Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

Posts

Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#1

Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

Tony

I've heard that A2 is best hone at ~35* because it tends to get edge chipping at lower angles. Not so for O1 from what I understand. I've got a few PM-V11 blades but I haven't seen definitely if there is a honing angle below which the edge begins to break down more quickly?

So how low can you go?

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#3

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've heard that A2 is best hone at ~35* because it tends to get edge chipping at lower angles. Not so for O1 from what I understand. I've got a few PM-V11 blades but I haven't seen definitely if there is a honing angle below which the edge begins to break down more quickly?

So how low can you go?

Tony, I think that you are referring to plane blades, since you posted on Sawmill Creek that you had purchased a Veritas Custom #5 1/2 with a 40 degree frog. The context is important.

Bevel edge angles are a trade off between "sharpness" and durability. Lower angles penetrate more easily, while higher angles hold an edge better. However, when you have a plane blade around the 25 - 35 degree range, the amount of extra penetration is moot, but the longevity of the edge is not.

In regard to the latter, the higher the bed angle, the higher the stresses on the blade edge. Conversely, the lower the bed angle, the lower the stresses on the bevel edge. I have compared a low angle plane (Veritas Shooting Plane, 12 degree bed) with a higher, common angle plane (LN #51 shooting plane, 45 degree bed), and the LA plane kept cutting long after the BD plane. Different blade steels made no difference here. In fact, a BU blade with a 25 degree bevel far outlasted a BD 30 degree edge.

Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/LVShootingPlane.html

In my opinion, no BD plane blade should be honed below 30 degrees. Some argue, like Steve Elliott, that the most durable angle is 32 degrees. I think that David Charlesworth would suggest 35 degrees.

It's not that simple. One cannot simply lower the bed angle to reduce the stress on the blade edge and expect greater longevity. There is a limit how far one can go before the clearance runs out. Generally, a clearance of 7 degrees is considered to represent the danger zone (too little). The clearance angle is calculated from the difference between the bed angle and the bevel angle. For example, the 40 degree bed of your Custom #5 1/2 with a 35 degree bevel angle would leave 5 degrees of clearance. Too little. A 30 degree bevel angle would leave 10 degrees clearance. OK. And a 25 degree bevel would leave a 15 degree clearance ... but the edge would not last as well as the 30 degree bevel.

I have a Custom #7 jointer with a 40 degree frog, and a Custom #4 smoother with a 42 degree bed. Both have PM-V11 blades with 30 degree bevels. The 10- and 12 degrees, respectively, of clearance are fine. I obtain good longevity of cutting.

The advantage of a low cutting angle is that it leaves a cleaner surface than a plane with a higher cutting angle. This is more noticeable on softer woods and those with tight grain. Going lower than common, especially in a smoother, makes sense.

The advantage of the 40 degree frog in the #7 jointer is that it can shoot endgrain as well as a BU plane with a 12 degree bed and a 25 degree bevel. Plus, with the chipbreaker set close to the edge, this plane will handle any potential tearout.

The disadvantage of the low angle frog is that setting the chipbreaker is important, and the lower you go, there is an added sensitivity to its placement. Unless you are proficient with setting a chipbreaker, or plan to be, then go for the relative safety of a higher cutting angle (a higher angle frog). Many will not see the difference between 42- and 52 degree frogs, especially after a finish is applied. Going low is for the extremists! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#4

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

David Charlesworth

Seems to me that has a masterly avoidance of making specific recommendations?

Best wishes,

David

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#5

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The steel LV choose to call PMV11 is especially tough. I doubt you will chip it. "On paper" it will be tougher than O-1. So a good guess is that it can be used at whatever angle O-1 can be used. That said, the exact angle will depend on what you are doing with it. Sorry, experimentation is not to be avoided. I found it to be about as tough as CPM 3V at similar hardness.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#6

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

AZ in Colorado Springs

That was interesting to read. Thanks for posting the link.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#7

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I don't have enough knowledge of the alloy's characteristics to make recommendations, I just referred to the site because it mentioned going down to a 20 degree bevel angle in their tests.

In the interest of full disclosure, I now work for Lee Valley, and therefore will refrain from commenting on LV/Veritas products so as to avoid any appearance of bias.

DC

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#8

The data-suspect

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I had not recently looked at the latest claims from LV. If anyone believes that a steel that is easy to sharpen as A2 has wear as good as M4 I have a bridge to Brooklyn I would sell you. I would like to see the raw data that supports this claim. There is nothing about the composition of PMV11 that suggests its wear resistance will be in the neighborhood of M4 or M2 or any other steel that has a significant amount of a wear resistant carbide composition. Until I see some explanation as to why the wear of steel rubbing wood would be any different than the wear rubbing a sharpening abrasive I will remain skeptical that the wear resistance of PMV11 is anything close to M4.

