Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Wood and steel wear *LINK*

Posts

Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#1

Wood and steel wear *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren asked me a question on Sawmill Creek essentially about the silica content of Jarrah, since I had mentioned that Australian timbers can have a high silica content. The context of this is the high wear properties that Oz timbers have on tool steel.

As it happens, Jarrah has low silica content, and therefore its high wear properties are due to something else. My thoughts ran to its hardness (Janka ratings are high) and resin content (it is common to find pitch holes and veins in Jarrah). Jarrah is a eucalyptus, and these are common through Australia (although Jarrah is only found in my neck of the woods, in the south western section of Australia). The other common species are the acacias. These are more common to the Eastern states (other side of the island).

I decided to post the question on the Australian forum. Commonly, we Ozzies tend to bang on about the impact our timbers have on tool steel, whether this is in plane blades, chisels (both lathe and bench), and machine blades. Over the years we have seen the introduction of HSS (M2), A2, recently PM-V11, and even M4 replacing the O1 and high carbon steels commonly used by Stanley and many other manufacturers.

Our timbers do tend to be harder than those in other countries and we assume that this is a central cause for steel wear. The question I ask is "is this really so"?

The Janka rating for many of our timbers is much higher than most other countries. But is this enough to create the extra wear we experience? Other than silica, what else causes extra wear? Jarrah (among other eucalypts) is often quite interlocked. Is this enough to cause wear?

On a Google search I came up with a gem of an article, AUSTRALIAN EUCALYPTUS TIMBERS (link below), which has a chapter on "The Chemical Products of Australian Eucalypts". Editing this to the salient factors, the introduction starts,

1. General. - The important Australian genus, Eucalyptus, is remarkable for the number and diversity of its chemical constituents. It might perhaps appear from a cursory glance that these were distributed throughout the several groups in an irregular manner, but research has shown that this is not so, for a most orderly arrangement is traceable through the various members and groups of the genus, a peculiarity which suggests a predominating influence of evolutionary conditions.

The article then goes on to discussing a number of influences:

Inorganic factors: Understandably, different regions in Oz will influence differently, however "A striking peculiarity in the eucalypts is the relative constancy of the element manganese in the ash of related species." ...."In some eucalypts the calcium oxalate is present in such abundance that at times as much as one-sixth of the entire air-dried bark consists of crystallised calcium oxalate." ...

Another relevant influence is tannin. "All the exudations of the earlier members of the genus, as well as those of the closely related genus Angophora, contain the crystallisable body aromadendrin ... Economically this is of importance because the tannins in those species which contain eudesmin and aromadendrin in their kinos can be utilised for tanning purposes". One of the thoughts I had - lacking any knowledge of chemistry and how these chemicals develop over time in their natural state - is whether this is the same as the resins in the wood, and then whether these hardened resin veins we so frequently see in gums, create an abrasive compound?

A friend of mine, Bob, mills trees as a hobby (he is a retired physics professor). He wrote about his experiences (anecdotal evidence but still ..): "Silica content seems to be dependent on climate stress. This is quite noticeable when milling a yard tree versus a tree that has been in an area of bush where it has not seen much water especially in the last few decades around Perth. Tuart seems to be the most common trees that have this problem. Some deposit enough silica so that occasional sparks can be seen when cutting a clean dry wood on a long dead tree i.e. tree has probably died from lack of water. This is also supposed to happen but to a lesser extent in Jarrah and Marri.

In general timber hardness still dominates chainsawing because it's as much a puncture and tearing action akin to chiselling as it is cutting. The first time I milled an ironbark I could not believe how much extra it demanded of the chainsaw. If ironbark had been the first species I had milled I would have given up and gone home. About the 3rd log I milled was some sort of rock hard desert gum and it was bone dry and I managed to blow up the 50cc 40 year old well used chainsaw I was using at the time. I was not that fussed because that saw owed me nothing and I treated it as a learning exercise.

Another species that has given me grief is Rock Oak, a type of hard sheoak that grows in the WA (West Australian) wheatbelt. This also pulls up a lot of silica and I won't mill these unless they promise to yield a decent bit of timber."

While I have mainly posted about Jarrah, it is simply an example of trying to understand what properties are responsible for wear in tool steel. That different timbers wear steel differently is clear. What can we learn from American woods?

Regards from Perth

Derek


AUSTRALIAN EUCALYPTUS TIMBERS

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#2

some thoughts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The effect of density on wear has a straightforward component. With a dense wood more wood rubs against the steel per length planed. With a lighter weight wood the blade cuts through more air to get from here to there. There can be a factor of 2X between the amount of solid stuff in per unit of volume in a dense tropical wood and our lighter weight species.

