Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Millenials and craftsmanship

Posts

Millenials and craftsmanship

#1

Millenials and craftsmanship

Josko Catipovic

Just heard an interesting NPR segment on the millenials' lack of interest in antiques, ants and crafts, and it got me wondering if anyone is observing this lack of interest in new and custom high-end furniture, as well.

According to NPR (and a Skinners' dealer I know) this lack of interest is seriously depressing the market for high-end antiques, including furniture.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#2

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

david weaver

It exists, and I'm sure it will continue.

The mrs. has a bunch of friends who are physicians, and some who are low-mid 6 figure executives. I have never seen any of them purchase anything old other than shabby furniture that you would find at a flea market.

All of these folks have no interest in creating, nor buying anything that was created by hand. They want to spend their money on their kids, on travel and on eating. They want to do things like work abroad for two years, even if it's a net loss, and take their kids and spouses with them - for the experience. As in, people with money are moving away from things and more toward experiences. My relatives, some of them with a significant amount of money, valued travel less (at least a lot less frequently) and didn't value blowing a lot money on dinner at all. To them, antiques were a connection to the past that they enjoyed.

We don't have the same income my wife's friends have, but my wife definitely would prefer an empty house and dinner out + travel over pretty much anything. To her, a $2k solid wood table and chair set from an "amish furniture" dealer is an over-the-top furniture purchase.

This exists in the antique tractor market, too (some of my relatives were farmers). The generation of farmers who grew out of the depression and some after them have made a great deal of money on land appreciation when they retire, and some of that has been spent on rare tractors or just older tractors that they remember using but discarded. They find antiques and if they're not that rare, have them "done up" to look like new. The generation following them is going to have a lot fewer farmers in it and nobody else is going to buy a 6 ton antique that doesn't fit in a garage. This has been discussed by collectors on that side for about the last decade. I've moved away and haven't followed it, but would suspect that for both furniture and that, the truly rare stuff will continue to appreciate. The nice stuff that's not that rare is where the market is going to disappear.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#3

When we were in our 20's

Chuck Nickerson

how many of us were interested in buying high-end custom furniture and antiques? Very few that I know.

On the other hand, my local woodworking club has enjoyed a nice influx of new members under the age of 35. We've been averaging five new members a year and four are under the age of 35.

This influx started once we redesigned out website, and we keep the site updated.

They're out there.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#4

Re: When we were in our 20's

david weaver

Your point about the influx is a good one. I think more people want to build things now that most of us don't use our hands for much during the day. We just (me included) don't want to buy anything expensive from other people.

(I'm not a millenial, though. I'm early 40s as are our friends - but they, too, have no interest in buying expensive things, and no qualms about spending $10K to go overseas with their kids for a week).

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#5

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

Tony Memphis

I don't know about the furniture bit, but there is a huge maker community out there and they are extremely creative and most I see are very young. So, I think creativity is alive and well. Different tools and tastes? Perhaps, but creative none the less!

I don't buy into the labels anyhow. Not sure what I am supposed to be! Depends on who you ask! ha!

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#6

The next generation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The next generation has been bringing the world to an end for thousands of years. Og the caveman probably complained about how few of the kids out there understood the nuances of a good rock for clubbing the mastodons. When the millenials get older, some of them will be interested in traditional furniture; most won't. The same is true of Baby Boomers, and the parents of Baby Boomers.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#7

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

North of the Border

Several years ago, I watched a PBS program and one of the views expressed was that if you are a collector of items in antique nature (toys, collectibles, etc.), the best time to sell them to recover your investment or to draw the best return is NOW, before the generation which collects such things dies completely.

I figure that most antique stuff including tools are in the hands of people who are between 50 and 85 and the segment of people is thinning by the day. In 25 to 30 years, I would guess 60 to 70% of current collectors who are main the source buyers of these old things are gone, leaving behind more antique possessions in the market for sale but fewer and fewer potential buyers. Antique shops and malls are also dwindling in number.

I know not one single person under 35 (other than my family) who are interested in paying a couple to several hundred dollars more for a handmade furniture than a mass produced piece. Has any one of you known personally someone who does furniture making for a living and is considered well-to-do, because of his woodworking career? I have known none all these years.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#8

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

TM Stock

Nostalgia for the things that we grew up with will not change, but each generation sees a change in the nature of those things. Don't expect millenials who grew up with PS3 and Xbox electronic games and toys to show much in the way of interest for our generation's G.I Joe or Rock'em Sock'em Robots.

