Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

Posts

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#26

Re: Longevity of the edge

Brian Holcombe

There is a scale to this effect of weakening the edge. At one end are diamond abrasives and the other end are oil stones and natural water stones.

Mail your blade to me and I'll hone it, that way you can experience first hand the difference between the two.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#27

Not quite...

John in NM

I was critiquing Wiley's speculation that the results could be explained by different wear mechanisms having drastically different properties for this steel vs. more conventional steels.

The one PMV-11 blade I have is a very good blade, though I've not yet used it enough to have a solid feel for how it compares to O1 or A2 - out of the box it was sharper than other new blades I've had. I've not read through LV's material on the stuff, so I make no judgement on their claims. Up to a point, I'm quite willing to trust their word - that these tools will be products worth their cost - because I have always found LV to be very good in that regard.

I find it quite plausible that the alloy has wear resistance on a par with other alloys but its grain structure helps a blade take a very fine edge, providing the appearance of greater wear resistance. That alone justifies some additional cost in my view of it.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#28

Re: Longevity of the edge

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Brian

Thanks for your offer :)

I am not disputing that a Nakayama Asagi is a synergistic match for your white steel or O1 blades. In your shop this is clearly a match made in heaven. However, in my world, it is most unlikely that O1 is going to experience a magic turn-around and become abrasion-resistant simply because the edge gets a tad "sharper" (ignoring the fact that I do manage to achieve pretty sharp edges all on my own). I do understand that you are referring to a "smoother" edge as well. In my experience, the green compound is very capable in this regard. There is a limit one can go to before the solution becomes unrealistic.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#29

follow up results

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Wiley said, sagely....."I was moved to seek an explanation for the wear results, because I set great store by Lee Valley's integrity and competence. One does wonder whether similar results would have been obtained between PMVII and M4, had the wear test been performed on oak, cherry, or maple."

Well, in light of the challenges to the LV claims, the fact we have not seen corroborating results in a more relevant test speaks volumes, I believe. You can have integrity and still reach a flawed conclusion with a poorly designed experiment.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#30

Different planing worlds

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I appreciate the fact that you and Derek have provided enough background on your work that your planing and sharpening experience can be put in perspective for someone planing in a different world.

Surface finish off a plane is irrelevant to me so long as I don't get tear-out. It has been proven that with a finish that builds, and those are the only finishes I use, anything refined beyond 180 to 220 grit is indistinguishable so certainly the nuances of planed finishes are too.

My planing objective is to remove wood, reliably and without tear-out. Surface finish is irrelevant. My planing could be leveling a M&T joint, leveling an edge joint, fitting a tenon, shooting a board end, etc. I find it unlikely that the edge details you speak of persist for much of the life of an edge as I use it. I sharpen when the blade quits cutting. I can see the wear bevel at this time. Theory, testing and experience show that an abrasion resistant steel lengthens the time between sharpening a blade as I employ it.

Kato, who was developing planing machine technology to plane Japanese house beams, was able to plane hundreds of linear meters more wood, to whatever house bean specifications are, with abrasion resistant blade steel, compared to the steel used in the Japanese hand planes. As I understand it, you will not find hand plane steel in these machines.

For the bystanders, different objectives can lead to different conclusions. Abrasion resistant steel may or may not rightly find a place in your wood working/lifestyle.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#31

Re: Different planing worlds

david weaver

In terms of surface finish, was there more than one brief fine woodworking article that addressed the topic?

I've tried a couple of times to see a difference in finish with plane vs. sanding, but only two, and I didn't pick very interesting wood, so there wasn't anything to so.

I always finish either with shellac and wax or shellac and then WB lacquer, but not tons of that lacquer - just enough that it's uniform.

There is only one thing I've done a lot of where I can see a difference - making planes. I believe Larry sands his planes. When Brian got one of my planes, he put a picture of it up and Warren could tell that I planed the surfaces on it. I didn't tell Warren that, either.

