Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Posts

We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#1

We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

:b

I have been delving into more natural stones lately, something I can't dispense with for some reason. And my little $12 scope has served me well in sharpening razors that I sell - just making sure the edge is even, but as I get better at sharpening razors (it sounds ridiculous, but you do get better at it with various stones because they don't all work the same way), the results from different things get closer together.

In order to see the difference, I've ordered a metallurgical microscope with a camera mount. I was a little bit disappointed to find that there aren't any cheap, and even one from india (which is where I ordered from) at a relatively low true power (600x in this case) is about $450 delivered, but sometimes you just feel the need to satisfy curiosity, and I want something good enough to take pictures looking into an edge.

Nothing new, there are edge pictures with SEM, but they get so close in that the effect can be the opposite - it's difficult to tell when something that's really smooth isn't rough, because at high enough magnification, every edge looks terrible.

I'm hoping this thing will get a good view of wood and stone surfaces, too, to study the stones and the wood surfaces, etc, and just as a device for my kids to view things that you can't see in a biological microscope.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#2

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Bruce Mack

In April 2016 I got a soft arkansas from Dan's. It is my favorite for sharpening my pocket knife and the short blade wood handled knife used for trimming. I bought it because of your counseling. Over the years I acquired more sharpening media than needed but the process was so much fun.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#3

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

I'm enabling...that makes me feel a little guilty (though arkansas stones are immensely practical).

Inevitably, if I start posting (elsewhere, I won't pollute this board with much of it) about the edges gotten from various stones, etc, people will buy. that seems to be the nature of the internet....

... it is in fact what got me to buy a scope (which isn't here and won't be for a while, so I probably shouldn't count my chickens before they hatch assuming it will be undamaged). I saw someone looking at things on razor edges that I can't see (which I have been able to hone without issue for almost a decade, but still)...

I'm curious about what i'll be able to see at higher magnification, because the low-cost scopes take a degree of experience to interpret (some abrasives make a very even edge, but scratches on the bevel catch a lot of light).

Anyway, glad you've found favor in the soft ark. Very versatile stones if you're willing to spend some time with them.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#4

what microscope?

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

I was playing with some cheaper electronic microscopes a few years ago, and even that was intriguing if kind of tricky.

Thanks,

Simon

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#5

Re: what microscope?

david weaver

The electronic microscopes are definitely tricky. There are light issues, work holding issues, and adjustment issues.

The one I got is on peebay:

$432 with economy shipping:

"Trinocular-Metallurgical-Microscope-Metal-Surface-Inspection-w-1-3Mp-USB-Camera"

I'd like higher power and more resolution, but apparently, the turret cameras for microscopes are a lot more expensive than regular cameras. Stuff with turret and binocular view in the 800x category+ seems to be another notch up in price.

We'll see how it goes - the stability, light control and true magnification should really help do what I want to do, and maybe give me the opportunity to educate my kids on some interesting (but not critical to know) non-metal things that don't fit on a bio microscope slide.

All in all, I can't fault what I've gotten out of my first scope for $11.

http://straightrazorplace.com/hones/111422-full-rotation-oilstones.html

(these pictures were taken from it, but I can't coax any more out of it with edges and that's at high magnification. Still not bad - you can see enough to know what's unfinished or damaged by a strop if you're honing razors).

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#6

Re: what microscope?

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

Your $11 microscope results look better than my $80 microscope...

Enjoy!

Simon

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#7

Re: what microscope?

david weaver

I'm making unnecessary comments at this point, but when I looked to improve upon my microscope situation (and really didn't want to spend what I spent, which is going to make the wife major p.o.'d), it appeared to me that almost everything that works with reflective light was about the same below the $250 level.

They all seem to operate around either the pen size chip-inspection type camera (which takes really clear pictures, but is low magnification and not that cheap), or the turret style thing that I have that comes with various apparatuses to hold the scope (mine came with the worst - a stand that couldn't actually stay upright if you tipped the microscope down - which you have to do with everything).

