Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

New tools..

Posts

Re: New tools..

#26

Normal Day to Day Testing

david weaver

I understand that LV tested irons with MDF (at least that's what I recall hearing).

Years ago, I received an IBC iron and tested it after several honings against an also new LN iron. I was comped the IBC iron, probably because the retailers selling them hoped that getting a bunch out there would equate to free advertising.

On the package was a statement attributed to Cosman (though I think anonymously) that said that the "ibc iron lasted many times longer than brand x" or something along those lines (maybe someone with an old package would find it). I thought this was sort of a strange comment because it's A2. Unless it's defective (and my shepherd iron was defective), there's relatively little practical difference.

I stroke tested the two irons. I don't have the document, but found the LN iron to last longer because it chipped less. On a piece of maple about 20 inches long, I ended the session of 2 thousandth shavings (advancing the iron as I was working if the shavings did not continue to measure 2 thousandths) with 770 or something with the IBC and around 1100 with the LN, Perhaps it was 1050. I remember that it was 4 digits. Would the result have been different after an eighth of each iron was used? Possibly, I don't know.

At any rate, that is what I would consider to be a practical test. There's no cocobolo with visible silica particles in it that look like tiny diamonds, no MDF and no planing across the end grain of something janka 2700. 99% of the stuff I plane is somewhere between softer cherry (low quality) and hard maple.

It took quite a long time to plane the 1800 or so strokes that i planed with an LN smoother and those two irons, and it was careful work to try to perform all of the strokes identically.

Before we conclude that V11 lasts to the moon, I would like to see a test like that. In "normal" wood that most people plane. Not across endgrain, not MDF. I think the V11 irons are very good irons, but in planing plane billets, I didn't see what I was expecting to see and couldn't get through a full try plane billet, which I can always do with a try plane that has a butcher iron in it, or the second one that I made that has a mediocre greaves or hearnshaw bros iron in it. The difference in that case is the plane - less friction and a bigger shaving out of the try plane. Perhaps full throttle planing of the beech makes something like a 7 thousandth shaving (I can do a hundredth in cherry full width unless the cherry is exceptionally good and dense). I couldn't do as much with the V11, but still expected it to outlast the try plane, and it did not. A2 would not have, either.

I haven't had V11 and tsunesaburo irons at the same time, but recall how far the tsune iron would go in the dullness cycle (maybe v11 would, too) without giving up cut quality and without having to lean hard on the plane (sometimes that's useful, maybe you have a board foot or three left to smooth and just want to finish the job).

Beach's work is the closest thing I've seen to showing something that lines up with my experience. Most of the other accelerated tests are biased toward wear resistant steels because they're using something more abrasive or abusive than normal work.

(the other thing I noticed is that several times I read that the ECE primus planes had an iron that was really hard wearing. And that they solved "all of the problems with stanley planes". I found them to be pretty unimpressive, both the plane and the iron. The style of the plane is nice, but it's available in vintage planes for very little money, without the adjuster, and without the very mediocre irons that don't wear that long and leave lines all over the work. I see that Brent's page came to the same conclusion, and I'm glad to see it. I also had a terrible shepherd iron, but it was usable - it was thick and A2, slow grinding and didn't hold an edge very well. I'm not sure that brent's version is).

Not accusing LV of anything untoward. I think they had to choose a testing procedure that could reasonably be completed, and they did, and they came out with a nice steel at a reasonable price. A bit better than the best A2 iron that I've used, though in plane irons, if I didn't have 10 panels to flatten with two irons and do five with one and five with another, I'm not sure I'd notice. It (the difference) appears to be more stark with chisels.

Re: New tools..

#27

Stress and strain...

John in NM

The one thing I remember clearly is that the stress/strain moduli do not change (in general at least) with different heat treatments - O1 has the same modulus of elasticity regardless of heat treat, ie it takes the same force to deflect it. It's brittleness is modified by the heat treatment however.

