(Message Deleted by Poster)
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Posts
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#2Re: Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints
Gary B.
Interested test Bill.
Takes me back to 1997, in my first year of Wood Products Technology at SUNY Morrisville. We did a strength test per ASTM standards of every glue type we could get our hands on to look at the results. It was done on maple blocks similar to yours.
If I recall correctly, they taught us that the gluing process must contain the following 5 steps to work:
Flow
Transfer
Penetration
Wetting
Solidification
What i'm surprised about is the penetration in your example. Perhaps the porous nature of the walnut helped? Maybe another test in something like maple would lead to a different conclusion. Unless you're exposing fresh wood with the scraping.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#3Re: Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints
Warren in Lancaster, PA
Did you ever take apart apart a dovetailed drawer or a frame and panel door that was glued years ago with titebond? Have you ever used hot hide glue?
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#4Re: Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints
david weaver
Is 24 hours enough? I once had a waterbased finish that boasted that it is chemically cured after 24 hours. I had made a top for a case and rubbed it out, it was lovely (back when I was into that "encased in glass" thing).
I took just the top to a friends house and sat it on something that was plastic after more than 24 hours while we were talking about something else, and the plastic and the finish reacted (very quickly) and I had to refinish it. Despite the boasts, it was nowhere near chemically finished.
I wonder if the result would be different with a joint a couple of decades old.
(that said, I have repaired some very cheap furniture for people, just sanding the joint partially so as not to shrink it - then regluing it with cheap TB II and told them to bring it back if it separated and I'd do a more thorough repair. I haven't gotten any of it back, but it's likely that it broke elsewhere and they threw it away. I can't offer any true to life stories of repairing sanded TB with TB and then seeing an instant failure).
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#5Re: Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints
TM Stock
I've always considered Titebond to be an excellent joint contaminant for when I want work that will creep in both hot and cold conditions, difficulty in rebonding, and general PITA-iness in handling due to super-low initial tack, unpredictable 'grab' as the gunk finally decides to be a glue, and miserable 'clean-up'. What's not to like?
Peel matters for load components...shear failure assumes nice alignment of forces and minimal couples, but loaded components on everything from guitars to wood aircraft show multiple off-axis loads that generate high peeling forces. it's one of the reasons why smart luthiers hate the stuff.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#6What was your point?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
What is it about the "traditionalists" on this Forum that compels them to attack with superfluous arguments anyone posting something that doesn't mesh with their world view of woodworking? My post showed that Titebond and Liquid Hide could bond to themselves with considerable strength. This information could be of interest to anyone repairing a well made M&T joint. The relevance of the scope of this brief experiment would be apparent to anyone contemplating a repair.
My post had nothing to do with whether I had ever used hide glue, mending airplanes or building ukuleles. Nor did it address the other properties of these glues, properties you claim, that are at odds with the experience of people that actually use them. Clearly you have no experience building furniture with Titebond types of glue. That is fine. Just leave describing these properties in this or that application to those that use them.
So what was your point? To perhaps discredit me as a source of information that might tempt the undecided to not follow your way of doing things? Ok, you all win. I'm done with this Forum. I'll confine my information to an audience not stuck in some previous century that feels threatened by any modern way of doing things.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#7horses for courses
Joseph Piotrowski
all the glue talk is overrated? ill bet that any glue will work just fine for 80 pct of all tasks. maybe even more accurate would be to say: i'll bet that there is only a few cases where one glue is absolutely wrong to use.
i think arguments that try to discredit one glue as inferior to another glue for all things miss the truth of the matter.
just my .02c
Joe P.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#8Re: What was your point?
david weaver
When it comes to commodity guitars, last I saw, most are put together with standard glue (the manufacturer isn't thinking about a guy 50 years from now repairing them, and you can still repair them, anyway, it just might take a lot more work).
When it comes to most furniture, someone building a bookcase isn't going to care that much about what glue was used to laminate the panels.