There were some others like the QX3, and follow-ons but reviews are inconsistent and it sounds like they don't have updated software to use with current operating systems.

The only low-cost device that tempted me was an inverted surface reflective microscope that was $90 on amazon and had a true 800x optical (more than mine). But it's 800x, period and very limited in scope.

There is a huge market of student-ish scopes for biology (really capable devices that are maybe a bit lightweight, but inexpensive), but not much for surface reflective - the version I bought is probably what would be referred to as homeowner grade, because the western-world versions have another zero on the price.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#8

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

I am hoping that once you get this metallurgical scope fired up, you'll be willing to show us some edges. Maybe you'll be able to show the difference between different finish stones, or the effect of stropping, etc.

Wiley

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#9

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

Poking my head over the WC parapet, having read a lot of David's writing elsewhere....

Do you happen to know the effective resolution (um per pixel) of that rig at maximum magnification, and the resulting effective f/#.

I've been satiating my shameful sharpening compulsions with a 5X macro lens (Canon MP-E 65) on a 20 Mpix digicam (Canon 1Dx II). The resulting pitch is 1.3 microns/pixel at the subject, but the catch is that the lens' effective aperture at that magnification is f/16 wide open (and f/22 when stopped down a bit to optimize quality). The resulting diffraction-limited resolution is more like 4 um at the subject.

EDIT: I looked at the auction-site listing and it doesn't call out numerical aperture, which is what determines resolution (assuming minimal aberrations). My macro lens has an NA of .32 at 5X, which is on par with cheap metallurgical scopes.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#10

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

Will do, Wiley. I got the scope Thursday, I believe, and set it up this morning.

It's a little harder to use than I thought it would be, but it was quick to set up. 600x is also much closer than I thought it would be - it's so close, in fact, that the tops and bottoms of particles on a sharpening stone are in different focus. Same with the grooves in normal pieces of metal - the tops and bottoms are not in the same focus.

But it takes much clearer pictures, I just need to get the light figured out.

I expect that my favorite washita edges will look pretty doggish and torn at high magnification, but they will still be my favorite, anyway. They're like a four wheel drive ford utility van with no frills and a 300 cube six. All utility and easy to maintain. And discontinued.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#11

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

Am I correct that you're looking for the answer of what shows up on the digital image, and not what you see with the naked eye?

The scope is 600x max, which I thought would be too little, but that's actually too high of magnification. I haven't hooked up the camera yet, so I can't really answer the question of how much distance is covered from edge to edge in the picture.

I understand the 1.3MP picture is 1280x1024, but until I find out how much territory the image actually covers, no clue about what will be shown in the picture.

My needs are simpler. I can see whether or not an edge has damage with my old scope (a razor edge). I would guess at this point that the old one was probably 100x or so, despite its claim of 500x. It can't quite get a clear image at 100x, and 500 is probably a digital zoom, which only worsens that problem unless I'm missing something. I just want to get a little closer to see the difference between whats at the very edge when a coticule was used and what's at the very edge when a very slow japanese natural finisher is used. I might take pictures of synthetics, but my interest in them for anything other than coarse work is pretty much long gone (and coarse work on razors is still better done with naturals).

How this will apply to woodworking, it probably won't, and there's definitely a danger of looking at things at 600x and drawing invalid conclusions. I have seen other peoples' pictures of 800x edges, and everything that you can use to sharpen something looks terrible at that when viewing a razor - looks like the edge of a mountain ridge with undulations, etc.

Not sure where visible light cuts off, either - half a micron? Chromium oxide razor edges always look spectacular under a microscope, but they feel only scarcely sharper than the best natural stones, and functionally not even that sometimes - just the same.