Whether this extends to PM materials I don't know, but I would expect it to do so. The PM steel may seem "weaker" because it breaks, but what does that matter? Same force applied to produce a broken blade or a severely bent one, who cares? Either way you have a ruined blade! :D

Re: New tools..

#28

Re: Stress and strain...

Patrick Chase

That's right, all steels have elastic moduli of 29 +/- 1 Mpsi. This means that for a given geometry all steels will develop roughly the same external stresses at the same deflection.

Where steels differ is in their tensile and ultimate strengths, and also the difference between the two. A soft steel with low tensile strength will fail elastically at lower deflection, but it may fail by bending instead of breaking, which is advantageous in the specific test David described.

Re: New tools..

#30

I don't see the advantage of bending

John in NM

Plastic failure is what he described - and a knife is just as useless bent as broken. Depending on the application, both are often characterized as failure. In some applications a bending failure is more desirable, yet still a failure.

To my thinking, the test described is pretty pointless. A more interesting test would demonstrate that some blades can behave elastically under the conditions which either bend or break other blades.

Bending or breaking blades with no measurement of the forces applied and the point when deformation changes is a pretty dull test if one wants to actually find the better steel.

Re: New tools..

#31

Re: Normal Day to Day Testing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I stroke tested the two irons. I don't have the document, but found the LN iron to last longer because it chipped less. On a piece of maple about 20 inches long, I ended the session of 2 thousandth shavings (advancing the iron as I was working if the shavings did not continue to measure 2 thousandths) with 770 or something with the IBC and around 1100 with the LN, Perhaps it was 1050. I remember that it was 4 digits. Would the result have been different after an eighth of each iron was used? Possibly, I don't know.

At any rate, that is what I would consider to be a practical test. There's no cocobolo with visible silica particles in it that look like tiny diamonds, no MDF and no planing across the end grain of something janka 2700. 99% of the stuff I plane is somewhere between softer cherry (low quality) and hard maple.

It took quite a long time to plane the 1800 or so strokes that i planed with an LN smoother and those two irons, and it was careful work to try to perform all of the strokes identically.

Before we conclude that V11 lasts to the moon, I would like to see a test like that. In "normal" wood that most people plane. Not across endgrain, not MDF.

David, that is YOUR idea of testing. You and Brent can stroke away 2000 shavings per blade. Good luck to you! :) I do not have the patience for that, and believe that there are more efficient ways to test an edge.

Lee Valley's idea of planing MDF is very reasonable. It offers an abrasive surface (quicker wear = quicker testing) that is reliable, reproducible, and fairly universal. It's not Real Wood, and this bothers you.

The fact is that one is unlikely to find a real wood board that another will be able to plane that is identical for all. The best one can do is set parameters that others can understand and infer from.

What did I do? I chose a wood that I knew to be abrasive and used the same piece for all blades. I used a shooting board (Stanley #52) as this controlled the action of the blade on the wood. I used the same plane (LN #51) for each blade. I sharpened the blades at the same angle (30 degrees). All that differed was the blades: Clifton O1 (about 10 years old); Smoothcut (about 10 years old), and PM-V11 (about 2 months old). If anything, the PM-V11 was at a disadvantage with respect to chipping, as it was the newest. The other two blades had long been worked past the brittle area.

All blades could pare end grain pine to start. The question was, at what point would they stop doing so after planing the hardwood end grain? That is a measure of real world sharpness and edge holding. I am not looking at a test of ultimates. That would have less to offer the woodworker, who really wants an estimate of a blades longevity. The paring of end grain also aids in ruling out a blade as "working" sharp if it is cutting with chips.

This way I could conclude that the PM-V11 was able to do 60 shavings without affecting the paring of end grain; the Smoothcut was tired by 40 shavings, and the Clifton gave up the ghost at 22 shavings.

That tells me a lot.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New tools..

#32

Re: Stress vs strain

TomD

"2. The test as described doesn't distinguish between elastic and plastic strain, so a softer material that deforms plastically would appear to last longer even though it's useless as a knife once it starts to deform. Softer materials will therefore appear to do better."

