Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Posts

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#26

Re: Planes don't fly

TomD

Or they had a higher profit margin, and the idea they were better hardly even had to be stated. You look at a metal plane, or a wooden lump, with the eyes of a 19th century person convinced by events of amazing material progress, it's obvious the metal plane has to be better.

One thing, of course, is that metal planes don't fly. Whatever claim has been made for a metal plane, it is not clear what advantage it actually has. The period was full of devices that brought on the modern world. Horseless carriages, airplanes, cartridge firing weapons, table saws, the sewing machine. What the heck does a metal plane do? Uh, it's better. It not only isn't true. A far bigger crime is that it isn't in the least evident.

Metal planes do have characteristics that are different from wooden ones, but that is a different mater.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#27

Re: Planes don't fly

Jim Matthews

The steps involved influence cost. It may be simpler to train factory staff to work with metal blanks than the alternative wooden billets.

I suspect that the reason for adoption of cast iron, bronze and steel for hand tools has more to do with suitable raw materials. Stable wood of sufficient density requires another layer of skilled labor.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#28

Right on both points...

John in NM

It had much more to do with manufacturing efficiency and cost to the consumer than it did with product performance.

I wouldn't say this justifies one product over the other - in the case of planes I wouldn't know, but in the case of rasps I do prefer the expensive hand cut ones.

The point is not to say that manufacturing efficiency should dictate end use, it is to understand why things are the way they are after a century or more. Understanding why "we've always done it this way" is the best way to buck that if you find a better way (or perhaps rediscover an older better way).

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#29

Easier for the carpenter

Brian Holcombe

Balloon framing started around 1830 and become quite popular soon after, I would imagine the carpenter transitioned from what we might consider a timber framer to what we might now consider a carpenter right around that time period.

I think it may be easier for the carpenter to carry a metal plane. One of the complaints WRT Japanese planes is that the carpenters who use them (timber framers) tune them regularly in the field due to the fact that they change with the environment. It's much less a problem for someone working in a shop, much timber framing is made in the shop then brought to the field so many of them just deal with it in the field when the problem arrises since they are generally preferred.

As I write this I have a wooden plane from my ancestor sitting on a shelf behind me, my father added a date to it of 1850-1931....so I could be completely incorrect in my assumptions.