New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

diamond paste question

Posts

diamond paste question

#1

diamond paste question

Bruce Mack

Since starting to hollow grind, I've been using my Veritas plates again, perhaps because the two ridges of the hollow give such positive registration on a metal plate. Anyway, I wanted a fresh tube of 6 micron paste as my old tube had dried. I found a 7 micron paste from a seller "goldencoulee" (moderator-this is not an overt plug but feel free to delete seller name) which works really quickly as judged from a black swarf. The edge sharpens right away and I then move to 1 micron paste on a plate followed by chromium oxide on a strop. I assume that pastes have widely varied diamond concentration and I stumbled on one of the higher grade. This does make a big difference in my ease of sharpening. Thought I would mention this and see if others have had a similar experience.

Re: diamond paste question

#2

Re: diamond paste question

Chuck Bjorgen

I'm curious about the steel honing plates from Veritas. I'm aware that conventional wisdom says cast iron is the best medium for diamond paste but I've to been unable to find any that are reasonably priced. I also don't have any machine shop friends. I picked up a 7- pack of diamond paste on eBay with grits ranging from .25 to 5 microns, total cost with shipping from Hong Kong was $8.

I've tried one of the 1 micron pastes on planed hardwood and it certainly seems to work. Are the Veritas plates a reasonable solution? And can these be cleaned to use a different grit? Thanks in advance.

Re: diamond paste question

#3

where to buy, and other stuff

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" I've been using my Veritas plates again, perhaps because the two ridges of the hollow give such positive registration on a metal plate."

I think you have discovered one of the three main reasons for using a metal plate, that, and speed and cost.

Curious, what do you think a reasonable cost would be for a plate that is superior to a "stone" for sharpening?

Two reliable sources of diamond paste are a machine shop supply and a lapidary supply store. I would be skeptical of the grading and concentration from other places.

PS I thought of another advantage. I like my 12" plates. The extra length makes sharpening more convenient. One would need to get a home loan to buy a modern stone 12" long. And another....they stay flat.

Re: diamond paste question

#4

Re: where to buy, and other stuff

Bruce Mack

Bill- I think I paid well less than $100 for the initial Lee Valley offer of 3 plates and paste, possibly $75. They're now sold for ~$25 apiece. I'm pleased with them and use only 2 as the middle grit of 3 microns seems unnecessary. I cannot get an edge as good as my 15,000 Shapton with 1 micron diamond and don't mind the final step of chromium oxide stropping which does refine the sharpness.

As you said, it's quite convenient and cheap and I don't have to flatten stones. When I'm done I drop a piece of waxed paper over the plates to keep debris from settling on them while I work in the shop. I'm not fastidious about cleaning the plane iron as I move to the finer grit, using just a paper towel to wipe the iron before transfer. I even leave the glop on the plates and just freshen it with a drop of oil before the next use, cleaning them with mineral spirits only when the honing becomes slow. This works for me.

Thanks for the lapidary shop suggestion. I would pay $50 for a cast iron plate and even considered buying a table saw wing to use. Next life :)

Chuck- I'd recommend 2 plates so you don't have to clean the plate each time you change grit. Also I suspect the Hong Kong price reflects a low diamond concentration.

Re: diamond paste question

#5

Re: diamond paste question

Hank Knight

Chuck,

I'm certainly no expert on diamond sharpening technology, but I'll give you my observations. I bought a Japanese steel kanaban sharpening plate several years ago and tried it with 5 micron diamond paste. It worked OK, but I was not impressed. It went into a drawer and stayed there. Recently I invested in a cast iron plate that a friend flattened and polished for me on his surface grinder. It has a very fine, flat surface. I'm using 3 micron diamonds on it as my finishing "stone." It performs miles better than the steel kanaban.