An there is a mechanical component. A more dense wood provides more resistance that can lead to folding and/or chipping at some scale at the edge.

The vast majority of what we call wood is cellulose and lignin. The cellulose component is the same chemical composition no matter the kind of tree. I know less about the possibility of the lignin chemical composition significantly differing, but I will bet that all lignin has the same "abrasivity", along with the cellulose.

So any differences must come from how dense these components are packed, maybe their relative amounts (but I doubt it) and the mineral junk the tree accumulates as water is sucked up and evaporates.

There is another possible component and that is corrosive wear. Do the chemical components in wood dissolve metal as the metal rubs across the surface? This factor is important in high speed wood machining and coatings like vanadium nitride are added to mitigate the effect.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#3

Re: Wood and steel wear

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There are other factors besides hardness that can make a certain wood rough on edges. Jarrah falls into the hardness range of our hickories, but I think it is tougher on edge longevity. (There are five or six hickory species here in Pennsylvania, around a dozen in North America). Persimmon, Diospyros virginiana, is harder than jarrah and black locust, Robinia pseudoacacia, is softer, yet it is the locust that is more like jarrah with regard to edges.

We often use the word texture to describe this. A wood with even or mild texture is easier to work than one of the same hardness with "stringy" or uneven texture. I think that weak places in the steel edge get caught on harder areas in the wood and cause mechanical distortion. My observation is that steel with fine texture does better in this regard. I have better results with 19th century steel (very fine texture) and I would expect poorer results from harsh sharpening abrasives which cut deeply into the edge and cause uneven texture of the edge.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#4

heat

david weaver

I wonder if there is more heat with woods that are more dense. I wouldn't be surprised if there is.

If anyone would've measured that, it would be LV.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#5

Of course there is

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Work becomes heat. If you have to push harder in dense woods it follows more heat is generated.

It's called the conservation of energy. Work equals force times distance, in this case how hard you push the plane for what distance. This work gets converted into heat(conserved)......1 J = 0.02 calories.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#6

Re: Of course there is

david weaver

Right, and playing the devil's advocate, I don't know for sure that the work here generates appreciable heat or that in this case, that it makes a difference at the edge of the plane. It probably does, but other than knowing that the shavings sometimes come out warm, I don't know for sure that the heat generated is appreciable and that it's focused at the edge.

I only mentioned heat because it wasn't mentioned. I recall Rob Lee saying something about heat and speed of planing a long time ago, and he's sitting on a pile of data from testing things, I'm sure, but didn't share details above and beyond that. Given that LV didn't use a high speed steel, but instead chose a high alloy steel that wasn't high speed, it must not have been that big of a deal to them based on their testing data.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#7

Re: Wood and steel wear

david weaver

I've gone around in circles on this, but have now given up using planes with wondersteel irons unless they happen to be a plane that I also like a lot. I notice that O1 is sort of like a lithium battery in cocobolo in that it planes well for a while, and then all of the sudden, it's as if the sharpness falls right off the table and I have to resharpen.

My high speed steel irons are the opposite (I don't have any M2 or M4, though - I suspect muji's high speed steel is something else, though I've ground it until the edge is a dull red to make sure that it's high speed steel, and it is). They take a little bit of damage and then work sort of dull for a long time. It does make it harder to tell when it's time to sharpen something like cocobolo, which can be difficult to plane even with a sharp plane if the grain orientation isn't in your favor.

I can say that this is yet another thing that I used to do, though (planing hard billets) and found tedious and slow and full of risk, but it has been made much faster with the use of the cap iron. I think I'd find a single iron plane with O1 steel to be unacceptable because it would need to be resharpened all the time. Being able to double the shaving thickness, which has a two-fold effect (more shaving coming off each stroke, and the plane will plane longer into a wear cycle since less clearance is needed for a shaving twice as thick) and do it without risk is a luxury.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#8

have you used a card scraper lately?

Ian Neuhaus

David commented

playing the devil's advocate, I don't know for sure that the work here generates appreciable heat or that in this case, that it makes a difference at the edge of the plane. It probably does, but other than knowing that the shavings sometimes come out warm, I don't know for sure that the heat generated is appreciable and that it's focused at the edge.

the heat generated when using a card scraper is easily measurable -- sometime the scraper becomes too hot to handle.

a plane blade does considerably more cutting so will generate significantly more heat, which away from the cutting edge will be dissipated through the plane body.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#9

Heat generation

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I believe dullness is more a factor in heat generation than the hardness of the timber. I have at times noticed loss of temper when planing with a edge that is too dull. The damage from excessive heat can persist for several rounds of sharpening. A lack of clearance due to excessive honing angles would seem to generate heat also.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#10

Re: Of course there is

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Trivial to calculate for your planing situation.