All of that said, when I plane finish or plane and then very lightly scrape, the wood takes in much less shellac and is faster to finish. I like that. By that, I mean when I shellac wood, I do it until the shellac finish is uniform and that's it. Then wax or lacquer. It takes about 1/2 to 2/3rds the coats to get the shellac to that point on the planed pieces, and the first coat is much less heavy (on a sanded board, it just sucks in the first padded coat). The feel of applying the padded shellac is far different, too - it's much more pleasing to put it on the planed or carefully scraped surface.

Carefully scraped means that i scrape as most people would, but then come back with a light scraper which is probably cutting a very thin shaving but burnishing at the same time, too.

At any rate, I believe the author who wrote the FWW study observed what he wrote. I don't know if it's universally true in all cases, though.

(my plane doesn't necessarily disprove your theory, I put oil and wax on planes and expect that if I am giving one to someone, they will continue to do the same. I hate the look of a film finish on planes, even if it's a satin looking finish).

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#32

Re: Please explain reply

david weaver

Didn't Lee Valley do the tests with MDF? In my experience with HSS irons (not talking about V11), they tend to fare better against plainer steel irons when the material being planed is more abrasive - all other things being kept equal, and equal in this case often involves inexperienced planers taking lots of thin shavings - that kind of thing has clearance ending more quickly than it would end in heavier planing.

I see muji HSS irons lasting several times longer than carbon steel and cutting well much much deeper into the cycle when planing cocobolo with visible silica in it. On cherry, I don't see nearly as much difference.

I made a plane last year with the LV custom plane design (as in, I did the sizing of the block with LV's plane), and I found that I could get more work done planing with my try plane (which has an old butcher iron in it) because I could take a bigger shaving with it. That emphasizes that the proper plane can be more important than the iron itself. The butcher iron I have is good, and harder than butcher irons often are - sometimes they're a bit soft - but it would be no match for the V11 in a smooth planing contest where the shavings could be no thicker than 2 thousandths or some other arbitrary number. The try plane is better than a mid sized metal plane for that kind of work, though.

Most have vouched that the LV chisels are in the ballpark with japanese chisels of decent quality - I'll defer to them because I've never tried them. That's about as good as a chisel will be. The planing, I think depends more on case by case.

I gave LV my opinions on the plane and the cap iron in return for my plane, so take it with a grain of salt if you'd like. I tend to believe that LV is about as objective and honest as you will find, and the same is true of LN. I have seen Robin extend help to people where it really wasn't at all in the interest of the company in terms of allocating resources - especially when it's budding toolmakers. That is in great contrast to Japan Woodworker who would not respond to questions that I had that didn't involve buying their stuff.

At any rate, I think if the data doesn't translate to real life with the planing, it's not likely because the data is false, it's likely because something is different between the tested scenario and real life - i'm speculating in this case that it's because something really abrasive was planed. LV is more principled than to just create false data sets or make false claims. They know the internet community would pickle them, too. It seems that there are at least two people who will pickle them, regardless.

As to M4 and chisels, I have an M4 chisel, I think I still do even though I've meant to sell it several times. It's not the only HSS chisels I have, but the only M4. I keep one high speed steel chisel around in case I make another infill plane and want to flush the infill and the steel. But I haven't found the virtue of M4 in wood. You sharpen it with diamonds, which I don't like to keep out, and it just doesn't seem more favorable than carbon steel when the whole cycle of work and sharpening is accounted for. However, in flushing wood down to metal surfaces like you do making an infill plane, it will last 20 times as long and take no serious damage. If I had to chisel through wood that had staples in it, I'm sure it would do it with only small marks whereas carbon steel would take catastrophic damage.

If I was working australian woods where they were just up to the point where derek's are (derek has nice machine tools and I don't), I probably would have the same opinion.

