Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

One tail or two?

Posts

One tail or two?

#1

One tail or two?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Shown is a rail that will bridge between to tops of the front legs of the display cabinet. (The rail has not been thicknessed yet. It will be 5/8 to 3/4" thick). A drawer will go under it. The question is whether to make one big tail or two smaller ones. This size is at the point where I don't have a clear answer. On a smaller leg I would use one tail, but my feeling here is that two are needed.?.

Re: One tail or two?

#2

One Would Be My Vote


Re: One tail or two?

#3

Re: One tail or two?

Don Orr

If it will be seen at all I think 2 might look more balanced and you have room, but if not seen one might be stronger. Just my opinion.

Re: One tail or two?

#4

Re: One tail or two?

Sgian Dubh

Perhaps neither? What about a double bridle with two quite small diameter cross reinforcing trunnels? Slainte.

Re: One tail or two?

#5

Re: One tail or two?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I use two, mainly because I saw it that way in Charles Hayward's joinery book, and then when I did it, it's very satisfying. In fact, Hayward shows a top rail wider than the legs, which wraps around the leg on the back side and sets a small tail into the side rail as well. Overkill, but it's hell for stout.

I suggest two.

Wiley

Re: One tail or two?

#6

Where's my English -English dictionary

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"double bridle with two quite small diameter cross reinforcing trunnels? "

say what? :)

Re: One tail or two?

#7

Trunnel='treenail'=wooden pin, dowel


Re: One tail or two?

#8

Re: Trunnel='treenail'=wooden pin, dowel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Oh, he means a pinned box joint?

No, don't like that idea. It will be two tails. The purpose of the joint is to hold the legs together. Nothing beats a dovetail to deal with this kind of force. Besides it is what I see in Period Am. furniture so it's got to be good. :)

Re: One tail or two?

#9

Re: Trunnel='treenail'=wooden pin, dowel

Sgian Dubh

It was just an alternative idea Bill. It gives a different visual appearance to dovetail, and as far as I can see would be effective if well executed. But I admit I'd kind of forgotten you're not too fond of some contemporary design aesthetics - although you did use a bridle joint on the end frame of your cabinet with the unconventionally dovetailed top panel, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: One tail or two?

#10

I never put a nail in a tree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Nothing about the joinery here will be visible except the line of the joint intersection. I don't like the looks of a pinned joint in any style of furniture. I find the pin visually distracting.

I have some fancy wood for the drawer, to be seen later. Don't want anything nearby to take attention away from the drawer front.

Re: One tail or two?

#11

one of the half lap dovetail

Joseph Piotrowski

i was just reading a back issue of FWW and they were talking about this joint for ability to prevent racking.

i have no opinion but just regurgitating some info i read ...

thanks,

joe p

Re: One tail or two?

#13

Chris Scholz

Use the dovetail equation  *LINK*

Chris Scholz

When eyeballing does not work, use mathematics. So why not use the "dovetail equation" that states

Nt = w/ (3/2 * t)

where

Nt: number of tails

w: width of the board

t: thickness of the board

For less than 7 tails round to lower integer.


Devetail equation

Re: One tail or two?

#14

Chris Scholz

Use the dovetail equation  *LINK*

Chris Scholz

When eyeballing does not work, use mathematics. So why not use the "dovetail equation" that states

Nt = w/ (3/2 * t)

where

Nt: number of tails

w: width of the board

t: thickness of the board

For less than 7 tails round to lower integer.


Dovetail equation

Re: One tail or two?

#15

that's a new on on me

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

And 2 is the answer, which is what I used. Leave it to the Germans to develop a dovetail equation. I will have to consider it in my next Arbeitsplan.

Re: One tail or two?

#16

A side note on Hayward's joinery

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hayward's practice of using wide rails in front, which wrap around the back side of the legs, has some advantages. He uses these wide rails above and below the drawer. You can then tenon your runners and kickers into these rail wraparounds, so that they are perfectly registered with the rails. I think this is also why he drops a tail into the side rail--it locks the rails, runners, and kickers all into the same plane. Also, the runners and kickers have to be anchored somewhere, and the leg itself may not be ideal, since it is likely chewed up pretty well with dovetail sockets, double mortises for the lower rail, and cuts for the side panels.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: One tail or two?

#17

Follow up

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The dovetailed piece is a top drawer divider between the legs. The purpose of the dovetails is to keep the legs from separating. I did two tails. It looks right. However, I would do one tail if doing over. One would be good enough.

