Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

side table mockup

Posts

side table mockup

#1

side table mockup 

Joseph Piotrowski

I started tossing around ideas and looking at 100's of side table like pieces to replace my folding tv tray that has been used as an table for ever.

so i wrote down some rough dimension culled a few ideas together and went into the shop and grabbed some construction grade pine and a few left over test cuts form some other experiment. the only real cuts i made where to rip a 1x3 in half and some work on the leg bottoms.

the leg bottom are 2 pcs of 1x3 glued together.

the side are 1x3 ripped in half.

there are two top rails ot teh legs of 1x3.

the top is a left over scrap from a practice cut of dados. i left it as is.

the self is 1x6

this took about 2 hrs of shop time across two days. i don't really fuss over the dimensions or flatting to any great level of tolerance. just a lot of big box wood screwed together. down and dirty.

so i place it where it will sit took a few pictures and will think about the design details for a day before writing them up. decide final dimensions and joinery.



i plan to make refinements to the pieces now that i can visually see it. overall i think it will be 2-4 inches wider.

the leg bottom will be about 1" shorter and the relief along the bottom will either be bigger or have two levels( cloud lifts?).

the top is planned out to have a 6/4 thickness and be back beveled 15 deg or so.

the top rails(table support/attachment pieces) will be narrower than the 1x3 and will be tapered down form the 3/4" thickness to 3/16 at the front.

it going to take a while to makes this with a lot of work travel coming up but it was a great exercise to get all the stuff out of my head and into the physical world. now to actually make it for real. the base will be African mahogany and the top will be something like spalted maple or birdseye or ribbon or something interesting.

thanks for looking,

Joe P

Re: side table mockup

#2

Re: side table mockup

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Something about the foot not quite perfect. Maybe a bit longer and a bit less tall?

Re: side table mockup

#3

agree on that foot

Joseph Piotrowski

too tall. i will shorten it at least an 1" and make the relief on the bottom wider also. that should give it better looking proportions.

Re: side table mockup

#4

Re: side table mockup

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Joe

I find your table too top heavy. If it was mine I would lengthen the feet, either change the side twin legs to a single or reduce the widths of the twins (make it slimmer), double the length of the top, and lose the shelf - replace it with a low stretcher (to drop the visual point).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: side table mockup

#5

comments on comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would lengthen the feet.....agree either change the side twin legs to a single or reduce the widths of the twins (make it slimmer) .....agree, your suggestion of a single width foot could be the solution to making the feet more dainty.

Double the length of the top, and lose the shelf - replace it with a low stretcher (to drop the visual point).......here we get into utility issues. For where it may go and what it may be used for the top size and shelf may be a desirable practical matter. I am building a chest of drawers for son-in-law and you all are going to say that its proportions are maybe acceptable, but not ideal. Well they are ideal from one perspective. For what he wants to put in them they are perfect and that settled the size decision.

I would like to see a better reason than "interesting" to have already decided that the top will be some other kind of wood to make the top "interesting". "Interesting" is not high on my list of attributes that I design for. Perhaps I am recoiling to the trend in Studio Furniture that puts novelty and interesting ahead of inherent good design. The pieces seem to be all about the novelty and interest of the wood and the rest of the design is there to provide a canvass to display the wood- featuring its knots, splits, fungal attack, insect holes, bark, figure etc.

Someone said, maybe Krenov, that the furniture should look good made from something plain. Then decorate it, tastefully, with some nice wood.

Re: side table mockup

#6

Re: side table mockup

Brian Holcombe

Looks tall Joe, I would shorten it. Most often I find that a table lower

than the chair arm rest to be more comfortable to use than one higher than the arm rest. This will help your aesthetic as well, heavier work looks better at a lower height.

Re: side table mockup

#7

top heavy and other comments.

Joseph Piotrowski

thanks for the comments so far.

the feet will be longer and shorter

the overall height will be shorter

the length will be longer.

as for the sides, i had considered solid pieces with with slight cured sides instead of straight to break it up from being too block looking

i might raise the shelf up closer to the top just a bit to give it a better proportion look.

the shelf will be handy for cell phones and tablets to hold while charging and get them off the kitchen table :)

in person its not so bad looking but the pics really show off some poor choices so far.

but that is why i made it so i could correct it. :)

thanks,

Joe P

Re: side table mockup

#8

Racking?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

Good start! I have only one suggestion. Test the mock-up structurally by pushing against the top laterally. Does the mock-up rack side to side? Don't see much to prevent it, but you're the best judge.

