The post below where the Kato video is referenced reminded me that there is a bewildering amount of woodworking stuff out there and most it is misleading at best.
I have a son-in-law that both loves to troll the internet and an interest in woodworking is kindling within. I get comments from him about stuff he has found on the internet. It has led me to conclude that the Internet is not a place to send a novice woodworker without an experienced guide.
I have been critical of magazines for publishing techniques for their novelty rather than their time tested features. Apparently the Internet takes novelty to another level without the benefit of an editor.
The result for the novice woodworker will be for them to waste time learning techniques that are flawed, inefficient, unsafe, etc. which in turn could lead to struggles and failure that will extinguish their budding interest.
Personally I am thankful that at two critical times in my learning I was able to be mentored by a professional cabinet maker who at least showed me one time tested way to make cabinetry.
Yes, there is a lot of ill information out there on youtube. In my opinion, a lot of it is from people with good intentions, but without the experience necessary. But, I think Youtube in general is like that. I was trying to learn some computer programming, and found a dedicated learning site like Lynda.com much better.
I'll give you an example from my own point of view. From my point of view, It's interesting seeing the videos on Card scraper sharpening. You'd think it needs to be a religious experience to get a usable edge.
Nearly 20 years ago I was a young "apprentice" under a skilled cabinetmaker. My job one entire summer was to glue 3/4" x 1 1/2" solid wood edges onto veneered plywood shelving. No trim router allowed. My only tools were a card scraper and block plane, and an 5" pneumatic to sand the surface after it was flush. He wanted me to learn tool skills. Yes, my thumbs were sore, and black at the end of every day. In my experience, you can get 4 usable burrs on a card scraper in less than a minute and get back to work. I never even went into a vise. Just held it on the work bench. A flat single cut file and a burnisher is all that's really needed. I suppose draw filing in a vise may even produce better results.
For fun and to increase my knowledge (I believe there is always more to learn), I've perused all the free videos from the better sites....Paul Sellers, Richard Maquire and the Renaissance Woodworker. I would push a novice woodworker to these sites.
As we see regularly on this forum, sometimes there are two or three contradictory opinions on a proper method, so it's not surprising to find text and video that are not always in complete agreement.
Personally, I visit daily WoodCentral and a couple other woodworking forums to be reminded of what I've forgotten, to be inspired, and to be exposed to different ideas and approaches. It is especially helpful when the poster includes his or her rationale when presenting a method or practice, so that one can evaluate and compare more fully with prior personal learning and experience. And when the opportunity presents, I try to share in a positive manner what I have learned from others and from experience.
Unfortunately, almost every activity in woodworking has the potential for serious immediate or long term injury or illness, and too many videos do not caution about the injury potential, or even demonstrate what many consider to be risky practices.
A woodturning forum to which I belong maintains its own collection of videos and video links, and moderators review new submissions to exclude those with risky or dangerous activities. Although I don't have the time or inclination regularly to browse Youtube and similar, I have occasionally followed a link to one of these unmoderated videos and some are excellent, so one can't make a generalization.
There can be a fine line between a good new idea or practice, or revisiting of an old one, and a bad idea or practice. I can't speak for anyone else, but for me it is most helpful to be exposed to one's rationale, rather than simply be told "that is stupid" or "this has to be done this way" or "this is how so-and-so does/did it."
Of course, some people asking for help already know the answer they want, and keep asking the same question despite friendly, informative responses to the contrary, until someone finally says "I did it that way was am happy with the result."
The Internet sometimes, in some ways, makes posting of text and/or video too easy. The public needs to be reminded of that constantly, and the need to evaluate the quality of information found there. WoodCentral is one of my daily visits because of the quality of questions asked and responses provided.
There is also a host of terrible information in everyday life, however the internet at least offers access to both good and bad in greater volume. The user must determine which is which.
Without the internet you are largely limited to what is available locally or in magazines and in books which are available locally.
In what other context are you offered direct and long standing conversations with experienced users? If one chooses to circumvent that experience for superficial entertainment videos then they will have a poorer learning experience.
The fact is, the entire internet (and the whole of the world's accumulated knowledge, for that matter) is filled with myths, half-truths, lies, bad advice, etc., etc.
Learning to discern good from bad, useful from useless, etc., is part of life's journey.
If you never learn to do that, bad woodworking technique will be the least of your problems.
I say thank God for the internet -- the instant availability of information is both astounding and unprecedented in the history of the world!
Libraries are generally good sources of books - and, I presume, DVDs, although I have no direct experience in that area - for woodworking.
I'm a dinosaur: my intellectual learning on woodworking was done through books, long before VHS and DVDs were available. Nothing, of course, replaces actual mangling of wood; but some grasp of the theory is good to get started with.
