tips for deep mortises?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I am chopping 24 mortises that are as deep as they are long. The last row of chips is hard to pry out. Any tips to offer?

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
tips for deep mortises?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I am chopping 24 mortises that are as deep as they are long. The last row of chips is hard to pry out. Any tips to offer?

Re: tips for deep mortises?
William Duffield
A swan neck chisel, maybe? Usually, though, they are used for timber framing and thus are too large for something as delicate as furniture joinery.
Re: tips for deep mortises?
Todd Stock
Swans in 6mm, 10mm, and 12mm are available from TFWW...Henry Taylors in Imperial widths for about half that money from Lee Valley. The 6mm does double duty for full mortise locks.
Re: tips for deep mortises?
Todd Stock
Oops...no more 1/2" HT swan at Lee Valley...but TFWW still carries all three sizes.
Re: tips for deep mortises?
Larry Barrett
Make your own cleanout chisel. Even mild steel will do, although it won't remain sharp for long. Use a piece of steel slightly thinner than the width of your mortise.
Sharpen the end, something like the one in this picture. You can pry with it, but it works well to just drop it into the mortise, bear down and tap the side to slide it along the bottom of the mortise. Back and forth a few times and you are done. Take another piece of steel, flat on the bottom, and tap this along the bottom of the mortise to mush down stray fibers.

Drill each end, chop out the middle
Re: tips for deep mortises?
Jack Guzman from Maine
When I'm chopping deep mortises I keep a chisel that is narrower than the mortise at hand to help with cleanout. I always thought a swans neck would be handy for this but I don't do that many so I never bothered.---Jack
Re: tips for deep mortises?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I have a Sokozari nomi, or bottom cleaning chisel, by Koyamaichi ...


Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: tips for deep mortises?
North of the Border
Saw this tip in a magazine:
Use a $1 paint can opener.
My hardware store carries two sizes 1/4" and 1/8" or so.
Re: tips for deep mortises?
Todd Stock
I'd go with Derek's bottom cleaner - the Japanese have that whole process down pat. If easily startled, you might stick with the basic model and avoid the 'spritz & dry' feature, but otherwise, not a bad way to get things all spick'n'span.
Re: tips for deep mortises?
Kees
Me too. I have a 4mm mortise chisel and use that one too lever the waste out of the hole as soon as I am getting rather deep.
Usually I don't reach full depth on the first traverse with the mortise chisel from one end of the mortise top the other, despite using a big oak mallet. So I start to chop into the triangular waste pieces on the bottom. This usually is enough to bring me down to full depth (and deeper) in no time.
Derek beat me to it.
Brian Holcombe
Sokozari nomi for me as well,
I make a lot of mortises deeper than they are wide, which is a PITA but makes for a strong light frame.
I made some recently that are 3/4" long and 1-1/8" deep.
Question, flummoxed
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I don't see how this device or the swan neck would be helpful to getting chips out any more so than any tool, for example a chisel, that is more narrow than the mortise.....a statement that likely reveals that I don't understand how to use it. Exactly how is it used?
My mortises are 1 or 1 1/4 x 1-1/4 deep. First row of chops goes fine as there is sufficient clearance between the tip of the chisel and the opposing wall to pry out the chip. When I chop to depth and pivot the chisel off the back wall to pry out the chip the chip lodges against the front wall before it clears. The problem is not making and shearing off the chip. The problem is getting it elevated up and out of the mortise. I can get behind the chip with a more narrow chisel and pry it back toward where it came from and clear it. But that involves exchanging tools and that eats up time. It is taking me 10 min to chop these deep mortises and almost all that time is prying up and out the deeper chips.
The swan neck seems designed to make the bottom of the mortise smooth, something I don't have any need to do. Unsure if the tool you describe has a similar function or it can be used in some way that makes it better than a more narrow chisel for chip ejection.
What has helped
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
1. Patience. Put up with the fact that the process is going to be slow, 10 min per mortise.
2. Don't make several chips and then try to clear several at once. Several pack so tight that it takes a lot of effort to dislodge. Clear each chip as it is made.
3. Drill each end of the mortise to provide some clearance and a depth gauge.
4. Take small chips, about 1/16" thick per chop.
Still yet as the mortise gets deeper there is not clearance to pry out the chips with the mortise chisel. Prying off the back wall, the chisel tip hits the front wall and stops before the chip is raised enough to clear it. I have been relying on a more narrow chisel and prying from the reverse side of the chip to clear it. It is just slow changing tools to eject the deep chips.
newbie question
Joseph Piotrowski
i chopped a few mortises and i'm learning. i'm leaning towards drilling out the waste. is that a viable solution?
I don't think so
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The mortise chisel self aligns on the mortise side as the chisel is driven into the wood. I think you would not get the proper shearing action on the mortise side if there were an abundance of holes that would provide the opportunity for the chisel to wander. But, I should try it to see.
Re: Question, flummoxed
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Bill and all,
Where I find the sokozarai valuable is ensuring that you have gotten to depth, but not chopped too deep. In other words, it's protecting the live wood below the mortise, where you don't have a lot to spare and cannot afford to over cut. IAnd it gives you positive proof that the entire bottom is at depth, because you've pared the whole thing in a few strokes.
I think the key to what you're doing is to not try to clear every chip as you go. Instead, make enough clearance in the mortise up front so you have room to operate. Specifically, either drill three or four holes, or, as I prefer in a narrow, deep mortise, chop out a deep triangle the first thing you do. Make a triangle with two angled chops, say 3/8" deep, right in the middle of the mortise. Then ride the bevel from both sides, making good-sized chips-- they'll pop right out because of the angled cut You can dig out about half the waste of the whole mortise this way, for the size of the ones you're doing.
Having created clearance, don't worry about chips anymore. Just chop the whole bottom to depth, and let the chips go where they want, cause they're loose in the hole, and won't impede the chisel. If you have a scraping tool or sokozarai, use it here to ensure you're everywhere at depth. Then move on. When you've done all mortises on that stick, unclamp it and shake/blow/scrape out all the remaining waste from all the mortises. Again, the key is to make your clearance, or working room, up front.
Just my own experience, not trying to preach atcha.
Wiley
Re: Question, flummoxed
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I use a mortise chisel and a 30 ounce wooden mallet with a short handle; no drilling, no narrow chisel. This gives a fast and precise mortise. Using a mortise chisel requires skill however. There is nothing wrong with drilling, but I think that if you can learn to use a chisel you will like it better.
I wrote this to Bill in 2012:If you use the chisel with the bevel toward a hole you already have (sliding along the back instead of along the bevel), the bevel tends to compress the waste and push it to the bottom of the hole.
The Japanese chisels for flattening the bottom are used because the Japanese like to mortise to within 1/4 inch of the other side of the timber, so they must be flat. This gives a strong joint, but is more tedious. If you have a little more leeway (I use 5/16 from far side or through mortise) the holes can be a little more carefree.
One problem with levering out waste is that the deeper you go the less of an arc the chisel has to travel through when levering. If you chop out a corner with the chisel slanted and the bevel vertical, you get an extra 30 degrees of arc for levering. Also if you have a nice flat 30 degree bevel with no secondary bevel, you get a nice heel on the chisel which helps with the levering.
I misunderstood or that didn't hlep
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"Having created clearance, don't worry about chips anymore. Just chop the whole bottom to depth, and let the chips go where they want, cause they're loose in the hole, and won't impede the chisel. " Chiseling chips ain't the problem; its getting them out of the mortise that's the problem
Well mine are not loose in the hole. You could say they are chopped free of the matrix, but the "loose" chip is stuck in the mortise. And if I don't clear each chip the next chip compresses against the first and becomes even tighter bound in the mortise to where they won't pry out with the 1/4" chisel.
I'm not having any problem excavating the first 75% of the waste. The very last chip from the bottom- back of the mortise can not be pried out because the chisel tip hits the forward wall of the mortise before the chip is elevated enough to eject. It is simple geometry. The fulcrum is the back of the chisel off the top corner of the back of the mortise. If the chisel is deep enough in the mortise the tip hits the front wall as it is rotated on this fulcrum and that situation will not elevate the last chip to be removed, nor the few before it, or any of the chips off the last row to be freed.
If you have a scraping tool or sokozarai, use it here to ensure you're everywhere at depth.
If you look at the picture you will see a Starrett depth gauge which I set as a go/no go depth gauge. It has the additional function that it checks that the side walls are orthogonal to the face. Additionally, I draw a magic marker line across the chisel face at 1 1/4" to estimate depth. I have 2 3/4" of wood beneath the floor of the mortise so if it goes a little deep it is irrelevant. It would appear that the Japanese device is of no use to me, unless it pries better than a 1/4" chisel. A piece of 1/4" bar stock might be best suited for prying.
I'm with you.....
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"I wrote this to Bill in 2012:If you use the chisel with the bevel toward a hole you already have (sliding along the back instead of along the bevel), the bevel tends to compress the waste and push it to the bottom of the hole." I must have remembered this advice because I don't chisel that way.
"The Japanese chisels for flattening the bottom are used because the Japanese like to mortise to within 1/4 inch of the other side of the timber," I have 2 3/4" under the mortise floor.
"One problem with levering out waste is that the deeper you go the less of an arc the chisel has to travel through when levering"....that's the problem! And I have not heard the better solution to it. Festool Domino
I bought one (used and cheap) and can't bring myself to use it on a Period piece. .
"Also if you have a nice flat 30 degree bevel with no secondary bevel, you get a nice heel on the chisel which helps with the levering. " Once again, I have no secondary bevel. The bevel works as advertised in a wider mortise. It fails in deep narrow ones. Insufficient arc, as you described.
Re: I misunderstood or that didn't hlep
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Bill,
Since you're getting to depth OK, with no high spots, and the only problem is getting wedged chips out--why not wait til you've done all the mortises on that stick. Then unclamp, turn it upside down, and dig out all the hung chips with anything, with gravity on your side.
Wiley
Re: I don't think so
Joseph Piotrowski
that makes sense. i guess it would have to be a bench chisel or maybe a paring chisel . so much to learn 
I found the most useful tip
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I have no problem making a chip. Releasing it from the walls of the mortise is the issue, especially when the chip is deep and there is not sufficient arc for the tip of the chisel to clear the far wall of the mortise.

