Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

Posts

Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#1

Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

Lee

Lie Nielsen is quite difficult to get hold of up here in Canada. Works out to be about twice the price of the Veritas when I factor in shipping and exchange rates.

I'm torn?? Reviews are great for both. Have to say I like the more traditional look of the Lie Nielsen over the Veritas.

What are your experiences with either saw?

All thoughts and comments welcome.

Thanks

Lee

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#2

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

david weaver

I've not made a saw like the LV saw, but I have made a couple that are similar to the LN (but with a folded back).

I'd say that I'd choose (if I were you) the saw that more closely matches your choice in sawing from the start unless you file, and then it's either-or.

I understood the LV saw (without the tiny teeth) to have a 14 degree rake and LN close to zero, at least at one point. If you can file, you can make either of those work.

Not sure how new you are, but if you're not too new, you'll probably find 14 degrees to be too relaxed, and I think all people newer to the hobby will find zero to be too aggressive, and would probably prefer the slower but more easy going nature of the relaxed rake in the LV saw.

Personally, I'd avoid the 20 tooth saw because it poses a problem with files and is a nuisance to sharpen. Not necessarily difficult, and it doesn't matter if you file tiny teeth like that perfectly, but it's just small and more tedious.

Benefits of the two from afar (again, not the tiny tooth LV version here):

* ease of use if new - LV

* style - LN, by far (you might not care)

* price - LV

* speed (as from the factory) - LN

I've seen more than one person say they don't like the zero rake LN, so I do think that's important if you haven't used an aggressively filed saw.

Someone can correct me if they have relaxed the rake 5 or 6 degrees.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#3

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

Michael Brady

David, I have four rip-filed joinery saws from LN. None of them had zero degree rake filing that I can recall. Certainly none of them now do. A call to LN can confirm this, I'm sure.

As to the original question, your evaluation of the brands is similar to mine. There is no need for 20 tpi filing unless you are making snuff boxes. I have a nice saw with that filing that I seldom use because I never want to have to file and reset those teeth! Many infrequent users of a dovetail saw choose the LV saws because they are a good value, and I can't argue that.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#4

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

david weaver

Are any of the joinery saws LN? I don't have experience with the LN saws, but recall a lot of people - perhaps 8 years ago or so? - expressing dissatisfaction with the dovetail saw because it had zero rake.

If that was true, I wouldn't be surprised if it was changed.

Even if they did have zero rake at one point, only the tiniest bit of a tooth needs to be kissed at 5 degrees for the saw to cut like it's got 5 degrees of rake on the whole tooth.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#5

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

North of the Border

I have used the Veritas saws (14, 20 & x-cut) extensively since their release and other saws (LN, Bad Axe, Rob Cosman, and others -- much less) for dovetails, tenons, and other day-to-day cuts.

Since they are all good functioning saws, there is NO difference in their sawing performance IF you have the proper sawing skills to start with. I can cut anything to the same or similar results with any of those saws. Therefore, your skills, not which of those saws you will pick, will determine your work. In a nutshell, assuming you are reasonably good at sawing:

if style and appearance are more important to you, pick the LN.

if budget is an issue, pick the Veritas (14 and x=cut) for the price of one LN's. I got the whole set of 3 because of the package deal.

If you can try them out, do it before making your decision.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#6

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

Patrick Chase

The old Independence Tool dovetail saw had zero or near-zero rake.

Independence is the company that became L-N's saw business (Thomas L-N bought it from Pete Taran and Patrick Leach), so it wouldn't surprise me if the L-N's were initially filed that way as well.

Recent L-Ns that I've seen had geometries very similar to their LV counterparts, and fairly relaxed rake, though I'm not absolutely sure of whether those were filed by their owners.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#7

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw? *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Someone can correct me if they have relaxed the rake 5 or 6 degrees.

I replied to this this thread when Lee asked the question on the main forum. My comments there were essentially the same as David's.

I have had the LN 15 tpi dovetail saw for about 15 years, and the IT for close to 10 years. Shortly after receiving it, I wrote a short comparison (link below).