Joules can be directly converted to calories as shown. A joule is a force of 1 Newton applied over a distance of 1 meter. Trivial task to estimate how hard you are pushing the plane over the planing distance and convert to heat (calories) which will be generated. Now the hard part will be determining what fraction gets absorbed by the wood shaving and substrate and what fraction by the steel. Considering the thermal conductivity of each I think a reasonable estimate would be 1:3.

That said we know heat in hand planing is not significant. If it was blades would be dulling by deforming at the tip due to loss of hardness.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#11

Single Irons

Brian Holcombe

David, I cut a single iron dai recently for Kez and it surprised me. The iron seems to take a very fine shaving for a quite a long while. I set the cutting angle to 36 degrees, set the mouth and wear to only accept an extremely fine shaving and expected to need to sharpen it very commonly.

So far, it seems to last and last. Typically when I set a double iron to such an extremely fine shaving the iron will wear to the point where I need to either take a heavier shaving or resharpen and I've so far assumed that to be due to the accelerated wear happening when the cap iron is working a chip.

So, I would think O1 would probably work out surprisingly well so long as it is a plane where you can set it for a fine shaving.

I've used single irons for a heavier shaving as well, but they require careful attention being paid to grain direction, any reversals of course make for heavy tear out, basically I can only use them after riving the material. The extremely fine shaving is obviously less particular about grain direction.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#12

Re: Of course there is

david weaver

Now you're getting to the part that's important to me. I went to college for mathematics, but I've since lost some of my analytical sense in terms of imagining every step of what's occurring (unless I have to). Call it advancing age, anxiety, whatever...

We can easily calculate how much work is done, what the total heat output is, but the simple problem I'd like to know the answer for is this:

* how hot does the actual edge of the steel get ( is it enough to cause temper problems? Or more importantly, longevity issues )

* how deep does the heat go (that might not even matter)

* do we know which situations might cause significant issues with heat and which situations don't? (certain woods, certain planing speeds, etc).

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#13

Re: Single Irons

david weaver

That sounds like the case of a very good iron, and maybe design (maybe 36 degrees has something to do with the longevity?). I've had planes that cut well with a single iron (the infill plane that I made lasts a little longer than I'd expect - single iron and 55 degrees), and planes that don't last like I'd like (JT Brown jointer with a butcher iron), but the latter may be due in combination to iron softness as well as the desire to use the plane in situations where tearout occurs - which always makes a plane seem disagreeable and dull.

I agree on the very thin shaving in a double iron. The whole mechanism seems to work better when the shaving is thick enough to keep it engaged mechanically.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#14

Re: have you used a card scraper lately?

david weaver

Usually, the contact point between a plane and an iron is a pretty small area, so I'm not sure how much heat is dissipated. The contact between the cap iron and iron is larger, but further up from the edge.

I'm not sure how much heat is generated from a plane compared to a card scraper, but I think the card scraper generates more or a thin iron like a stanley iron would be hotter if we just took it out of a plane quickly. I can't say I've paid enough attention to ever try getting the iron out quickly after smoothing a large panel - I think I may vaguely recall that the iron is a little warm, but with the amount of heat that a card scraper generates, if the plane iron was generating the same, it should be very warm.

If that doesn't satisfy as a theory (due to the possibility of the frog absorbing heat), then in wooden planes where the irons aren't that thick (I have some double iron planes where the contact point is small at the cap - so it shouldn't be dissipating much heat, and the iron itself is fairly thin - 1/8th or so attributable to being made in sheffield after some makers went to all steel / non-laminated). The wood wouldn't absorb that much heat, but I still don't recall anything other than the shavings maybe feeling a little warm (as in, I don't recall a warm iron - perhaps due to not paying attention if the warmth is more subtle). I know the bedding contact points for the irons are pretty small because I made the planes and fitted them that way.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#15

easy empirical solution

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is the hardness of the edge that keeps it from deforming. If the edge was dulling by deforming the result would be obvious by observation. It would curl and the curling would occur on the first or second stroke.

If heat was a significant dulling contribution then dulling would be strongly dependent on planing speed for the heat from the work of planing would be dumped into the blade tip with less time to dissipate.

The conductivity of the blade and the heat capacity of the blade is sufficient that the tip is not going store significant heat between plane strokes. Hence, whatever heat does to the tip will occur on the first pass ( and maybe show up no later than the second pass).

