Re: Boggs Shaves
TomD
1) I think the simple answer is that the material that goes into the adjusters on the LN, goes into the body on the Boggs, and to boot on mine the body is bronze. (I don't particularly buy the idea the adjusters make the tool top heavy and I assume they are removable.)
2) Then you have the whole simplicity of inertial adjustments vs, screws. Normally on this board I am the guy pushing the simplicity of say Japanese planes (or the shaves as above), while the rest are all for the latest gew gaws. But since I have been buying LV tools since the 70s and never lived more than 20 minutes from one of the stores while in town, I bought their line of shaves. My first non-dad assisted project was when I built bent shaft paddles in the 70s/80s and I used spokeshaves for those (love to try out the LV monster shave). But at the end of the day, if you can handle a simple adjustment system, then why would you use a complex one.
So to some extent when you look at the shape of the Boggs blade, or the mass of the frame casting, the reason for those features is so you can adjust the blade by just hitting the thing against something. This is made clear in his spokeshaves tape. I do this all the time with my Japanese planes. If they aren't set just so I tap, them against something like the endgrain of what I am working on. You would miss it if you were just watching. But again, I think you could do that to some extent with the LV.
This approach requires parts that have weight, have de-horned surfaces so the striking doesn't beat stuff up, and things like heavy blades so that when you rap the frame the blade moves, or curved blade shoulders so you can rap and get a blade skew in or out.
LV is a very ethical company. I don't know the story about how they gave the Boggs shave its first break, but it ended up being made by LN. But it is like LV to just carry on, and cover the part of the market that wants adjusters, and wants info on how to reset the concave blades to OE specs. Wants the tool that will have various settings for different work styles, etc...
3) It is worth remembering that Boggs went all mechanical at one point and now is also in the studio furniture biz. Would he still use shaves at all if he wasn't in the tool biz. I imagine he would, but he is making his furniture, and is totally up front about this, with as much tooling as he can reasonably use. He figured in order to make his furniture pay he would have to either sell at insane prices or raise his production. A guy like him can end up in a box when he starts from the craftsmanship end but ends up a designer. How do you monetize superior designs, if you came up through the craftsmanship end. At some point he may break into a Maloofian stage where he is mechanized to a large degree and is able to charge insane prices. But regardless. He isn't a Luddite, so his shaves are basically finishing tools.