I am completely ignorant when it comes to talking about this stuff above "looks good" or "doesn't" or "blurry" or "clear". And when it comes to cameras, even worse so, despite having a sister who is a professional photographer with about the same spending sense as i have with tools...actually, she's far worse.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#12

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

Advanced photography is WAY worse than tools. My camera was $5K new, the 1X-5X macro lens I referenced is $1K, the tripod/head/rails setup for serious macro/micro work adds another $2K, etc etc.

Higher-end metallurgical scopes from Nikkor etc have numerical apertures of about 1. If we define resolution as the highest frequency with at least 10% MTF, then a perfect microscope (purely diffraction-limited, no aberrations) with an NA of 1 can resolve 1400 cycles/mm at the plane of optimal focus, or a bit better than your 1 micron guesstimate.

The catch is that resolution falls off VERY rapidly as you move out of focus. An NA of 1.0 means that the cone of light forms a ~52 degree angle an the object. Moving 1 micron out of ideal focus in either direction creates a blur disc ~1 micron in diameter. At 2 microns on either side of the plane of optimal focus MTF10 has already fallen from 1400 cyc/mm to 550 cyc/mm. Needless to say, the actual resolution that you can achieve when photographing 3D objects is quite a bit lower than these gaudy numbers would suggest.

For that reason "magnification" matters a lot less than people think, and as you say your scope is probably overpowered relative to its underlying resolution. Beyond a certain point all magnification really does is fill your eyepiece with blur. It's probably worth noting that the aforementioned Nikkor's, which have first-rate optics and basically realize the full potential of visible-band microscopy, top out at 200X or so.

SEMs have much more favorable tradeoffs because of the way they operate.

I'll post a couple images from my setup when I have some spare cycles. It does OK for edge examination. Nowhere near SEM territory, but OK.

EDIT: Fixed "100% MTF" typo. I meant 10.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#13

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

The trouble with SEMs is they show such a small cross section that people get confused with what they're looking at. There's nothing that you can't see with visible light that matters in steel sharpness because, well, the level that the edge is held is not any finer than that.

There was a big to-do last year maybe when someone opened a sharpening blog and posted SEM pictures, but I don't think anyone who was interested in sharpening really learned too much.

My interest is a bit more specific, at least as far as this thing goes (because the other $11 scope could tell me if an edge had damage or was subpar quality in that stropping removed large chunks). It's to see what creates a finished edge with various stones, because sharpening a razor is a bit different with different stones. You can use the finest hardest japanese stones and as long as you finish the edge on a decent razor, it's sharp. However, you can also get to about the same level of sharpness with coarser stones, but you can go past the point of maximum sharpness and create a fragile edge with them.

I think this isn't useful for woodworking, but I'm curious, because if you can find the happy medium with a given setup (which an experienced barber with only a couple of stones would find out by trial and error), you can get a very good edge very quickly.

I'm doing most of my examination looking, so the items you're talking about don't seem as relevant to me ( I gather what you're saying, if you can get a high enough resolution image, you can zoom in ). Most of the time that I'm looking at something, though, it'll just be through the binocular eyepieces on the scope.

600x, though, is too much (surprisingly) because no edge really looks that good at that magnification. It may not be too much for pictures, but I'm not sure. I didn't get a very good camera with mine because the scope mounted cameras are expensive, and the pictures are secondary (but might be interesting).

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#14

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

I basically agree, though your approach is far too reasonable to live up to its "100% sharpening perv" billing.

Science of Sharp (the blog you reference) on the other hand is the unquestioned benchmark for sharpening perviness.

Seriously, any diagnostic tool requires some judgment both with respect to what to capture and how to interpret the results. SEM shots can be great if you limit yourself to "meaningful" magnifications and/or ignore meaningless differences. The problem with scienceofsharp is that the author lost all perspective and went totally overboard.

