Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Posts

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#26

Re: Thanks, and a question (long)

Hank Knight

Hi, Wiley.

First of all, your wife's 4:00 A.M. tour of there city is a wonderful development! I hope it marks a lasting change for the better in her mobility.

Second, I'm happy you put in an appearance on Bill's behalf earlier. I started to do so, but you got there first. I agree generally with David's comment that lively disagreement and the ensuing discussion often brings helpful details to light that would otherwise would have remained obscure. However, I think the quality of the "lively disagreement" is important. One can disagree strongly but still express his position in a gentlemanly, respectful, appropriate manner. I thought Todd's attack on PVA glue above was none of those things. It was a sarcastic, snarky attack that had little to do with Bill's point and added little, if anything, to the discussion. It appeared to be an attack on Bill for bringing up the PVA bonding issue in the first place and I, thought it was inappropriate. Todd's subsequent posts did add to the substance of the discussion and provided good information that you, I and others find useful. But for the tone and target of his original post, we would not be having this discussion.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#27

Re: Thanks, and a question (long)

david weaver

I wish there was a section of sites where you could cut loose, and people who didn't want to participate wouldn't. I don't so much need the cut loose part where people. are nasty, but I'll take the stuff that people scream about when they're really trying to win an argument and are working at their best to get their barrels hot, if you know what I mean. That's when people stiffen up at their chairs and spill all of the details through the keyboard.

The discussions between Larry, Todd (Hughes), Derek, Warren, etc years ago are pretty much the start of the interest in the double iron (or at least the re-kindled interest in the double iron) and if it weren't for arguing, we wouldn't have heard anything from Larry - at least that seems to have been the case. Todd had good insight from a blacksmith's point of view, and I knew he liked to let the air out of peoples' tires when he had the chance ("that plane you showed that you got today, I think the seller saw you coming from a mile away. My girl ___ will bring me one of those a week for $3, and the one you have, I wouldn't have had her pick up because someone restored it"). Those were great fun (the name of the girl seemed to be different every time, with pictures to back it up), but a little hard on newbies if they hadn't seen todd's routine.

Anyhow, my experience in forums is that even when a forum owner is OK with that kind of stuff, advertisers are not - I guess if a reader can't get satisfaction begging a forum moderator, they take the low road and start threatening advertisers. It's too bad people have to be like that.

At any rate, Todd S. knows a lot about glue, and unlike most on here, I don't really care how I learn it from him. We all perceive things differently, and I didn't see as much of an affront, but that doesn't mean that other people shouldn't perceive it differently so that they see it the same as I do - that's not human nature. It's just too bad that it seems that the only way we can really get into the details lately is a disagreement, and when there is a disagreement, it usually leads to a cease and desist order one way or another.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#28

Funny...

John in NM

I've found just the opposite - people seem to me to make their most sensible and well thought out points when they are NOT all steamed up or enjoying whatever snarky put down they just thought up. That kind of emotionally driven reply usually gets in the way of objective discussion and people's ability to use reason.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#29

Re: Funny...

Hank Knight

My experience too, John.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#30

Re: Thanks, and a question (long)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

That's very helpful Sir Wm., much thanks!

Wiley

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#31

Re: Funny...

david weaver

I guess it depends on who it is. It's certainly true that once a conversation gets into fight fight mode, there are a lot of people who won't participate at all. Just as well as there are people who won't participate until it gets there.

The trouble is that when it does get to fight fight, I guess, is that it attracts two things:

1) the people who look for a fight but don't have anything to offer

2) the complainers who never post or read much, but they do like to participate if they can complain

#2 came in spades on another forum when George Wilson was there. Someone would disagree with him, it would turn into a fight and people would literally register to post and complain.

Some of it also depends on what we're all looking for, not just on a forum, but in life. There are folks who want to have a good relationship with everyone, and curiosity takes a back seat, or no seat at all. Some in the middle, and some (I suppose I might be more like the last) who are just about all curiosity, sometimes to the extent that I see nothing but the curiosity.