I didn't ,by the way, have any trouble sharpening the V11 fine on a washita. It has to have less of a bevel worn on the grind, and the wire edge needs to be worked thin with more care, but it still sharpened fine, and so does cryogenic A2. The myth that these things can't be sharpened on oilstones is due to lack of creativity. I wouldn't want to grind it by hand on oilstones, though, it would end up burnishing the surface of the stone.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#33

Re: Longevity of the edge

david weaver

I agree with the edge quality. The small failures occur more quickly off of synthetic stones, even when the edge is driven to a high level of sharpness.

The same is true of razors, which is sort of apples to oranges, but a shave off of a sigma power 13k is very uncomfortable (even after linen and leather). A shave off of an oilstone honed edge is wonderful after linen and leather.

There are some tools that won't tolerate synthetic stones, and some razors, too.

One of the parers I got from wiley is hardly cut by natural stones, but at the same time, if you try to do some rough work with a diamond hone or a crystolon stone, the edge will fail. It is a chisel that I don't use much, I'll admit - if it chips, it'll be a serious time penalty.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#34

Planing MDF

david weaver

Early on, when I didn't know what I was supposed to do or not do, I made a router table. The only plane I had that was reasonably able to work was a Lie Nielsen 6.

The surface of the router table was MDF, and rather than try to be perfect in manufacturing the base, and attaching the top, I figured I'd recess the screws holding it down and then just plane it flat. It worked fine.

After the MDF absorbed moisture in the first year, I got to plane it again.

The first time, I planed it with the LN plane and it didn't last long. I resharpened twice, if I recall (I have no idea why I remember such dumb things).

The second time I planed it, I had gotten Muji HSS planes. I'm sure I dulled the iron some, but I didn't have to resharpen anything.

I don't see the same difference when planing "normal" wood. The gap between the two is much less.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#35

Re: Longevity of the edge

John in NM

You said:

"The advantage I find with PM-V11 is that it is about the same to hone as O1 and has the edge longevity of A2."

I find it very easy to believe this and very easy to relate it to the empirical results related by Veritas. As I said in my other replies, it also wouldn't surprise me if the grain size and particle metallurgy had a significant contribution as well.

What I do doubt, and always have with my default skepticism, is that they could have created something that wears like an M series steel and sharpens like O1.

Now what would be really interesting to me would be to compare some of the PM super alloys to an O1 made by a PM process if such a thing exists. That would control one variable that I've yet to see anyone pay much attention to (probably because these alloys are not designed for the use we put them to, so the metallurgists aren't as interested in the questions we want answered - Kato being the exception).

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#36

Re: Please explain reply

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

Thanks for such a comprehensive reply. Your observations tally very well with mine.

Most have vouched that the LV chisels are in the ballpark with japanese chisels of decent quality - I'll defer to them because I've never tried them. That's about as good as a chisel will be. The planing, I think depends more on case by case.

One of the points I made earlier was that the PM-V11 steel has excellent impact resistance in my experience. I ran tests comparing a number of steels in chisels used for chopping (as expected in morticing or dovetailing), and the PM-V11 ran a close second to the white steel of Koyamaichi. Both these steels were simply lights years ahead of A2 and O1.

Chisel test: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/FourChiselSteelsCompared.html

I didn't ,by the way, have any trouble sharpening the V11 fine on a washita. It has to have less of a bevel worn on the grind, and the wire edge needs to be worked thin with more care, but it still sharpened fine, and so does cryogenic A2. The myth that these things can't be sharpened on oilstones is due to lack of creativity. I wouldn't want to grind it by hand on oilstones, though, it would end up burnishing the surface of the stone.

This is the point I have made many times - that steels with reputations for high abrasion resistance can be sharpened very easily given the appropriate technique. It is possible to hone a 3/4" M4 chisel blade with 2 strokes on a 1000 Shapton Pro, 2 strokes on a Sigma 6000, 2 strokes on a Sigma 13000, and a couple of strokes on green compound on hardwood. that is all up about 30 seconds. Of course, the preparation is a hollow grind on a CBN wheel as close to the edge as one can get. And that is just one way to efficiently hone abrasion resistance steel. You asked, Bill.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#37

Re: Larry Williams

steve voigt

This is not a reply to David's post but instead it is a generalized post since I learned much of this from David in our correspondance along with my own trial and of course reading and learning from experienced woodworkers.

