Re: Please explain reply
david weaver
Didn't Lee Valley do the tests with MDF? In my experience with HSS irons (not talking about V11), they tend to fare better against plainer steel irons when the material being planed is more abrasive - all other things being kept equal, and equal in this case often involves inexperienced planers taking lots of thin shavings - that kind of thing has clearance ending more quickly than it would end in heavier planing.
I see muji HSS irons lasting several times longer than carbon steel and cutting well much much deeper into the cycle when planing cocobolo with visible silica in it. On cherry, I don't see nearly as much difference.
I made a plane last year with the LV custom plane design (as in, I did the sizing of the block with LV's plane), and I found that I could get more work done planing with my try plane (which has an old butcher iron in it) because I could take a bigger shaving with it. That emphasizes that the proper plane can be more important than the iron itself. The butcher iron I have is good, and harder than butcher irons often are - sometimes they're a bit soft - but it would be no match for the V11 in a smooth planing contest where the shavings could be no thicker than 2 thousandths or some other arbitrary number. The try plane is better than a mid sized metal plane for that kind of work, though.
Most have vouched that the LV chisels are in the ballpark with japanese chisels of decent quality - I'll defer to them because I've never tried them. That's about as good as a chisel will be. The planing, I think depends more on case by case.
I gave LV my opinions on the plane and the cap iron in return for my plane, so take it with a grain of salt if you'd like. I tend to believe that LV is about as objective and honest as you will find, and the same is true of LN. I have seen Robin extend help to people where it really wasn't at all in the interest of the company in terms of allocating resources - especially when it's budding toolmakers. That is in great contrast to Japan Woodworker who would not respond to questions that I had that didn't involve buying their stuff.
At any rate, I think if the data doesn't translate to real life with the planing, it's not likely because the data is false, it's likely because something is different between the tested scenario and real life - i'm speculating in this case that it's because something really abrasive was planed. LV is more principled than to just create false data sets or make false claims. They know the internet community would pickle them, too. It seems that there are at least two people who will pickle them, regardless.
As to M4 and chisels, I have an M4 chisel, I think I still do even though I've meant to sell it several times. It's not the only HSS chisels I have, but the only M4. I keep one high speed steel chisel around in case I make another infill plane and want to flush the infill and the steel. But I haven't found the virtue of M4 in wood. You sharpen it with diamonds, which I don't like to keep out, and it just doesn't seem more favorable than carbon steel when the whole cycle of work and sharpening is accounted for. However, in flushing wood down to metal surfaces like you do making an infill plane, it will last 20 times as long and take no serious damage. If I had to chisel through wood that had staples in it, I'm sure it would do it with only small marks whereas carbon steel would take catastrophic damage.
If I was working australian woods where they were just up to the point where derek's are (derek has nice machine tools and I don't), I probably would have the same opinion.
I didn't ,by the way, have any trouble sharpening the V11 fine on a washita. It has to have less of a bevel worn on the grind, and the wire edge needs to be worked thin with more care, but it still sharpened fine, and so does cryogenic A2. The myth that these things can't be sharpened on oilstones is due to lack of creativity. I wouldn't want to grind it by hand on oilstones, though, it would end up burnishing the surface of the stone.