When it comes to building something that needs to be authentic, that you want to be repairable long after you're gone, and that you want a stable glue joint on, then I don't use anything less fixable than liquid hide glue. I wouldn't use TB if I was making chairs, either. If someone else does, that's fine, but I have repaired enough chairs made with it to know that it's not ideal, despite the fact that you may be able to put a test together to show that you can get a one-day old joint to bond in a specific situation. It just doesn't negate the dozen or so chairs that I've seen that were both poor design and cheap yellow glue - repaired and failed over and over before they get to me and I strip everything back to at least some wood contact.
I gather that part of warren's work is repairing things professionally. There is some level of resolution that comes from that that we won't get making pieces for us or for us and a few people, and repairing things for friends from time to time.
I know you have a lot of time invested in going back and forth with franklin and examining these glues, but I can't help but feel you'd have been better off from the start if you'd have just learned the various protein based glues and stuck with them.
I don't think it's anything to get mad about, either, or get frustrated when people rely on general sentiment to stick with something that didn't need to be changed in the first place (other than for cost and convenience). Certainly, if you said you had a workshop that was 50 degrees and you were tossing together commodity pieces, I wouldn't suggest that you set up a liquid hide glue gluing station instead of using a modern adhesive that will still cure properly at 50 degrees. The same time, i wouldn't use something inferior just because you can get by with it, and titebond is inferior as a long-term glue unless something is exposed to steam or moisture all the time (even that can be worked around with hide glue).
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#9Re: Regluing Titebond and Liquid Hide joints
John Aniano in Central NJ
I have to agree for musical instruments. I was given an assembled unfretted clavichord (a keyboard instrument made from a kit) years ago that was assembled with a titebond-like yellow glue and almost of the joints that were under tension failed. Those in compression seemed fine, but who knows. The builder should have used hide glue, even fresh liquid hide glue would have been better. Just my 2 cents...
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#10Re: What was your point?
TM Stock
I come at it from the viewpoint of a well experienced professional luthier - and while I have built ukes (they are cute little things), it's more likely to be something a bit more highly stressed. After seeing hundreds of AR/PVA glue failures over the last 12 years of repair work, I prefer something that does not creep under load, heat-release at the sort of temps seen in summer sun, and lacks the abysmal handling and clean-up qualities of TB.
That said, I do use TB where I want a controlled failure...it's pretty good at being a 'fuse' for joints that should fail before overall structural failure if the joint is properly designed, or where a heat release at relatively low temperature is desirable.
Gel temp issues? Just use 315g...gels at about 125 F...192g about 95 deg, and 251g at about 105-110...shop cold...warm the work and use 192g; shop 110 deg, use 315g.
I have 45 years of experience building with TB. Furniture work is a hobby now, but that, as well as trim carpentry work have paid the bills from time to time.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#11Wow... how completely unhelpful
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#12Re: Wow... how completely unhelpful
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi all,
I feel the need to put a comment in, and am parking it here under John's because Bill has pulled his original post.
To my mind, the critiques offered in are interesting, and make valid points which people should know about. To take a couple, Warren's implied point that the ability to non-destructively take apart a joint in a piece of fine furniture is surely valid. And Todd Stock's comments on glue creep are important to know, for those like me who don't keep up with these things--I learned from his remarks, and it will stick with me.
However, my dominant feeling by far is that I just felt sick for Bill, who did in no way deserve the disrespect his post was greeted with. He had conducted a straightforward experiment, and shared his result without disparaging anyone else. He didn't deserve what then occurred.
Wiley
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#13Re: I missed what was that bad..
david weaver
I had a genuine question, about whether or not a 24 hour test is really a decent test. I think to get a good read on this, one at a day, a week, a month, a year and a decade would be interesting. I found out the hard way that what a manufacturer says is "chemically cured and stable" wasn't what they said, but I didn't have the guts to test my redone finish 2 days out or a week out.
At a decade old now (older, I guess), it no longer reacts with things.
Warren asked a short question (a relevant one) and todd offered his own thoughts. This is the internet, though, and generally anything we say will be challenged without the ability to see the expression on the face of the person asking questions.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#14Re: I missed what was that bad..
John in NM
I think many people on this side missed the point -- it was not "ra ra, PVA is great and everyone should use it and nothing else" -- a couple replies lead me to conclude that the poster had not even read the OP before replying about how mind numbingly awful PVA glue is.