I always find myself resharpening the few alloyed blades that I have just as soon as I would any high carbon blades.

I'm typically resharpening most finish planes within an hour or two of starting my work since after all it is a fine finish that I'm seeking. This is true of both Togo-Kou, O1, white 1, etc all the same. Sometimes I will finish plane a panel and before the final strokes I will resharpen to make the final few passes.

The extreme sharpness that makes for a brightly finished panel fades quickly and so it is best to simply resharpen right before the last passes.

One way to have your blades last longer is to take a heavier cut, as David mentions. In scenarios where longevity matters I am taking heavy cuts to get the work done in a reasonably time frame. My frames, for instance, I prep the stick by hand and go from sawn finish to defect free in three plane strokes. When you have hundreds of feet to plane by hand there is little time for romance. In that instance I may get 1/2 day out of my plane. Carbon steel is key becuase it wears without creating lines in the finished product.

There are situations where I want a very fine cut, and I mean see-through shavings. The plane typically needs to be sharpened right before hand.

So my point is, if anything, forget about the steel composition and start sharpening far more often. I can set my planes in seconds and resharpen western or Japanese blades in minutes and so it does not interrupt my process.

If your HC steel blades are wearing too quickly then you should use a lighter abrasive like fine oil stones or fine natural water stones. I've convinced myself through much trying and comparison that synthetics and diamonds are too harsh for finishing HC steel blades and they contribute to accelerated wear which results in users feeling that their blades are inadequate for normal use.

I quoted Brian's post in full because it's one of the best I've ever read on the subject. Anyone who's not getting satisfactory results should just copy everything Brian is doing here. The rest, all the wailing and teeth gnashing about supersteels, is just a waste of time. Possibly there is an exemption for shooting planes and for people who work primarily in nasty tropical, high-silica woods, but that's it.

Oh, and when I clicked on this forum today ans saw that there were 34 new messages, I knew right away it must be a sharpening topic. LOL.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#39

Re: Different planing worlds

Brian Holcombe

I've deleted my reply to replace it (too late to edit). Since I fear we're going well off topic of what the intention of my commentary was.

My comment is not "HC steel and Light abrasives are the best thing in the world", I do in fact, feel that way whole heartedly and especially for American hardwoods but that is not the intention of my statement.

My intention is that you should be sharpening much more often, alloy or no alloy. There is no other way to get the best use out of your plane. Chugging along with a dull blade is an awful experience.

The routine needs to be quick and painless and get you back to sharp fast. If it takes me more than 2-3 minutes to get a blade back into a western plane, then it's a long time. And that includes working the wear off of the edge, which I do for every sharpening.

I knock the plane apart, work the bevel on a 1k stone to get rid of the wear. Work the flat on the Nakayama asagi. Grind the bevel to a very thin landing, then finish with a 12k stone followed by the Nakayama asagi on bevel and back. Finally I touch it with a plain strop then back into the plane. 2-3 minutes, max, everything is set and ready to roll.

The Japanese planes are longer since I like to apply a nice finish to the bevel.

Planing machines are not a good comparison and experienced carpenters who use those machines are quite aware that they are not producing a finished surface for key areas. Anything that really needs to shine will be worked by hand plane and so they're not a direct replacement for hand planing.

Most of those shops are going: Jointer, Planer, Super Surfacer, Hand plane. This is according to those I know who use them, not speculation. They do use them for a finished surface in certain situations where a very high quality surface finish is not a requirement.

