Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

Posts

Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#1

Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

david weaver

We often hear about how we should purchase things locally to make sure that we can get them locally.

I have few wants that I can find locally, but one of them used to be 2 packs of lenox 18 tpi hacksaw blades. Anything that I make of metal that's 1/8th thick or more ends up being cut with those, whether it's self-made plane irons or infill parts.

I went to home depot today to find that they no longer carry them, they now carry "dewalt" bimetal blades that are made in mexico. The price of the dewalt blades is about the same, perhaps a few cents cheaper.

The lenox blades were made in the US. Some of what I cut is steel. Other bimetal blades that I could get locally ("buck brothers") have not held up even for a fraction of an inch of cut. The lenox blades gradually lose teeth, and perhaps after cutting every metal part for an infill plane (all of the dovetails, etc), I have to replace them. Translation - even though they get beat up, they last a long time and are worth every penny to me.

I could buy the dewalt blades and try them. But, if they don't last, they won't last right away, and I will need to go back to home depot to take them back, or remember to take them on another trip. It's just not worth it.

I also need 3 door knobs, cheap ones, for interior doors here. They are about $10 per set. They are the kind of thing that costs a fair amount to ship vs. the package size and their value because they're not that small and they're not expensive. Still, I go online to look, and the door knob sets are cheaper elsewhere despite having to pay shipping. Their markup must be over 100% on those for that to be the case. Why? That's exactly the type of item they should compete on.

The list of these things could go on and on (they used to have 3x paper, but they've replaced it with something as expensive and much less durable. They used to have 3x discs, albeit not competitively priced if you need to get a lot, they were at least good discs. Now they have "freud diablo". What the hell does freud have to do with abrasives? The ones I got in a pinch last week to sand something in the house looked good, but did not last very well. They lost their tooth almost right away).

I'd hoped for some 3/16th bits to waste (I don't have a mill, so I waste some of those bits opening infill mouths). The options at HD again? $3 a bit for chinese made bits. Are you kidding? No bulk packs of any common sizes.

Why bother shopping local for anything?

(I found boxes of 10 of my favorite hack saw blades for about $19 shipped on line. I am happy with that, but that's one less thing that will get me in the door at home depot - their fault. It's not uncommon that I would've gone in for hack saw blades and picked up several other things).

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#2

Question re old-time hardware stores

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

Dr. Johnson I believe it was who said something like all change is in and of itself an evil. That pretty much nails it for me, especially when I'm trying to figure out what I touched on my iPad screen to make everything go kablooie.

That said, I do like two things about Home Depot: the garden section, and renting trucks by the hour. Incidentally, Lowes out here has those Lenox 12" hacksaw blades--ymmv.

Anyway, what I'm trying to get around to is the old-time hardware store. There are 300 or so smallish towns in L. A. County, and every one of them used to have a couple or three hardware stores. And that's what they were called--every last one of them was a hardware. With scuffed wooden floors, that were sometimes swept. And an old guy who knew what you needed, even for plumbing jobs. Oil paint. Revolving dolly of nails with a scales to weigh them.

Are any of these left?

Wiley

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Question re old-time hardware stores

Jack Guzman from Maine

We had quite a few old time hardware stores around my area in southern Maine. My favorite went out of business a few years ago and all the rest were bought out and converted by either True Value or Ace. ---Jack

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#4

St Paul used to have one

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Seven Corners Hardware, best of the best. Got bought out in a real estate deal and decided to just go out of business. Sad day when that happened.

We have a pretty good Ace hardware here, and that place just oozes service.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#5

Local Hardware *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here in this Pennsylvania Dutch area we have three hardware stores within three miles and more within 10 miles. Here is an example; they do carry Lenox:


Sensenig Hardware

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#6

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

Mark Nowicki

We have one, not exactly local but short enough of a drive.

http://www.pontmercier.com/

Staff that knows their stuff, no-nonsense approach, no fluff talk.

Needed some metric all-thread to cobble together a harmonic balancer press-on gizmo for my Dodge, and a 37 mm box wrench for the camshafts. They had both.

There is another one walking distance from my house, he is popular with the type of crowd that gets three estimates to fix a loose door handle. You can wait for half an hour to pay for a roll of electrical tape while he is talking about bee keeping with the person ahead of you.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#7

Re: Question re old-time hardware stores

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Our Ace hardware here in town is pretty decent, with good staff; but it's not like the old ones.

It's been 44 years since I lived in Ann Arbor, MI; but I still miss Schlenker Hardware. My roommate was convinced that they had tunnels running under the entirety of downtown, because, no matter what you needed, they'd have it.


img

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#8

Seven Corners....

Brian Roberts

was one of the first big time mail order power tool sellers......back in the 90s.

They beat pretty much anyone's prices.

The tool dealers here in La Crosse hated them!

And we LOVED stopping at Cossetta's Italian Market any time we went to Seven Corners!

