Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

Posts

What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#1

What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

cross cut or rip. If someone knows it will save me a research project.

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#2

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill and all,

I suggest experiment on scrap with your saws. I just went and made a few test cuts with my Japanese saws. Rip and crosscut both did the job; rip was incrementally faster, but then what does fast matter when you're going less than an inch? Finer tooth is happier than coarser tooth.

Suggest make a couple test cuts with your finest-toothed saw, whether rip or cross, and see how that does for you. Then compare with your finest-toothed saw of the other gender.

If you were going to do a lot of this, you might consider a combination tooth saw like a not-so-expensive Sun Child Japanese saw (I'm assuming they still make them).

Wiley

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#3

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Western Saw, Japanese saw, cross cut, rip, three levels of tpi.

Hummmm, a 7 level factorial design. It has taken me almost 20 years to get started on this display cabinet. What's another few for Research!

At least so far no one has asked why I would want to dovetail Baltic birch :b

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#4

why on earth do you want to dovetail Baltic Birch


Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#5

But Bill, the research

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

consists of your going and trying out your saws on Baltic Birch scrap. How many fine tooth backsaws do you have?

That is, unless you intend to optimize a saw and go buy it, or have it made custom for you. The research is in your shop, isn't it?

Of course, I may be totally wrong :) . It's happened before.

Wiley

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#6

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, dovetailing is typically a rip cut. Why should a rip cut on Baltic Birch be any different to a rip cut on another wood?

How thick are the boards? Is the Birch the face- or side board?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#7

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The project has a sketch describing it in the story stick post. The side of the cabinet is like the door, namely a frame with a glass panel. A piece of veneered plywood top and bottom will hold it together, plywood because it will be dovetailed into the long grain of the top and bottom rail of the frame that makes the case side.

The half blind dovetails in the rail will be essentially cross cuts and I will presumably use a cross cut saw here. These sockets will be nasty to pare. The tails in the plywood are more complicated to analyze. The face veneers will be oriented for a rip cut but the plywood with orthogonal plies presents a mix of grain orientation. I use a combination blade on the table saw for plywood. Maybe I need a combination dovetail saw :) The ash face ply is 1/16" thick. I may have a difficult time starting a cross cut saw in it, but I'll bet the cross cut works best in the plywood......we shall see.

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

crosscut

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill,

If it were me,I would choose a crosscut saw.It may be a little more difficult but a rip saw could tear out.---Jack

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#9

It didn't make much difference

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

15 tpi LN dovetail vs 16 tpi LV cross cut. I had just sharpened the LN and the LV is new. I think it was a mistake to have sharpened the LN. It was grabby in the plywood.

I had never used these very different "looking" saws side by side. To my surprise I didn't detect much difference between them in the "feel" in the hand. There is no doubt that I will be recommending the greatly cheaper LV to others.

There were small differences in performance sawing the 13 ply birch core, ash veneered assembly. I found the LV harder to start but thought it sawed a bit smoother once it got going, but these differences were slight.

Sawing the tail waste at the tail board ends was easier with the cross cut, maybe because the thick ash veneer was being cross cut in this operation.

Given the small differences I expect 6 people would come to 6 different conclusions.

In both cases the plywood didn't saw as smoothly as solid wood. There was a vibration in the saw, I suppose caused by the teeth traversing the alternating hard grain of the birch plies.

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#10

Re: It didn't make much difference

Joe shelton

Did you use a full factorial analysis, or Taguchi methods to account for missing data?

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#11

Re: Arrrgh!

William Duffield

Bill, you are driving me nuts with these double posts! For some totally inexplicable reason, I always look at the Messages forum before the Hand Tool forum, and therefore miss getting involved in all the really interesting discussions. Couldn't you mark them as "Double Posted from Hand Tool Forum" or some such?

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/messages.pl/page/1/md/read/id/505501/sbj/what-saw-for-dovetailing-baltic-birch/

Derek, if you are comparing plywood to some of the other Oz woods,like I mentioned in my other post, yes, I agree, it's just like rip sawing. But most of us don't have that advantage, and for us ripping is significantly different than cross cutting. ;)

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#12

Cleaning up the tail board

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

To my surprise the tail board waste removal and clean was up was easier than solid wood. The dense (13 ply plus the ash) plywood pared easily. Again the core is birch so I am paring hardwood.....and glue.

Now I need to mark the pin board which in fact is a tall frame. Haven't decided how this will be done yet. I have enough issues marking a drawer. I am anticipating that doing pins in the rails is not going to be pleasant.

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#13

Re: Cleaning up the tail board

TomD

I just use whatever saw I have around that I don't mind sawing dovetails in plywood with. I used to make the neck joints on my guitars and some shop furniture out of baltic birch, or boat ply. I also use to use it when demonstrating my special way of cutting blanket boxes, it was just cheaper than making up scrap pieces for demonstrations alone. Most of these high end plies have tight glue lines and the glue probably doesn't hurt saws, but I still preferred caution. High end plies are also very nearly 50/50 in plies so there is little benefit one way or another. The Japanese have plywood saws, and they have dovetail saws that are a combination of rip and CC, they look like rip teeth, but have bevels on them.

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#14

That glue...

John in NM

Is really hard, btw.

Years ago I jointed the edges of some baltic birch to size it down to fit, or square it up, or something. Jointer then cut a nice micro-corrugated edge on everything else :D

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#15

Re: That glue...

William Duffield

Been there; done that, with lauan lumber core plywood. I learned from the boss that it was just considered a cost of doing business. Now, with a Festool tracksaw, I find it unnecessary to joint the edge of the ply after ripping or crosscutting or whatever you want to call it.

Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#16

Re: That glue...

TomD

I plane ply all the time with no ill effect. I do have hard blades in my planes, but they can't be that hard. When I built my trimaran i took one plane, with one sharpening, to the shop I was renting to build the boat. I planed plywood scarf joints (though it took too long and I built a jig with vac holdown that used a circ saw), I planed edges to trim the glass and epoxy back. These did wear out the wooden sole of the plane, but that was an easy fix. And of course I plane scarphs in solid wood, and bulheads projections and so forth. Over six months I never sharpened the plane and it had to project further and further to do any work. By the end it was useless, but it did work up to about that point. I had to resole it and sharpen the edge and it was back to work. $13.50 CAD LV Japanese plane blade in a NA white oak block.

When you plane 1-8 scarfs you get reasonably extensive exposure to the glue as you can see from the wide dark stripes between the even wider wood stripes. This pick was grabbed from the net. Guy who did it said "It does not take long to do and is pleasant work".


Re: What saw dovetailing Baltic birch

#17

Re: That glue...

John in NM

For what it's worth, it was a power jointer :O

Like you, I don't see the same effect with a handplane :D