The rake on the LN was close to zero. Mike Wenzloff looked over the IT for me, and commented, "the rake is about 4 degrees or less". He then added fleam to the teeth to help with the brittle woods with which I work. This made a big difference.

A comment made by someone was 'avoid the LV 20 tpi'. I would disagree with this - it really comes down to the wood you are working. For the average 1/2" - 3/4" board of soft to hard woods, the 14 tpi LV is a good choice. However, as you go thinner, and/or the wood becomes harder and more brittle, you will benefit from a higher tooth count. A comparison may be made with using a high-tooth Japanese saw. These leave a smoother cut, but more so, they do not bind or chip as much as a saw with 15 tpi and less.

When Mike added fleam to my IT, it effectively reduced the chopping effect of the rip teeth by giving it something a little closer to a crosscut tooth.

Comparing the LN #15 tpi with close-to-zero rake and a LV #14 tpi with 14 degrees of rake is a bit like apples and oranges. For the experienced sawyer, either will do the job very well. It will come down to looks, which is personal, or cost, where the LV is much cheaper. What the experienced sawyer will notice is the LN cuts more aggressively and a lighter touch will make it start easily; while the LV will start easily but saw a little less aggressively (note that the lower tooth count on the LV offer it a little more aggression than if it had simply been 15 tpi).

Both are excellent saws that will not disappoint.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Independence Tools and Lie-Nielsen saws

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#8

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

Gary B.

I too bought the 3 saw package deal from LV about 3 years back. I've never used the LN for comparison, but I haven't felt anything lacking. They cut fast, and are a joy to use.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#9

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

TM Stock

I checked the thin plate LN and looks like something around 12-15 deg...likely balanced off against a narrower kerf. In any case, a fast-cutting saw that starts easily. No reason to miss the IT.


Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#10

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

david weaver

That's a significant amount of rake and definitely different than what was described in early post-independence discussions.

I can't imagine that they wouldn't change, anyway - the complaints from beginners (who are actually buying most of the tools) would be constant.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#11

Same rake as LV

Patrick Chase

It looks like LV and LN are offering very similar factory filings at this point.

They're both high-quality saws, so IMO it's basically a matter of whether to spend some extra $$$ for traditional construction and appearance.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#12

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

Patrick Chase

It appears (per other posts) that the factory tooth geometry on the L-N has changed quite a bit since your writeup, such that it's almost identical to LV.

Wentzloff basically put what Mark Harrell (BadAxe) describes as a "hybrid" toothing on your IT. I've done that with a couple of my spare saws, and as you say it makes a world of difference. I personally like that toothing quite a lot.

I agree that the LV 20 tpi DT is an underrated saw. I like mine, especially now that I've made the toothing a bit more aggressive.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#13

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

david weaver

I'm not sure how much fleam Mike put on, but I had a discussion early on when I was first learning to file and asked him if he thought 5 degrees of fleam on all dovetail saws was something worth doing.

That came up because I was switching from japanese to western saws at the time and wasn't satisfied with the ability of western saws to make a clean cut without stringiness (but a crosscut saw will do that fine).

I think mike was shooting for a milder amount in general, even if Derek's got more, and not something as significant as Harrell's hybrid.

I still don't think it's a bad idea to add fleam to a dovetail saw, but I don't remember to do it and in reality, once you start sharpening your own saws and get them all set up properly, only the carpenter rip saw is one that gets a frequent refresh. Which is nice, because the whole process on a rip saw to refresh is probably less than 5 minutes. (the back side of the cut quality that I was hung up on was similar to getting hung up on microns with sharpening goods - it only seems like it matters, and it rarely does with joinery saws. Maybe not never, but rarely).

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#14

Japanese saws (FWIW)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

Dunno why it should be, but every Japanese rip saw I have, and that would be a bunch, has negative rake. This is true from a 3ppi, 420mm Mitsukawa to a 32ppi, 180mm Yataiki rip dozuki. Includes ryobas, tatebikis, and panel saws--everything. My favorite dovetail saw is a 240mm Yataiki, which is filed like a 210mm with 22ppi (21tpi), and at least 5 degrees negative rake.

