Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

Posts

Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have both the curved bottom and flat shaves by veritas. These are the wood handled adjustable types designed similar to a stanley 151. I use these every day for many chairbuilding tasks and they work well. I am looking at the brass shaves sold by Lie-Nielsen that were designed by Brian Boggs. I've heard alot of good things about these shaves.

What I am wondering about is whether they are any different in use than the ones I have. Is there any advantage in acquiring them in addition to what I have? Do they function better at any tasks than the veritas ones,or are they just another tool of the same type only built out of different materials?

Has anyone had the opportunity to use both that could give an opinion on this subject?

Happy New Year everyone.---Jack

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#2

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

TomD

Jack, I haven't used the Boggs shaves that LN makes, but I own the LV shaves, and the Boggs shave he made with LV before he made ones with LN. It is basically the same as the LN models, though it was smaller than the current LV ones, and maybe it would be smaller than the LN ones also.

Functionally they are really similar to use when you arecutting. The LN just added the adjusters and the spacers. I have never bothered with the spacers, and if I did want to use stack thickness to narrow the mouth I would probably just bake up a new blade in my shop. The adjusters work as well as anyone elses, but there is something to be said of the simplicity of the single retaining screw, in that you can tap adjust cut, or skew at will, and it becomes very fluid. Of course that kind of learning curve (of a few minutes) is what folks who want the adjusters are trying to avoid.

Myself, I wish LV had been able to continue with the Boggs designs in quality bronze, in the size of their current shaves, but it didn't happen. LV is 10 minutes down the road; the LV shaves are cheaper; they work fine; I won't be replacing them ( did replace Records with the adjustors when I bought the LV shaves, and the records replaced Kuntz. At this point I am done), but I probably would prefer the ones LN is now making, just not going to change out for them, unless they came up with some trade in deal. :)

I think the next step beyond what the boggs shaves are is Japanese shaves, pretty easy to make (not so sure about a concave mouth shave though.

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thanks Tom. That really answers my question.---Jack

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#4

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

Tony

I haven't tried either but have been trying to make the same decision as you. I just ordered the LV shave with the free shipping mainly because of the PM-V11 blade and mouth adjustablility. I'm sure I'll be happy with it but I think I would have been happy with the Boggs LN (it sure is pretty).

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#5

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

William Duffield

I have the curved L-N Boggs shave, and love it. However, I don't have a Veritas shave that I can compare it to. The only issue with the L-N shave is that it is only a finish tool, due to the tight mouth. You cannot set it to hog off thick shavings, but I don'e expect that is a problem for you, since you probably have all sorts of chair making tools to accomplish that part of the process. Another minor issue is you can't get it with a PM-V11 blade.

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#6

There was a time when......

roger lance

I could claim to be an expert on tennis racquets.....and my preference was Bancroft bamboo laminated frames.....and, even of those there were only a couple of models that gave me the feel, power, and control I sought.

To be sure, there were other racquets that were desirable.....played, used, and endorsed by the greats of those days. But, my muscles, my timing, my game had become habituated to Bancrofts after countless hours of use.

I think it is the same with good hand tools....some prefer this brand.....someone else prefers that brand.....and there are craftsmen producing great work with lowly regarded tools as well.

In tennis, I never much cared which brand of stick a guy used.....just what he could do with it.

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#7

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Like Wm., I have the LN Boggs shave (the straight one), but no LV shave to compare with. The Boggs shave is a great tool. I have tried to figure out why--balance, heft, very solid feel.

One main thing I like about it is the fact that the handles sit low, not far above the blade line. This gives it a very solid and quick action when shaving with one hand, and holding the stick in the other, like if you're making a hammer handle. The low handle means there is little or no upward moment, so that your force is in direct line with the blade edge and the shaving. it hugs the cut without your thinking about it as you shave away, rotating the stick with the off hand.

The LV shave may have this very same property, and Jack would be in position to know, of course. But the Boggs shave is a pleasure. Best of the New Year to all!

