New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Sargent transitional

Posts

Sargent transitional

#1

Sargent transitional

Joe shelton

I'm about to put a sole on a severely distorted and worn plane, and have two questions. One, I have some white oak. Will that work well? And two, I'm fairly certain that I see 34 on the front of the toe, but the remainder of the imprint is too faint to read (TVA has cut back on their output voltage, yet again). The plane measures 24", or a little over. If I recall correctly, the iron may be 2 3/8". Anyone know what I have?

Re: Sargent transitional

#2

Re: Sargent transitional *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

Here is a listing from Bob Kaune's excellent website:

https://www.antique-used-tools.com/sargent.htm

He lists two jointers, #3424 and #3426. Perhaps someone else can tell you whether the last two numbers, xx24 and xx26, refer to plane length.

Anyway, a possible clue......

Wiley


Bob Kaune's Sargent listing

Re: Sargent transitional

#3

Re: Sargent transitional *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You may find the link below useful.

People call these "transitionals," as if they were bridges between the old all-wood-but-the-cutting-iron planes and the newer all-metal planes. But, in fact, they existed side by side with the metal planes. Stanley produced some of its "transitionals" until 1943. I personally think "hybrid" is a better term.


http://www.timetestedtools.net/category/hand-planes/sargent/

Re: Sargent transitional

#4

Excellent link, and

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

the Sargent 1926 catalog shows jointer plane #3424 to be 24" long with a 2-3/8" iron; the other jointer being both longer and with a wider iron.

So Joe can look at his plane, including the 1926 advertising for it!

Wiley

Re: Sargent transitional

#5

TNX Wiley and Bill. And the oak sole?

Joe shelton

Still haven't started attaching a new sole. Will the white oak be a good choice?

Re: Sargent transitional

#6

I'm going to defer to people who know better

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm not confident on the wood movement of white oak vs. other species; so I'll let others weigh in on that question.

Re: Sargent transitional

#7

Re: Do Your Homework

William Duffield

You need to do the math yourself. It's good for you!

Go to the Wood Database:

www.wood-database.com/

or the USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Lab, Center for Wood Anatomy Research (where I strongly suspect the wood database gets their numbers):

https://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/research/centers/woodanatomy/

Look up and compare the wood movement rates of the two woods you want to glue together. The closer the numbers are, the less problem you will have in the long run, but you also need to consider how they were sawn so you can figure out how much of their radial expansion rates and how much of their tangential expansion rates are applicable. Since it is a western plane, its is probably quarter sawn beech, so the tangential number is mostly applicable there. A little simple trigonometry will help if there is a lot of difference in the grain directions. (If it were a Japanese plain, the dai would often be oak, not beech.) Oak wears well, but if you decide your white oak is inappropriate, or just risky, and want to consider other species in your collection, then to choose one, you will want to also consider it's hardness. This will give you a good idea of how well it will wear. Note that in the case of oaks, old growth wood with lots of rings per inch does not wear as well as new, fast grown oak. This is not necessarily the case for other species, especially diffuse porous ones.

Re: Sargent transitional

#8

wear?

Joseph Piotrowski

so a newbie hand tool question. does wear matter for an hobby woodworker?

it makes sense to me that a full time woodworker, flattening boards 8hrs a day for years would want the hardest most stable wood no mater the cost due to being paid.

but if you doing 8-16 hrs a week, will it matter?

i have several old planes in the rehab process and desire to make a few of my own. so i'm curious about this factor. i need to buy some wood soon.

TIA,

Joe P

Re: Sargent transitional

#9

Re: wear?

William Duffield

No way I could keep it up 8-16 hours a week. :( Rough calculation tells me that my hobby plane sole would only last 2-1/2 times as long as your straw man's plane, all else being equal. My straw man, otoh, would be worried about the wear on his cast iron infeed and outfeed tables and the cabide tooling in his helical head. :D

Re: Sargent transitional

#10

Re: wear?

Joseph Piotrowski

i'm pretty sure i could use the same helical head for like 10 years!

i'm also considering wear isn't much of factor. i wish that wood database had like actual database features where i could sort and filter.