Not a huge fan of the ABS tests, but they bend them 90 degrees, and then back, and then they do a cut test, and examine the edge for chips. It has to do all that. Basically they want using characteristics that allow easy sharpening, long edge holding and the ability to take abuse as defined by bending without loosing the edge, vs not bending at all.

The a thing called a copper rod test I think. Where you deflect the edge by pressing on it with a copper rod. I think just copper so the edge isn't dulled, or the rod slip. But that is the key point. It just deflect, doesn't chip but does the number of rope saw throughs you want.

I think the reason for the bendability is just that you can get that in a forged knife, stock reduction probably could also, but they don't shoot for it. It seems to smiths to be the natural excellence in the forged knife. But that is cultural.

Re: New tools..

#33

Re: I don't see the advantage of bending

david weaver

I can't disagree with it being pointless, but it seems to be a fairly standard test (whoever the american bladesmith guild is, or whatever they call themselves, they require members' knives to be able to sustain a 90 degree bend from the handle).

I tend to like mine for slicing, but there is one real consequence that happens quite often that such a test may be useful for, and that is how easily the tip breaks off of the end of a knife.

At any rate, most of the "destructive" and other tests for knives online are pretty pointless. I'm not sure of when the last time was that I used a knife for more than slicing, but if I did, it wasn't a "good" knife.

Re: New tools..

#34

Re: Normal Day to Day Testing

david weaver

Hi Derek, you're right (paraphrasing), they're just two different tests. The reason I push on it is simple, though, and it's this:

* I have planed abrasive woods and MDF (sometimes you have to plane it if it's a surface on a router table, for example) and didn't find the results to be the same as they are for a more "normal" task here in the US (comparing the muji HSS irons to A2 and carbon steel - muji will excel in cocobolo that's a problem as well as MDF - the gap narrows a lot when you go to sizing rough lumber - even the penultimate and ultimate parts of the job).

Brent has done an excellent job, but he's missing some of the more recent offerings. I pretty much match what he shows on what he has, but I'm more interested in edge quality as a part of the cycle and not so much in the length of the wear bevel, which seems to be his biggest measure unless there is really gross edge quality. I think LV's iron would do well in this, as there are two powder metal irons shown and one of them does well (steve elliot's), but the disparity isn't there for the 3v irons vs. carbon steel that one would suspect given the reports of 3v's ability to make a super long-lasting chisel.

Maybe I will do something similar again in the future now that I have a good microscope, but there are all kinds of curiosities that I'd like to chase and I'm kind of wishing someone else would do it!

From time to time, though, i see something about V11 like (From a user, I haven't read LV's opinions or study results in a while):

* it lasts twice as long as A2 and it's easier to sharpen.

Makes me wrinkle my brow a little bit. Is it better than A2? I think so, better in every way. How much in normal use? I don't know. I haven't had an even fair comparison yet. I haven't used the chisels, so I'll take someone else's word for it on those (which seems to be universal that it's FAR better than A2).

Re: New tools..

#35

bridger

Re: Normal Day to Day Testing

Bridger

Derek-

What you have tested is edge holding ability in the hard abrasive woods you use. Your assumption that this test is an accurate proxy for edge holding ability in any other material is just an assumption. D.W. has presented some data that seems to indicate a different curve in different materials. Are you able to look at the data on it's own merits? It may well be that there are faults in his methodology- there is a glaringly obvious one in yours.

Re: New tools..

#36

Re: Normal Day to Day Testing

Patrick Chase

I should think it would be obvious at this point that different uses (paring, chopping, etc) and woods (as discussed above) place different demands on the tool. No single review or test can possibly be valid for every use case. YMMV, etc.

Re: New tools..

#37

Re: Normal Day to Day Testing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

D.W. has presented some data that seems to indicate a different curve in different materials. Are you able to look at the data on it's own merits? It may well be that there are faults in his methodology- there is a glaringly obvious one in yours.

Bridger, please do say what is the "glaringly obvious" fault in my methodology. I am curious to know.

