Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Posts

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#26

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

Sorry about the double-reply, but...

w.r.t. saws I agree completely, unless we're talking about "one-shot" impulse-hardened blades of course. Most saw files have surface hardness somewhere in the low/mid Rc60s, and can easily handle sawplates up to Rc50, and a bit more with exceptional filing technique. The hardest three-square needle files on the market (Glardon-Vallorbe Valtitan, Corradi Corinox) are Rc72 and can handle objects up to the (very) low Rc60s.

We had one of those discussions on The Other Forum recently, with fairly extravagant claims about the hardness of D12s in particular. One complication was that one of the people claiming high measurements was Pete Taran, who's forgotten more about saws than I will ever know, so it was difficult to resolve the apparent contradiction. I suspect an apparatus/measurement issue. He was using a Rockwell surface hardness tester and applying C-scale conversions that assume homogeneity, so it's possible that his saws were simply face-hardened.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#27

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

One last business-related comment about Shapton: Harrelson Stanley recently lost his exclusive distribution arrangement (though he apparently still owns the "Shapton USA" trademark and 'shapton.com' domain. Awkward).

It will be interesting to see if they reintroduce the Glass stones to Japan and/or reduce the US prices on the "Pro" stones to make them more competitive with grey-market importers like Stu and MetalMaster.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#28

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

My sister is a baby photographer. Just my opinion, but I think she probably doesn't need what she buys, except for the ancillary equipment, as you mention.

I don't think the elephant is part of her stuff (haven't seen her stuff in a while, so went out and looked since this topic came up)

http://www.christinehsiehphotography.com/

"arranging the babies" properly and making sure the light is good is probably a lot more important than the camera. (not throwing her out there as a photography expert, either - I think the guys who hang upside down from running helicopters to take action shots probably think family photographers are the bob ross of the picture world, but my sister is a tough nut, so I'm not about to say that to her - the response would be something that would make freddie roach proud).

My level of high end spending on cameras is limited to whatever compact (but not credit card size) camera panasonic had three years ago (those come in around $150 but at least have a decent optical zoom). I think my current camera is an FZ35. I have to admit that I don't remember the last time I used it because the phone cameras seem better than it is (on a good phone, at least). I'm tempted to take some pictures with it and see how much I can see.

(I still have one chosera, but like the shaptons better - they craze less. I don't like what naniwa told us about needing to discontinue the chosera series and replacing it with "professional" because they still sell the chosera in japan for less than it ever was here - it's still expensive for what it is, though, and I'm sure it was more here because there's an extra layer of distribution. I think in about 6 or 7 years of mostly using the shapton pros, I used about a millimeter off of one, but I never lapped stones that often). Even an easy suita stone is harder to use than a shapton, so once you go to natural stones, coming back to shaptons makes them feel stick-free.

Maybe more interesting than modern stone offerings is the vintage synthetic stones I've fished out of japan - some of them much more like natural stones, and I've also managed to find india stones over there that are probably about 3 or 4 microns (norton had an extra fine at one time, but I have never seen one new).

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#29

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

the working distance for the high magnification is extremely close with the scope I have, and your camera distance is a lot more practical.

At the lower magnification, it's a little easier to work with, though. At 600x, you can pretty much only get something that's within a thousandth or two of the surface - what's in focus is a split second flash when using the coarse adjustment.

It's all new to me. Makes me appreciate what the $12 ($11, whatever) scope is capable of getting in terms of razor edges. All I need to know from them in terms of whether or not they're finished. There's only one thing that vexes me a little bit, and that's kamisori. They should come out sharper than a western razor, but they are more work and I have to resort to chromium oxide to get to that. I'm hoping I can figure that out with the new setup. The "secret" is always trivial.

(of note is the fact that I can pull used kamisori out of japan for $10 each, and someone said to me once "those are generally made for export", which is code for the natives really not favoring them that much, or at least not widely. I can shave in five minutes with them, but whereas you can use a single straight razor for your entire life, the kamisori will eventually need to be ground and I doubt the average homeowner has the skills).

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#30

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

Not sure what to think about the domestic shapton stuff. The glassstones are very good stones from the standpoint of if you rub something on them, they get sharp. I can't get on with the bonded diamond flattening thing, nor can I settle with the fact that you get 5mm of abrasive (common abrasive, there's nothing groundbreaking about any of it in any of the stones - they all oversell what they're really making - american hone made a far better-feeling hone a hundred years ago than any of them make today) and the 5mm comes for a princely sum.

I've thought about maybe making an epoxy-based or shellac based hone with white alundum, but it's a complete waste of time to do something like that.