Professor Kato studied dulling of plane blades planing wood of various kinds. The work was supported by force data and exception microphotography. The results were predictable from the composition of the steel and its grain structure. Exceptional wear resulted from tungsten or vanadium in the steel. PMV11 has neither in any meaningful amount. The high chrome will make it more wear resistant then 0-1 but not in the league with M4.

Tough it should be, and I have found it to be in chisels.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#9

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The steel LV choose to call PMV11 is especially tough. I doubt you will chip it. "On paper" it will be tougher than O-1. So a good guess is that it can be used at whatever angle O-1 can be used. That said, the exact angle will depend on what you are doing with it. Sorry, experimentation is not to be avoided. I found it to be about as tough as CPM 3V at similar hardness.

Abrasion resistance vs impact resistance.

Bill. On the tests I have completed, I find the impact resistance of PM-V11 steel is significantly better than than A2 and O1. Abrasion resistance is better as well, but not at the same lofty heights as impact resistance.

How to explain this in the face of the relative sharpening ease of PM-V11? I imagine that has to do with the way PM steel is manufactured - it is a fine grain composed of coarse grain/abrasion-resistant material, that is, it is the way the cake is baked. Perhaps someone here with metallurgical acumen can explain this.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#10

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

Kees van der Heiden

I have looked into PMV-11 a bit as well. On a simple, controllable, sharpening setup I saw that it takes twice as long to remove material from PMV-11 then it is from O1. A2 is somewhere in between. So, compared to stuff like M4, yes PMV-11 is relatively easy to sharpen. But O1 still trumps on the sharpening front.

A2 has a problem, the large chromium carbides. These form during the forging and heat treating process, and are relatively large compared to the surrounding steel matrix. The carbides are very hard, which gives A2 the edge in wear resistance, but they also like to break out of the steel, creating the typical chipped edge. Increasing the bevel angle helps to avoid this chipping.

PMV-11 also has a lot of chrome, even a lot more then A2, 16% against 5% . But because of the powder metallurgy they managed to keep the chromium carbides very small. This helps to make sharpening easier when using sharpening material that is hard enough to actually sharpen chromium carbide (oils tones are not such a good idea). But it also helps to avoid the chipping. And it increases the toughness.

So, like everybody in this thread allready said, PMV-11 is nice stuff. It is a bit harder to sharpen then O1, wear resistance is a bit better, even a bit better then A2, without the typical chipping problem. Because of its toughness it is great for chisels. It is quite expensive. But it is no magical material and still follows the laws of the universe!

In a plane, a big factor is the clearance angle. Wear on the bottom side of the bevel (loss of clearance) is going to affect the feeling of your plane. Wear in this spot wants to push the edge out of the wood. So, the more clearance you have, the longer you'll be able to use the edge, until of course you make the bevel angle so small that the edge fractures under the pressure. You'll have to experiment to see how it works out in your 40 degree plane. But the typical properties of PMV-11 seem to indicate that you could get away with something like 30 degrees, without too much trouble.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#11

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

Chuck Kettler

Has anybody tested the abrasion resistance of PM11V using ASTM method G65-A and compared with other steels such as 3V, O1, A2?

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#12

Query

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill and all,

It is a mystery, how a material can be highly wear-resistant in cutting, and yet not particularly abrasive-resistant in sharpening.

I notice in looking at Crucible Steel's site, that they qualified wear as 'adhesive wear'. With this in mind, I did the lowest form of research--google search, and indeed the lowest form of google search, wikipedia.

Nevertheless, the article I found here,

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wear

distinguishes between 'adhesive wear' and 'abrasive wear', and seems to characterize them as two different mechanisms.

I'm already over my head in the physics, having gotten this far :) , but I do wonder if a steel can have relatively high adhesive wear resistance, combined with relatively small abrasive wear resistance (emphasis on 'relative' in both cases). Perhaps PM VII has managed this?

Wiley

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#13

Re: Larry Williams

david weaver

If I recall, Larry used to say that most of the wear on a plane iron was adhesive wear.

I can't remember why, maybe one of those old Todd, Larry and Warren salvo-firing sessions would bring that back.

I'd assume it was in support of simpler steels like Larry prefers.

It does lead me to wondering whether or not there is any practical search for extra wear resistance from folks who can sharpen quickly. I've never felt that any of my quality chisels are trouble to use, even the softer old buck brothers chisels which always seemed to be tempered a bit short.

Same with all planing that precedes smoothing. A softer iron that sharpens easily is nicer to use as it takes a very long time for clearance to be a problem when shavings are .006 and thicker (much thicker in the case of a jack).

