Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Game Changers.....

Posts

Game Changers.....

#1

Game Changers.....

roger lance

Just for grins, I'd like to follow-up on the discussion below that made reference to a new tool/method/technique that was a profound improvement over what had been available to woodworkers.

I'd like to start this list of wonders with an improved tool that some would consider a game changer and nominate the New Concepts saw frames (coping/fret) as a great improvement over prior saws. I find the ease of installing a blade in my NC fret saw as being very much an improvement over my old saw.....a game changer.

So, what will you nominate?? Derek has dips on the CBN wheels.

Re: Game Changers.....

#3

Re: Game Changers.....

Ian Neuhaus

how far back can we go?

my nomination would be the Lee Valley / Veritas saddle squares, and saddle dovetail markers and saddle mitre square.

or if that is too far back, then it would be the support tab Chris Vespers added to his Try square.

Re: Game Changers.....

#5

Stanley Bailey

Kees

The Stanley Bailey planes. Allthough i am a fan of the wooden planes, these must have been a game changer. No wear on the sole, easy adjuster, thin irons for easy and quick sharpening. A huge commercial success.

Re: Game Changers.....

#6

Skill

steve voigt

The game changer for me was realizing that the development of skill was the answer, not the discovery of a game-changing tool. Derek's answer of the chip breaker is a good one; it's hard to imagine getting more bang for the buck than one gets from learning to use the cap iron effectively. But the cap iron was always there (well for 250 years), patiently waiting for us to master it. It was the skill that was lacking…

Re: Game Changers.....

#7

Re:mindset

David weaver

Mindset and skill. A lot like Steve's answer. Mindset referring to observation and positive view toward the future when learning something (despite poor results that can occur on initial attempts). Tolerating, and embracing mistakes as part of learning.

Re: Game Changers.....

#8

Steel

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

great improvement over bronze and rock.

Re: Game Changers.....

#9

Re: Steel

roger lance

as was toilet paper over leaves.....

Re: Game Changers.....

#10

Re: Skill plus...

Ron in Sterling, CT

I would agree with skill, but in my mind basic knowledge/awareness comes first. I can't count the number of times during my many rust hunting years that I have found basic planes (#'s 3, 4, & 5) with the blade installed upside down. I just picked up a rusty #3 this weekend (needed for hardware parts) and when I dis-assembled it lo and behold---the blade was installed upside down. The guy who last used this plane is probably one of the many who I hear say "I never could use a plane very well".

Re: Game Changers.....

#12

Re: Ditto!


Re: Game Changers.....

#13

Re: Game Changers.....

roger lance

Pity the company that tries to pitch a new product to this crowd as being a "game changer"......most here not impressed since God invented opposing digits evidently.

Re: Game Changers.....

#14

Re: Past game changers..

david weaver

...and why at least on hand tools, we're a little slow to declare a second theory of relativity has been achieved in a hand tool sense.

(playing devil's advocate here, and not trying to start an argument)

* synthetic resin stones - oops, these aren't new. They've been made for razors for more than a hundred years, and the bench stone sizes didn't catch on. They can still be bought cheaply if you can find them. They were resin bonded with aluminum oxide in them...and the new ones are.....resin bonded with aluminum oxide in them.

* fine carborundum stones - sold for the price of good natural stones originally, bought in droves, often used little (get a hand full of silicon carbide particles floating around on your fingers and it's like having sharp fine dirt all over the place - I understand why they weren't favored so well - none of them finish an edge)

* A2 (and other diemaking steels) - it does make a decent plane iron for high wear situations, but few of us actually need them or get a real time gain with them. With certainty, they make it easier for a tool maker to heat treat an iron with minimal warpage. Terrible for chisels, but good for the tool maker. Makes no sense for the user, though - even in a parer where you could suppose long planing cuts. Very popular with companies obsessed with accuracy (Karl Holtey started them commercially, and Karl would probably love a plane made of parts to be used at absolute zero where every single molecule has stopped moving so that perfect indefinite stability can be achieved).

* any number of adjustment mechanisms that's supposed to be more precise and better than the stanley bailey adjuster (I have tried a lot of them, none are better but lots are quite a bit more expensive.)

* heavier planes (insert all of the ping pong with a cast iron frying pan smoothers here - stole that from warren). All of them feel great for a few strokes, and get really heavy and sticky on a board once you start to sweat and notice weight.

