Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

New tools..

Posts

New tools..

#1

New tools..

david weaver

I would be pleased if new manufacturers would buy some rikizai (pre laminated) material from hitachi - it's made in droves for knives - and make some of their plane irons from it for an upcharge.

I don't suppose they'd ever feel it was worth the effort, but it's rolled out into pre-laminated sheets or bars and either glued together industrially or forge welded by rollers, and I think it needs little more than just to be cut and then heat treated on a given schedule. It makes a better iron than O1 or A2, and better (if we're being honest) than any vintage iron that I've had. It could be made in a hardness range that most can tolerate (low 60s) and still be better than anything offered.

I understand the idea of skilled labor processing of irons is sort of out (except for the part where skilled labor runs surface grinders, etc), but I think the prelaminated material with a published vacuum heat treat schedule makes it possible to produce irons without knowing that much about them. And it tsunesaburo can sell them for $40-$50 through stu tierney's store front, the material cost can't be *that* bad.

Re: New tools..

#2

Along the same lines...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Several days ago I posted about pocket knives, and my friend Konrad Sauer wrote offline to tell about a knife he was given by a friend. This friend is a very experienced craftsman, who happens to be way into Japanese tools and steel. Anyway, the gift knife was a Fallkniven U2, one of the less expensive models, but using this laminated stainless steel, where the inner cutting steel is powder metallurgical. The message from Konrad was this--if you want a steel that can take it, this is the thing. The knife guys are also talking about the Japanese cobalt stainless that Fallkniven uses.

Link to Fallkniven's discussion of the steel they use:

https://www.fallkniven.com/en/product-information/steel/

Elsewhere on their site, they show the knives available, fixed and folding.

FWIW.

Wiley

Re: New tools..

#3

Re: Along the same lines...

david weaver

Nice solution to the issues I've seen previously where the PM blades are good at edge holding, but they don't tolerate lateral forces that well (that is, they break more easily from bending).

Hard to tell from the description, but it looks like the core is powder metal and the outside is probably not (I hope not, as "not" would be better for bending strength).

I don't generally beat my tools, but once in a while when you're under something or in a corner, you know....you use what you have.

Another good item for the Christmas list. I have no good knives in stainless.

Re: New tools..

#4

Not glued, not forged

Patrick Chase

IIRC rikizai is welded during rolling, but not forged. The grain structure is therefore ~isotropic, which sacrifices many of the advantages of traditional Japanese construction. I for one don't find the couple Tsunesaburos that I use to be superior to my solid/Western irons (though admittedly those are mostly PM steels at this point).

There's no adhesive in existence that could stand the required processing and use, so purge that idea from your mind :-)

If I could make one change to Western plane makers' alloy selection, it would be to stop using A2. Modern sintered steels have similar or better mechanical properties with much finer grain structure, so there's simply no reason to use it any more.

Re: New tools..

#5

Re: Along the same lines...

Patrick Chase

Fallkniven's "Super Gold Powder Steel" (SGPS) is notably similar to Carpenter CTS-XHP, a.k.a. PM-V11, which is also a PM stainless.

SGPS has slightly lower Carbon and higher Vanadium, but otherwise the nominals are close. I would expect SGPS to be harder to sharpen and somewhat more abrasion resistant because of the Vanadium.

It's probably worth noting that Konrad uses PM-V11 at Rc62.5 in his plane irons, so his tastes appear to be self-consistent :-)

Re: New tools..

#6

PM not weaker in bending

Patrick Chase

If you look at the measured properties of various PM steels and their non-PM counterparts of similar composition and hardness, then you will find that they perform about the same in bending.

It is perhaps possible that the specific PM steel that you had this experience with was weak in bending, but a conventional steel of similar composition would have been equally problematic.

Re: New tools..

#7

Re: PM not weaker in bending

david weaver

It was actually knife torture tests that I saw breaking with much less tolerance to bending. Not bending force, but how far they'd go before they break.

Could've been steel that wasn't up to spec, but that wasn't documented.

I may be an old fart, but I still like my steel to be squished by something heavy if given the choice. Concessions to that if the alloys start getting nutty, but I don't drink white wine and don't usually go for carbon above what's in super blue or much of anything else.

(Lie Nielsen does A2 quite well, though - best I've seen when I've actually measured - and LV's V11 is nice, but not something I'd give up White #2 for, nor my old wards - but those are getting tough to find - especially in parallel irons)

Re: New tools..