Bill, I'm 73 years old. I've been interested in woodworking my whole life. For many years my efforts, struggles and learning experiences were solitary. I didn't know any woodworkers, so my experience and advancement in the craft were based on trial and error (lots of error) and what I picked up from Tage Frid's books and, later, Fine Woodworking Magazine. It was slow going. Then I found the Internet and my life changed. The Internet catapulted me through several levels of proficiency. It introduced me to other woodworkers whose skills far surpassed mine and who have been unbelieveably generous with their advice, instruction and assistance. I've met tool makers through the internet who have accelerated my understanding and appreciation of tools far, far beyond what I would have experienced plodding along on my own. The Internet has given me access to tools and materials I never dreamed of. My enjoyment of the craft has never been greater and I thank the Internet for that. Yes, I've waded through a lot of junk; but, by and large, I've learned to recognize and appreciate valuable information there and to ignore the eye-catching trendy stuff that has little basis in traditional methods or techniques. I will be the last person to condemn the internet as a source for woodworking knowledge. It has been invaluable to me and my enjoyment of the craft.
Hank, I agree with you. The internet has kindled interest and sustained my development. And where else could I read about secondary bevels and who will man the Gamecock secondary, all at the same source?
"reminded me that there is a bewildering amount of woodworking stuff out there and most it is misleading at best."
Last year I joined a FaceBook group that is hand tool woodworking only. The amount of blatantly wrong information there on a daily basis is mind boggling. It seems to be mostly young people starting out too. It's a shame. Even though I've been making saw dust since the 80's I consider myself a beginner and don't pretend to know it all, but I know wrong when I see it.
Yes, a lot of the information is misleading and misguided.
WC is the only WW'ing forum I have ever been a regular member of. It's where I believe I can get good information because of the experienced people here.
"I have been critical of magazines for publishing techniques for their novelty rather than their time tested features."
Even though I've been a subscriber to FWW since the early 90's, I tend to agree. It seems every couple years they repeat articles with different pictures and text. Seriously, how many times can you write about the "Best ever wipe on finish", the best way to chop a mortise, the best way to sharpen... I don't know why I continue to subscribe. I know, they are a business. They are there to make money and sell product. I always hope to see a good article by Hack, Becksvoort, and a couple others.
I don't know, it just seems WC is the place for me to go to get good information, no drama, and no BS.
A lot of the headache, whether it's on the Internet, in books, or even in conversation, comes from the many ways to achieve the same task. For beginners, what you can do is pretty clear, but how to get there is definitely not.
I'm very slowly making a run at a coherent story, at http://toolbytool.org/, but my rough completion goal for that is late 2020.
I'm sure that folks will have problems with whatever I come up with, but hopefully it will be enough to help people get started with less time spent lost in the pile. (Or maybe it too will just get lost in the pile.)
I have never felt like such an outsider as I did at my niece's wedding. She went to USC and her new husband when to Clemson. No fights, but there were a whole lot of football cheers for a wedding dance. Also, when did it become de rigueur for the new couple to head off for their honeymoon on a four wheeler?
I am literally thrilled with the opportunity to eatch Paul Sellets, Curtis Buchanan, Peter Follansbee and others do a task that lies in front of me and learn from them , and replay the video as many times as it takes to penetrate this thick skull.
OK certainly it eould be better to be standing next to their bench as I learn . Ain't gonna happen, so I love my internet connection with these guys.
A Form has "editors", to borrow a book analogy. If my son in law asked here if the clever jig he saw on Utube for making box joints should be replicated in his shop in lieu of learning to cut dovetails he would receive a sage answer.
the whole question of quality control was a big discussion item in academia, particularly among the librarians (who, by profession, are interested in ensuring that students of anything get good information for their studies. After all, if someone is told that Poe wrote "Romeo and Juliet," s/he will be sent down a seriously wrong/confusing path.
The state of the modern internet confirms that no one figured out the solution to this conundrum.
Ron Harper's right that there's lots of good information on the internet - much of it for free - that, in the old days, you'd have had to pay good money for and, more likely than not, drive to get to. I recall going to some of the workshops at wood shows years ago. The shows were always south of San Francisco, so I'd be driving two hours each way to get to a one hour workshop (well, I did spend plenty of time drooling over tools, took in the free workshops too, and usually signed up for a couple of the paid workshops, to get maximum value from the drive). Now, a lot of this information is a click away.
But there's also garbage. I've seen some videos on the internet that terrify me: if people took them as good advice, there'd be a lot of people walking around with nicknames like "Stubby" and "Three-Fingered Jack."
I've got no solution; just observing that the problem's not new, and it's difficult of solution.
That's certain. My wife took me to a wedding a month ago that was at a hunting camp. They can't run hunts all year, so they built a chapel and now have a sideline.
