Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Cleaning Old Stone

Posts

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#27

Re: Stewie....can you describe...

William Duffield

If you don't know the answer to my serious question, why not just say so? If you do know the answer, why not share it with us and save us the time of doing a redundant experiment? Right now, I don't have the SiC powder, and I don't have two identical dirty oil stones for the experiment. I have always been happy with the results of flattening my Arkansas stones on a diamond plate with oil, so the additional mess that I can imagine would result from mixing oil and water would need to be countered by some significant advantage before I went to the trouble of experimenting with it.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#28

One point, then I'll drop it...

John in NM

Yes, dish detergent removes the oil (and much of the steel swarf goes with it). Since the stone contains no oil buildup when new, and the detergent does not effect the stone itself, I say this does not harm the stone.

One could argue that it sets one back a bit if the oil build up is seen as beneficial, and that would not be an unreasonable point to make. Since I use kerosene rather than oil, I've probably not experienced the wonderful convenience of that oil buildup.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#29

Same experience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Back in the stone age when I used oil stones I found that a lubricant of lower viscosity resulted in better gunge removal. That said, I have not used this ancient abrasion technology since discovering faster means of metal abrasion.

As I recall, these stones seemed to come in two varieties. There was a soft variety that wore quickly but cut more quickly. And a hard version "India Stones" that I never experienced any wear on and cut slowly.

If someone has nostalgia for this technology I have a new 12 x 3" dual India in the box I'd love to sell. I bought it just before the discovery of how quick I could sharpen with the right grade of sand papers. All that was pre-diamond.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#30

Thank Stewie!

Brian Roberts

My reasoning for the cast plates was...well...the scrap was available....as was the machining center and surface grinder availability......and the ability of the abrasive to "bed" into the softer cast surface.

If all else fails the plate will make a dandy place to put abrasive paper (self-stick, double stick taped, or spray adhesive have all worked well for me) for honing and flattening.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#31

There are diamond....

Brian Roberts

wheels made for use on surface grinders.

Usually they are a steel wheel with diamond bonded to the edge.

They are commonly used in grinding and polishing ceramic, stone and aluminum alloy.

The problem becomes how to fixture the stones....securely and accurately....and I wonder how fast the process would be?

Of course the speed would depend on how bad the stone is....the grit size of the diamond wheel, etc., etc..

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#32

Re: One point, then I'll drop it...

david weaver

You may have something in the stone pores, though, but if the stone action is as you like it (I generally like mine settled in some), then freshening the surface will just set you back to waiting for the stone to be settled in again.

I have gotten washitas in the past that were clearly being used for razors. One that cuts relatively fine had a very uniform burnished layer of caking on the surface of the stone so that it was just barely cutting. The caking was neatly left on the stone and undamaged - sharpening a knife or tool on it would've instantly messed it all up, but razor sharpening is subtle and would allow something like that to occur and make a stone that isn't that fine seem like a finer stone.

Generally undesirable for tools, though - settled in is good. Impacted stone poo, not so good.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#33

Re: Same experience

david weaver

I don't know the usefulness of a 12x3 india. It's hard to keep hard stones flat when they have that much width.

However, an 8x2 or longer x 2 inch wide india stone is extremely useful if you are using plain steels (over-hardened O1 is fine, too).

I've never sharpened faster than I can now with oilstones. I felt the same way before I got proficient with them, because they don't excel at things like flattening new chisels or sharpening high speed steel (but they'll do that well once you are an accurate dry grinder).

As with all things, it's a matter of use. If you use india stones and are good at grinding, you'll get pretty fast using them. If you use diamond hones and then try to use india and arkansas stones like you would a diamond one, then that doesn't work that well. An inexpensive stone, though, that has a lifetime of use in it for anything, and will do well with carving tools, card scrapers, etc, that are maybe not a good idea for steel on steel loose diamond.

The india and carborundum stones do work better for me in an oil bath, though. You only use them, then, never have to clean them, and any contaminant that gets the stone just ends up in the bottom of the oil bath instead rather than becoming something you have to fish off.

No advice on the 12x3, though. Just a tough size to use freehand sharpening because it will get hollow in its width no matter what.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#34

Re: Why clean it at all?

david weaver

No functional need to clean it, but Stewie's stone does look a lot nicer when he's done.

I'm sure if he were to resell it on ebay, it would bring a fair bit more money like that, too.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#35

Pores

John in NM

My stones work ok, I wouldn't say there's much in the pores. I cleaned my slipstones once, but haven't ever bothered with the bench stones.