After using the CI plate for a while I dragged out the kanaban and charged it with 15 micron diamonds to flatten the back of a chisel. It performed much better than it did with the finer mesh diamonds. The kanaban has machining marks - tiny grooves - in the surface. I believe the fine mesh diamonds failed to imbed well in the hard steel and quickly got swept into the grooves along with the swarf. This slowed the cutting action considerably. The coarser diamonds may have imbedded better in the steel or continued to cut even after they were swept into the machining grooves. This is pure speculation on my part, but the coarser 15 micron diamonds clearly worked better on the steel than the finer 5 micron ones did.

Cast iron is much softer than the steel kanaban, and the fine diamonds imbed well in the polished surface. Consequently, they continue to cut aggressively for a long time, and surface of the CI plate remains smooth and flat.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: diamond paste question

#6

Suppliers

John in NM

Graves Lapidary in Florida sells both loose grit and paste in their own packaging, and outfits like Kingsley North and the Rock Peddler sell Crystalite diamond compound. Graves is most likely buying Crystalite stuff in bulk and re-labeling it. Crystalite is the industry leader in lapidary diamond.

The only downside to a lapidary supplier for this is that they tend to list the size in grit rather than micron, but its not too hard to find a chart online to convert (14,000 grit is 1 micron - that's the only one I ever seem to remember).

Loose grit is the cheapest way to buy it usually, but for sharpening the paste will be the most efficient.

Re: diamond paste question

#7

Re: diamond paste question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Chuck, I got 1 and 3 micron paste from Woodcraft some years ago but now the Bloomington store doesn't carry it at all and neither does Rocklers. I got a tube of 15 micron paste (and fantastic service) from MN lapidary supply in Princeton, MN.

A friend of mine gave me a chunk of cast iron and I arranged to have it surface ground at the local community college machine tools program. They do it for free as a training opportunity for students.

Re: diamond paste question

#8

Re: diamond paste question

Chuck Bjorgen

Hi Bruce -- I recall your telling me about getting the cast iron from a friend. I need a friend like that. Do you have separate plates for different grits or is that one big plate? I've read Derek Cohen's article on making plates out of broken hand plane bases but I have no such items. I've also checked the various sites that sell plates all of which seem way larger than what I'd want. They're also very pricey.

This is all pretty academic to me because I already have several sharpening systems and the one I routinely turn to now is the ceramic medium and ultra fine

Spiderco stones followed by a leather strop. But, you know...always messing around.

Re: diamond paste question

#9

Re: Questions for Discussion

William Duffield

I've noted comments on superiority of CI over steel, but has anyone used ductile iron? There are at least 3 plane makers using it who might be able to manufacture plates.

Has anyone asked old tool dealers to be on the lookout forbroken #8 bodies?

Re: diamond paste question

#10

Re:More Questions

William Duffield

I've mixed Chromium Oxide with mineral oil and loaded it into a syringe for charging a strop. Why not do the same with loose diamond?

Re: diamond paste question

#11

Re: diamond paste question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have one big block (3 x 12) for 1 and 3 micron and another smaller one 3 x 6" for 15 and 3 micron. The small one was made from a chunk of cast iron bathtub. The small one is to take along when we travel and I want to bring a project to work on.

Re: diamond paste question

#12

Re:More Questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

No reason not to. The lapidary supply guy told me essentially the same thing. He said that's what rockhounds do.

Re: diamond paste question

#13

Re:More Questions

John in NM

The only reason I can think of is that diamond is kind of overkill for stropping on leather. The advantage of diamond on an iron or other metal surface (tin or copper in lapidary work) is that only a tiny amount is needed to do the job. The relatively soft strop material is typically heavily loaded with polishing media compared to a plate loaded with diamond.

Re: diamond paste question

#14

Re: Questions for Discussion

John in NM

I would not expect there to be a great difference between the two. Ductile iron is just a more resilient version of cast iron as I understand it. I seem to remember reading that the difference between the two is that the free carbon is rounded in shape leading to less weakness in the metal's crystal structure. I may be mis-remembering however.

Re: diamond paste question

#15

Crucible Tool, Lee Valley, Lie Nielsen...