They're still a poor comparison to hand planes because they provide mechanical pressure to force the material past the blade and so they can obviously work with a blade long considered too dull for a hand plane. It is for that reason that most people are not using replaceable blade hand planes (that do exist) with exception to scenarios similar to what David had mentioned.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#40

Re: Larry Williams *LINK*

Kees

This is one of the reasons why I lost interest in testing various kinds of steel. I am personally very happy with my vintage tools. The edge lasts long enough for me and sharpening from time to time is no bother.

The other reasons are that the subject is highly complex, not easy to conclude anything conclusive! And it is a huge amount of work.

I posted over on sawmill creek in this thread about my findings, back in 2015 or so. Nothing really conclusive, but to summarise:

- PMV-11 grinds about twice as slow as O1 and A2 is somewhere in between.

- PMV-11 looses its initial sharpness just as quickly as O1 but then holds on to that medicocre edge a lot longer.

- I couldn't find a reason to think that corrosive wear plays a role in planing wood. The wear rate of PMV-11 and O1 was similar for beech and oak.

For me personally, those modern steels are not very enticing. But I could see how I would like a PMV-11 blade in a shooting board plane. That is the one area where I think my edge looses its sharpness a bit too quickly. If I were Derek my view could be copletely different, I don't know.


http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?250260-Some-CTS-XHP-tools-steel-observations

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#41

Re: Please explain reply

david weaver

Sharpening is one of the most annoying things to talk about, but we do it all the time, anyway.

It's annoying to me because there is always praise by someone new for some protracted method that guarantees success, but then it pigeonholes the user into using a specific set of stones with a specific guide.

I know not everyone agrees, but I think that stuff is like training wheels. Most people are able to ride a bike with some experience, but few are able to do it their first time. If we kept training wheels on a bike through the point where we transitioned to a clipped in road bike, we'd find that they are pretty annoying, but we don't because we have seen other people make the transition away from training wheels.

We understand geometry and for the part of the iron that will ever be in the cut, polish. The polish part is tiny.

When you try to get to that point, then it usually results in a revolt from the few people who have really tried to get away from guides.

I can also sharpen the M4 chisel with oilstones. I can't grind it with them, but I don't need to. The desire is for "really fast cutting" stones, but once we minimize what we're doing to the edge, those can be a detriment, because they remove more than we want to remove sometimes.

If they are used sparingly on the last bevel as you've described, then they work fine. The videos on the internet where people are using really fast cutting stones and just honing and honing and honing with them, I just wonder if they've ever thought maybe they could get by with a little less.

(not that it's related, but this is a popular thing with razor sharpening, too...just hone and hone and hone on a really fine stone. It turns out on some stones, like on shaptons 15/16k stones, the edge of a razor will eventually fail from all of this honing. I have *no idea* why that occurs, but it's been documented several places. The tool bevels are blunt enough that such a thing shouldn't occur, but sometimes I have no clue what people are chasing).

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#42

O1 smooth, PM-V11 rough

Tony

In the back of my mind I've though I might get an O1 for smoothing and a more cambered PM-V11 blade for rougher planing.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#43

Re: O1 smooth, PM-V11 rough

david weaver

Rough vs. Smooth planing: I have had two V11 irons, one of them now gone with the BU plane that it was in. I didn't notice them to wear as unevenly as kees mentions, but we may all perceive things differently.

I think that it makes more sense to put the high wear iron in a smoother if you want to have one of both. Rough planing is not as sensitive to clearance running out, so it's nice to have an iron that sharpens easily vs. one that lasts forever.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#44

Re: Longevity of the edge

Warren in Lancaster, PA

As I wrote on this forum in 2010, the idea that one would mangle the edge with a harsh abrasive and get good results is ridiculous. Brash stones not only leave a fractured surface but do damage beyond the depth they actually cut.

I am getting very good longevity with early 19th century chisels in chopping not only our more difficult timbers but jarrah as well. A smooth uniform texture in the steel and in the edge makes for the most durable chisel. In fact I would say that a smooth edge is more helpful for those timbers that are not uniform texture, because when a harder spot in the wood hits an irregularity in the iron, damage occurs.