Somewhere I have a broken plane sole I've saved for years to make into a diamond lap. Never got around to milling the sides lower for easier mounting though. Maybe one day when I need to sharpen more often - I'm still too busy to do much proper work (ie woodworking rather than the day job :D )

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#36

Re: An easeir way? *LINK*

steve voigt

"The problem with a glass substrate is that glass is too hard. The abrasive doesn't embed in the glass and become fixed."

Bill,

Yes, that is true. The problem is easily solved with psa-backed plastic laminate sheets. They last a long time and save your glass. See link at bottom.

"I still find it astonishing that the superior properties of a diamond abrasive are used to flatten rocks which are in turn used for sharpening, rather than cutting out the middle man and using diamond to begin with."

I've tried diamond stones and diamond paste. Even with a "super" or "extra" fine stone, the deep scratches it puts into my blades are horrifying. Moving to diamond paste, this tendency (of making very deep scratches) necessitates using a very fine paste, say 1 or 2 micron, for final honing. As a result, final honing with paste is, for me, no faster than on an Arkansas stone. The paste also lacks the tactile feedback of a stone. As a result, I simply don't enjoy sharpening with diamonds, the way I do on oilstones. Since I spend a lot of time sharpening, it's important to me that it not be an unpleasant activity.

I'm not interested in trying to persuade anyone to use oilstones, but perhaps this will help you understand why not everyone is in love with diamonds. As John Aniano pointed out above, there is more than one way to do things.


LV lapping film

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#37

Re: Question *LINK*

steve voigt

Darryl Gent boils old stones with a little baking soda in the pot. I tried it on that old Washita I bought on ebay, and it seemed to work pretty well. Darryl posted a pic on Instagram, see link below.


boiling a stone

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#38

Re: In a word...

steve voigt

"You sir are a time waster, I won't argue with people who troll with a straw man for bait. Adios."

You know Stewie, since you started posting here, I've seen more comments like this in the last month than I've seen on this site in the last two years. I guess it was inevitable that you'd show up here, after wearing out your welcome on SMC, Woodnet, and all the others, but it sure has brought the level of civility down. It would be great if you could either learn some basic social skills or crawl back under your rock.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#39

Re: Stewie....can you describe...

AlanWS

I have flattened oilstones much as Stewie described, but have always used loose grit dry. To keep the grit from slipping out from under, the only thing I do differently is to leave spent sandpaper on the glass under the grit.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#40

To be fair...

John in NM

Those were mine - he was just needling me for it.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#41

Re: Question

david weaver

Very nice, thanks Steve!

I have a utility pot that I use to make soap and to make oil and wax mixes. It'd be ideal for that.

I'll have to wait until my wife isn't home, though - most men probably wouldn't, but it would cause a war in my house. Such things as putting stones in the dishwasher aren't even close to happening - the Mrs would order a new one the next day, and the joke would be on me since I'd be the one to foot the bill.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#42

I hear ya


Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#43

Re: To be fair...

steve voigt

I was thinking about the cause rather than the symptom.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#44

Re: Question

steve voigt

Dave,

I grinned from ear to ear at this story!

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#45

Fair enough

John in NM

Just wanted to be sure...

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#47

Re: Why clean it at all?

david weaver

Well, if you're going to sell a stone, I guess you could clean it. If you're not, it's just cosmetic - flattening the surface of a stone does everything functional you could have to do.

I wouldn't generally advise someone that they should do something with their tools so that they can sell them for more later.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#48

Re: Fair enough

david weaver

This isn't the only forum that Stewie has been leaving a trail of stinkers on lately (pretty much trying to gotcha-post all over the place, combined with John M's favorite - the post with several pictures and very little explanation of what we're supposed to get out of them).

Stewie, I've had my battles with the same thing you have had battles with. I think you need to step back and sit in the sun a little bit or something - this mindset usually ends with a crash when the fun of the nitpicking wears off.

Re: Cleaning Old Stone

#50

Re: Fair enough

david weaver

Stewie, that was a genuine comment, not a snark. I've seen the pattern before, and it ends with a crash.

Sunlight and the real world usually even it out.

Same thing happens to me. But I recognize now when I have nothing positive to say about anyone, and have the urge to keep going and sticking a finger in peoples' sides, it's my mood that's out of whack - not everyone else. As Ron White says, "maybe it's me?".

You've been on a bender with Derek and others for the last couple of weeks that is way beyond the normal pace, and little of the material has applicable value for the rest of us - attempting to set verbal traps and not engaging in any real genuine back-and-forth conversations. Take a break.