I think that Leonard Lee's book is a good example of "SEM done right". He used the tool in a manner that leveraged its strengths (lack of specular "glint", favorable resolution/DoF tradeoffs) while avoiding the pitfalls of excessive resolution and over-interpretation.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#15

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

When I look at high-magnification edge photos, I always wonder what I am looking for in the photo. When a blade has the quality of sharpness in action, in actual planing say, can we identify and see in photos the specific qualities which make it sharp-in-action, and which distinguish it from blades which have lesser initial sharpness or durable sharpness?

For example, if we limit ourselves to say, blades sharpened at 30 degrees, is a really sharp, or durably sharp, blade more 'compact' at the edge? Meaning, does it have smaller and more uniform dentition or serration? Or does it have shallower vertical scoring normal to the edge? Or both?

If we could establish the visible attributes of sharp-in-action, perhaps that would lead to interpretations of which stones, which strops, which protocols best provide these attributes.

I realize this is all easy to say and immensely hard to do, especially if you have a day job, but I believe you are highly gifted in making these interpretations.

Wiley

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#16

Evaluation

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think you are getting to the heart of the matter, Wiley. The best way to evaluate an edge is performance: ease of use, quality of wood surface, edge life (that is edge life at a high level of performance), ease of maintenance.

Some think that one can evaluate an edge by looking at the number on the box, as in "sharpening to XX,000 grit". Thinking one dimensionally like this leads to emphasis on "grit equivalence" and such. This stuff is only valuable when it jibes with observable phenomena in actual use.

It is likewise with the magnification. The picture of the edge is helpful insomuch as it helps explain what we already know about the performance of an edge. If by looking at a microscope David can help explain why one regimen or one stone is better than another, something he already knows from experience, then it can help guide him in further experiments. Looking at magnification alone is a clumsy way to evaluate an edge.

For a skill like sharpening, intuition and logic should move forward hand in hand. Our progress is guided by observation and experience. For best results, a high level of concentration is needed both during sharpening and in using the tool.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#17

Re: Evaluation

david weaver

In response to both Wiley and Warren - you are 100% right. Especially in the context of woodworking here, I'm not going to learn anything new with this scope. The cap iron was a lot more important than studying edges, and my desire to chase edges and angles, etc, sort of went away with it. It works better with the washita than any stone works without the cap.

Maybe I can learn something interesting, but use in the cycle of work is a better teacher. Too much talk about angles and stuff convinces us that something like a stanley chisel won't hold up in cocobolo just because it doesn't at the same angle as V11.

Hopefully I'll learn more about it with razors, but if I manage to put a page together showing various things, hopefully I can avoid getting people fascinated with close-up pictures that lose context of edges in use.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#18

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

Yeah, that guy is definitely overboard (more "perv" about sharpening than me, at least in display of it) than me, but I'll admit I stopped reading his blog pretty early on. The things he was showing had already been shown by alex gilmore (with razors) with an optical scope and the magnification was maybe too close for anyone to learn anything useful.

Since we're talking about him, I went out and looked at his page and did finally see something I always thought wasn't true - the sentiment that working a japanese slurry "breaks the particles" down into something really fine. He has pictures of the silica particles showing that they pretty much stay the same size, and the non-cutting part of the mixture breaks down. I always figured that we could dull those particles and maybe clog the stone surface with them a little bit, or dull the stone surfaces, but silica isn't particularly friable or it wouldn't feel so dull so quickly.

(only interesting in the context of sharpening razors where you take advantage of that dullness).

I've gotten nowhere saying that on razor forums, but I don't have an issue with that. I rarely believe other people without examining something or thinking about it and don't expect anyone to believe anything that I say (but still get annoyed when they don't!!).

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#19

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

One thing I give 'scienceofsharp' credit for is finally debunking some of Brent Beach's more risible claims.

For example the "massive scratches" that Brent claimed to have found with Shapton polishers are nowhere in evidence. Shaptons run coarse (~33% larger abrasive size at any given grit #), have sh*t for feedback, and have obvious economic issues, but the one problem they don't have is "rogue particles" as Brent claimed.