The point was this:
1. PVA has a reputation of not bonding to itself, and thus being a poor choice if one plans to make wood products that can be repaired.
2. Bill speculated that this was not entirely correct, based on his knowledge of organic chemistry and a healthy skepticism.
3. Bill formulated a really quick and easy experiment to test his speculation and reported the results.
You and Gary had the only replies worth reading!
Bill cross posted on the general Messages board - far better reading than the replies here.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#15Re: I missed what was that bad..
Kees
I am late in replying too. The test was interesting. Some of the comments were pretty laughable. I'm interested in longer time spans and different kinds of wood too.
The stuff is unsuitable for musical instruments I guess, but used with succes in many other applications.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#16Re: I missed what was that bad..
Brian Holcombe
I remain open minded about the traditional approach because it has really helped my woodworking and provides a lot of proof simply from the age of things that the techniques work. The trouble is not so much that the traditionalists dont want to hear about anything new, it's that they've tried it and it doesn't improve upon their traditional technique.
I have used Titebond III for a long time, but have tapered off in my use of it recently in favor of hide glue in furniture applications. The fact that it is easily reversible will make future restorations easier. I'm not entirely concerned about someone doing this years from now, more so concerned with having to repair some of my own work years from now if something happens to a piece here or there. I want to make that easy.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#17Re: I missed what was that bad..
TM Stock
I read the original post and understood the objective of the experiment was - can PVA and liquid hide be reglued and retain reasonable physical properties, given Franklin's technical staff and conventional wisdom suggest that cured PVA does not bond well to uncured PVA, while drying glues such as liquid hide, hot hide, rabbet, or fish simply need a bit of moisture to rehydrate and re-dry for a full-strength bond.
First - I do like these simple shop tests - they give us an idea of how things might work out, even when they don't actually measure physical properties beyond LGEFM. Bob Smalser's post on how well epoxy stuck to various failed joints (this was maybe 10 years back) was pretty illuminating, even though it it lacked any quantitative data - mostly because it provided some basis of comparison. Same with other posts on other sites on glue qualities.
I get the whole 'that's not what the OP was talking about', but hey - it's the internet, things are really, really slow on most craft fora these days (and decelerating), and the meta issues are the interesting things to talk about in any case. If we all built stuff that just had to sit there and look pretty, no issue...a joint fails, and we likely don't even know it. But lots of work has to work for a living, and anyone that has done repair or restoration work knows what a PITA it is to get a real repair on glued joint even without the complications of the adhesive acting as a contaminant.
So totally outside Bill's qualitative assessment of repairability of AR, what I take issue with is the use of adhesives which a) are known to be difficult to repair in b) structures where the prep required to get a partial-strength repair on these glues is a huge PITA. For those that felt that was out-of-bounds, I will offer apologies for my lack of an internal line judge.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#18Thanks, and a question (long)
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hello Todd and all,
The gel temps you posted above are very useful, to wit,
--315g ........ 125F
--251g ........ 105-110F
--192g ........ 95F
I use hide in all dovetail joints and M&T's, and also in what one might call ' thick veneering', where the veneer is 3/32 to 1/8 thick--it's a stick of thin wood, quarter sawn generally. Many times the choice arises: Do I have time to get this thing together using hot hide, or would it be more sensible to use Old Brown Glue (OBG) and gain more work time? Your data give an idea of how much work time is available for the different gram strengths, and I was happily surprised to see how much flexibility there is in 192 gram glue, starting from say 140F. Never seen this info before, and it's a big help. Thank you.
My question is about veneering thin quartered wood onto a substrate, the substrate itself quartered or quasi-quartered (pieces ripped and re glued in a quartered direction). The question is how to go about keeping the upper side of the veneer--the unglued side--wet enough until the glue join seizes. For those that haven't done this operation, a thin piece of wood, and especially if it's quartered, just absolutely comes alive when the wet glue hits one side--it's curling within seconds. So of course you need to get glue on both sides of the veneer ASAP, and on the substrate as well, and sometimes a balancing glue up on the bottom side of the substrate, so that's a lot of glue spreading. To have enough work time, I've used OBG. But by giving up the hot hide option, I've given up the 'fast seize' benefit of hot hide, so the veneer piece has to be kept wet on the topside long enough for the OBG to grab hold at the join. To manage this, I put a wet towel over the veneer piece, After all glue layers are applied, and clamp it down using a full width caul. It works, but this is a big messy affair, and in clamping a caul onto the work, you have some risk of the darned thing moving a hair.