Wiley

Re: side table mockup

#9

Re: Racking?

Joseph Piotrowski

thanks i'll test it out

Re: side table mockup

#10

Clint Searl

Re: side table mockup

Clint Searl

Taken together, all the comments are worth about as much as you paid for them...ZIP. Your eye is as good as any, so go with what looks right to you. And as far as "interesting" goes, 99% of current studio and home crafted furniture is so boringly rectilinear and unembellished that a little spalted this-or-that will bring a smile every time you look at it. Don't worry, be happy.

Re: side table mockup

#11

Clint Searl

Re: side table mockup 

Clint Searl


Re: side table mockup

#12

inlayed? or carved?

Joseph Piotrowski

WOW! that is a lot of detail. you have to look at it a while to soak up all the craftsmanship in it. that is 3 or 4 levels above my skills so far.

i'm toying with added some small carving details to some future projects. add a little personal touch that you don't get from ikea! :)

Re: side table mockup

#13

Some makers just don't know when to stop.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am reminded of a desk I showed an artist friend who has an interest in furniture. She identified at least 10 design elements, about as many as the furniture student could cram into it. The basic shape was elegant. Stripped down to a few that went together it made a handsome desk.

I do like the inlay pattern. I'd like to try it on a drawer.

Re: side table mockup

#14

When to stop?

Joe shelton

I remember a topic from NPR about a woodcarver who wrought doors. The interviewer asked him how he knew it was finished. He replied "When they come and take it away."

Re: side table mockup

#15

You said,I do like the inlay pattern. I'd like to  *LINK*

Keith Newton

I do like the inlay pattern. I'd like to try it on a drawer.

Hey Bill, I used to do a bit of inlay about 30 years ago, and managed to figure out some pretty good quick tips that I keep thinking I ought to get back to, but have moved so far away from that, I can't see getting back unless it would be on some of my carved turned vessels.

one quick trick for inlaying little squares of different colored wood, is to use a tapered drill, followed by a special tool I ground from an old nail-set into a tapered square with sharp corners. Drive this tool into the tapered hole will square the corners.

Take a 2x2x2" solid block of wood to the bandsaw, then cut a bunch of wedges out of one side with about the same taper as the tool mentioned above. The wedges cut out are trash, but then rotate the block 90º and cut in from the 2nd side, which will leave a block with a bunch of square tappers sticking out like a meat tenderizer on steroids. Those double tapered plugs can then be dipped in glue and driven into the square tapered holes quickly and easily, and trimmed after the glue grabs.

If you want the inlays flush, a multi-tool laid down on a piece of thin polycarbonate like things are packaged in nowadays will protect the background surface. If you want some of these little squares to be raised, then carved, just use a thicker shim for the first trim, then either chisel or detail sander to do the details.

A week ago while at my local Ace Hdw, back where they keep drills and driver bits, I found a tool that looks great for this. It's IRWIN ,Hanson ST-3 Straight Screw Extractor 53603. It has a longer taper than the one I made years ago, and isn't sharp on the tip, but would work from about 3/16" - 5/16" as is, but would be easy to modify on a grinder. Getting a couple might be a good idea if you wanted to use the larger portion, it could be cut in length, so you didn't have to drill out the back of the substrate to have a deep enough hole.

Bill, I think I recall you mentioning that your not that creative, so I thought I would plant a see for you to think about. With this coming eclipse, this would be a good way to commemorate the event, by featuring it on a piece. A dark circle inlaid, then surrounded by gradually smaller light squares would make a pretty good halo.

I believe you are going to be right in the path of it too, so aren't you lucky, I hope you share this time with your grandkids.


http://www.acetoolonline.com/Irwin-53603-St-3-Straight-Flute-Screw-Extracto-p/irw-53603.htm?gclid=CK7t0eGDidUCFYYCaQodToECiA