I do understand the quest for beginners, though. I remember that, as it wasn't that long ago for me. I preferred A2 planes because it seemed like a 10 minute process to get them apart, sharpen them (with a guide), reassemble and reset them.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#14

Re: Larry Williams

Brian Holcombe

This is not a reply to David's post but instead it is a generalized post since I learned much of this from David in our correspondance along with my own trial and of course reading and learning from experienced woodworkers.

I always find myself resharpening the few alloyed blades that I have just as soon as I would any high carbon blades.

I'm typically resharpening most finish planes within an hour or two of starting my work since after all it is a fine finish that I'm seeking. This is true of both Togo-Kou, O1, white 1, etc all the same. Sometimes I will finish plane a panel and before the final strokes I will resharpen to make the final few passes.

The extreme sharpness that makes for a brightly finished panel fades quickly and so it is best to simply resharpen right before the last passes.

One way to have your blades last longer is to take a heavier cut, as David mentions. In scenarios where longevity matters I am taking heavy cuts to get the work done in a reasonably time frame. My frames, for instance, I prep the stick by hand and go from sawn finish to defect free in three plane strokes. When you have hundreds of feet to plane by hand there is little time for romance. In that instance I may get 1/2 day out of my plane. Carbon steel is key becuase it wears without creating lines in the finished product.

There are situations where I want a very fine cut, and I mean see-through shavings. The plane typically needs to be sharpened right before hand.

So my point is, if anything, forget about the steel composition and start sharpening far more often. I can set my planes in seconds and resharpen western or Japanese blades in minutes and so it does not interrupt my process.

If your HC steel blades are wearing too quickly then you should use a lighter abrasive like fine oil stones or fine natural water stones. I've convinced myself through much trying and comparison that synthetics and diamonds are too harsh for finishing HC steel blades and they contribute to accelerated wear which results in users feeling that their blades are inadequate for normal use.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#15

Re: Query

Stewie Simpson

Bill and all,

It is a mystery, how a material can be highly wear-resistant in cutting, and yet not particularly abrasive-resistant in sharpening.

Wiley; there is no magic pudding. View the Test Results at the bottom of the page. http://www.pm-v11.com/TestingSharpening.aspx

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#17

Longevity of the edge

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I always find myself resharpening the few alloyed blades that I have just as soon as I would any high carbon blades.....

.... There are situations where I want a very fine cut, and I mean see-through shavings. The plane typically needs to be sharpened right before hand.

Brian, finish planing - smoothing - is where we agree that we want the best edge. Since this thread is about PM-V11, here is a contrast of steels .... not an objective test, as I generally try to report, but a subjective one (as you have).

I should precede my example to note that context is important, as always. Keep in mind that the West Australian wood I use is pretty abrasive, and my edges do not last as long as you may expect in the USA. Everything is speeded up somewhat in my world.

The example: I have three blades from which I can choose for a LN #3 (45 degree bed, used with chipbreaker set close) - the original A2, a older Clifton O1 (this is the hammered, not cast, variety), and a Veritas PM-V11.

The Clifton O1 sharpens quickly on Sigma stones, but lasts a dozen strokes before the dulling is felt. The LN A2 also takes a very good edge, although more time is spent removing and fussing over the wire edge, which can be tenacious (I suspect a lot of problems users have with A2 is due to vestiges of the wire remaining). This blade lasts twice as long as the O1. The Veritas PM-V11 takes less time to hone than the A2, partly because the grain is finer, and largely because there is much less of an issue with the wire edge. Indeed, it is not much more effort on Sigma stones than the O1 steel. The edge lasts about 50% longer than A2, which is significant.

One could argue that the "quality" of the edge - the fineness of the grain - is all important. It is relevant but, when sharp, all blades feel pretty much the same and produce a result at first that is identical. It is only when they begin to fail - dull - that differences appear. Sharp is sharp. Getting sharp depends on the media you use, and the technique you have. The advantage I find with PM-V11 is that it is about the same to hone as O1 and has the edge longevity of A2.

Like you, I still sharpen early rather than when the edge is already failing, however generally this is further away with PM-V11 and A2.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#18

Maybe.... but its a big stretch...

John in NM

There is simply not a great deal of cohesive force found between such dissimilar materials as wood and steel. While I wouldn't say it was absolutely impossible for the primary wear mechanism to be adhesive on a plane blade, and for one alloy or PM method to produce superior results re that mechanism, I would have to see a very convincing explanation of it, that so far is not to be found.

You more commonly see this happening between similar materials like two metals or two pieces of the same metal. Wear on bearing surfaces and the galling of aluminum are two examples of the mechanism.