This situation can be seen in the picture. The tip of the chisel has hit the wall and will not pry any higher. If the chip is not loose enough to flick out at this point it will have to be pried out from the other direction. What I was looking for was a technique improvement for forming the chip such that it would release easier
Drilling holes at the ends of the mortise is a time saver. Maybe it wasn't done in 1720, but they didn't have a drill press and Lee Valley spur bits in 1720. It takes no significant time to jig up and drill the holes. The holes provide a most useful depth gauge as well as some clearance to get things started.
The breakthrough was making thinner chips. A Duh moment. The friction of the formed chip against the mortise wall seems to increase dramatically with thickness. And when they are lodged it takes a substantial prying force to release them. I was having to chisel the chip loose from the matrix and then pry it out with a more narrow chisel.
Thin enough chips have little enough friction on the mortise wall that they can be flicked out without needing a prying fulcrum for the mortise chisel. Hence deep chips are readily flicked out with the chisel tip.
When I reduced the chip thickness to something less than 1/16" I no longer needed to put down the mortise chisel, pick up a prying device (in my case a 1/4" chisel) and pry out the chip. It appears that the chip needs to be thin enough to deform across its width for wedging friction to substantially decrease.
How to
Brian Holcombe
When I cut a mortise I do not lever my chisels. It's a fine practice with western chisels, not so much with extremely hard steel Japanese chisels.
Instead, I run a round of chops, then turn the chisel around and chop right back into the waste. In a softwood, I can then pull the chips out with the sokozarai nomi, in a harder wood sometimes I may need a third round.
I continue doing this until the desired depth is reached. It takes longer (for me) then a wide mortise, however it is all but required in thin framed items like shoji where the stiles are 30.5mm square.
Video of chopping
Brian Holcombe
I uploaded a video for you to watch.
I do some levering in this case since I'm working with cedar, but with with Japanese chisels I'm not using it as a pry bar. Instead, I unseat the chisel and clear the chips, subtle difference but critical.
These joints are framing joints, but the idea remains the same. Yellow cedar is not something I like to clamp, too easy to damage the wood, so I let the piece float while I cut the joinery.
Also note, that if you wear a recently pressed shirt the process seems to go along well.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HhsMtTnp_4s&feature=youtu.be