Question: There's got to be a better way. All ideas/experience appreciated. Can the above be managed by one person using hot glue?
Note: I'm not using hide because I think I'm doing museum work
. I like hide in DTs and MTs because you get a spotless cleanup with a moist rag that won't show in the finish. In fact, with shallow drawers, I just dip the join pieces into the hot glue, and assemble them dripping wet. For the veneering described above, hide gives you a second chance--if anything goes wrong, reheat the glue and try again. With PVA, I would have to plane away the expensive appearance wood, and then try to find more of it.
Thanks in advance for all suggestions!
Wiley
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#19Re: I don't have an answer, but..
david weaver
..one of the reasons that I like fighty fighty posts (prefer if someone else does the fighty fighty these days) is that they seem to be the only ones where folks actually show all of their cards, and then specific discussions spring from them that we all learn from. I think because people get involved enough in "winning" or at least clarifying what they're saying that they'll return and spill details.
And then what springs from that is discussions that get away from the "everything is fine, and your mileage may vary" sentiment, which is polite, but often not very instructive.
There used to be a lot of spirited very detailed discussions on here, but not so much anymore.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#20Re: Thanks, and a question (long)
steve voigt
Wiley,
Have you tried adding canning salt (urea can also be used) to extend the open time? I haven't tried it myself, so take this with a grain of…er…you know, but my understanding is that when added in large enough quantities, salt actually turns HG into LHG, but in smaller quantities, it simply extends the open time. Same for urea, but salt is easier to find.
If you look online, Don Williams and Joshua Klein have both written about it. By sheer coincidence, I may see Don this week, and I'll ask him and report back if there's anything interesting.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#21Re: Thanks, and a question (long)
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Steve and David,
David, I had mixed feelings about my own comment, because I felt an unfortunate thing had happened to my friend and I couldn't just let that go, yet at the same time it was all exactly the way people are, no more or less, plus there were some very useful insights from yourself, Warren, and Todd and the others commenting, so I didn't want to offend though I probably did. In any case, nothing can cloud me over now, as my invalid wife of 50 years got up out of bed today about 4 am, got dressed with help, got to her wheelchair, got to the front door steps, got to the car, got in the car, and rode around town with me to get a guided tour--for the first time in 20 years. It's a miracle and a new life.
Steve, on the technical point, the biggest insight of the thread for me was Todd's quantification of the gel times for the different strength hot glues. Specifically, 192grams has a long gel time, and I'm more inclined now to take advantage of that, and find a fast spreading way to eliminate a bunch of the steps I described above when using OBG.
Thanks for your comments!
Wiley
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#22Re: Thanks, and a question (long)
steve voigt
Hey Wiley,
That's pretty wonderful news, I'm very happy for you and the missus. Congratulations!
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#23Re: Thanks, and a question (long)
david weaver
Congratulations and good news, Wiley!
And, you never offend. Your concern for others and your concern for fairness is always evident in your posts.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#24Re: Thanks, and a question (long)
William Duffield
Ed Wright, Master Harpsichord Maker at Colonial Williamsburg Foundation gave a presentation at a SAPFM meeting last November describing his process for gluing down sawn veneers to curved substrates using hot hide glue. His methods, often using wet linen cloth to cover the hammered veneer while the glue set, are similar to yours. I wish I had taken better notes, as he described lots of checking of progress and modifying of conditions depending on the progress of the tack. He did note that with modern dry atmospheric conditions the linen cloth still dried too quickly, before the bond was complete. Sometimes he had to resort to increasing the humidity of the atmosphere by turning the piece over and laying it on the ground or burying it in sawdust and shavings.
Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)
#25Re: Thanks, and a question (long)
Brian Holcombe
Wonderful News!
I second David's sentiment in that I didn't find anything offensive about your post.