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#9

Re:  Local Hardware

david weaver

Warren, I have been to Paul B's several times (I think that's in ephrata), but not Sensenig. Paul B's always has enough US made stuff in stock that if you want it, you can actually find it. My jobber bits are from there and they cost 3 times as much as import bits, but the flutes are 10 times as sharp and I haven't had to sharpen any of them yet, which would definitely not be the case with any imports.

We just don't have much like that around here, because it's the suburbs, I guess.

There are some places here that service tool and die shops, I'm sure, and there is a genuine commercial woodworking equipment dealer (like production type stuff - 85 horsepower total three stage wide belt sanders, etc), and they might have that kind of stuff, but nothing like Paul B's local enough to make the drive. Anything more than 10 miles here in the wrong direction ends up being an hour-long trip due to the traffic.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#10

Re: Question re old-time hardware stores

david weaver

The popular one here on the south side of pittsburgh (a large affair for the location, with the ability to fabricate parts for your needs in the basement if nothing was available) went out about a decade ago. I think that was about it. I remember the guy who owned it saying they kept galvanized tubs in large numbers because people these days think they're stylish to ice down beers.

(I agree about the garden section at HD, it's handy and relatively large. I have had to replace any equipment I've gotten there with something better - for example, a lawn spreader that had a non-stainless steel wire connection inside a plastic sleeve so that it could eventually get some kind of fertilizer inside the sleeve and rust the wire to failure after about 8 years. Most manufacturers these days would consider that twice the design life, I guess. There is a mediocre ace near here that has a true commercial lawn mower sales and service wing in the back, and they carry something better - shindaiwa in this case, which I hope never shows up at HD because it will be the death of the brand - a brand that has already been sold to a corporation that does business at HD.... But if you need fert, seeds, etc, that stuff is at HD in droves).

Other than out warren's way, I just don't know of much in the type of stores you mention. The buildings are there in a lot of the suburban towns here, still with hardware stores, but usually ace or do it best, and they're filled mostly with junk, and with a little luck, still can get you some stuff cheap - like screens for a door or window.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#11

Re:  nearly forgot...

david weaver

..Wilhelms in Myerstown. Not a large store, but a little bit more like a traditional hardware store with quality goods in it (rather than lawn flamingos and beach chairs).

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#12

the Demise of Local

Brian Holcombe

I have two local hardware stores that are doing well, they are smart in how they are approaching their offerings. They generally offer high quality construction materials, like WRC/Doug Fir 4x4's with tight growth rings, and good quality plywood. They're Festool dealers, which when you want something right away is very handy and the odds and ends like drill bits and screws are good brands.

I usually see the more established design/build firms shopping with these guys.

Both also offer kitchen cabinetry from the better brands and one has a serious custom shop that is doing high quality commercial work.

I also have a local lumberyard that has really started working well to accommodate the mid-small builders and furniture makers. They have become very competitive and really want to work with the local consumers, it's doing well for them.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#13

Re: Question re old-time hardware stores

steve voigt

Same here Bill, there are no true old-style hardware stores around here (Shenandoah Valley), but the local Ace ("Rockin' R Hardware") is pretty darn good. I buy the Lenox 2-packs there all the time. They sell drywall screws in bulk bins, $4.29 a pound. I can nearly always find Nicholson XX-slim saw files* in stock. And an exhaustive supply of screws, bushings, threaded inserts, whatever. Consequently, I go there much more often than HD, even if the prices are a tad higher.

I think this is very location dependent, though. There weren't any stores like this in Bushwick, Brooklyn, when I lived there, and I'm not surprised that there aren't any in suburban areas like where Dave lives.

*Completely off topic, but the new Nicholson "Black Diamond" saw files really do seem to be a lot better than the Nicholsons of just a couple years ago. I recently made four 3/16"-thick edge floats with a single file (had to break out a second file for the post-heat treat sharpening).

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#14

Re:  the Demise of Local

Gary B.

Agreed, it's really sad. I had the distinct pleasure of working in an old school hardware store when I was 16 and 17. The owner was in the business 50 years.

He had a collection of old odd plumbing connections that seemed to be known in two counties. If someone needed a cast iron fitting, he likely had it. Learned a ton of general "Man" knowledge, even got payed for it :-) It was great at that age to learn how to sharpen lawn mower blades, repair window screens, cut and glaze window glass, etc. My favorite was when a customer came in with a problem, and I'd watch and learn as the owners (father and son) came up with a solution. Last time I went back home, I noticed that they had sold the business to another couple with an ACE franchise. It was still OK, but not the same.

Sadly, I don't think it's going to get any better. Walmart and the other large chain stores have killed the Mom and Pop business model. At this point, my money's on Amazon and other online retailers. I live on the outskirts of Metro Atlanta. I was notified that prime now exists in my area. I needed an item at work the other day, ordered it at 6:30 am, and they delivered it just before 8am. If they get that model worked out for the larger suburban areas, it's going to devastate the local businesses even further. IMO, we're on the verge of the next big shakeup.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#15

Re: follow up - not everything was rosy

david weaver

Looking back before walmart, which is usually given the honor of busting up mom and pop shops (home depot did a lot more damage to places I shop, though, or in my area, it was lowes).