I've gone whole hog in the naturals and have been buying stuff off of japanese proxy sites (buyee for those who'd like to try). I need to dump a lot before I continue, because I've got a little problem with the infills now, too.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#31

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

surface tensioned saws are definitely harder on the surface - something is going on there. Jonathan McCullough knows I like Woodrough and McP saws, so he sent me a rusty one a couple of months ago. I tried a scotchbrite wheel on it just for something new, and completely removed the rust. I also completely removed the tension doing that (not from heat, but because the deburring wheel took the surface off and I'm speculating here, but I'll bet the work of the rollers all existed in what I took off). It was like a rag after that and I had to rehammer it.

What's on the surface isn't a good indicator of what's in the saw.

I supposed at the time that argument first came up that anything even 52 becomes undesirable to sharpen. The woodrough and McP saws are a little bit harder (that includes the saw after the surface was ground off - the core is still hard) than disstons and they are really hard on files, to the point that using a couple of disston mexico files resulted in dead mexico files. Quickly.

Not very practical. I had a saw once that must've been a reject, too. A #7. It had a straw color, I don't know what the issue was with it. Nobody ever tried to file it and the crosscut teeth were original (including a large amount of set) and worn rounded on the tip. I guess someone else may have tried to file it and gave up. vintage simonds double cut would file it just a tiny bit. It burnished the teeth on single cut files right away. A real downer. I had to throw it away. I got it from the late great walt quadrato, and I doubt he knew it was a dud. By the time I figured it out, I just had to throw it away. It was marked with a run of the mill #7 etch, still no clue about that one. I'd bet upper 50s by the color of the plate - completely unmanageable, and still puzzling how it was tempered to straw and then the straw was still on it. Could someone have rehardened it successfully? It seems unlikely, but how would it still have straw color and not have been finished to have the tempering colors removed.

Long story short, knowing the hardness of the file and then filing teeth with it is probably the best way to judge hardness after a piece of properly tested untensioned reference plate is checked.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#32

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

That's really high-quality portraiture work. The really good action types wouldn't scoff, because they're self-aware enough to know that they can't do that (especially the "subject interaction/management" part) any more than a typical portrait specialist can shoot motorsports or ski races.

The other thing with pro-level bodies is that they're engineered to the nth degree for responsiveness and rapid operation (once you've learned to use them, which is not simple). I don't shoot action sports much any more and don't really need one, but once you've used them extensively they're awfully hard to give up. I can make basically any adjustment I need near-instantly, without ever removing the camera from my eye. near-infinite 16 fps bursts of raw images. In summary you almost never have to wait for a Pro-level camera.

The "ancillary stuff" costs a lot more anyway when all is said and done.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#33

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

You can flatten a Shapton Glass stone just fine on loose SiC or a metal-bonded diamond plate (I use Atomas for the most part) but in general I agree: They're obscenely expensive for what you get, particularly when you consider that they're softer and wear faster than the Pros. The only one I have is the 10 mm 500#, and I consider that to have been a mistake.

The fact that they're softer than most of the Pros (there are softer, HSS-oriented stones like the #1500 in that line) means they do better with higher-alloy steels. I realize that's not your thing, but it's a consideration for some of us, though even then there are more cost-effective options.

I'm wondering if different distribution might bring them back down to Earth though.

My snarky comment about Shapton feel was more about subjective "feedback" (being able to feel what's going on) than about difficulty. They all work just fine, though you have to be careful to keep the #5000 sufficiently lubricated.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#34

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

With respect to that dud #7, the next time you see something like that you might try a Valtitan or Corinox file. They aren't made in conventional triangular taper sizes AFAIK, but if you could make a larger or smaller one work then I bet it would get the job done.

They're hardened to Rc72, which is quite a bit harder than any NOS Simonds that I know of. I tried filing the bevel of an Rc62 chisel with a Valtitan for kicks once, and it worked pretty well.

The Valtitans are made in Vallorbe Switzerland while Corinox are made in Maser, Italy (IIRC). I don't see much difference in quality between the two.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#35

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

Unfortunately, those files cost about the same amount as another saw. I thought about it too hard at the time, because it was about $65 or something. These days, I wouldn't buy a saw for $65 unless it was near perfect (that one had a repaired handle).

I'd throw it away sooner now, but I have to admit I haven't used the rest of the simonds double cut files for anything, so it's not like I wasted anything I'd use, aside maybe from 2 triangular files.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#36

Re: Evaluation

david weaver

Now, I know the edge was functional but nothing special. But when you need to function, functional is good! Plus, it's really easy to reproduce that edge in about a minute.

