Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

Posts

Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#1

Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

roger lance

Beyond the more basic question of whether or not I need (want) to add some gouges to my hand tool kit, is the question of what is the difference to the work of having the cutting edge honed on the inside or outside of the blade?

Is one easier or more difficult to sharpen?.....does one require more stuff to get sharp over the other?.....etc, etc.

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

Jack Guzman from Maine

The position of the bevel determines what kind of cut the gouge makes and how you direct the tool to get the results you require. If you were cutting a hollow in a flat piece of stock in incannel gouge would tend to dig. In the same case you could determine the depth of your cut with an out cannel gouge by the angle at which you approach the cut.

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#3

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am more used to the term firmer gouge for bevel on the outside, and scribing gouge for bevel on the inside. Here is some work which illustrates the difference in use. The picture is a mantel tree, the large beam over a fireplace. This one has a large moulding cut in with moulding planes, and a return moulding at each edge which is carved with chisels and gouges.



At the bottom of the moulding is a cove, which is concave; the return on this feature would be done with a scribing gouge (inside bevel). The next feature up is an ovolo which is convex; this would be done with a firmer gouge. In both cases the gouge is held vertically and chopped straight down.

In sharpening the firmer gouge we sharpen on a wheel or stone and then work the flute with a fine slip stone, which has a rounded edge. For the scribing gouge we need a rough slip stone to work the bevel on the inside, and then a fine slip stone to polish.

The firmer gouge is also use for roughing work, like roughing out a cove moulding to save time with the moulding plane, and others.

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#4

Regarding sharpening

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Roger,

Coupla opinions on your sharpening question. I'll stick to sharpening and honing here; grinding is another matter.

The out cannel gouges can be sharpened on whatever stones you use for your other tools--it's a matter of developing a rolling action to do the sidewise sharpening, and practice. However, you also want to be able to work the upper side where the burr forms, and this wants a slip of the proper size, or else a dowel of the proper size wrapped with either an abrasive paper (such as the LV microabrasive film) or embedded with an abrasive paste. Lots of people like to put just a few degrees bevel on this upper surface (I do), but opinions may vary, and I'd like to hear Warren's view of this.

The in cannel or scribing gouges are the other way around. Here, you need slips of the right size, or a properly sized dowel or other round object (even a drill) with abrasive film wrapped around it or abrasive paste embedded into it--to work the primary bevel on the inside. Then get the burr off the back side on your stones with the rolling sideways motion, but no bevel on the back of the scribing gouge--keep the back straight.

This is just what I have learned as an amateur to do on my own. it works. However, I would much like to hear Warren's views on sharpening the two types of gouges.

Wiley

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#5

Re: Just bought some

TomD

The basic set are gouges sharpened on the outside. I just bought a set off Amazon. I had been watching these Grizzly chisels for a while and decided not to buy them. I chanced to see the price fall to about 66 dollars so I hit the buy button.




Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#6

Re: Just bought some

david weaver

I have that set. They are a bit chippy, but given an extra couple of degrees, they hold up extremely well. Especially for the price. I use them with a mallet in the handle mortise of a plane.

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#7

Re: Regarding sharpening

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have three slip stones: coarse India, fine India, and soft Arkansas. You want slip stones that are about 2X4 with edges about 3/8 and 1/8. Smaller slip stone sare hard to grasp and get sufficient pressure and steadiness.The curvature of the slip stone does not have to be the same as the gouge; it should be enough smaller that you can concentrate on a particular area of the gouge or go gradually and evenly along the edge, drawing back and forth in and out of the flute. If the diameter of the stone (or abrasive wrapped dowel) is too close to the curvature of the gouge people tend to just rub without thinking about where the abrasion is concentrated.

For a firmer gouge, abrade the bevel on bench stones, either back and forth or rolling side to side, then clean up the flute with a fine slip. Most people don't use a small bevel on the inside with firmers.

For a scribing gouge, abrade the bevel with coarse slip stone, medium slip and fine slip, then work the outside lightly flat on a fine stone. Then strop.

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#8

Excellent!  Thank you.


Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#9

Re: Just bought some

TomD

I don't pry (and you probably don't either), so I never have any problems. When I do have issues, usually it is just a little brashness in the hardening, and it eventually passes. Thanks for the review, David, because this is the least I have paid for a set of Japanese chisels/gouges, ever, and I am talking number for number, back to 79. It will be a while till I will get them up and running. Good to know.

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#10

Firmer gouges different than carving chisels?


Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#11

Re: Just bought some

TomD

I wouldn't want my micro gloat to throw off the OP's purchase. I don't carve formally, I shape things. If I was taking up a euro form of carving, I would probably pick what I specifically needed from one of the better known sets, or conceivably make them. But at any rate follow conventional format carving tools.

Re: Gouges.....in- or out-cannel??.....

#12

Re: Firmer gouges different than carving chisels?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Firmer gouges are more robust than carving gouges, sometimes twice as thick. Carving gouges taper toward the neck and bolster and the flute kind of disappears in this back area. Firmer gouges usually have a uniform flute with ears or wings at the back end. Here are some illustrations:

Firmer gouges



Carving gouge (#63)