Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Millenials and craftsmanship

Posts

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#26

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

TomD

"The "maker" trend is growing so at the very least the next generations are working with tools :)"

I think that is probably true to some extent, both as you mean it: that Makers may move on to other things or at least continue to make stuff. And also because there isn't much of an entry fee to becoming a maker, everyone is welcome, so are successors can have dual citizenship from the get go, even if perhaps they didn't particularly seek it.

But in another sense makerism is the evil other. The basic concepts come from rapid prototyping, and the idea is that everyone can be a maker without any skill whatsoever. These are the people who will invent a technology that will 3D print furniture from parametric files (zero design skills) using extrudable lignin that bonds in a realistic wood structure and is indistinguishable from real wood, and where the depositions, as they are now in plastic, can be in real dovetail form, right down to the mediating glue layer. David can have his lumps and tool marks.

Makerism is a radical idea of going directly from ideas to things with all the actual making being done by machines, or other strategies. It is making free making. Which is, if you don't mind terrorists 3D printing viruses and one hopes doctors 3d printing the organs that are needed to repair the viral damage, is a pretty good idea.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#27

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

TomD

"I personally have zero interest in something it is symmetrically identical and has completely lost the human element, but that doesn't mean I want to make something that looks like it would be in the berenstein bears tree house."

It is interesting that you are drawn to planes, as are we all, when they are the most dehumanizing tool in the box, potentially. Planes have several levels of function but making things identical and without the human element (screwing up) is pretty much what they do on some of those levels. Though personally I see a lot of human history, both tragic and otherwise as very connected to the idea of order, and all that jazz. Maybe jazz is the wrong term. I wouldn't call straight lines non-human, any more than mathematics would be, even though it is precise. Maybe it is another of the en-soi, pour-soi type dichotomies.

"I guarantee that as few of people as there are out there who like what I like, there are zero in my house (my wife would like for me to quit woodworking and just "buy stuff" instead)."

Maybe you should see if you can't find some kind of woodworking she would like to do with you:


Maybe you can sell her on the idea that sinking a 16 penny is like driving in golf?

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#28

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

David Weaver

Oh, no. I was just combining the two options that tom provided. My cable knit sweater would have to have dream theater or led zeppelin on it.

If I had to choose a Madonna type, I'd at least choose cyndi Lauper. Good enough.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#29

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

david weaver

I'm not sure planes are that great for making things identical. They're good for making a surface flat, but it's not the flat surfaces or straight lines that make things identical. I do prefer lines to be straight when you want them to be straight, and not when you want them not to, not like log furniture where there are lines that are all over the place.

My wife definitely wouldn't get any golf analogies!

She specializes in routines, organizing and cleaning. And father figures being sort of martyrs - the opposite of my upbringing!