As you say and to paraphrase MacArthur: SiO2 doesn't break down. It just dulls away. I suspect the confusion originated from the fact that natural waterstone slurry leaves a dull finish like SiC, and people not realizing which shared attribute was actually causing that.

I think the "meta-point" here is that even scienceofsharp's images can contribute useful knowledge IF you're careful about interpretation (i.e. focus on the scales and attributes that matter). He was not.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#20

Re: Evaluation

Patrick Chase

I've watched your videos, and I don't question the results you get with your Washitas [*], but I just can't bring myself to go from something that coarse to a bare leather strop. A good synthetic polisher or a well-broken-in translucent or black Ark, yes, but not a Washita.

I agree about relative importance of cap irons. By popularizing that knowledge (and being a bit more willing to engage in endless discussions and provide remedial education than certain people who knew all along :) ) you've improved the work of countless aspiring woodworkers.

[*] On a semi-related note I particularly appreciated the one where you whaled on a dished Washita with a dull belt sander for so long that the direction of sunlight had obviously changed and everything in the vicinity was covered in not-so-fine dust.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#21

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

Retreating to an earlier point in this thread, the reason I prefer a camera to a metallurgical scope for this sort of thing comes down to working distance.

My setup has an effective resolution of a couple microns at 5:1, which is more than good enough for most work, but also has a working distance of 40 mm (from the front of the lens to the plane of focus). In contrast most scopes are down to a few mm at most at that sort of resolution. I don't think I would have been able to capture the shots of Iwasaki float toothing that I recently posted on the forum-that-you-no-longer-frequent with a scope. At the very least it would have taken significant fixturing to place the plane of focus along one of the diagonal cross-channels, whereas moving the camera around the file was pretty simple (though admittedly I used a geared head and XY micrometer stages on top of that).

Note that camera magnifications and scope magnifications are very different things, because a camera at 1:1 is already heavily magnified compared to the human eye. My setup is probably equivalent to a high-quality scope at 100:1 or so.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#22

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

david weaver

They can - as you mentioned, and I've suggested to other people, just getting data or observation isn't very useful if you don't know that much about the subject.

I've dealt with a lot of people (and admittedly, I can be bullheaded and hard to convince) who believe that enthusiasm and new information is a substitute for experience. The thread about saw hardness that got carried away a couple of years ago was a good example. Saws in the 60s hardness were asserted with measurements on parts up to 70. Makes no sense, and neither does the assertion that we just want harder and harder saws - we have to file them at some point, and it's not much fun filing a saw that doesn't match the files very well.

Brent Beach is dismissive of other people, leads newbies into a trap of extravagant and super overwrought sharpening devices (that are ultimately very limiting), and has no clue about cap irons (and doesn't want to learn anything, either). that's OK, there are things I have written off, too, but all of us aren't infallible and those of us who get too consumed with the data end up being the easiest to prove wrong. It took me a long time as a beginner to pay attention to warren and george instead of the blogroll (actually, george was able to convince me that I didn't have much to offer, but should listen...and pretty quickly). Warren's words require the observer to supply interpolating information and effort, which I was a little slower to get to.

So, brent's got the data everywhere and is very certain of his conclusions, but they aren't something you'd see in a shop where people make things.

(having trouble making a point today) We're all responsible for actually using things we learn rather than just parroting them or drawing conclusions and dismissing experienced conclusions. I have no clue why Brent thinks shaptons aren't closely graded - they might be the most closely graded stones you can buy, and they have a heavenly feel to a sharpener who is not a beginner. I am guilty of going crazy about a decade ago buying every synthetic stone I could find, and they were my favorite because they're not fragile under an edge like some others. And if you buy the kuromaku from japan, they're cheap. What they've done to price abrasives to the US market (either them or their distribution) is another thing - that's a shame.