One of my students - a gent that operates a 'man's antique store' - has observed that the bottom is falling out of the market for old china sets, antique silver, and all the other stuff that used to routinely show up on wedding registries. Why? Because the last generation that was told as children to "...get out the good china, dear - it's Sunday dinner" are dying off, and the market for formal dinnerware and good silver with it. Don't expect a recovery until we see a return to the social and societal values of the 1940's, which is to say never. We have moved on.

Lots of parallels. I cannot recall the last time I saw a commercial for Rogaine targeting men...Vin Diesel and Bruce Willis made bald cool, so baldness has ceased to carry any social stigma (recent surveys show it is perceived as 'more masculine', though still 'less attractive' than a full head of hair...that will change as well). Not sure if we will ever see a wave of nostalgia for hair pieces, but I know I would hate to be sitting on a warehouse full of men's rugs OR hair restoration products right now.

Recognition of quality in durable goods is a very different issue, not to be confused with nostalgia for our lost youth or a desire to acquire an excess of material possessions (aka collecting). Millenials - like every generation before them - will eventually mature to the point where 'good enough to get by for my crash pad' will become 'there's got to be something better than this crap' - so I don't expect the bottom to drop out of the high-end furniture market. Unless VR becomes much, much more popular, we will still want to have quality durable good in our lives, if only because the kids are less likely to destroy them.

Where we can expect to see some marked differences in behavior in something relevant to this forum is in hand tool acquisition. For Boomers like me, the only option to the crap that Stanley, Record and other tool companies produced in the post-WWII period and beyond was older Stanley, et al stuff, so the value proposition was such that we had to buy used/vintage/antique to get the quality we desired - there were no real options in the new tool market.

For those equipping a hand tool shop today - including Gen X and Y woodworkers, there is no real issue beyond cost in finding new tools which - with a few niche exceptions like hand saws - equal or exceed the quality of available used/vintage/antique stuff. I am not certain what this will do to the market for used/vintage/antique tools, but I don't believe that we will see much of an expansion in that market, barring a failure of our millennials to finally move out of our basements/spare bedrooms and become gainfully employed such that trading money for time becomes attractive enough to justify $300 hand plane purchases.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#9

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

CJ in MPLS

Depending on how one defines 'millennial', they likely don't have a hell of a lot of money for high end antiques. What is more, they have spent a fairly large chunk of their lives going through some tough economic times. It doesn't seem strange to me that IKEA is more up their alley.

That being said, having the bottom drop out of the antique market is the kind of trend that gets young people buying antiques. By extension, once the kids are old enough to be more biddable than the family dog and checks aren't bouncing all the time, one can start thinking of how to replace the IKEA stuff with something that won't break in six months.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#10

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

Brian Holcombe

This is really something hard to judge until they're in a more established age range.

I sold furniture professionally before working for myself, many many many young people are interested in mid century works and 20th century design.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#11

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

Josko Catipovic

Sort of along the same lines... I followed up on this topic with Skinner and was just able to buy a Vienna Secession bronze for roughly a tenth of what I had expected it to be worth. I put in a silly lowball bid with Skinners, the statue came up for auction, and I actually got it. :O Apparently there are just unbelievably good deals in a wide spectrum of arts and crafts art and objects.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#12

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

North of the Border

"the IKEA stuff with something that won't break in six months"

I suppose you used this description figuratively, because none of the IKEA stuff I have bought and still owned has broken, some as old as 18 years.

They include guest beds, night tables, bookcases/shelves, kitchenware and lights. All made in China, except a few in Europe.

I think people like to describe IKEA furniture this way, because it is mass-produced. When my son finished his college and moved out his apartment, he sold all his IKEA belongings still in good condition after 4 years, to new college kids looking for a good deal (mostly sold at 50% of what he paid for). I can imagine the new owners will sell theirs when they are done with it, 4 years later or so. In fact, lots of IKEA pieces are sold and resold on kijiji these days.

Most traditional furniture cannot be disassembled unlike IKEA's. Young people, more mobile than the old generations, seem to like the fact that they can take apart, say, a bed and transport it without incurring a heavy moving cost.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#13

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

TM Stock

I think I speak from experience here, as I've been an Ikea customer for the past 30 years. I have had a bunch of Ikea stuff that has moved through the house and out to nephews, nieces, donated to the dump, etc. As long as the stuff is solid wood or wood laminates, it holds up decently other than the KD fasteners on bed frames, end tables, etc. that need attention on a routine basis. Much of the lower end stuff and nearly all of the casework has a fair amount of chipboard or MDF content that is a lot more delicate. Try moving one of those Melomine-covered chipboard wardrobes or bookcases...best to plan ahead and glue up the piece at assembly with polyurethane or similar, and waterproof the bottom 4" if anywhere near moisture.