Heat is linear with planing force. If the planing force is 2X when the blade is dull the heat is 2x but the heat is distributed across a vastly larger dull and rounded tip. Hence, if heat is an issue it will only be an issue with the first few strokes after sharpening. After that the planing work goes up slowly while the volume of the blade tip , and hence heat capacity, goes up as some power function of feet planed. If planing a dense wood is twice the force of softer wood the heat is 2X unless the stroke is slower if which case there may be no difference is tip temperature.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#16

Re: heat

William Duffield

I was at a SAPFM meeting on Saturday at which there was a presentation by a maker of wooden moulding planes. He observed that the bottom of at least one plane had been significantly darkened (maybe almost charred) just behind the mouth, where the iron bedded, due to the friction of planing. To me, that indicates the wood had reached a temperature of at least 450° F, which is higher than the tempering temperature he recommended for O1 steel plane irons, around 350° F.

That tells me that the closer the chip breaker is set to the edge of the iron, and the more carefully the chip breaker is bedded to the iron, the more effectively it can dissipate the heat that otherwise can cause loss of hardness at the edge. The conductivity of the material the chip breaker is made from should also be important.

That would suggest less heat damage from a heavily copper- or silver-plated chip breaker. There are thermally conductive greases that the computer industry uses between high power and high speed ICs and their heat sinks, but these may not be advisable for planes, because I think they are silicones. Maybe we should add cooling fins to our lever caps? :D How about a squirrel cage fan and a LiIon battery? :D Since a wooden bench dissipates heat faster than still air, this is another reason we should always rest the plane sole down on the bench, and not on its side. :D

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#17

Re: easy empirical solution

david weaver

I would suppose that maybe heat might be more of an issue than just after sharpening - because it could occur instantaneously at the surface of an edge and create wear in a part that is too small to deform (and be worn off at the same time).

I'd love to know if anyone has ever been able to measure this stuff.

I'm getting to a point where I think I will probably stick with simple steels, because maturation of technique seems to make use of those much more enjoyable (as does the fact that they are in familiar tools, so even if there are rare cases that simple steels result in some significant sharpening time increase - yesterday, it may have been 2 minutes - the familiarity with the tool breeds better results overall). Getting to the point that I'm making, I'm asking these questions only out of curiosity. There used to be a great gap between how long I could get the muji irons to last in difficult wood vs. a typical vintage iron, but a lot of that has erased, even in cocobolo where I used to be tortured using A2 and oil hardening steel.

The cap iron is one variable that negates some of that, but experience is probably contributory, too.

Absent minded today - still missing what I was going to respond about: the heat stuff is interesting if it can be applied somehow. Like if it can be blamed for what I used to see when I took lots of thin shavings - the HSS irons in the chinese planes would last several times longer than O1? Or was that due to just silica. The cap iron seems to have solved my issues better than anything else, because even a mildly dull iron will continue to stay in the cut.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#18

Re: heat

david weaver

I have also seen that on some moulding planes, but not often.

I am skeptical about whether or not that was due to regular planing, though, and if it was, what was being planed? And who was doing the planing - skilled cabinetmaker or youthful heavy-handed apprentice full of fire? If an iron gets hot enough to burn wood like that, it should blue and become unreasonably soft for planing, or at least annoyingly soft.

The planes I've seen it on are hollows and rounds, which don't tend to be used on heavy planing in dense woods, and it does seem to be rare.

Other possibilities:

* The black isn't charring, but discoloration due to some other reason (we should find one that's literally turned to charcoal-ish stuff, but the ones I've seen, the wood is still sound and just dark).

* The plane was used in some sort of fixture in a really deep cut. Most craftsmen with sense would smell smoke and decide that they should stop for a second. At least one would hope that to be true.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#19

Digging in and "marsh" boards.

GolfSteve in Calgary

My theory is that harder wood needs a sharper edge to "dig-in" and initiate the cut. Once the blade gets a bit dull it is easier for the blade to skip over the surface than cut. With a soft wood a slightly dull edge can initiate and continue a cut.

I made my workbench out of hard maple; starting with 200 bf of 10' long 8/4 boards; all hand-jointed and face planed. Some of these boards stank when cutting them; I called them marsh boards. The marsh boards were usually variegated with white and brown stripes. These boards would dull a freshly sharpened plane within two or three swipes. It got to the point where I didn't believe in myself anymore; I though I was incapable of sharpening properly. Just when I was about to give up hope I would hit a board (usually a board of white coloured maple) that would cut like a dream.

I still spit on the memory of those marsh boards. They stank and they made my life miserable. Unfortunately I cannot predict which boards will excessively dull my plane blade. Every one in a while I run across a cherry board that dulls my plane quickly. I never have any problem with pine and fir.