Wiley

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#8

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

William Duffield

I had no idea why I like mine so much, but your analysis makes a lot of sense. Before I got the L-N Boggs shave, my favorite was a simple, old Bailey with a 1858 patent date*. It's too cold in the shop this afternoon to do any ergonomic analysis of a cast iron spoke shave, or even a wooden handled one. I think Leonard Bailey probably understood a lot about the tools he designed and built. :)

When I first met Brian Boggs several years ago at a woodworking show, he was using a prototype of this shave. I've wanted one ever since, and I have no idea why I put off buying it for so long. Maybe it's because I learned very well how to control rasps, files and scrapers, and didn't find much advantage in the modern spokeshaves I have.

* 21,311, Aug. 13, 1858, Securing Plane (& Shave) Irons, Leonard Bailey, Winchester, Mass.

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

finishing shave

Jack Guzman from Maine

What I got from all your responses is that the Boggs shave is basically a fine finishing tool and as such I have a place for it in my chairbuilding process. The LV shave is my go-to spokeshave for most operations. After initial shaping with a drawknife and then drying I do the final shaping of my spindles with it.I find though that when I'm cleaning up the chair before painting,it is hard to get an acceptable surface from it. I usually folllow up with a scraper. Also when fine tuning the shape of the seat I need a finer tool for putting in the finishing cuts. I'm hoping that the Boggs will excel at this.

Thanks for all your help.---Jack

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#10

Re: finishing shave

Tony

From what I've read and seen I think you are correct in your assessment of the Boggs. I think it would excel at what you want.

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#11

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

My assessment is essentially the same as yours. I must be clear that I have not used the Veritas shaves. My early experiences came with Stanley #51 vs #151, and I learned that I preferred spokeshave sans adjusters. It seemed to me that the latter had a lower centre of gravity, and this improved balance and control. Of course, one cannot conclude that this would be the case with the Veritas spokeshaves as well.

I moved to the HNT Gordon shaves (woodies). These are similar to Japanese designs but with a high cutting angle (55 degrees). They are the ones I turn to with interlocked or reversing grain. For roughing out I like the Stanley #51 because of its wide mouth, and add to this a Stanley #53, which has a variable mouth.

Several years ago I purchased the Boggs shaves. I have all three. As mentioned by others, they could be considered finishing tools. However, one can (and should) just open the mouth if this is not the task one wants them for. I really like their balance and control. I may try making a different set of handles for them as the existing round set reduce control. One learns to put up with these features, but it is not necessary to continue doing so. The hollow handles of the Stanleys and the rectangular handles of the HNT Gordon offer much more directional information.

Lastly, I have the Veritas LA Spokeshave. This is great on endgrain.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#12

Re: finishing shave

Kevin Adams

Jack,

I didn't get the chance to reply yesterday. You are correct (and what others have said), the LN is a well balanced, fine finishing tool. There are always trade-offs as toolmakers add things and while the LV adjusters are handy, I find that they make the tool seem top heavy. The open mouth is nice though.

There is something about the LN where you can cradle it in your hands (or use one handed as someone above said), while feeling the edge of the wood. I will often have one hand on the shave and then the other underneath while feeling the wood as I go...very sensitive and you can feel the fairness of the curve or where the facets need a touch more work.

Take care,

Kevin

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#13

Adjusters

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Yes, adjusters can make a shave feel top heavy/off balance. I also find, although I seem to be the only person who ever brings this up, that they can get in the way in inside work. My Stanley flat shaves can go around a corner tighter than the adjusters can fit into.

But I just like the sports car feel of a shave without adjusters.

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#14

Boggs Shaves

Ron Harper

I have the Veritas. I have tried the Lie Nielsen. There is no comparison The L N is a better tool. Also more expensive. Did not buy it as I love my antique Prestons

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#15

Re: Boggs Shaves

Tony

Since I'm due to receive my new Veritas shave tomorrow, can you please elaborate why you think the LN Boggs is the better tool lol?