* super thick irons - same as heavier planes. Feel great, like riding an old cadillac that had power steering so jacked up that you could hardly feel the road through the wheel, and you could turn the wheel with your pinkie while driving over a 4 inch deep pothole. Pain in the rear end to grind - combine high alloy with very thick "two improvements in one", and you have something exceptionally slow to grind. They also remove your senses when it comes to feeling tearout when smoothing.

* two handed saws and various saw guides - every gadget has its own learning curve. Probably not a bad idea if freehand is no option, but limiting otherwise and a pain to learn to use and then what do you do when you can't use one on a cut. Suffer through risky cuts, I guess.

* Primus smoother - I mention it because it literally claims to have solved every stanley plane shortcoming, yet it somehow is a relatively undesirable plane to most people who have tried one.

* Stainless steel infills - the ultimate collector's item - won't rust despite the fact that you don't actually use them. Hope the iron is stainless, too, because it won't be replaceable by the time you find it rusty and the maker's style has changed. Maybe just paint the iron with shellac in advance.

* planes with disposable blades - no comment needed

* planes with super hard irons - great idea if it takes 15 minutes to sharpen. Not so great in practice once you learn to sharpen quickly (George Wilson used to tell me all the time that irons should be right at the edge of being file-able with a good file, which I thought was too soft. He has publicly stated before that irons 62+ hardness in common tool steels are too hard, so I'm not stepping on toes accidentally by stating that.). Just like heavy planes are wood show planes, I've started to refer to those super-hard irons as catalog tools. As in, you buy them when you view them in a catalog because they have a higher number than other tools. It's like getting more french fries in a combo meal - the number is bigger - it must be better. When the maker charges more for the higher number, of course it must also be better.

* planes with or without handles that depart significantly from what was used when people made a living using planes heavily. Krenov said handles are uncomfortable, so lots of people believe him because he said that. Never mind the tens or hundreds of thousands of period woodworkers who didn't find much favor in going without handles.

There are some improvements, but it seems like a 100 to 1 thing (what's actually an improvement for all). For refreshing hardened steel, CBN is just better. It's faster, no water (I never used water to begin with, but now the iron isn't even too hot to put it in your palm). Certainly, it's not necessary, but it's better and may be cheaper in the long run.

Belt grinders - not particularly useful for regular woodworking, but in tool and knife making, and rasp making, better than a wheel for a lot of operations. Not many deadly accidents with them, either.

Carbide - also not much of an improvement for woodworking, but making tools and working metal, huge improvement for certain things.

Stanley bailey plane design - an affordable metal plane with interchangeable parts, great adjuster, great cap iron design.

(I can think of gobs of things that have improved in terms of metalworking, shaving, etc, and enthusiasts of those things tend to figure that if there were improvements in those, there should have been in woodworking, too, but I don't see much practical improvements in actual tools since the introduction of the stanley plane with a lateral adjuster. things have definitely gotten cheaper in terms of days of labor needed to afford a given tool, but a lot of the subtleties are lost).

Re: Game Changers.....

#16

Re: New CBN wheel offered by Woodturners Wonders

david weaver

Nice. Excellent design idea, too, to make it less expensive.

Ken is a top quality guy.

Re: Game Changers.....

#17

Re: Past game changers..

roger lance

I'm not only impressed with the volume of your response but also the content of your thoughts.....theres hope for you, young man!!

Re: Game Changers.....

#18

Re: Skill

TomD

And it was the institutional memory, in the case of the breaker. When you know nothing, everything is a game changer. I remember how taken I was with the idea that laminations could be stronger than a piece of solid wood. I have 12 gallons of epoxy sitting behind me and magic is going to happen.

Re: Game Changers.....

#19

Re: Past game changers..

TomD

I basically agree with you, though:

Fixed it for you: "* any number of adjustment mechanisms that's supposed to be more precise and better than a wedge (I have tried a lot of them, none are better but lots are quite a bit more expensive.)"

"* super thick irons - same as heavier planes. Feel great, like riding an old cadillac that had power steering so jacked up that you could hardly feel the road through the wheel, and you could turn the wheel with your pinkie while driving over a 4 inch deep pothole. Pain in the rear end to grind - combine high alloy with very thick "two improvements in one", and you have something exceptionally slow to grind. They also remove your senses when it comes to feeling tearout when smoothing."