#8

Re: Along the same lines...

david weaver

I doubt this will unseat my daily favorite, which is a Tidioute Wall Street knife in 1095. I'd guesstimate hardness about 61 - one of the very few knife makers who does 1095 right these days.

But something that doesn't rust is something I'm missing - especially in lockbacks. Two years ago, I went through a stockman binge and found that of all of the stockman's I bought, I only really liked the case and the tidioute. The others (queen, etc) all had issues. Even the puma had problems - the walk and talk wasn't right and it was righteously hard to open. The case wasn't "great", but it was decent given the fact that it cost $30.

Anyway, the only lockback I got in that binge other than the wharncliffe wall streets was a "rough rider" knife after reading about how well finished they are. Maybe they are, but the folder that I got is not up for lateral anything, and it won't take a decent edge off of natural stones because it's too soft.

I have kitchen knives in VG10, which sharpen *very* well on oilstones, so I'm in for giving this one a try.

(often in rabbit hole discussions hear people say "what do you do when your tidioute folder gets wet or discolored". I buff it, and then the buffer leaves a thin coat of wax on it. If not buffer, dursol - same thing - but dursol is probably not good for a knife that you cut food with from time to time).

FWIW, if someone wanted to do 440C the way friodur does it in razors, it would also be just fine. I guess that costs something (the cryo treatment) and it's not a sexy label to say a knife is 440c.

Re: New tools..

#9

You mean like this?

Patrick Chase

https://cartech.ides.com/datasheet.aspx?I=101&E=343

Note first para of description and also the very 440C-ish composition. Also keep in mind that this *is* PM-V11 as far as any of us that have run XRF on it can tell :-)

It's basically 440C with tweaked composition to allow for higher maximum hardness (Rc64, though LV uses it at Rc62.5) and PM to provide drastically finer microstructure. It's a really nice steel for both knives and edge tools IMO. Some of the exotic PM steels with higher Vanadium are more abrasion-resistant, but they're also difficult to sharpen (and impossible on your setup).

Re: New tools..

#10

Re: Along the same lines...

William Duffield

Fallkniven U2, one of the less expensive models

The folding model is about $140, including shipping, at current exchange rates, if anyone is interested.

Re: New tools..

#11

Re: You mean like this?

david weaver

Right, I understand that, but I have an old man preference for the way it's done in the friodurs. Drop it in a die, smash it, heat treat it, and then trim, grind and finish it.

Somewhere in there, Friodur cryo treats it, so it doesn't fail in big bits, and it holds up reasonably well even at 17 degrees or so.

It's probably 59 hardness or so and would make an excellent pocket knife, and could, perhaps be a click harder.

The other thing it does that V11 does not is sharpen pretty easily on natural stones. I think that's why it's a click softer than carbon steel razors (or it probably wouldn't).

I'm not a wonk for super edge holding in a pocket knife. Instead, I'd rather have one that touches up easily on a natural stone (thus the tidioute wharncliffe - once per week or two for 30 seconds). The lower threshhold on hardness is based on the fact that soft steels sharpen well on very fine synthetic media, but they are cut too drastically by natural finishers that are 3-5 micron and they get scratched up, raise a fat wire edge and don't polish well. When the wire edge is removed, the edge itself isn't very fine and the knife has no ability to hold it.

(side note, I don't think the friodur in kitchen knives is as good as the razors, but that may be a hardness issue - the razors are too hard to be steeled. The knives are harder than most current offerings like Wusthoff knives that are 0.5 chromium, but they can still be steeled).

Re: New tools..

#12

Re: Along the same lines...

david weaver

They are on ebay for $86, too, and in the section of amazon with alternate vendors for the same amount.

VAT and shipping from Europe probably kill the price from the original supplier.

Many inexpensive VG10 knives in japan, too, but proxy service fee plus shipping increase the price by about $20.

Re: New tools..

#13

Re: Adhered

david weaver

Tsunesaburo uses the term glued or adhered for the high speed steel (HAP 40 and SKH 51 - or whatever letters and numbers they use for it) irons that they sell, thus the supposition that it may also be true for the blue 1.

Not that they are glued and then rolled, but the separate layers could be rolled and then glued together as is the case with the high speed steels.

I recall asking george about forge welding when he said the smiths had trouble getting higher carbon steels to forge weld to wrought by hand, and he said that the higher carbon steels are difficult. That may not be an issue with industrial rollers or power hammers, but they wouldn't have been using those at CW in public view, unless they had the type (basically a piece of metal on a long wooden arm) that was used industrially in the 1700s and earlier. I don't recall seeing anything like that.