I have some 2x4" x 8' Jarrah at home (used as shipping bracing). This stuff suffers from horrible tear-out, but I don't recall that it dulled my blades particularly quickly. Once again it is very hard, so I think that you need a very sharp blade to get the "bite" into the wood. Tear-out is a different issue.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#20

Re: heat

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am not sure if this is similar ...

I notice that the backs of the 1/4" thick O1 single irons I use in my HNT Gordon planes (smoother and trying plane), which are bedded at 60 degrees, turn brown after a planing session with Jarrah. There is a hardened resin-like substance along with a discolouration of the steel, itself. The bevel is not discoloured, only the back.

It is as though the steel heats up (the 60 degree bed is closer to a scraping cut), and the heat attracts resin in the wood.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#21

Re: heat

William Duffield

Is it the cellulose that is discoloring, or the resins, or maybe the wax applied to the bottom of the plane, or even the camellia oil used for rust prevention? Maybe we should switch to grapeseed oil, which has a higher flash point? :D

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#22

Not easy

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It takes quite a bit of experience to notice that the iron has been altered by excessive heat. These are subtle things not gross things. A guy who repeatedly dulls a plane iron to the point that it doesn't cut may never notice something like this. In fact if an iron is dulled repeatedly it might experience excessive heat every cycle. And the user may blame the steel for poor performance.

High performance of a plane or chisel and the ability to notice subtlety go hand in hand. One cannot learn to sharpen well or plane well without the ability to judge the results.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#23

Re: easy empirical solution

William Duffield

I don't think it's quite that simple. There are other factors that might disrupt your model. Whether they are significant, however, I don't know. It's been too long since I've studied thermodynamics and calculus, and I never used what I learned after I got out of college.

On the initial pass, the iron, chipbreaker, etc. are cold. On subsequent passes, they heat up, as heat flows into them. The hotter they get, the slower the heat flows from the cutting edge, and is retained longer at the cutting edge. It's temperature therefore rises with each stroke.

Not all the heat is generated at the cutting edge. Some is generated by friction of the chip against the front edge of the chip breaker. Some is generated by friction of the chip against the top of the mouth opening. Some is generated from the bottom of the blade against the planed surface of the stock. Some is generated from the sole of the plane against the stock.

Different metals have different heat capacity and rates of heat conduction. I know this from cooking with cast iron pans, aluminum pans, stainless pans, aluminum clad stainless pans, copper clad stainless pans and glass/ceramic pans. Of course they are much different than the parameters of hot plates and chopping blocks. Something similar applies to the complex systems that are planes. For example consider the difference between a single iron wooden plane with a wedge and a metal bodied Bailey/L-N with a thick iron, chip breaker, and lever cap. To add to the complexity, a bevel-up blade is seated to the bed of the plane much closer to the edge than a bevel-down blade.

I'm not much of an experimentalist, but something might be learned from equipping a wooden, wedged, double-iron plane with a closely set non-ferrous chip breaker. In this configuration, the double iron would effectively be a thermocouple. I suppose there are also sensitive infrared probes that might be mounted close to the edge to measure the temperature, but the chips would get in the way.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#24

Re: Not easy - definitely not

david weaver

Even the discussion of what dull means can't be fixed to a certain condition. If I use the word totally dull, it means (to me) that I can't get the plane to stay in the cut without influencing it by pushing it downward more than I would just with a regular grip orientation and "normal" stroke. To someone just starting out, they probably consider totally dull to mean that there is absolutely no way that the plane will continue to cut no matter what they do. It takes much longer to get to the latter.

Re: Wood and steel wear *LINK*

#25

Nicker Burn (is that like liar liar..)

david weaver

pants on fire?

See the picture of this item on peebay (certainly not advocating buying this for scientific purposes, either - it's quite expensive for a plane with a not-so-well made replacement handle!).

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Extra-Fine-McQuaid-Co-Canton-Il-14-1-4-Panel-Raising-Plane-AWP-Inv-J48/222525334702?_trksid=p2047675.c100005.m1851&_trkparms=aid%3D222007%26algo%3DSIM.MBE%26ao%3D2%26asc%3D43781%26meid%3D0d661aaa096c4e4f9ed222167d9759e8%26pid%3D100005%26rk%3D1%26rkt%3D6%26sd%3D172715969468

I get the sense that the black spot made by an iron might have more to do with a reaction than heat? Perhaps on an iron, it might be oil left close to the bevel or a reaction with the steel itself and something else in the wood, or wood being planed? I just have my doubts about that being heat related in regular planing, no matter how vigorous.

I doubt anyone was moving the nicker up and down on the linked plane fast enough that it would burn the slot :b