There is a reason we have used fine oil stones for centuries.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#45

re Warrens comments.

Stewie Simpson

Warren; you might enjoy reading this post back in 2012.

Posted by Derek cohen

Hi Jim

It is interesting that the use of a chip breaker, as discussed here, has been recorded for 250 years. It is not new. Nevertheless, the prevailing view in recent decades has been that the chip breaker served only to stiffen thin irons. Blame it on Stanley? No, I think not. There are many cabinetmakers who were taught correctly. But carpenters probably were not. And the literature in recent times generally neglected, or ignored, this procedure.

I was looking through old FWW mags. There is an article in the October 2000 edition. I shall not say who wrote it, but it is a frequent contributor, who has a very good reputation, The article is "Planing Difficult Grain". The author goes to pains to describe the tuning required: flat sole, sharp cambered blade, small mouth, etc. But of the chip breaker he says: "The chip breaker stiffens the blade, reducing vibration and chatter. For the chipbreaker to function, shavings coming off the board must travel smoothly along the back of the blade, over the chipbreaker, and up through the throat .... Or if the chipbreaker's edge is blunted, the shaving won't travel up through the throat... The first step is to feather the leading edge with a flat file ... once the chipbreaker is in good shape, set it 1/16" from the edge of the blade". (1/16" is approximately 1.6mm, which takes it completely out of the picture).

None of this changes the need, especially in Oz, for high cutting angles. However, those double bevel BD now may be tuned to perform at their potential. In a way I see the chip breaker effect as if one was adding 10 degrees to the cutting angle of these planes.

Regards from Perth

Derek.

Nice write up and i applaud your documenting and sharing your discovery about the chipbreaker or cap or back iron as it is often referred to, i am sure you will learn more as you go along and i think it is helpful to others.

however i have to ask what qualifications do you have to state in relation to basic (let alone more advanced) use of a plane that tradsesmen have or have not been taught whist completing their indentures and attending trade school, that "many cabinet makers were taught correctly" what not all? and that "carpenters probably were not"...seriously i have never heard anything so ridiculous in my life...it appears you are only just discovering fully what the cap iron does, how would you know what tradesmen have been taught? are you a carpenter? a cabinet maker or any other trade? sheeze! frankly i dont think you have to be a carpenter to know, i am sure in high school they taught us the fundamentals about the plane and cap iron and out of curiosity, because i was sure it was well known, i dug out my old copy of Walton that was often used as a text in aust for high school woodwork class..it indeed lists the primary function as breaking the shavings, preventing tearing up and enabling a smooth surface, it secondary function also provides tension to the cutting edge preventing chattering. i would have to disagree wholeheartedly that the prevailing view in the past few decades has evey been only to stiffen the blade, it may have been in your eyes but i dont see how you can speak for others..certainly any texts i have read distinguish the purpose of the back iron correctly, i'd say that either you misread, misquoted or the fellow that wrote the article was somewhat slack with his wording, although it made sense to me but perhaps i read between the lines

Sir, you do all carpenters and cabinet makers in Australia and probably the world a great disservice and are insulting them by suggesting they dont know about basic functions of using a plane. i guess that might mean that you feel you know more than them? i wonder what poor impressions you must have towards carpenters and how they fill their time over 4-5 years (if not their lives) on the job and in trade school, oafs that just swing a hammer or nail gun perhaps, good gawd you do need to learn more!

cheers

chippy

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#46

The purpose of this Forum...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

...should be to teach and inform and some occasional positive socializing. When considering a post ask yourself, will what I post be helpful to the woodworkers reading it? If not , make it a private communication.

You are new here. I have given you a chance. So far I have not learned anything from you so I will not read any of your posts in the future.

And a thank you to EVERYONE else, for over the years I have learned from all of you. Almost any question I have about woodworking can be reliably answered by someone here. Sometimes I even get several answers that don't agree :) but variety is helpful too.