My experience with V11 is that it's probably similar in edge holding to the tsunesaburo iron, and though the tsunesaburo iron isn't forged, it's better than most forged irons. Clifton's old forged iron is a good comparison. Clifton's "hand forged" iron was a decent iron, but it's never showed much in tests. The tsune iron has much less tendency to hold a wire edge than V11. That may be esoteric, but it's interesting to me (there wouldn't be any sharpening of the tsune on a regular basis on washita, so that's not the reason why).

Re: New tools..

#14

Re: Adhered

Patrick Chase

Ah, that makes sense.

HAP40 is basically a Toshiba-proprietary PM version of M4 HSS BTW. I have a set of (Japanese, laminated) chisels made from that, and it's a terrific steel.

You'd probably hate it, though, as it's noticeably slow to sharpen even on Alumina :-).

Re: New tools..

#15

Re: Adhered

david weaver

I have some of it.

:\

It's slow on the grinder, but if you keep the sharpening at the tip (which is generally how a lazy person like me goes about it), diamonds cut it pretty well.

It's nice to have a chisel or three like that one around in case you're flushing wood to metal on an infill plane. You can use a carbon steel chisel, but I only have iyorois and they don't like that. Western chisels for that are out of the question.

Re: New tools..

#16

Re: Adhered

Patrick Chase

Exactly. Those are my "chisels to beat on", which at something like $60 each IIRC is decidedly not the same thing as "beater chisels".

I'd be willing to bet that we obtained the same chisels from the same source (Stu) for that matter. He doesn't seem to carry them any more though.

Re: New tools..

#17

Re: Adhered

david weaver

Yeah, Stu. I got mine a while ago in some kind of trade with stu (sometimes he wanted things that were only available in the US). I also got two cheaper semi HSS chisels, and I have to admit that while they're kind of ugly, they also hold up extremely well to abusive stuff.

Iyoroi sells the same chisels as yxr-7 chisels and they're a lot cheaper than the brand that stu carried, but still not exactly cheap. I figured if I was to get more of those things, I'd have just gotten the iyoroi mark instead.

http://www.330mate.com/product/193

($33 for a 24mm from iyoroi).

I asked stu why iyoroi's chisels were so much cheaper and he just said "don't know!!"

Re: New tools..

#18

Test results

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My experience with V11 is that it's probably similar in edge holding to the tsunesaburo iron, and though the tsunesaburo iron isn't forged, it's better than most forged irons. Clifton's old forged iron is a good comparison. Clifton's "hand forged" iron was a decent iron, but it's never showed much in tests.

David, I have had the PM-V11 - Clifton O1 (vintage hammered version) - Smoothcut (Tsunesaburo) on test head-to-head using a LN #51 shooting plane/Stanley #52 shooting board, planing the same piece of hardwood end grain. This was a fairly controlled set up.

The PM-V11 was the clear winner (60 good shavings), followed by the Smoothcut (40 good shavings), and the Clifton a weak third (22 good shavings).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New tools..

#19

Re: Test results

david weaver

I don't do a lot of end grain planing (because I have little of it exposed).

I haven't seen the same difference that you're seeing with V11 when surface planing, but I also don't do tons of planing because the V11 plane I have is a middle plane (and something I normally use a wooden plane for. We've had that discussion before - I can get further with a try plane that's got a really not-that-great iron than I can with an iron plane with a V11 iron in it).

It would be nice if Beach would add the V11 iron to his test group. I see that really, the iron that held up the best (small wear bevel and relatively even wear) was Steve Elliot's 3V iron.

(even if there is a small difference between V11 and rikizai blue steel in long grain, I still have a preference for the blue steel, but I think in gentler activities, the difference between the two narrows, just as it does in those tests with the eskilstuna iron and A2)

Re: New tools..

#20

Chris Scholz

I think he wants to say shear strength...

Chris scholz

...although I am not convinced that would be different either.

What do you compare it to though. My understanding is that the whole idea about PM steel is that you can use material compositions that are not possible with conventional eutectic materials.

Re: New tools..

#21

Re: I think he wants to say shear strength...

david weaver

Not shear strength.

I saw a "test to the death" of knives years ago. They put knives in a vise and bent them with a cheater pipe until they broke.

I can't find the video now because there are so many knife test videos on youtube that it's hard to get past the people cutting ropes, golf balls and water bottles.

Lots of bend tests, too, but it appears that to be an ABS master, you need to be able to bend a knife 90 degrees and not have it break, and most of the videos stop without the knife breaking.