I bought and sold and now have two of them again - the pro orange and cream (kuromaku versions from japan). The pair with shipping was about $95. Maybe the most practical combination of synthetic stones you can find if you're just trying to do work with them.

I pondered the camera idea a little more, it makes more sense now that I've thought about it. I ogled my sister's cameras a couple of years ago (I'm sure they're out of date now - D4 or something (4, N4? who knows), overly complicated but I guess photographers looking for a write off can justify them). If you can get the lighting right, I'm assuming that some of those have high-resolution real time video and you could just do the same thing as you can with a microscope and a low-quality turret camera. but the latter is about $450, or $11 if you're willing to deal with hand held, and I think the camera body my sister praised was about $6K when new. It should make toast and choose your outfit for that price.

I still haven't gotten the software installed on my computer yet for the turret camera on my new microscope, but I'll get that done soon enough. That would seem a simple thing to most people, but my kids broke my DVD drive and my standalone drive cable is missing.

"getting the light situation worked out" is different for you and me. There's plenty of light in the metallurgical scope, but deciding what will actually look good is something else entirely, and then holding a razor at 25 degrees on a flat aluminum bed is something else (so far I've worked out a piece of O1 stock, a couple of magnets and maybe I'll stick a piece of paper to the opposite side of whatever I'm scoping. Everything has a learning curve, just like I thought it would be great to view something at 600x, but it's actually too much magnification for practical use, even in judging a razor edge.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#23

Re: Evaluation

Brian Holcombe

Howdy Patrick, good to see you on this board. David works magic with the washita stones, I have had the pleasure upon receiving David's planes to try out the resulting edge from a washita. On these plane carbon steels that edge is really fantastic, I worked the blades with what I have which are Japanese stones and really didn't sense much if any change.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#24

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

Patrick Chase

Point accepted w.r.t. stone feel. I prefer Choseras, most Sigmas (the "1000 hard" is no fun IMO), and Bester/Imanishi to Shaptons, but everybody has their own take, and I have no experience with JNats and therefore a different baseline than you. I bought my Shapton Pros from Stu like you, but even so the fact that they're 15 mm thick means the price per unit abrasive is on the high side compared to all but Chosera.

w.r.t. light, I mostly rely on flash (Canon MT-24EX) for close-up work. It provides 2 positionable heads with ratio control. When combined with glint-management techniques like cross-polarization it's enough for almost all purposes.

The issue with positioning complex objects on a scope is what I was referring to when I mentioned "fixturing" in another post. At some point it becomes a lot easier to move a camera around a fixed subject laying in a "natural" position.

We basically agree about interpretation. I concede that you have a broader base of experience and are therefore likely better at it.

$6K is about what pro-level bodies go for (and the D4 was replaced last year by the D5), though for the sort of work we're discussing here you can get almost equivalent results with a $1000 body. It's harder to save on the lenses, camera supports, and lighting, though. If you shoot any sort of fast-moving sports the pro bodies do indeed basically make toast and choose your outfit. High frame rates with bang-on depth tracking don't come cheap. Those bodies are also built like tanks, which again comes in handy for sports work.

Re: We will be going 100% sharpening perv...

#25

Re: Evaluation

david weaver

That was only about 15 minutes of time, but I did have to rush to do it just as the sun was going down. It probably looks like it occurred over hours.

Lack of planning.

I used this chisel to break in that stone (japanese chisels love washitas - they can't be cut that deeply by them, and the jigane (soft) cleans the top of the stone and keeps it active.

http://postimg.org/image/hbi7iv2w5/68680a13/

In terms of fineness on bare leather, it's a matter of using a stone for a while and fiddling. They can operate in a wide range, and experimentation will show you the full range, and you can then pick what part of it you want to operate in. I let mine cut finely and let a grinder do the heavy metal removal so that I can allow them to work in a small area (chisel above notwithstanding - I do use them on japanese chisels, though, as japanese prefinishing natural stones aren't abundant and most aren't very good).