Some of our small mom and pop shops in town where I grew up weren't exactly honest places, and from time to time, my friends' parents would work at one. The shops were set up as sole proprietors or LLCs with a few family members, and perhaps 10 of the general public working there. They ripped us off as customers (a local sporting good store comes to mind - everything there was double what open market price would be these days) and they were secretive about all of their services as to make them seem like they were more difficult and costly than they were (restringing baseball gloves, tennis rackets, etc.). People who knew to ask would end up getting someone like my dad to restring their glove (he was a coach of various baseball levels, amateur and semi pro, and a specialist in restoring good quality gloves before they were cheap from overseas).

The rest of the folks who walked in the door of said store got taken for a ride, and quite often, that was moms with kids where nobody had a clue what they were looking for, they just went because their kid started little league or peewee league football and they knew they needed to buy equipment.

And their ten or so employees got minimum wage. Not everything was rosy.

In terms of lowes, I recall in the early 1990s, they showed up and offered super high quality tradesman's tools for less than the local lumber yards and hardware stores, and without making proprietary slot sizes, etc, like sears did. Once they had the market, the quality of those tools started to drop, but that probably would've happened in mom and pop shops, anyway, as the wholesalers and distributors would've seen the opportunity to have stuff made overseas and share a little with the mom and pop shops and keep a lot for themselves.

I think it's inevitable that we're at this point because we cannot resist having more as a society, even if it means having only junk. In the end, if we have instantaneous delivery, it may not be that bad of a conclusion.

One other side comment: I live in the burbs and we have the ace stores and do it best. Some are helpful, and some are just trying to sell whatever junk they can to get by. One of them here sponsors a radio show and pushes really expensive lawn care routines, and they must sell them to folks around here who "need" a perfect lawn that costs a couple of grand a year. There was probably a time in the burbs before we had so much disposable income that at least some of the residents were fixing things on their own properties, but in my neighborhood of 350 houses, I don't meet too many people who are interested in more than watching a game, drinking beer and figuring out their next vacation. They aren't going to buy anything at a hardware store.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#16

Re: Seven Corners....

Ray

I remember shopping at Seven Corners when I lived closer in - are they still in business?

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#17

Re: Seven Corners....

Ray

ooops, just read Bruce's post. Sorry.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#18

Re: Seven Corners....

Bruce Mack

When I lived in PA they shipped me 4 48'' bar clamps at such a low price I winced. Years later when I moved a little west of Minneapolis I made occasional pilgrimages, buying my American made Delta bandsaw with riser there. A happy day.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#19

Re: Seven Corners....

roger lance

The name Seven Corners Hardware takes me back.....I bought a lot of tools from them.....always looked thru their full page ads in FWW and other publications.....good prices.....and good service.

But times change.....there was another store.....Wm. Alden (I believe) out of Boston area that also was a good mail order source of ww tools.....also, long gone.

Even, some rock solid tool makers like Record (vises) have disappeared.....thats a mystery to me still.....must have been some major mismanagement to sink that ship.

But, new companies also come on the scene with great products like BenchCrafted.

Sometimes these discussions don't recognize that people are using tools that are no longer made by companies that no longer exist......and products of today which may be preferable were not available.

I remember when Tom Lie-Nielsen was a clerk at Garrett Wade.....and seeing his picture in a Garrett Wade catalog as a new tool maker. And, Lee Valley was not always the tool company it is today.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#20

I grew up helping in Dad's hardware store,

Keith Newton

When Dad sold it, the fellow that bought it tried to run it like Dad had for about 40 years before, but the businesses in our little town started drying up due to Walmart in the neighboring counties. Finally he had to make a move, so he bought a building across the parking lot from the Walmart in the next town. Rather than looking out at empty streets, there is always a parking lot full of cars and people.

Believe it or not, it was a great move. Even though his prices are higher, there are people that would rather pop in and out faster than they can get through the mart. Location location location is the name of the game.

I still shop at a locally owned hardware store that I've been going to for about 40 years. It is an Ace affiliate, and finally bar coded. I took Sassy in when she was a pup to meet the new owners kids, who fell in love with her, so they got a Golden Retriever of their own within the week. Leo stays there in the store most of the time, so when Im going there, I take Sass with me. All I have to do is ask her if she wants to go see her people, and she heads for the truck.

As soon as we get there, she finds and grabs one of Leo's toys and runs around with him chasing her. But she really likes going to see all the people that work there.

Today While I was checking out, she brought one of Leo's toys over, stood up and dropped it on the counter while I was checking out. She put it right between me and the checker, then looked up at me like she expected me to buy it for her. Everybody was laughing at that as we left.

Re: Home Depot - And the Demise of Local

#21

Dogs and hardware stores

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Our son is known in the hardware store as "Satch's Dad." Satch the dog gets plenty of love there - and biscuits.