At any rate, the two knives that I saw were a carbon steel knife (I can't remember if it broke), old style, and one in powder metal that broke very early in the bend. No clue how much resistance either had to bending, but presume that's what patrick is talking about (the force applied to the pipe to get a certain level of movement/bending). I thought the video was interesting, but I'll concede that I'm not ever going to buy a knife and put a cheater pipe on it, bend it over and call it regular knife use.

As long as something like this doesn't happen:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2EQWCpnIR8

(this was a fairly famous video that predated youtube. I'm not going to mention the name of the site that had videos before youtube, because it's been taken over by filth peddlers, which is a shame because it had a very small selection of very funny videos)

"oh, that got me good!!" :b

Re: New tools..

#22

Stress vs strain

Patrick Chase

What you're describing is a strain test, i.e. how far can you bend the knife before it fails.

Strength is usually specified in terms of stress, i.e. how much force does it take to break it.

There are two problems with the test you describe:

1. The maximum strain that a beam can withstand depends on its thickness.

2. The test as described doesn't distinguish between elastic and plastic strain, so a softer material that deforms plastically would appear to last longer even though it's useless as a knife once it starts to deform. Softer materials will therefore appear to do better.

I suspect that the only thing you can really conclude from the test you witnessed is that the PM blade probably had a thicker spine and/or was harder. I'm also not convinced that that test has any value at all as a predictor of the object's performance as a knife.

Re: New tools..

#23

Reason for PM

Patrick Chase

The reason for PM isn't so much to achieve compositions that are impossible as to allow compositions that would otherwise have unacceptable downsides.

For example the most popular PM alloy for woodworking (CTS-XHP, aka PM-V11) is similar to 440C and D2 in composition. It would unquestionably be feasible as a eutectoid alloy, but it would have huge grain/carbides like 440C/D2. The old joke that D2 "takes a crappy edge and holds it forever" is referring to exactly this downside. In contrast PM-V11 takes a pretty keen edge (but still holds it for a long time).

The situation is similar for other PM tool alloys: HAP-40 is simply a PM version of M4-HSS, and CPM-3V would also be realizable with conventional processing (though it would be very difficult to sharpen).

Re: New tools..

#24

Re: Stress vs strain

david weaver

They were probably similar in thickness (i don't remember anything like a benchmade knife, and I'd recall that if it was the PM knife). Likely different in hardness, but I'd have to have the video to confirm what they actually were (not many carbon steel (non-PM) hunting style knives in 64 hardness, and if they were, I'd wonder if someone using them ever actually cleaned an animal, because such a thing isn't remotely necessary).

In terms of breakage, I wonder if more could be found on YT. It's probably been 5 years since I saw what I saw, but I have a great long term memory and a short term memory that's not so great. Stuff that i vaguely recall in the short term somehow ends up clear in the long term. Maybe Derek would know something about that.

(what I mean by that is unless the video has been pulled, I'm sure it's still out there and it will show what I'm talking about. Whether or not that's true for other PM, I don't know. I'd like to see more, though. None of the knives that I've seen bent end up straight when the bend is over, so the point of the test is sort of odd unless you're trying to pry your way out of a trash compactor and don't care if the knife survives. I have had a couple of defective things break in the middle of use, though, and wouldn't want it with a knife. Last thing that broke on me was an early mex. nicholson file that I had bought right after the transition. literally in the middle of a brisk tooth reset, the file broke 2/3rds of the way to the end. Never had that happen before.)

Re: New tools..

#25

Re: Reason for PM

david weaver

Yeah, aware of that.

I understand there are a lot of other advantages, too, less specific regarding alloys (creating small parts that would be expensive or awkward to machine, etc, and that are closer to finish dimension than a casting would be).

I would've gauged V11 as a fine grained 440C if someone asked me what I thought about it. Someone else tipped me off that it doesn't rust, though, so I didn't have to guess much regarding why it's got abrasion resistance (figured chromium, which was later confirmed).

Didn't find it to be easier to sharpen than A2, though (neither is difficult, but A2 sharpens better on natural stones, even though I'm not really that sure what's so great about it to begin with other than that it's stable in heat treat), and haven't found a great deal of difference in day to day wear in "medium hardwoods" vs. A2. Not sure if that would hold true if you back off to taking only very thin shavings (I don't do that often) - that tends to really separate the good abrasion resistant steels from other steels.

Never much cared for D2, though the RI chisels are decent. Hated it in a queen stockman, and never had the urge to buy an iron with it - especially after seeing the worn edge on Beach's page. More impressed by irons that are partially dull (so much so that you can literally see the dulled edge), but still leave a good surface.