Most youngsters will be fully satisfied with even the low-end stuff. We still have a few pieces in the house - some solid wood stacking end tables and a Euro size queen bed frame in the second spare bedroom that has only required repair a few times over the 30 years we've owned it, but then some couples are harder on beds than the average, so might have been trouble-free for others.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#14

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

North of the Border

It is true that Ikea pieces need more attention and care when moving them. The last time I moved, I took apart the assemblies if I could (bed frames, for example, storage cupboards, another example) and reassembled them. Over the years, we have given away some because the styles were no longer our liking rather than were thrown away because of failure. I have not come across any Ikea furniture failures due to its design or use of material. Of course, if it was veneered mdf and you treated it as solid wood, it could fail.

IKEA has been working on a new assembly system (a competition to the Domino Joiner connectors?). I don't know the release time-frame but it promises to simplify the assembly process and reduce its difficulty. IKEA products cannot be compared to high-end or custom furniture, but it serves a large segment of consumers so well that it is possibly the world's largest furniture producer.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#15

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

CJ in MPLS

IKEA was a place holder for cheap furniture. I actually like IKEA, but I do have to recognize that to hit the price point that they do have, they have to cut a few corners. I've found that it is good value, but that it is not going to go the distance.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#16

Clint Searl

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

Clint Searl

My impression of the current high end furniture market, especially the stuff coming from small "crafty" outfits, is that design has devolved to either a bunch of boxes with drawers and doors or slabs of urban harvested natural edge and reclaimed "environmentally friendly" wood slapped together and pretentiously promoted to affluent young professionals as high fashion. It's that for the money crowd or IKEA for the rest.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#17

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

Very good discussion as it has been on my mind lately. A trend I see is that of painting antique furniture in trendy pastel colors. I could not believe how large the market has developed for this. Painting over perfectly good antiques. In one case, I saw an "Art Deco" piece with patterned veneer. Completely painted over with no regard to the historical period significance. A few months ago I read an article of how "brown furniture" has completely fallen out of favor with millennials in and around that age group. This was an eye opener because most if not all furniture makers assume furniture needs to be brown. It's just the way it is. So times are changing it seems. Younger people perhaps don't want furniture that they associate with their parents home and furniture? What I would like to see is a good survey of the under-35 crowd about this subject. Maybe show images of furniture and ask them which one they would live with or own?

Norman

www.refinededge.com

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#18

Re: we don't even think

david weaver

People in my generation don't think that hard as far as I know, and the successful folks (like two attorneys or two doctors) spend money on the house first and furniture second if the house didn't drain their wallet.

When they do get furniture, they often allow a designer at a mid-range furniture store (read, one where couches are $3k instead of $500) pick the furniture and coordinate their house.

In terms of wooden, I've seen only shabby chic (as you describe, paint over it, whatever it is) and lighter colored (unstained) furniture with metal parts mixed into the design.

If it doesn't fall into that category, it's whatever is cheapest or something at Ikea if those two aren't the same thing.

I'm 40, and a little older than a millenial. The thing millenials are now is protective of their time (less extra hours at work), and they don't want as much "stuff" as people in the generation prior to mine wanted. It's common for us to have friends who spend $200 on dinner regularly, and that kind of spending would probably keep me from retiring before 65 (they "do better" than my wife and i). They do things like work overseas for a stint and take on debt to do it as an adventure, and certainly don't want to have a home base full of stuff they have to think about.

For my parents' generation, it was more of a status thing to be able to have a big house and fill it with nice furniture. Now it's more of a status thing to put yourself out there as someone with a perfect life and who is experiencing new things every day (and putting up pictures to show everyone).

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#19

Re: we don't even think

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

Excellent response David. It appears ownership has fallen out of favour. Experiences are where money is spent. Society today is far more mobile than ever. You never know where you'll be working next,, unlike in past years. So having less to move around makes sense. Then there is the whole "minimalist" movement which is gaining traction,,, as I also follow them. I am personally trending towards minimalism myself and only purchase what is absolutely necessary , or to replace a broken item. So investing in expensive, antique heirloom pieces is on the wane. Price points are also much less than they used to be since the same cohort doesn't intend to keep the furniture for long, why spend a fortune on furniture? It is also no longer an investment.

Norman

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#20

Re: we don't even think

david weaver

I was talking to my dad about this a couple of weeks ago (my parents have a large house full of furniture - I don't have that much and don't want more - would rather save the money for retirement instead).

When I was a kid, you went to the auction to get furniture if you couldn't get new furniture or didn't want to spend the money. The only thing low cost was the 80s reconstituted sawdust stuff that sagged almost immediately - other than that, used was the only cheap stuff.

