Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

Posts

Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#1

Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

roger lance

I've got two LV back saws.....the 14 t.p.i. dovetail rip saw and the 12 t.p.i. carcass rip saw.....that I'm thinking of increasing the teeth rake angle of the first inch or two to make the saws easier to start.

The LV dovetail saw comes with a 14 degree rake and the carcass saw has a 10 degree rake.

I'm considering modifying the first inch of the carcass saw to 20 degrees and the second inch to 15 degrees.

The dovetail saw could have the first 1 1/2" modified to 20 degrees of rake.

The question is....is this a reasonable approach ?......worthwhile?.....etc....etc. Any suggestions or experiences much appreciated.

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#2

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've got two LV back saws.....the 14 t.p.i. dovetail rip saw and the 12 t.p.i. carcass rip saw.....that I'm thinking of increasing the teeth rake angle of the first inch or two to make the saws easier to start.

The LV dovetail saw comes with a 14 degree rake and the carcass saw has a 10 degree rake.

I'm considering modifying the first inch of the carcass saw to 20 degrees and the second inch to 15 degrees.

The dovetail saw could have the first 1 1/2" modified to 20 degrees of rake.

The question is....is this a reasonable approach ?......worthwhile?.....etc....etc. Any suggestions or experiences much appreciated.

Hi Roger

My understanding of what you are trying to achieve with the dovetail saw is that you want to saw thinner boards or start the saw more easily. Going from 14 tpi to 20 tpi over the full length will do that. Veritas already sell a saw like that, and just purchasing one is a consideration since you are assured of well-shaped teeth. Changing all the teeth on a saw is no small deal. The down side of more teeth is a saw that cuts more slowly. Of course, only a few teeth should not slow it down that much. However it does have other effects.

Even changing the first 1 1/2" of the saw will require refiling the full length as the height of the teeth will be changed by refiling smaller. This type of configuration is indicated for a smoother start. There are a couple of saws on the market that are designed this way (e.g Rob Cosman and LN). I was sent a variable tooth dovetail saw for opinion (not LN, RC or LV). The saw must be started at the front of the toe, otherwise the coarser teeth will cause the saw to bind. I really disliked the saw. Conventional saw plates are more predictable.

The LV saws have 14 degrees of rake, and this is a very relaxed set up already. By comparison, my LN came with zero rake. It took me some time (years) to get used to it - to have the light touch needed - but now it cuts wonderfully (well, it is not original any longer as I have touched up the teeth over the years. Still, it remains zero rake). If you are having difficulty starting the LV saw, then you want to look at your technique, not the saw. The LV saws are sweet users. Absolutely the best saws for those wanting smoooooth.

The same comments apply to the carcase saw. The 10 degrees of rake there should create a slightly more powerful saw, but this is a relative statement - 10 degrees is still quite relaxed. At 14 tpi the saw still has a lot of teeth and this configuration suggests a saw for crosscuts, wider dovetails, or small tenons. The saws I use in these applications have coarser teeth and require a gentle hand when starting a cut. After this, however, they cut quickly. I fear that your modification is going to affect this aspect, speed. Again, look to your technique.

One strategy to start the cut with less binding, is to angle the workpiece away from you (as with a tenon), or angle the saw more vertically (if sawing dovetails in a vise).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#3

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

david weaver

I never measured rake when I relaxed front teeth, but the results are good (as in, I don't know if 20 is enough, but if it's not, you can easily do 25 later).

I'm sure you know that you don't have to do much to those front teeth to relax them, just a kiss on the tips at the angle that you want and the saw will not bite at the front (it does it's work in the middle/middle-back, anyway).

The light kiss on the teeth also preserves the ability to refresh them back to standard rake later if you'd like without doing much reprofiling.

I agree with derek's sentiment about a 20 tpi saw, except I don't like to use a 20 tpi saw unless I have to. I'd rather just relax the rake entirely on a coarser saw that doesn't take special files (if grabbiness and breakout/filth at the back side of a cut is a problem).

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#4

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This seems like one of those times when someone is trying to solve a problem that will disappear with any experience. I wonder if the time would be better spent practising.

I have used zero rake for these saws for about forty years. I usually start the first sawing stroke in the forward direction, an inch or a little more from the tip. So changing the first 1 1/2 inches would have little effect for me. I wonder if your idea would encourage one to start the cut at the very tip, which seems awkward to me, and might delay your learning to do this easily. You really don't want to be tentative when you start the cut.

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#5

Re: Warren's post reminds me..

david weaver

I'd relax more than the first two inches on the carcass saw - more like 3.