The only explanation I've found so far would be that the particles themselves are quite wear resistant, but the bonds between them are less so. In that way I could see a long lived edge when presented to wood, but a faster sharpening rate when the particles are bumping up against relatively large abrasive particles. But even that is a stretch too.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#19

3 kinds of wear

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are in fact three kinds of wear- abrasive, adhesive and corrosive. I don't remember details but when I looked up adhesive wear in a tribology book the properties of wood precluded adhesive wear.

What could be interesting is the fact that PMVII is a stainless steel and hence corrosion resistant. However, nobody is claiming that PMII is in another universe of wear resistance other then Lee Valley. Until they supply data to support their wear claims it isn't wroth speculating how they came to believe that PMVII is as wear resistant as M4. M4 is indeed in another universe as predicted by the high concentration of abrasion resistant carbides it can form.

Knife makers are using what we believe is the Carpenter steel LV calls PMVII. The knives are durable but no unusual wear resistance is claimed. The steel is pricey. PMVII plane blades seem to be a bargain.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#20

Re: Longevity of the edge

Brian Holcombe

Derek,

To give that O-1 a fair change you need to finish it with an oil stone or fine natural water stone and not a sigma.

My edges off of a Nakayama asagi last considerably longer than those off a sigma 12k and the 12k is technically a finer stone.

You may be understandably disinterested in doing such a thing since you are keen toward alloy steels and use them well, but the O-1 and similar carbon steels are not near to the peak of performance off a sigma stone as they would be from a lighter (for lack of a better definition) abrasive.

Sharp is not simply sharp, I'm surprised that you would write it off as such. Fineness of the stone absolutely matters and surface finish has a considerable effect on strength of the edge and its ability to resist damage.

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#22

Re: Longevity of the edge

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Sharp is not simply sharp, I'm surprised that you would write it off as such. Fineness of the stone absolutely matters and surface finish has a considerable effect on strength of the edge and its ability to resist damage.

Brian, I finish all my edges (regardless of steel) on green compound. Usually this is after a 13000 Sigma or an Ultra Fine Spyderco. That is a very fine edge. I really doubt that something magical is going to happen if I instead use a Nakayama asagi.

Some media (diamond, for example) create deeper scratches and this can weaken an edge. For all intents and practical purposes, a refined edge is a refined edge.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#23

Please explain

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What I see are some highly questionable claims being made by Veritas on the benefits to the user of PM-V11 alloy steel.

On what basis do you state this? Can you support your opinion, or refute LV?

You must offer something more than a mere unsubstantiated feeling.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#24

Re: 3 kinds of wear

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill and John,

"when I looked up adhesive wear in a tribology book the properties of wood precluded adhesive wear." And John said much the same.

_______

The thing is, the rough equivalence in wear resistance between PMVII and M4 was not obtained on wood, but on MDF. Everything depends on MDF being representative. Now, LV's sharpening test was straightforward, and indeed Kees in his impressive post in this thread reported similar sharpening relationships to LV. True, he has PMVII a little harder to sharpen than A2, and LV has it a little easier, but given the methodological differences and interpretative variance, I find Kees' results do roughly corroborate LV.

I was moved to seek an explanation for the wear results, because I set great store by Lee Valley's integrity and competence. One does wonder whether similar results would have been obtained between PMVII and M4, had the wear test been performed on oak, cherry, or maple.

In any event, I recall Derek gave PMVII very high durability marks in a perfectly credible test, which he illustrated.

Myself, I like Brian's approach of sharpening fairly often, and while the iron is still cruising sharp.

Wiley

Re: Lowest honing angle PM-V11?

#25

Re: Please explain reply

Stewie Simpson

Derek; I am not the only person to have raised concerns on the integrity of data being supplied by Veritas on PM-V11 alloy steel.

Stewie;

John in NM.

There is simply not a great deal of cohesive force found between such dissimilar materials as wood and steel. While I wouldn't say it was absolutely impossible for the primary wear mechanism to be adhesive on a plane blade, and for one alloy or PM method to produce superior results re that mechanism, I would have to see a very convincing explanation of it, that so far is not to be found.

You more commonly see this happening between similar materials like two metals or two pieces of the same metal. Wear on bearing surfaces and the galling of aluminum are two examples of the mechanism.

The only explanation I've found so far would be that the particles themselves are quite wear resistant, but the bonds between them are less so. In that way I could see a long lived edge when presented to wood, but a faster sharpening rate when the particles are bumping up against relatively large abrasive particles. But even that is a stretch too.


Bill Tindall

What could be interesting is the fact that PMVII is a stainless steel and hence corrosion resistant. However, nobody is claiming that PMII is in another universe of wear resistance other then Lee Valley. Until they supply data to support their wear claims it isn't wroth speculating how they came to believe that PMVII is as wear resistant as M4. M4 is indeed in another universe as predicted by the high concentration of abrasion resistant carbides it can form.