Re: questions for Bill
John in NM
Years ago I knew a guy who made petrographic thin sections. He had two 24" iron laps that spun and were contained in a large sink. He had two polishing grits of diamond in big shaker bottles and didn't seem to worry about contamination much as he could flush the whole thing with large amounts of water.
My conclusion from watching him work was that diamond does not embed easily in iron. Rinse it well before charging (1 lap or plate for each grit) and it should be fine. --- BUT --- he was not using anything to press the diamond grit into the laps, as I believe most people do for honing, and he was not using oil for lube, so water flushing worked well.
Another BUT - the petrographer might actually be less fastidious about the polish of a thin section than the woodworker is about a chisel! 
(the humor actually probably won't work without knowing a few petrographers - they are typically fussy people).



