Re: Teeth rake angles on rip saws.....
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I've got two LV back saws.....the 14 t.p.i. dovetail rip saw and the 12 t.p.i. carcass rip saw.....that I'm thinking of increasing the teeth rake angle of the first inch or two to make the saws easier to start.
The LV dovetail saw comes with a 14 degree rake and the carcass saw has a 10 degree rake.
I'm considering modifying the first inch of the carcass saw to 20 degrees and the second inch to 15 degrees.
The dovetail saw could have the first 1 1/2" modified to 20 degrees of rake.
The question is....is this a reasonable approach ?......worthwhile?.....etc....etc. Any suggestions or experiences much appreciated.
Hi Roger
My understanding of what you are trying to achieve with the dovetail saw is that you want to saw thinner boards or start the saw more easily. Going from 14 tpi to 20 tpi over the full length will do that. Veritas already sell a saw like that, and just purchasing one is a consideration since you are assured of well-shaped teeth. Changing all the teeth on a saw is no small deal. The down side of more teeth is a saw that cuts more slowly. Of course, only a few teeth should not slow it down that much. However it does have other effects.
Even changing the first 1 1/2" of the saw will require refiling the full length as the height of the teeth will be changed by refiling smaller. This type of configuration is indicated for a smoother start. There are a couple of saws on the market that are designed this way (e.g Rob Cosman and LN). I was sent a variable tooth dovetail saw for opinion (not LN, RC or LV). The saw must be started at the front of the toe, otherwise the coarser teeth will cause the saw to bind. I really disliked the saw. Conventional saw plates are more predictable.
The LV saws have 14 degrees of rake, and this is a very relaxed set up already. By comparison, my LN came with zero rake. It took me some time (years) to get used to it - to have the light touch needed - but now it cuts wonderfully (well, it is not original any longer as I have touched up the teeth over the years. Still, it remains zero rake). If you are having difficulty starting the LV saw, then you want to look at your technique, not the saw. The LV saws are sweet users. Absolutely the best saws for those wanting smoooooth.
The same comments apply to the carcase saw. The 10 degrees of rake there should create a slightly more powerful saw, but this is a relative statement - 10 degrees is still quite relaxed. At 14 tpi the saw still has a lot of teeth and this configuration suggests a saw for crosscuts, wider dovetails, or small tenons. The saws I use in these applications have coarser teeth and require a gentle hand when starting a cut. After this, however, they cut quickly. I fear that your modification is going to affect this aspect, speed. Again, look to your technique.
One strategy to start the cut with less binding, is to angle the workpiece away from you (as with a tenon), or angle the saw more vertically (if sawing dovetails in a vise).
Regards from Perth
Derek