Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

has anyone made a Raamtang?

Posts

Re: has anyone made a Raamtang?

#26

Re: tucker vise?

Peter Gee

Not strictly true. The patternmakers vise that LV used to sell is still made by the same factory in Taiwan and still available to buy, in Europe at least.

www.dictum.com/en/tools/woodworking-metalworking/workshop-accessories-toolkits/accessories-and-clamping-devices/705767/multipurpose-bench-vice

and

https://www.fine-tools.com/schraub.html

I show two suppliers in Germany selling them, with a price of €279 or €319, depending on which supplier you want to buy from.

Re: has anyone made a Raamtang?

#27

Re: Moxon vise

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The only problem I have with your dovetailing setup is the extension of the work above the top of the vise.

William, this is a typical height. The board is about 3/8" thick ...


It appears that you have replaced your L-N DT saw, shown in the older pictures, with a Veritas, as you are using in the more recent pics. Can you make any comparisons of the two saws? I'm still using the L-N DT saw, but have upgraded my tenon saw from a Disston to the Veritas and am quite pleased with it.

I have a "few" dovetail saws - I do admit to indulging myself a little ..

The LN (15 tpi) is one of my favourites. I like the balance and the handle is comfortable. The whole saw feels solid and capable. I have refiled the rake a little, by about 2 degrees (it was zero to start), which has made it a little smoother. It is still an aggressive saw.

The Veritas is 14 tpi, however has 14 degrees rake. As a result it is much smoother, easier to start, but not as aggressive. Also nicely balanced. A little lighter in the hand. Very similar hang.

Another great dovetail saw is the Gramercy (19 tpi). This has a higher hang than the others, and a lighter saw plate/back. This translates into a saw that requires the lightest of touches, and rewards you with being the easiest to start a cut and more control.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: has anyone made a Raamtang?

#28

Well

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Peter and all,

1. For the Taiwanese Emmert clone, you don't have to go to Germany. Here it is at Woodcraft for $300 + shipping:

https://www.woodcraft.com/products/woodriver-pattern-makers-vise

To get a real Emmert, expect to pay more. A lot more. Not knocking the Taiwan product--there are some comments on the Woodcraft site, under the picture/description.

2. Here is the Tucker Vise, once sold by Lee Valley. It was made in Canada:

http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=31143&cat=1,41637,41652,31143

As you can see, when available it was $700 + shipping. Bruce's post, just above tells you what one has sold for NIB ($2,800).

Wiley

Re: has anyone made a Raamtang?

#29

Re: Nitpicking Details

William Duffield

There are a couple of significant differences between the Taiwanese Emmert clone sold by Woodcraft, Dictum and Dieter Schmid and the Tucker.

The picture of the clone on Woodcraft's site shows an auxiliary jaw that allows tilting both horizontally and vertically at the same time. The Tucker did not have one of these. The jaws of the clone also have keyhole slots with which you can attach shop-made auxiliary jaws.

The clones, however, are not quick release, while the Tucker was. Additionally, the Tucker's quick release mechanism was spring loaded and could be foot pedal activated. I once almost hit myself in the face with the vise while down on my knees examining how the quick release mechanism worked.

Re: has anyone made a Raamtang?

#30

Moxon vise- any other benefits to consider?

Gary B.

I've never used a moxon vise, but I'm fond of the idea. I think raising the work, I may be tempted to try and saw the lines, then cope them out, then pare at least the face closest to me by hand, without ever removing it from the vise. has anyone tried this? The front chop would make a nice horizontal surface to reference your chisel to if you placed it in the vice on the marking gauge line (or slightly shy of)

Re: has anyone made a Raamtang?

#31

Re: Moxon vise- any other benefits to consider?

William Duffield

IMHO, chopping tails and pins is much more effective with a heavy bench surface backing up the boards, and holding the bench chisel vertically. Half-blind sockets are a horse of a different feather, and I find paring them while the pin board is held vertically in a vise is effective. However, for sawing these, I find a chamfered front vise jaw is advantageous. This kind of rules out using the top surface of the jaw for horizontally indexing the paring chisel, unless you have two vise jaws and are willing to move the pin board from one to the other. Instead of jigging the process like you would with a power tool, learn where horizontal and vertical are. It just takes practice, like most skills necessary for effective use of hand tools.

Re: has anyone made a Raamtang?

#32

Re: tucker vise?  Scores!

TomD

I seem to be making out like a bandit on vises these day. I bought this vise called a LAW, for fly tying. A guy sold me on it when I wanted a different one. I paid about 800 for it, but they now sell for about 4K-6K. I didn't really like it. I mean it is good for sure, but not so much that I still prefer my HMH original made by Bill Hunter. I always regretted getting the cheap one. I should have gone for the expensive one. They now sell for 3K, about a 10 fold increase (30 years). Not to say one makes any money on this stuff, but it does go to show you can splash out and still have the life cycle cost of Bill Tindall's solid core door. Heck if I sawed up the wood in either of my benches, I bet I could make back what I paid for it before the Maple fairies hit. I could sell the Tucker, the Tail Vise hardware from LV, and the beams, and it would probably come out even enough.

Anyway, I missed this thread. I will see if I have any pics of my Tucker. One nice thing about it is that it rotates, and it comes a little above the level of the bench which saves the back a little.

Re: has anyone made a Raamtang?

#33

Re: Nitpicking Details

TomD

I can rotate mine H and V, I think. Probably not what you are thinking.

I got one of the Taiwan Emmerts, but I have yet to install it. It was a lot cheaper at one time. The part for the handle arrived smashed, and you can tell it is that chunky cast iron that blows all the time. I got a replacement, but it had the wrong sized scroll pin hole. I think I did figure out how to fix it when the Milling machine quotient got high enough around here.

I never installed the foot pedal on the Tucker. It is probably a good idea, I could just never really come up with an installation I liked. The hand release is stiff, possibly because stuff falls into it. I love it though, It is great for how I work. (Plus I have the L vise on the other bench). It is a nice looking tool, but not to my taste exactly, it just works so darn well. It has some interesting artistic detail that will just take a knuckle right off if you come to rest on them.

-----------------------------------------

On a funny side note. I was gassing on about how much a liked the Tucker years back, when Rob, who was around more in those days, dropped some acid on me along the lines of how much more useful an endorsement would have been when they actually still made it. Made me smile, but also sad since I didn't realize they no longer sold it at the time.