Don't agree with this, one, though thin blades are fine. Japanese blades are pretty thick, and I don't feel hindered by them. I think I could put a Number 7 jointer into my grinder with a motion like shifting gears in a car, and it would swallow it, so for the grinding thing to be true, it would have to be a slow grinder. I'm biased to the extent that I just bought a 6" wide 1/2"thick piece of O1 for various projects, thoug admitedly I have lived happily without it for 58 years.

"* Primus smoother - I mention it because it literally claims to have solved every stanley plane shortcoming, yet it somehow is a relatively undesirable plane to most people who have tried one."

I don't like them more than others, but I suspect there is a cultural factor there. Klausz only dropped them because they confused the punters, and he seems to be fairly efficient. It would be interesting to know who got to various developments first as far as tech developments were concerned. There are probably more people in Euro using that stuff with real training, and to-do lists than over here. They are certainly lighted and slicker than Bailey planes.

"* Stainless steel infills - the ultimate collector's item - won't rust despite the fact that you don't actually use them. Hope the iron is stainless, too, because it won't be replaceable by the time you find it rusty and the maker's style has changed. Maybe just paint the iron with shellac in advance."

Floods happen. I don't think that stainless is worse as a base than sewer pipe, I like Bronze, though weight is a real factor, though I assume nobody with any of that stuff actually does much. As in 12 hours a day.

"* planes with disposable blades - no comment needed"

Rali plane is perfectly usable, and it has one of the best adjusters which could easily be adapted to a "real" blade, but the market would be punters and they have their ears to the internet, so the exercise is too fickle to be worth trying. Also, breaker wise they are not adjustable, though I can get through a lot of work without that being a problem.

"* planes with super hard irons - great idea if it takes 15 minutes to sharpen. Not so great in practice once you learn to sharpen quickly (George Wilson used to tell me all the time that irons should be right at the edge of being file-able with a good file, which I thought was too soft. He has publicly stated before that irons 62+ hardness in common tool steels are too hard, so I'm not stepping on toes accidentally by stating that.). Just like heavy planes are wood show planes, I've started to refer to those super-hard irons as catalog tools. As in, you buy them when you view them in a catalog because they have a higher number than other tools. It's like getting more french fries in a combo meal - the number is bigger - it must be better. When the maker charges more for the higher number, of course it must also be better."

I think this cuts both ways, yes the number isn't everything, it isn't even linear as far as durability is concerned, but it isn't linear as being bad either. There are a lot of tools out there that have high numbers and are super to use. As far as I can figure out your bio, I think even FWW disproved the linearity of Rockwell hardeness numbers in tool tests before you started in this game. Though they may or not have realized it. But they published chisel tests and such where tools of simplish steel had vastly different performances notwithstanding very close numbers.

I made a bad batch of plane irons at one point. I did the heat treating out of doors in winter, which didn't go well. Anyway, one of the blades made it into a jack plane and seemed fine until I hit a knot, and a small section of the blade actually bent. But it works well enough and so I have kept with it. More extreme, I suppose are things made of O1 like floats that aren't even hardened. And they work to some extent. SO George has a point.

"* planes with or without handles that depart significantly from what was used when people made a living using planes heavily."

Well there are places where people still make a living by hand, and still use planes with no handles. They just don't use Krenov planes. I like Krenov planes but they haven't kept to the front of the bench at my bench. Except, oddly, a scrub plane I use a lot. I just used a specialty Krenov, jointer the other day. The key is that Krenov didn't do heavy prep work with hand tools, though some do with handleless hand tools.

"Krenov said handles are uncomfortable, so lots of people believe him because he said that. Never mind the tens or hundreds of thousands of period woodworkers who didn't find much favor in going without handles."

You will have to share the diaries in which they related the extensive comparative trials they ran. :) They did of course use smoothers and molding planes and all those types.

"There are some improvements, but it seems like a 100 to 1 thing (what's actually an improvement for all). For refreshing hardened steel, CBN is just better. It's faster, no water (I never used water to begin with, but now the iron isn't even too hot to put it in your palm). Certainly, it's not necessary, but it's better and may be cheaper in the long run."