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#16

Jack Guzman from Maine

Ordered.


Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#17

Go with the Boggs?


Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#18

Re: Boggs Shaves

TomD

1) I think the simple answer is that the material that goes into the adjusters on the LN, goes into the body on the Boggs, and to boot on mine the body is bronze. (I don't particularly buy the idea the adjusters make the tool top heavy and I assume they are removable.)

2) Then you have the whole simplicity of inertial adjustments vs, screws. Normally on this board I am the guy pushing the simplicity of say Japanese planes (or the shaves as above), while the rest are all for the latest gew gaws. But since I have been buying LV tools since the 70s and never lived more than 20 minutes from one of the stores while in town, I bought their line of shaves. My first non-dad assisted project was when I built bent shaft paddles in the 70s/80s and I used spokeshaves for those (love to try out the LV monster shave). But at the end of the day, if you can handle a simple adjustment system, then why would you use a complex one.

So to some extent when you look at the shape of the Boggs blade, or the mass of the frame casting, the reason for those features is so you can adjust the blade by just hitting the thing against something. This is made clear in his spokeshaves tape. I do this all the time with my Japanese planes. If they aren't set just so I tap, them against something like the endgrain of what I am working on. You would miss it if you were just watching. But again, I think you could do that to some extent with the LV.

This approach requires parts that have weight, have de-horned surfaces so the striking doesn't beat stuff up, and things like heavy blades so that when you rap the frame the blade moves, or curved blade shoulders so you can rap and get a blade skew in or out.

LV is a very ethical company. I don't know the story about how they gave the Boggs shave its first break, but it ended up being made by LN. But it is like LV to just carry on, and cover the part of the market that wants adjusters, and wants info on how to reset the concave blades to OE specs. Wants the tool that will have various settings for different work styles, etc...

3) It is worth remembering that Boggs went all mechanical at one point and now is also in the studio furniture biz. Would he still use shaves at all if he wasn't in the tool biz. I imagine he would, but he is making his furniture, and is totally up front about this, with as much tooling as he can reasonably use. He figured in order to make his furniture pay he would have to either sell at insane prices or raise his production. A guy like him can end up in a box when he starts from the craftsmanship end but ends up a designer. How do you monetize superior designs, if you came up through the craftsmanship end. At some point he may break into a Maloofian stage where he is mechanized to a large degree and is able to charge insane prices. But regardless. He isn't a Luddite, so his shaves are basically finishing tools.

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#19

Re: Boggs Shaves

Tony

Good explanations Tom. I may end up with a Boggs down the road but right now I needed a flexible solution to be able to take off a bit more material without permanently altering the tool. In that way I'm in a bit different situation than the OP.

I have one tangential question on the Boggs: why is it bedded at 40*?

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#20

Re: A few of my shaves

TomD

Some pics of shaves for reference as to sizes, etc...

These are my two groups, the ones I keep at the bench, and the ones I keep in the roll for portability


Inside the roll, room to carry all the shaves though I generally don't. I used to have a Kuntz with a big radius, but it was cheaply made and snapped.


Size and form comparisons for the LV and record shaves. The top one is the LV Boggs.


Bench wall storage:


What a Boggs wants to be when it grows up. You could set this to take 4 tens.


Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#21

Jack Guzman from Maine

yes

Jack Guzman from Maine

I already have the one from Lee Valley

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#23

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

Larry Barrett

There is an advantage of the LV spokeshaves that I haven't seen mentioned. It is not uncommon, especially if working with green (moist/wet) wood for shavings to get stuck in the mouth of the shave. If you can't pull them out it is then necessary to remove the iron to clear the shavings. The LV with the adjusters makes it very easy to reassemble the shave and replace the iron in the same (or very close) position and get back to work.

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

#24

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Spokeshave : Veritas vs. Boggs

Jack Guzman from Maine

I like that feature and take advantage of it quite a bit because alot of the work I do is with green oak.---Jack