Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Files for sharpening saws

Posts

Files for sharpening saws

#1

Files for sharpening saws

Joe shelton

First, I checked briefly to see that this doesn't duplicate the other discussion of files. If I missed saw sharpening there, I'm sorry.

Are the Nicholson files I can buy locally good for sharpening saw? I think I've read criticisms of them, but I don't recall specifics.

If Nicholsons aren't sufficient, what is the right answer?

So far, I've had mildly successful results with two old saws, and I know that the real limit at the moment is the file holder, not the file.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#2

Re: Files for sharpening saws

david weaver

* yes, the nicholsons are fine. they aren't quite as good as they used to be, but they will sharpen all but the hardest of saws (and if you have a saw that's too hard for them, you don't want that saw - it'll cause you problems at some point).

* presumably, you get 6" xx slim and 6" slim files locally (since HD carries nicholson files). With those two, you can reasonably file standard rip cut and crosscut carpenter saws, as well as large back saws with coarser teeth

What are you looking to sharpen?

* there are other files that are somewhat better (bahco comes to mind), but they are either higher priced, or they have to be bought in packs of 10. And, they don't have small xx slim files for sale that I've found, despite having a part number for them.

* one other thing, whatever you settle on, different brands have different corners, and it's easier to use the same brand/size file on a saw every time you sharpen then just randomly change.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#3

Re: Files for sharpening saws

Joe shelton

Thanks, David. For the moment, I'm learning on 3 old Disston saws, all from eBay when I was still captive.

Ultimately I'll want to sharpen some nice old back saws, too.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#4

Re: Files for sharpening saws

david weaver

You'll need smaller files for back saws, but you can get them when you need them. Once you have a back saw set up, you don't have to sharpen it often like you would a carpenter's saw that gets used for a lot of rough work (if you're using saws instead of power tools).

You can buy enough files to refurbish the back saws and then get a couple of extra, and it will probably last you decades in terms of resharpening. I've got more backsaws than I should have, but perhaps 3 that I use regularly, and I think i've resharpened one of them.

Of course, if you somehow run across a dozen vintage nicholson files somewhere for cheap, then you can pick those up. Files have to be stored somewhere dry, though, they are about the fastest rusting thing you will find if they are exposed to any moisture at all.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#5

Re: Files for sharpening saws

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I limit my sharpening to rip cut teeth and the files from Lee Valley work fine

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#6

The thing that dulls them fast,

Keith Newton

Is dragging it backwards with pressure. You probably already know this, but someone else reading this might not. It is best to lift it out of the gullet on the back stroke.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#7

Re: The thing that dulls them fast,

William Duffield

Something that dulls them even faster is throwing them together in a drawer or tool box and letting them bounce against each other.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#8

Re: The thing that dulls them fast,

david weaver

Ditto that, rust is bad, especially if they're touching each other.

George Wilson gave me a nice set of needle files (or maybe it's more correct to say I gave him a fraction of what they're worth for his trouble), and he accumulated some gigantic number of sets from a closing dealer or something. Swiss, and made in the early 1900s, they are more finely made than any files I've ever seen.

All wrapped, and every set, he said, has rust on them somewhere, so you have to go through to find one that's relatively good. A shame for such fine files.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#9

Funny...

John in NM

The chainsaw guys know that the thing that dulls them fast is using them to sharpen chain! -- But then sharpening chains is much more frequent and heavy use than a handsaw file probably ever sees.

So yes, store properly, and don't drag 'em backwards, but remember that forwards motion with a file actually is harder on it's cutting edge than backwards motion. We just overlook that because forwards motion is doing the work we want done - sharpening. Files are to be considered consumable tools when used on steel.

Used on wood they last far longer, but still eventually get dull.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#10

I was thinking the same thing..

david weaver

I think (i don't pay attention) I leave my files in the groove when sharpening with no pressure. I think I also put a video on youtube once and had the no drag police see that and hear the file touch metal on the way back and they turned on their "correct" sirens and busted me.

I also know that keeping them in the groove with little pressure is much faster and easier than lifting them up and out, and as you say...

.... wait for it....

....using the files to actually sharpen saws or cut teeth is what I've noticed to dull files the fastest, whether they contact on the reverse stroke or not.

I would imagine with the light drag, I can touch up a saw a couple of times with the same corner (or at least I have), which extrapolates to sharpening a saw for about a dollar each time (though the the only saws that I touch up often are large rip saws).

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#11

Re: I was thinking the same thing..

Keith Newton

Well, I have to admit I've been caught by friends seeing me leave it in the groove on the back stroke. However it was on those tiny teeth of a multi-tool blade that is hard to see even with my magnifying visor on.

By the way, I know this is the hand-tool side, but some of you are probably corrupted by the demon electricity like myself, but if you have a multitool and somewhat indignant at the cost of those little blades, get yourself a small slim taper file and give it a try. I don't even bother to shoot for ATB, but just go straight across, and still get a good second life.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#12

Re: I was thinking the same thing..

David Weaver

I didn't even know they offered separate/replacement blades for multitools. I'd sharpen them just like you're advocating. Separate question -are any of the high dollar multitools suitably hard? The couple that I've had were a bit soft.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#14

Re: Like this?

David weaver

Silly me, I thought the reference to multitool meant something like a leatherman.

Re: Files for sharpening saws

#15

Re: I was thinking the same thing..

William Duffield

Ate these the same "friends" who tell you you must set your hand plane down on its side on your pristine surface hardwood bench? :D