My post was responding to Davids interest in comparing Clifton, Tsunesaburo and PM-V11 irons. The aim was to provide an objective comparison.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New tools..

#38

Tsunesaburo iron

Brian Holcombe

I tapped out the Tsunesaburo iron to form a hollow and I believe the edge created after doing so is sharper than the edge I could achieve from a flat back. The steel is wear resistant and with my stones I found this to be an improvement in sharpness and so an improvement in longevity.

I also feel the edges of Japanese irons (and plain carbon) are better wearing after honing with a good natural stone. I've tried it both ways many times and the natural stones always produce an edge that comes out on top.

For kicks I sharpened my blade for Kez this year with a 12,000 sigma rather than a natural stone (at first) the blade performed wonderfully but was still improved upon with the Nakayama. The only blade I have that is not noticeably improved with a natural stone is a blade that is heavily alloyed (more than blue 2).

Re: New tools..

#39

Re: Normal Day to Day Testing

david weaver

Let's assume we're talking about planes and the type of thing that we would normally do with them.

Chisels could be covered separately because the "winner" in both probably wouldn't be the same thing.

Re: New tools..

#40

Re: Tsunesaburo iron

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Brian,

I'm curious. When sharpening on the natural stones, do you make the final strokes head-on, at a diagonal, or sideways? I tend to start straight on, and gradually work around to diagonal, and finally full sideways. But this is without training or instruction of any kind, so am curious what you do.

Wiley

Re: New tools..

#41

Re: Tsunesaburo iron

Brian Holcombe

I'm usually working at a diagonal for most blades, except small chisels which are easier to just use straight on.

Re: New tools..

#42

Stroke Tester

david weaver

all we need is to find a stroke tester who is willing to go a couple tens of thousands of repetitions, and we could find out which type of edge lasts longer :)

Not going to be me. I also prefer the edge off of a natural stone, though not necessarily a washita if it has to be really sharp. I've noticed that all of the edges off of natural stones seem to be more consistent from start to finish, whereas the toothy deep groove synthetic stones have an early "slickness" through the wood that goes away pretty quickly.

Steve Elliot had something in a test in one of the articles that linked longevity to absolute sharpness, but I don't remember the details of the test that well. In terms of functional work, I haven't noticed a difference between washita and sigma power 13k - the time of use and volume of wood worked is about the same, though the 13k is definitely sharper to start. A test like that probably has many different conclusions depending on what actual use is.

Re: New tools..

#43

Re: Stroke Tester

Brian Holcombe

Haha! Perhaps a late and rainy night might be consumed by that test.

I find it interesting how fine a synthetic is needed before it begins to compete with a not so fine natural stone. I almost can't tell the difference in edges between the 13k sigma and the Nakayama but I can take a few micron thinner shaving with the Nakayama. The Yaginoshima which is about 6k turns out an edge that is longer lasting but slightly less sharp than that of the 13k synthetic.

I have the same experience in that I find the sharpness from a synthetic to be fleeting in a way that a natural stones edge is not. I've attributed this to the more durable edge created with a lighter abrasive.

I have a few irons, super hard, that benefit from a full regime of synthetics then finishing on a natural stone. One is the Yokoyama Kunio Togo-ko and the other is a Tanaka super white. The Tanaka is simply too hard to be much effected by natural stones and yet just finishing it on them has s nice effect. The Kunio iron is too heavily alloyed and so seems to need a refresher on fine synthetics every few hones.

Re: New tools..

#44

Re: Stroke Tester

david weaver

I have had similar experience with harder tools (one on a Mosaku plane, the other being one of Kiyotada's chisels - it's just harder than the other two that I have).

They pretty much need synthetic workup because few naturals will cut them. The synthetic edge at the end is still nicer and its toughness seems a little better. When tools get that hard, it can be difficult to find something that leaves the edge tough and sharp. The more slight the angle, the harder the task.

I should backtrack - I also have two very old (they were inexpensive to me, not sure about when they were made) irons that are extremely hard. They are almost unused - I think the hardness is probably why. I haven't put them in planes yet, but figure I will do the same thing, and if they can't hold their edge, I'll just put them in the oven at 25 degree intervals until I have something that's tolerable.