I have been hearing you guys on this, so went to the local store to buy a wheel. I forget what the guy said but he totally put me off it, which is odd since he sells the stuff to woodturners. I assume he is wrong, but it was one of those deals where one wanted to whip out the money and it all went in another direction.

"Belt grinders - not particularly useful for regular woodworking, but in tool and knife making, and rasp making, better than a wheel for a lot of operations. Not many deadly accidents with them, either."

+1, and I use them for general woodworking tool prep. It can work out in a variety of ways. The most extreme is you make the tools, and then while you don't abuse them, you have no qualms about using the grinder. Right on down to it just being the power tool to reshape, grind nicks, sharpen scrapers and such. Certainly using hand tools for production, they are invaluable. Even though I have a decent 2x72, most of my work gets done with the Lee Valley unit. So much so that it is on my agenda to make a better version of that tool. Which is the usual nonsense: it works great, so I need to change something.

"Stanley bailey plane design - an affordable metal plane with interchangeable parts, great adjuster, great cap iron design." Yeah, it is like pneumatic tires on a horse drawn carriage: Just in the nick of too late.

Re: Game Changers.....

#20

Re: Past game changers..

david weaver

I know you're just trying to stir the pot a little.

* re: the primus planes - there's nothing wrong with the original wedge design continental smoothers, the type that klausz uses. There's just no improvement by trying to bling them up with all of the junk that's on a primus plane, and then turn around and put a badly designed chipbreaker on them with a highly alloyed iron. I'm not assailing continental planes. I have three of them, but none with an adjuster. I just thought the ad copy that some sellers of the primus planes use is particularly "shystery". Catches beginners because it's so bold. Like Larry's comments about double iron planes catching shavings and not being able to be full width. Larry's wrong, but he says it in a lot of words and forcefully, and lots of people go for that kind of thing.

* iron hardness - nothing 58 or so hardness would bend hitting a knot. Saw temper is too soft for an iron. George is advocating a very specific range when he suggests dark straw to light brown temper. I agree on the linearity - though I'm not sure how you're referring to it. 56 or so is probably the start of usable, and 65 is probably the high end of it. At 65, even the sharpening stone used matters in terms of preventing chipping. Some HSS tolerates that hardness level well, but then the very edge fails right away on that stuff. I'd make the range linear from 0-9 with 56-65. Durability has to do with shaving thickness - all of the irons last similarly in a heavy shaving (more than 5 thousandths). At 1 thousandth, the contest is won by the hardest iron that doesn't chip. Ron Hock's irons are thrown around as a substantial improvement over stanley stock, but the HCS irons that I had of Hock's were chippy, and several people have privately told me the same thing (nobody wants to say that publicly). George has stated publicly that 62 is too hard for O1, but for every time you say that, there are 10 people who have never actually examined the durability of a hock iron in work context vs. a good condition stanley iron of reasonable vintage.

* don't care about coffin smoothers, moulding planes or japanese planes when talking about krenov. You don't pull a krenov jointer all day or cut mouldings with it. Krenov's removal of the handles in smoothers isn't a big deal - they don't do really heavy work. Taking them off of jack and jointer planes where they serve ergonomic purposes (as well as alignment on a jointer) is sub par, but folks who read more than do will quote krenov and tell you that all handles on planes are uncomfortable. Japanese jointing planes are subpar to western, jacking is fine. There is no superiority of them over western planes in function as is sometimes asserted, and the irons are good high carbon steel, but the stories of their durability are overblown when compared to any carbon steel iron of reasonable quality (for example, they are no better in any way than a ward iron that is reasonably hard). The difference in japan is the desire for or focus on tradition. We don't have it here. 98% of japan is uninterested in that stuff, though, and all you have to do is go to the japan auction site to find that out. Just like kamisori - the market for that stuff is export. The domestic market wants the latest digital rice cooker and digital gadgets.

I'll give you the "pam of the day" award, since Pam used to come along and always try to make the conversation about japanese planes. they're a fine esoteric enthusiasts tool. When considered to be a reasonable design that works, great. When considered to be better than everything else, that's just for the partisans.

* Stanley seems to have done pretty well with their adjuster, despite being like rubber tires on a covered wagon. Their planes were sold in larger numbers than any others, and used hard.

* floats made of O1 should still be hardened (unless they are throw away), at least the tip of the float. You can harden that and temper it saw temper pretty easily.