Of course, with all these saws, as has been said on these pages many times before, you hold the saw firmly but lightly, like eating a peach, and let the saw do the cutting. No crowding the cut.

For dozukis, the Japanese saw tends to be thinner than western equivalents--rip or cross dozukis 0.012" plus very little set, and tends to have more teeth. Perhaps those factors allow negative rake. But that doesn't explain why the larger and coarser-toothed saw also have negative rake. Seems a mystery.

We mostly talk about planes here, but saws are very complex creatures, with many different filings used.

Wiley

Wiley

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#15

Re: NOT the Same rake as LV

Ron in Sterling, CT

I read a lot of conjecture here...I think,....I heard....I believe... According to the article in the December, 2017 issue of FINE WOODWORKING regarding the comparison of Dovetail saws, the LN saw has 5 degrees of rake, and the Veritas Standard has 14 degrees of rake. Not the same in my book.

Ron

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#16

Re: Japanese saws (FWIW)

david weaver

I once tried to pull a zona saw by switching the blade around and quickly found out that the orientation of cutting teeth at zero rake doesn't really work pulling.

I guess you can't get the same orientation and pressure pulling a saw and the teeth really need that hook to get the appropriate bite.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#17

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

Lee

Thanks for all the great comments!!

I’ve decided to go for the Lee Valley 14tpi Dovetail saw.

Thanks

Lee

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#18

Not 5 degrees

Patrick Chase

See the picture "TM Stock" posted a few replies back. There is no way in heck that's 5 degrees, and I've seen similarly relaxed rake on recent L-N dovetail saws.

It would not be the first time FWW has gotten "confused" about something like that. I trust photographs and my own eye more.

It's really an irrelevant point anyway, because rip toothing is the easiest thing in the world to change. As David says it's minutes of filing (maybe a bit more for a significant rake change, but not bad).

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#19

Re: Not 5 degrees

TM Stock

Two different saws...Fine Woodworking reviewed the standard 0.020" Lie-Nielsen DT saw - not the tapered, thin plate (0.015") Lie-Nielsen DT saw. I've owned and used all three, as well as the LV, and the newest LN saw is a different animal - easier starting and faster cutting than the older LN saws. While I never thought the IT or the LN standard were hard starting, they did require the user to learn a little about sawing technique and to pay attention.

As Patrick mentioned, the photo shows a much greater angle than 5 degrees, but that could be either an error on the part of the review's author or the fact that the saw reviewed was not the one I photographed.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#20

By 'negative rake' above, I mean that the

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

JApanese rip teeth are aggressive, and lean into the work.

Wiley

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#21

Re: By 'negative rake' above, I mean that the

david weaver

Yes. I think without that, they wouldn't bite. At least the pull saw that I tried to make with zero rake so that I could use it push by taking the plate out and reversing it couldn't bite.

I have a giant maebiki to try soon (straight from japan where they're cheap), but I'm minus a log. The teeth on it are similar - significant amount of negative rake. It, however, is heavy when stood upright. I'd have no chance of getting it to move on a board if I pulled it under its weight, but I'll bet it'll work well with elevated wood or laying on its side. We'll see, i hope! I just need to find a tree trunk to cut.

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#22

You know you have Tool Acquisition Syndrome...

Patrick Chase

...when you have a rare and exotic tool, and are limited only by the fact that you have no log to try it on.

I would say "there but for the grace of God go I", but in reality it's more like "there go I".

Re: Lie Nielsen or Veritas Dovetail saw?

#23

Re: You know you have Tool Acquisition Syndrome...

david weaver

Well, they're about a hundred bucks in japan. It's not until someone brings them over here and puts them on ebay that they turn into a $250-$400 tool.

I work alone, so a pitsaw is probably a poor option (and they're expensive!).

(and I don't have a pit).

If I have the choice, I prefer functional exercise. The wood's not going to appreciate that I cut it by hand, but my brain likes that kind of thing.