Not sure if I can tell yet if there's any advantage to the super ultra hard irons and chisels. The "very hard" seem to fit the profile of the job well - hold an edge as long as possible to get through the day without resharpening on site. But, when they get beyond that, i think they may go in reverse in terms of durability.

Beach's display of the Hock carbon steel iron matches that. i could never get the Hock carbon steel irons to wear well, and figured they were overhard. Ron disagrees with that and feels that if they are heated to light straw, the temper is ruined. I think they would wear better at light straw, but I'm not willing to do the stroke test (plus, I don't have any of them any longer).

The eskilstuna iron on beach's page would probably be close to the hardness of the earliest temper colors appearing - it fails much more uniformly (plus, I've had a few eskilstuna irons, and one is overhard and fails the same way the hock does - in bigger bits). The interesting conclusion from Beach's site is that the wear bevel can be longer if it's more uniform. Beach uses the length of the wear bevel as his indicator of wear, but it's not the only factor (which you have mentioned, but I doubt many understand - the "I can see the wear, but it's still planing" kind of thing).

(I think I just went on a tangent! I'm still resisting refitting one of my planes with the tsune iron because I really don't have a need, but they are definitely good).

Re: New tools..

#45

Re: Stroke Tester

Brian Holcombe

I think the really hard steels shine in softwoods. I'm sure this is why the temple carpenters demand them. The benefit seems to taper off as the wood gets harder and resharpenings more and more frequent.

That Tanaka blade, for instance, puts a shine on yellow cedar that presents an absolute mirror. With oak by comparison, even a dull blade will leave a pretty decently shiny surface.

I'm tempted to put that 01 blade in my oven and take off a few points of hardness. It can be great at times and terrible others. Better still I may just replace it with another Tsunesaburo.

BTW your try plane may appear on Japanese TV soon, I had some interviewers at my shop yesterday that wanted to cover my use of Japanese tools but we're awe-struck by the try plane.

Re: New tools..

#46

Re: Stroke Tester

david weaver

That's a good point (about the softwood). I hadn't thought of that.

Re: the try plane - after seeing too many guitar battle shows between Paul Gilbert and Marty Friedman (both of them speak japanese and apparently spend a lot of time there), i can only guess what the try plane would look like on Japanese TV.

I hope we get to see the video segment if there is one! :)

Re: New tools..

#47

Re: Stroke Tester

Brian Holcombe

It should be highly entertaining, if nothing else. :D

Who can resist that try plane really, it is a wonderful tool.

Once it's up, I'll post a link as I'm sure it will be able to viewed online.

Re: New tools..

#48

Re: Stroke Tester

david weaver

Did they actually try to use it?

On a side note, I am so pleased to read your descriptions of experience with irons, because I know it comes from planing and not from tests. Sometimes, that can result in strange notions (for example, people will often say that the ECE irons wear like "iron", and their ad copy boasts about how they are hard wearing, but my experience and Brent's is that they really aren't that great - I think when a company says something in an advertisement or in literature, people often perceive it to be true, as if it was a weed seed planted and it's hard to remove).

At any rate, I'm glad to see a similar conclusion about wear, etc, and preferability, and the fact that your experience with the rikizai irons is the same as mine. It's so easy to read that they're cheap rikizai and not the equal of hand forged irons, but they are so good that it is maybe better to just not know how they were produced.

Re: New tools..

#49

Re: Stroke Tester

Brian Holcombe

No they wouldn't try anything, just wanted to film name using them.

Glad to hear that! Always happy to share.

Absolutely it is best to forget they're cheap blades and just enjoy them. I do t know if I mentioned it but I actually tapped a hollow into mine.

Re: New tools..

#50

Re: Stroke Tester

david weaver

I saw that you said that. I was curious about what that did to the opposite side of the iron - did it bulge?

minimizing the surface and biasing it toward the edge is always a good idea with an iron that hard.