It was at least 3 times longer to excavate the waste in the leg for two small dovetails than one larger one. It was tight in there chopping and paring with a smaller and hence more limber chisel. I did get speeder by the last one. I see why there was not a lot of colonial furniture made from ash (or oak).

Re: One tail or two?

#18

Ellis Walentine

Nicely summarized

Ellis Walentine

I would agree that for pure mechanical strength, one tail would have been enough. There's no cosmetic reason to go with two, either. It might have been a little more questionable if the single tail was perilously close to the edges of the vertical member, but even then, what kinds of stresses should you be expecting on this assembly?

Thanks for the follow up.

Ellis

Re: One tail or two?

#19

Re: FYI

William Duffield

Here is a pic of the related joint that was discussed, where the top drawer rail is joined to both the leg post and the side panel. This is from William Fairham's "Woodwork Joints".


Re: One tail or two?

#20

Re: FYI

William Duffield

I went to look for more detailed information on this joint, and Volume III, Joinery of "The Woodworker: The Charles H. Hayward Years" by Lost Art Press serendipitously opened to the appropriate page. In a reprint from Vol 40, No. 506, starting on page 1115, Hayward thoroughly describes and clearly illustrates constructing the sideboard end joint for two situations: for a solid panel with vertical grain orientation, and also for a frame and panel side. For the frame and panel case he describes the same difficulties with executing the joint as Bill encountered with his ash carcass.

Re: One tail or two?

#21

How do you find this stuff....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I usually can't find my glasses :)

Re: One tail or two?

#22

Re: FYI

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Sir Wm. et al,

Good reference, and Lost Art is doing wonderful work in its reproductions. I believe Lost Art has also done Charles Hayward's 'Woodwork Joints', where I found a nice drawing. In that drawing, he shows twin dovetails into the leg, with the rail wrapping around the back of the leg and another small tail into the side rail (exactly as shown in your picture above). I would copy the Hayward photo, except that I think I sent that book to a well-known E. Tennessee woodworker whose first initial is Bill :) .

Anyways....The thing that is so good about that joint IMO is that you get 1 or 2 tails into the leg post, and as the rail wraps the post, it converts the backside of the leg post into a half-tail, making the whole thing wonderfully stout. And beyond that, the arm of the rail which reaches around the backside of the leg post is a perfect place to tenon-in the runner/kicker, so that it is supported by and sligned with the rail, without needing to make yet another cut into the leg post. The design locks up and aligns the entire assembly.

Thanks again for the Lost Art Press reference.

Wiley

Re: One tail or two?

#23

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"And beyond that, the arm of the rail which reaches around the backside of the leg post is a perfect place to tenon-in the runner/kicker, so that it is supported by and aligned with the rail, without needing to make yet another cut into the leg post."

Why would one mortise into the leg to locate a runner? I mortise them into the drawer divider and simply add a filler between it and the side of the case.

This complicated joint only makes sense for a small cross section leg, or for those with too much time and too little to build.

Re: One tail or two?

#24

Re: How do you find this stuff....

William Duffield

Some times you just get lucky.

I buy moost of the books offered by Schwarz & Co., at least browse through them to see what is inside, and put them in my library. Sometimes, I read them cover to cover. For example, the Anarchist's Tool Chest, which I read three times.

I had the idea that this volume has lots of details of lots of different joints, so I pulled it out to search. Highly recommended! I knew where the book was was because I had just ordered Volume IV, after verifying that I already had only volumes I, II and III. I was amazed when it fell open to the right page. Since Wiley noted you already have access to a copy, I won't violate the LAP copyright by photographing the pertinent pages and e-mailing them to you. That would probably choke your primitive internet connection, anyway. :D

Vol III: https://lostartpress.com/collections/books/products/vol-iii-of-the-woodworker-the-charles-h-hayward-years-joinery

Vol. I & II: https://lostartpress.com/collections/books/products/the-woodworker-the-charles-hayward-years

Vol. IV: https://lostartpress.com/collections/books/products/vol-iv-of-the-woodworker-the-charles-h-hayward-years-the-shop-furniture

It looks like I'll receive Volume IV next week: https://blog.lostartpress.com/2017/02/16/its-early-the-woodworker-vol-iv/

Re: One tail or two?

#25

I think they owe you a comission

John in NM

I'm going to have to buy those!

I got out of the habit of buying woodworking books the last few years - burned out on all that FWW glitz in Barnes and Noble - but this series really looks like my speed.