I was a self taught carpenter when I discovered Woodcentral. I learned about Ian Kirby here. Read his book and learned to cut dovetails. I learned of Frank Klaus,Krenov and many other woodworkers who I would never have heard of if it weren't for the internet. I met many woodworkers in the forums who influenced my direction in woodworking. I learned windsor chair building by watching videos of Curtis Buchanan on the internet. I have successfully built many cabinets and now chairs. I have met a few woodworkers in my area but they are few and far between. I learned it all by practice,reading and surfing the internet. It was the only option for me and I'm glad of it's invention. I don't believe everything I read here. I just take from it what I can use to further my education.---Jack
It's been quite a while since I posted on this forum. I come and read often, but only post when I feel like I can add something that hasn't already been said.
For sure, there's a lot of misleading information, and that's everywhere. Not just the YouTube video's. Do you think that good information is easy to get on the forum's? Most of it is, shall we say, sketchy at best.
My take is this....there are theoretical woodworkers; the guys who like to sit on the forums and argue about the best way to microskin and dissect the best procedure for setting a chipbreaker on a double iron plane (hope I didn't hit a nerve), and those that actually get in the shop, make some sawdust, and take 5 procedures out there with them, and figure out for themselves what the best way for THEM is.
I've been at this trade earning a living for almost 30 years, and I can tell you that there is never only 1 way to do anything. There's always several, and it's up to the individual to get their butt in the workshop and figure out for themselves (as long as it's safe!) what the best way is for them. Sooner or later, they will learn who to listen to for advice, and who is completely full of theoretical knowledge that doesn't translate to the saw and chisel.
At the ripe age of 52 (geez I'm getting old), at the behest of my family and friends over a couple year period, I just started my own YouTube channel to hopefully become a place where interested and like-minded guys and girls can come and get some answers that work. I'll be showing exactly how to do it, and alternative ways to get it done. If you're watching somebody's channel, and their showing their procedure, and it's maybe not the best way, but still gets it done......like I said, always more than 1 way to get there.
Plenty of ways to make grain pop in curly figured wood; plenty of ways to sharpen a plane iron or chisel; plenty of ways to cut a dado or groove across or down a board using hand or power tools. My point is, get it done! After a while, an inquisitive person will explore alternative methods for doing the same job, and figure out on their own what works best for them. They'll also figure out who's advice to totally ignore in the internet, due to it's theoretical nature.
Ok, back to the shadows for me.....hello Ellis. Met you at Montanafest.
Hi back at ya, Jeff. Montanafest is a distant but satisfying memory, I think for all of us who got the hat and t-shirt.
This topic goes to the essence of what we do here -- what we've always been about. I've been running forums and chat rooms since the AOL days in '94, and I've seen the evolution of internet woodworking from a real catbird seat. It really took off when bandwidth started growing exponentially about 15 years ago.
Having been in magazine world until then, I knew then that video was going to be key to the delivery of woodworking information -- real time moving images as opposed to two-dimensional photos and text. No contest. YouTube, with all its channels and opinions, is essentially a three-dimensional woodworking magazine; and all those individual voices are analogues to the individual opinions of magazine article authors. At least in magazines, you do have the benefit of some editorial oversight, although that, too, can vary greatly in quality and wisdom. Nevertheless, it's what differentiates and personalizes individual magazines, for better or worse.
The reason I've stuck with the forum format, as I've mentioned many times here over the years, is that I value the crowd-sourcing dimension that forums bring to the table. Topics open, generally, as queries, not lectures. And, as new voices and opinions are added, the outlines of the issue begin to emerge, often incorporating many of the same opinions as respected authors have voiced in magazines or YouTube channels, but also adding perspectives that contribute to what I used to call a "look around" the topic. In the magazine, we could provide a look-around with sidebars and alternate opinions, but it was rigid and bound by deadlines and production schedules. On the forum, it's fast and fluid and unbound -- not always edifying and sometimes not even valuable, useful or correct. But, depending on how active a thread is and how insightful the contributors are, it can provide a really wonderful look around a given topic.
Sorry for the pedantic nosebleed. I might as well be passionate about WoodCentral. It's more than the exchange of information; it's also about community. As I said in my original introduction to the site in '98, it's "by and for" you. Keep up the good work!
Thanks for replying, Ellis. No "pedantic nosebleed" here. I agree with what you're saying. I believe that an aspiring woodworker can learn a great deal from lively debate and discussion, as is found on this, and other, forums. It really doesn't take a very long time to figure out who's who, and what advise is worth running with, and what advise is, well.....
I only replied to this thread because I felt strongly about what I was trying to say. I think the online community of video's and forums is only going to get stronger, and print magazines are going to find themselves going the way of the dinosaur. Evolution of the ease of finding everything you need sitting at your computer, smart phone, tablet, or whatever your hardware is.....
BTW, slightly off topic, and I doubt you remember, but at Lee's place back in '05, you spent some time teaching me how to turn, along with Don. You may be happy to know that it only took 12 more years, but I'm finally turning in the shop. I'm restoring an Oliver lathe, and the addiction is growing....