case (and case are a lot lower in cost - there's another case or two that I'd like to have), but the combination of finish and style that GEC has on their knives is really a step above.

I have a red micarta knife that I'll have to fish out (tidioute) that has, I think four wharncliffe or two wharncliffe and two sheepsfoot blades. It's a dream knife for someone who likes to sharpen straight blades.

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#14

Re: Couple photos

david weaver

A terrible picture, unfortunately, but beautiful knives.


They look a little dirty because I have oil on them.

The left is the wall street knife, I'd have sold it to you before your binge started for original cost ($92), but must admit that the knife you bought is much more of a looker. This wall street knife is the best simple lockback I've ever used (my daily user is a bit dirty, but if it gets a spot of starting discoloration on it, I just buff or polish it off and 3+ years later, I think I'll have it for decades).

I've seen some unfavorable thoughts about the square ends, but I've never noticed any discomfort. If I did ever lose my first one, I'd immediately regret if I ever sold the second.

The cuban stockman (cigar shaped body), I didn't remember - I thought it was micarta or acrylic, but it's red jigged bone. Each blade is perfect in walk and talk, but I've never sharpened it. I think it was only about $110 about the same time (3 years ago).

I looked through my pile, I still have the older queen knife (which doesn't have wondersteel but is a better knife than the D2 version I had), the case stockman, a lockback "rough rider", and two boker stockman knives. (And another tidioute stockman in a container). In the shop, I use two "coast" lockback knives I got from home depot for $15 as a pair, or maybe it was $8. Either way, they are cheap and they make a great tool for scraping handles, etc, in areas where you can't get a card. There's no guilt in zipping them over the belt grinder and buffer to clean them up .

I think you'll find that your tidioute is just about the most ideal hardness for japanese stones, or a washita. Few modern knives are. They're softer. I hesitated to get my first one because I'm so cheap, but I've not heard George Wilson gush about another knife and when I got it (the wall street was my first one), I was boggled that it can be made in the western world at that level of finish for $92. For size reference, it's a bit bigger and quite a lot heavier (due to the handle) than the fallknaven knife, but slim and extremely comfortable in the pocket.

The boker stockman I think was probably sort of a waste even at $22 for the tree brand, and the chinese version was $12. It is surprisingly well made, but the blades are soft. I've ground the sheepsfoot blade on both to work as a marking knife, because I always like to have a marking knife in my pocket walking around the shop (if building something that's not just at the bench). My floor is my "biggest bench", and i hate to get up and down mid work to go fetch a marking knife, and the fixed blade knives aren't quite so safe to just stab in your pocket.

All that said, I really admire the look of the knife you just ordered. The look from above with the blades closed is super. I hope you get one of their best ones (though I've never gotten a bad one).

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#15

Gent's knife w/ stiff backbone

Joe shelton

I have several of the pattern because I like the type so much.

Most of mine do not walk and talk with 'clicks' at the midpoint. Two of them do so, and all have definite pauses at the midpoint when closing.

With one exception, mine have the Case surgical steel, and it performs well. One of my older ones was sharpened exquisitely and then misplaced for a long time. When I found it, it was still so sharp that hair leapt off my arm to avoid it. That was late in 2004, and after occasional use it continues to be sharp, without further stoning or honing.

The one other blade is Damascus. Haven't sharpened it yet. I missed on the models that had ATS 34 blades.

The knife is large, stout and carries comfortably in the pockets of all the trousers I wear. The Wharncliffe blade is massive, and competent at every task I've set it to. The pen and coping blades are marvelous complements to the big blade, giving thin, flexible blades to do lots of fine work.

All the blades are set at ideal angles from the handle, allowing either power or fine control.

Lastly, the darn things look good.

That's my view of the Case Seahorse Whittler.

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#16

The stiff backbone

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe and all,

One of the things to love about this knife is the thick spine on the main blade. I thought I’d show a photo. Here’s the knife again,

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/37969086281/in/album-72157688411634134/

And here is a view of the ‘spine’,

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/26193550719/in/album-72157688411634134/

That ‘spine’ is better than 1/8” thick at its base, 0.15” to be exact, almost 9/32”.

The knife is very pleasing.

Wiley

Re: Who Else Bought "Wiley's Knife?"

#17

Re: The stiff backbone

Joe shelton

Wiley, I'm tickled that you like it, and glad I mentioned it to you.