Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Scraper Planes

Posts

Scraper Planes

#1

Scraper Planes

Chuck Bjorgen

When I finally learned how to set up my Stanley no. 80 cabinet scraper I was very pleased with its performance. Then, on another forum, someone suggested the Stanley no. 112 scraper plane was even better. Makes me curious about that plane but in researching the 112 I see asking prices on eBay for vintage 112's pretty high. Then checking both Lee Valley and Lie-Nielsen I see that both companies offer two or more such planes. The Lee Valley offering is $179 and seems attractive. The LN offering is a direct copy of the Stanley 112 and is priced similarly to asking prices for vintage Stanleys. LN also has one called a "Cabinet Makers Scraper" that is based on the Stanley no. 85 and I find that one mighty attractive.

So...I'm looking for recommendations on this type of tool. Price alone would lead me to the Lee Valley plane. Any thoughts?

Re: Scraper Planes

#2

Re: Scraper Planes

roger lance

Chuck.....FWIW, I'll give no personal recommendation; but, I've been reading various ww forums for awhile and I've consistently heard people say that they favor the smaller LN scraper plane over the larger.....easier to use, better results, etc.

Re: Scraper Planes

#3

Re: Scraper Planes

Hank Knight

Chuck,

I own a large LN scraper plane - the 112 copy. It is a fine tool, but I think its best use is for larger surfaces - panels and such (my opinion). It is fiddly to set up, but does a great job and worth the trouble when you have a large area to smooth. It is a large, heavy plane which makes it a bit unwieldy on smaller work. I do not own, but have long admired the cabinet maker's scraper plane - the 85 copy. Because of its smaller size, I think it would find more work in my shop. I like the facts that the iron reaches all the way to the edge of the sole and the tote and knob tilts so you can scrape right into a corner without banging up your hands. Again, my opinion. If I were to revisit my original purchase decision, I would buy the smaller one.

Hank

Re: Scraper Planes

#4

Re: Scraper Planes

david weaver

If you have to have one, the bronze LN 212 is the one to get in my opinion. Scraping wide surfaces is hard work, especially if the wood has moved at all. I've had a 112, the LV large and the LN 212. The small size of the 212 makes for a lot less work, and it does leave a bit of scalloping, but that can be cleaned up with a card scraper pretty quickly.

If you have a large panel that gets a little out of flat from humidity changes, or whatever, it will be a nightmare with the large scraper plane. Pushing through any significant amount of stock removal is like getting in a contest with a bulldozer. If you always manage to just run it over boards when they've come out of a planer and are flat, it'd be more tolerable.

I think they are a bit of a novelty if you have a high angle plane or plane with a cap iron nearby.

Re: Scraper Planes

#5

Scraper planes question....

roger lance

If the larger scraper planes are difficult to push.....why not project less of the scraper thus making a smaller more shallow cut??

Re: Scraper Planes

#6

Re: Scraper planes question....

david weaver

Certainly an option, just an issue of time. Reminds me that 8 or 9 years ago, I sat 5 curly maple panels aside and never finished a blanket chest I was going to make out of them.

Point of that, those 5 panels were thicknessed by a friend of a friend who had a 52" beach oscillating drum sander (what a fantastic tool for anyone who has 25 horsepower worth of three phase electricity available). By the time I got home and attempted to finish scrape them the next day, they weren't perfectly flat.

I broke out my trusty 63 degree muji smoother and large LV scraper plane and never got them finished. Someone on here, can't remember who (wiley or someone else?) mentioned the LN 212 being a lot easier to push and I ordered it and then finish scraped those. I should've just sanded and card scraped them and left them bowed, they'll fit in frames and would've gone back to flat, anyway.

The thing that made the muji and the large scraper a no-go was the volume of work that had to be done to get the panel flat enough to get a cut out of either of them. The little LN plane didn't require a surface as flat.

(those panels would've been easily finish planed by a stanley 4, but not with the skill set I had at the time).

Re: Scraper Planes

#7

Re: Scraper Planes

Chuck Bjorgen

I hadn't given the LN 212 any thought at all. But now I'm wondering if I should just be happy with my Stanley no. 80. At my age I'm not about to tackle large projects so large panels are out of the question. Speculation sometimes gets me in trouble. I keep telling myself I shouldn't be buying any more planes. In fact, I should sell off a few.

Thanks for the responses anyway, folks.

Re: Scraper Planes

#8

Re: Scraper Planes

William Duffield

I have an L-N #112, and a Stanley #80. I used to use the #80 extensively, but I don't use either one any more. Maybe I'm just lazy, but the scraper planes are a bit fiddly. Now, I just pick up a card scraper when something needs to be scraped. I rarely try to scrape the entire surface, except curved surfaces. Instead, I follow Frank Klausz' advise: "You plane; then you scrape; then you sand." Using a smoothing plane with a closely set double iron configuration, and a couple of Festool Rotex sanders, I have less need of scraping before sanding.

I also have a wooden toothing plane that works in the scraping configuration, and a toothing blade for the L-N #112, but they are used for preparing veneer and substrate for the veneer hammer and hot hide glue.

Re: Scraper Planes

#9

Re: Scraper Planes

david weaver

I think you're coming to the most reasonable conclusion. The adjuster on the 112 and 212 let you use them more between raising a burr, and they're more forgiving if your burr angle is a little off, but they're still fiddly and it's easier to just learn to set the #80 than it is to deal with those two wheel adjusters all the time.

If you can set the #80 reasonably consistently, then I'd keep using it (and if it's a bit coarse, then just a card scraper). If you have thick veneer that you like to use it on, it will do better than a scraper plane. Anything else should be done with planes or power tools if you're just looking to "get it done" and do a good job.