Re: Game Changers.....

#21

Re: New CBN wheel offered by Woodturners Wonders

William Duffield

Does the steel band keep the nylon wheel from destructing, or is it the flexibility of the nylon? Since their ad copy notes that the wheel works "…with the guards on…" does that imply that they do not recommend running the wheel without the guards? They do not describe how the steel is formed. For example, is it bent and welded, or machined from a solid blank?

Re: Game Changers.....

#22

Re: New CBN wheel offered by Woodturners Wonders

david weaver

I would imagine that the wheel working with the guards on is related to the width of other offerings, like the radius wheel. They are too large to leave the outside guard on a lot of grinders.

Re: Game Changers.....

#23

Primus Eliminatus

david weaver

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?255312-ECE-Primus-Plane-Lateral-Adjustment

Perfect timing. I've copied some of the comments about the primus adjuster below....the plane that, according to advertisement, has improved on all of Stanley's shortcomings.

"My problem is that the blade keeps going askew after just 1 or 2 passes, gouging one corner into the surface I'm working on"

"I love those planes, but what a pain to resharpen. It's like taking a gun apart."

"There is enough vertical give in the assembly to allow the chromed adjusting knob to raise and lower the blade. The clever trick is that this assembly is always in tension and so there can never be any backlash ie. slack. After a number of turns of the chromed adjusting knob, the tension in the piece of steel attached to the blade needs to be adjusted so as to keep the system in equilibrium."

what an improvement. Never heard an experienced user complain about backlash in planes, but it does sell to beginners as an argument

"This seems like a lot of extra fiddling just to be rid of backlash.

How much of a hassle is it to set up after sharpening a blade?"


A lot. When I had a primus plane, I figured I must just not get something, and that there was a quick release latch somewhere or something that would prevent the fiddling. The adjuster assembly was stamped and felt cheap, too. A no-backlash coke can feeling.

"Indeed. As an engineer I have a higher than average tolerance for complex gadgetry, but that design manages to offend even my sensibilities."

"The only issue for me is keeping the spring from rolling off the bench as you unthread the rear knob and remove the bolt. Oh yeah, and there are two washers buried in there that try to jump off my bench into the dust bin as well.

I have to say that despite their set up troubles, I still reach for the Primus jack because it is quite a joy to work with as a scrub or roughing plane."

I'll bet a real joy would be an inexpensive continental smoother with a wedge.

"Update: I ended up selling the Primus and got the simpler wedged one. Much better!"


PHEW!

Sounds like a real improvement over a stanley. :b I was happy to see mine go, but i got it unused for $75 after seeing gobs of people spend $200 for them and find they could only sell them for $75. I still felt like I must not have gotten something, because there are a couple of ardent fans and everyone else probably also figures that they must not understand the tedious system that is supposed to be easier than stanley (but holds you up dealing with springs and washers, etc, and takes longer to sharpen because of it).

When I first got into this hobby, which wasn't that long ago, people were selling them off in droves, and I read the ad copy and put it away mentally so that I could recall it later. I could never understand why LN and LV brought 80-90% of new price, and the primus planes could hardly be sold, and then at that, unused at half their purchase price. I figured that out quickly. Same with expensive japanese chisels and planes. You'd better like them, because if you didn't buy them used, you'll take a bath when you sell them. I played with a lot of different japanese planes and in the end kept one good one and two beaters. The rest of them cost me a lot of money to try, even when I bought them well (used).

Re: Game Changers.....

#24

Re: Primus Eliminatus

steve voigt

Hahahahahahaha…

It blows my mind that some folks are unwilling to learn to hammer adjust a wedged plane, but they're willing to deal with this level of Rube Goldberg silliness. Go figure.

Re: Game Changers.....

#25

Re: Primus Eliminatus

david weaver

The two nice old ones that I have are beech only (no need for a lignum sole or anything like that), wood wedge and a decent vintage laminated iron. They are lovely. I think the two of them together were $40.

The muji plane that I got was $60. It served its purpose, I'm not sorry I bought it, but it would be better with a beech wedge. That'll be easy enough to take care of at some point.

My recent experience with true norris adjusters makes me wonder why anyone bothers trying to make a more complicated mouse trap than stanley made. I sort of understand it on a norris - there's nowhere for a bailey adjuster to go.