Re: Sargent transitional

#11

Re: wear?

William Duffield

There are lots of old wooden planes with very open mouths, but it is a matter of speculation how and why the mouths were opened. Maybe they were planing ipe, or sidewalks? ;) Maybe they didn't know how to adjust a double iron? :\ Maybe the soles warped due to inundation in a flood? :b Maybe they were reclaiming barn boards in the Dust Bowl :( I'm sure you will find many domestics and exotics that will be more than sufficient for your needs. You don't have to follow ECE's lead and use lignum vitae. You probably would never wear out oak, ash, hickory, rock maple, dogwood, black locust, persimmon and many others. Others, like walnut, cherry, tulip poplar might be marginal, but your Borg softwoods, except SYP, would probably not wear very well at all. Some other domestic hardwoods might not be suitable because they tend to be unstable, or were not properly seasoned, are not straight grained, or have internal defects.

Re: Sargent transitional

#12

Re: Sargent transitional

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

You're not getting much advice on the question about white oak, so I'll share my ignorance with you :) . I'm assuming the oak is quarter sawn or rift, and the beech has generally horizontal grain:

1. The 'by the book' answer is that the beech has horizontal grain and the oak is generally vertical grain, so you have a cross-grain glue-up. This is thought to be risky. Now if the beech is rift, and the oak is rift too, then the issue goes away, for reasons listed in (2) below.

2. My experience (as well as some others who have posted here from time to time) is that the seasonal movement in already-dried hardwood is way less than the percentage radial and tangential movement listed for kiln-drying-from-wet. In other words, once the wood is dry, it doesn't move nearly as much. ($5 words like 'hysteresis' get mentioned in connection with this fact.) And when the dry wood is coated with a film coat, like shellac or varnish, seasonal movement is further retarded, though not stopped. Sometimes retarded is enough, especially for tools kept in a climate-controlled space.

3. Therefore, I am prepared to make a friendly bet of $20 that you could glue on a 1/4" thick slab of oak cross-grain with the beech, coat with shellac when dry, and wax it, and you'll never have a problem if the plane is kept in a climate-controlled place. This is just what I would bet, and I could be wrong.

4. For mostly aesthetic reasons, I would prefer to use plain-sawn hard maple (sugar maple) if I had any around, which I usually do. Why? Prefer the color; grain likely more favorable, depending on how the beech is sawn; finer grain than oak, so I could probably cut a cleaner mouth in it.

5. Would I go buy a new piece of wood rather than use the oak I already had? For my own shop use--no, especially if I wanted to get to work with the plane; if I were going to try to sell the plane or send it to someone else, yes.

Wiley

Re: Sargent transitional

#13

Re: wear? - No

TomD

I have a Japanese plane that I made with a US white oak sole and it has seen both some of my most abusive use, and longest use as I made it in the early 80s. I did wear out one sole, but at the time I was planing stuff like fiberglass, plywood, and I still occasionally do. Total cost of doing that was to pass the block through the planer, glue a new sole on, refit. I am not sure what plane we are talking about here, but if it is a transitional they also have square bases, so a refit is seconds of work. You can also make mouths more durable with endgrain saturation with epoxy, or you can just repair the mouth. All of these are nothing activities to someone who works wood.

My own belief is that the sole thing came in for marketing planes. If you think about it, how we as consumers feel about stuff, it seems reasonable to me that 1) when spending money we want reassurance the product will last, and 2) as woodworkers we want something we couldn't make at home. In an earlier time the average shop didn't maybe have Lignum in it, though it might have. But certainly affixing it with a criss cross of rebates would be pretty tough to do. So it adds to the idea the maker has some unique capability I should pay for. Of course the whole idea of attaching two dissimilar woods is not great.

By the way, at most times, the sole of my planes do not wear through the finish, or maybe around the mouth a little. These days few hobby woodworkers keep the same planes around, so lifetimes of use are an illusion.

Re: Sargent transitional

#14

Agree up to point 5

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Everyone needs some hard maple. Go buy some and use it for the task at hand. If you do any woodworking you will find good use for the left overs.

Disclaimer: I used to sell lumber :)