New was still mostly made in the US, and though it was plain (like pennsylvania house plain wood stuff that they called queen anne), it was wood and it wasn't too cheap (and was sold mostly by family owned stores who had a hefty markup).

Things have completely flipped around. Most of the stuff left at auctions is junk, and nobody young is shopping at them, anyway, and the new furniture is a better deal if you have a modern aesthetic desire and know you'll be tossing the furniture in a couple of decades.

The weird stuff (there's a guy local here in the city who sells $200 cutting boards and $5,000 walnut sideboards that are "organic" looking in that they've had just about everything rounded off of them, I don't know who buys it, but the makers of the weird stuff seem to be in business for a few years and then out)...anyway, I'd bet a lot of the weird stuff that's trendy isn't being bought by young people, but rather the typical white collar 55 year-old male or female who still wears designer jeans and listens to top 40 music.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#21

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

TomD

3 things:

I'm 58, and all my life the people I ran into weren't interested that much in brown furniture, or they had a ton of antiques. I remember Expo 87 in Vancouver, when the hotel I stayed at, the Pan Pacific, was entirely wallpapered in high quality birdseye veneer. That seemed to be the highwater mark for white woods at that time. People like white rooms, on and off, or want light furniture.

About 15 years ago, I started to notice the whole crafts thing was not being responded to the way it once was. One of the woodworking mags, I think, has an article on this and some coverage of an auction site that was adding city specific crafts pages, and you could "audition" to get your crafts for sale featured on their pages. A bit as some transit services will feature a particular busker in their tunnels or stations. It just seemed to be getting a little tenuous. The 60s saw a lot of interest in craft, but it turns out generational interests are specific and die off with their adherents.

That said, certainly all my life, it isn't as though it was ever everyone who purchased serious furniture, or liked hand made goods. You had to sell it, and make the market. Any time a craft does get a little hot, the supply of product soon inundates the market.

-------------------------------------------------

I have said here a few times, not as if I expect others to feel the same, that I pretty much just make what I want, and don't make stuff for others. And I mean me, not my wife or daughters, me. The whole thing is so infra dig, nobody is likely to get it, and people are so accustomed to disposables, there isn't much hope they will keep stuff you slaved over. Or if they do, it will only be for sentimental reasons. I don't show stuff much around the boards, because the stuff I make is hard to explain, which for me is pretty much as it ought to be. If it gets broad appreciation, then it is probably banal. Though there are certainly people who fire on all cylinders.

Fine woodworking has strong trends in the original and organic, while at the same time there being a feeling that if it is really good, it should somehow be universal, stylish, studio. That is like comparing a hand knit cable sweater to a Madonna T-Shirt. And if you are innovative, you may find a way to take that hand knit a step or so into the future, and nobody might get that other than you.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#22

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

david weaver

I think if you could hand knit a picture of madonna into a cable sweater, then you might have something.

What's "good" is something different to all of us. That makes it hard to market.

I personally have zero interest in something it is symmetrically identical and has completely lost the human element, but that doesn't mean I want to make something that looks like it would be in the berenstein bears tree house.

I guarantee that as few of people as there are out there who like what I like, there are zero in my house (my wife would like for me to quit woodworking and just "buy stuff" instead).

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#23

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

This phenomena can also perhaps be attributed to the advent of the Internet, smartphones, electronic distractions galore. Attention spans which are progressively shrinking with time? Information overload? If we look at craftsmanship, it involves copious amounts patience and planning. You have to be in a peaceful environment to be able to execute craftsmanship, an environment where one can focus and be free of distractions. This is becoming more difficult as time goes on. Computers, smartphones, etc. have infiltrated every aspect of life. Along with this is the barrage of advertising touting the merits of consumerism. So one needs to make a conscious decision to separate themselves from the current environment which is not conducive to craftsmanship. This is increasingly becoming an issue due to the pervasiveness of electronic gadgetry and reams of daily interruptions to wade through. I see this even at my age and I have lived through the "computer-free" era. Millenials don't stand a chance, they have been brought up in this culture and environment, a culture where interruptions are the norm. Not sure where I'm going with this but I foresee less hands-on craftsmanship in the future. So back to the original discussion, this leads to factory knock-down furniture and simple furniture becoming more common. There is hope. The "maker" trend is growing so at the very least the next generations are working with tools :)

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#24

When I take one of my more creative projects

Chuck Nickerson

to the WW club for Show & Tell, I consider it a 'win' if 3 of the 30 light up about it.

It could be the group or my idea is off, but I've learned to listen and talk with those who respond and not worry about the others.

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

#25

Re: Millenials and craftsmanship

Patrick Chase

Madonna?

Please. You are hopelessly dating yourself as a 40-something.