I think I said Ford 300 earlier. Nobody ever wrote an ode to the Ford 300, it didn't have a whole lot of horsepower, it didn't get great mileage, it was phased out probably due to fuel economy standards and emissions, but if you ever had one in a van or truck, it pretty much went when you turned the key and stopped when you turned it off, and it was a bit of a surprise how much it could move in regular driving if it had to.

People see the term "washita", then they go and read a chart and think it's a grinding stone. then maybe they get one and screw around with it and find that it's not finer than a translucent arkansas the first time they use it (it never really is, though you can make it finer than a trans ark that has just been lapped ala larry williams). But if you use one for a while, it's just like the Ford 300.

(I've shaved off of two of mine, too - it's not that hard to figure out how to use one to prepare a razor, which is something that a synthetic 4000 stone, for example, can never achieve).

The razor people have caught on to the washita as a utility stone and screwed up the price for them, though, so it's not like I'm trying to convince people to buy them. I've had to take risks to get the last few for $50 each, and sometimes those risks leaving you holding a hindostan or a coarse sandstone, and both of those are pretty useless in small bench stone sizes.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#37

oops..

david weaver

I should've looked a little harder. There's no shortage of praise on google when it comes to the Ford 300.

I never knew!

(I got introduced to one in an econoline van when I was in high school working for a tile contractor, and then saw them in pickups, on irrigation pumps, on tree chippers, etc...)

Moved a loaded super duty van better than any small V-8 ever would.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#38

Re: oops..

Brian Holcombe

Haha, I did expect heaps of praise over the Ford 300, I guess it's like the Chevy 250 in that there are some people who really like it.

That describes the edge pretty well, it's a wonderful workhorse!

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#39

Re: oops..

david weaver

I posted that because I knew you had a history playing with cars before playing with wood, and because in the last 10 years, I have heard more people complain about the loss of the Ford 300 to emissions than anything else, with the possible exception of the GM 3800 (which I also really liked). No winner of beauty pageants, but made for a really driveable car.

I never ran into the 250, but one of our "family" grain trucks (probably 8 ton payload) had a 292 in it. I remember very little other than the fact that the speedo, gas gauge and brakes all didn't work. The first to not at all, and the last just barely (emergency brake didn't work well, either - you had to park it against something).

Anyway, after this talk today, I went to etsy to see if I could find any hidden washitas and I found what might be a hard and fine labeled pike stone for $18. I could be wrong, but it's my form of gambling.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#40

Re: oops..

Patrick Chase

Rule 51 of the Internet: If it exists there is obsessive Internet fandom of it.

Note that depending on the nature of said obsession there may be significant participatory overlap with the better-known "Rule 34", though how that manifests itself in the context of classic Inline-6 truck engines is perhaps best left uncontemplated.

Now that I think of it this entire thread is a little rule-34-y...

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#41

Re: oops..

david weaver

The Y seems like an invitation to steer this conversation to the ford Y-block, at least until someone has a woodworking topic.

:\

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#42

This thread has more tangents than...

david weaver

... a Riemann sum, but I've enjoyed it until something woodworking comes along.

(noise of fingers tapping on desk)

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#43

Re: This thread has more tangents than...

steve voigt

I've always sort of loathed Riemann. Compare how Archimedes solves the area of a parabola--an aesthetically beautiful solution and an intuitive sort of proto-calculus--with Riemann's soul-crushing fifty gazillion little rectangles. It's just ugly brute force.

How's that for a tangent? :D :D :D

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#44

But...

John in NM

Which one is known as the "Method of Exhaustion?" :D

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#45

Re: This thread has more tangents than...

david weaver

i can't say much. My brain normally works on brute force and attempts to refine from there, but usually just craps out before a solution is found.

I only vaguely remember math, though. Aside from what I use day to day (which certainly isn't similar to riemann sums).

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#46

Re: oops..

Brian Holcombe

The motor I took out of my 67' Camaro before turning into a race car was a 250 inline 6. I hated it as a teenager and because I was building a 385" motor which was what replaced the inline 6, but as an adult I might actually enjoy that 6 cylinder.

There was maybe one or two guys in stock eliminator that raced them, and some were turning pretty respectable numbers. I raced mine a handful of times the season prior to putting the fast motor in.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#47

Re: But...

steve voigt

I'm exhausted just thinking about it.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#48

Re: This thread has more tangents than...

Patrick Chase

Isn't it sort of amazing that taking the brute-force solution to its ultimate conclusion ended up creating something as elegant as the Riemann Integral, though?

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#49

Re: oops..

david weaver

I like the way they sound when they've been worked up to high spec, even though they're not really that fast. (I'm sure my dad had a 250 i6 in his first "real" car, a 1969 firebird. He said even with that, it was deadly on wet or snow covered roads).

Big fan of the FE fords, too, but they're not common where I grew up (people are too cheap).