But still only a kiss at the front edge of each tooth in case you decide you don't need it later.

I've got a couple of hard starting saws, and they have zero rake, but they're hard starting due to their weight (one of them is a 16" tenon saw from when that was the craze - it's from a kit and tall and heavy - I find very little use for it other than cutting out plane wedges - big work can be done with a carpenter saw, so it's sort of in a limbo area). If I relaxed the rake on the whole saw to make it less grabby, then it wouldn't be fast. I should've just made a smaller and lighter saw instead. I'll bet a lot of people from that Chris Schwartz induced craze have found the same thing. The tall thin saws are flimsy and the heavier ones are bulky.

I've relaxed the rake on other saws in the past (and it got me over the hump), but I can't remember which ones because the saws that I have now don't have relaxed rake.

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#6

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

roger lance

Hi Derek.....thanks for replying......I don't want to change the entire teeth pattern of either saw.....just increase the rake on the first couple of inches of teeth at the toe to help the saw start easier.

I wanted to know if this was advisable.....if it was common to do.....was it productive.....was it effective?

The LV saws are better saws than I am a craftsman.....nicely made.....I'm happy to own them.....and I'm not suggesting that they need this alteration.....just wondering if this modification can be made without harming the saw and make the saw start easier and be more enjoyable to use as a result.

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#7

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

roger lance

David.....that's a great point that the teeth don't have to be altered completely to get a result.

A minor touch up of rake should give some indication if this will increase the ease of starting.

Sort of a micro bevel....sorta.

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#8

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

roger lance

Warren....thanks for replying. I am in agreement with you (and Derek) that I should also be looking at my own skill level/technique.

My objective in coming over to the hand tool discussions from the power tool side was to build my understanding of hand tools, build a good/limited kit, and begin to effectively use these tools in my work. In other words, I want to truly become a blended woodworker.....with competence, skill, and understanding of both hand and power tools.

I'm happy to report that I now find myself reaching for a hand tool without thinking about the significance of this choice....and making this selection without hesitation.....as opposed to heading to the table saw or some other power tool.

Your insight is appreciated.

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#9

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Roger and all,

I apologize if this is all old hat to you, but thought I would mention it for what it's worth.......Years ago, I read a suggestion from Ian Kirby on dovetail sawing, that I found to be very good. It may help with the LV saw, which you are finding a little aggressive on the start.

Kirby's suggestion was, when sawing the tails, to hold the saw dead vertical on the very first sawcut. His point was that your only objective on that first saw cut is to get a starting kerf that is dead square to the edge. Make the first cut straight down and don't angle the saw at all. There's no harm because you're sawing into the waste. I always gang two or four drawer sides. Anyway, after that first shallow vertical cut, with a square kerf established, angle the saw and complete that wall of the tail.

One result of making that first vertical sawcut is that, when you do angle the saw, you already have a little shoulder to register the saw against. Between that little shoulder and your thumbnail, you may feel less need to be tentative with that LV saw as you begin your angled cuts. Just take a little weight off the blade and make your second cut a full-length money cut. And then it all follows naturally.

FWIW

Wiley

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#10

agree and....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The prickly teeth on a new carcass saw are had to start, at least at first. However, you will soon learn to start the saw. I was in the same boat but now I don't have any need to change teeth. Leaning to lift the saw a bit on the starting cut will help as well as the confidence to put some gusto into the starting stroke. The other thing that will help is using the saw. Using the saw will dull it some and the less than prickly teeth will enable starting the cut easier.

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#11

Ditto.

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi Wiley, and all,

I also learned a lot from Kirby's book, and always start the tail cut with the saw absolutely vertical. It gives a straight cut all the way across the board, as opposed to starting with the saw at an angle and then trying to make a straight cut all the way across. This is especially important when cutting 7/8 pine for blanket chests.

I also agree with Bill about using some gusto when making that first pass. It takes some getting used to, but a good quick swipe gets me going every time.

Just my 2 cents.

Ron

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#12

Big tenon saws

Kees

Big tenon saws might have been a fad, but I really like my 18" one. It is pretty light though which makes a lot of difference. The plate is also not very deep.

I also made a 16" saw with full 1" wide brass back made from folded 1/8" brass plate. The sawplate is also >4" deep. It's a monster and I don't like it.

Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....

#13

Re: Big tenon saws

david weaver

I think the saw that I don't favor too much is a lot like the second one that you mentioned. 1/8th brass and an inch deep. I'd have to measure it to be sure, but it's definitely heavy and hard starting because of it.