Bruce Mack

...Tools for Working Wood, Bridge City and perhaps others have the capacity or sources to produce 3 x 8 cast iron plates. Is there a market? I'd love to see someone sell or set up a subscription plan for these. Although I thought $50 was my limit, now it's $100. I just want to try them before crossing the Rainbow Bridge.

Re: diamond paste question

#16

You'd think....

John in NM

That one of those outfits would have done a few to see how it went. I tried to get a friend interested a few years ago - he has tons of machine tools, including a couple horizontal mills, perfect for this job. No luck, too busy making the stuff he makes already.

Biggest problem I think is sourcing the material for a small run - Looking at $43 for 3" x 12" piece, and then it needs surfacing. An outfit like LN or Lee Valley that regularly works with cast iron wouldn't have that problem though.

Re: diamond paste question

#17

Re:More Questions

William Duffield

I was thinking more about starting with loose diamonds and mixing up your own pastes for charging metal plates, and maybe saving some money and giving you better control of the properties of the pastes.

Re: diamond paste question

#18

Re:More Questions

John in NM

Oh, I see now. Sorry about the confusion.

Yes, that should certainly be feasible, though perhaps not practical as a savings mechanism. Depends on how good one is at stuffing grease into little tubes :D

I suppose a jar would do as well, something small with a wide mouth. One could put the grease of choice in there, sprinkle in some grit and mix, then dab it out as needed during sharpening.

Other than cost savings, the main reason I can see to try this is that I believe the commercial preparations use a silicone grease (I do know that those "extender fluids" they sell for use with the paste are silicone oil). Having not heard of any adverse results from those like Bill who've used this stuff for years, I don't imagine it is a major issue however.

Re: diamond paste question

#19

questions for Bill

Bruce Mack

How do you isolate the plates/diamond media from each other, i.e. what cleaning of the blade between plates? What is the practical consequence of a little transfer of 6 micron paste to the 1 micron plate? I would guess that embedding has a half life and eventually the plate is cleared of the coarser grit.

Re: diamond paste question

#20

Re:More Questions *LINK*

William Duffield

Been there, done that! I stuffed mine into Monoject 412 syringes, and in the process got oobleck all over everything! But, now it's contained, and finally in a very convenient form.


Bartholomew and the Oobleck

Re: diamond paste question

#21

dry particles vs paste

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Dry particles are inconvenient compared to paste. Cheap as I am I see good value in buying paste. I have containers of particles that sit unused. But dry particles are cheaper.

Re: diamond paste question

#22

answers, thoghts and opinions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"How do you isolate the plates/diamond media from each other, i.e. what cleaning of the blade between plates?" I believe that if you use loose diamonds on cast iron there is no way to avoid cross contamination if more than one grit size is used. I only use loose diamond in one particle size for my sharpening regime. My notions are confirmed by what I have read from the machine shop literature using loose diamond on cast iron. (It's not my invention, been around for decades).

What is the practical consequence of a little transfer of 6 micron paste to the 1 micron plate? First, this step is way too small. 15 micron to 1 is more ideal. History: Early on we used WAY too much diamond to charge a plate. We experienced significant carry-over of coarse particles to the fine plate. Thus, it became a notion that carry-over was fatal and must be avoided. Maybe it is not the issue we once thought now that plates are charge with times less material. I need to get brave and just try it again.

"I would guess that embedding has a half life and eventually the plate is cleared of the coarser grit. " Diamonds are tough and don't break down like other abrasive particles. I don't know how long it would be to "clear" a contaminating particle. Now if I knew how to scrap cast iron, that would be a way to restore a plate. But I have never been successful in scraping because I don't know how.

Re: diamond paste question

#23

Re: questions for Bill

Hank Knight

Like Bill, I only use on grit size in my sharpening regimen. Consequently, I have no problem with cross contamination. While diamonds may speed up the sharpening process for those who use more traditional methods, I don't find the nominal increase in speed/efficiency the attraction. For me the attraction of diamonds is the ability to sharpen modern abrasive-resistent steels. I sharpen with oil stones and a strop. While I like the simplicity of oil stones, I struggled for years to get a really keen edge on my A2 cutting tools with them. I added a single step to my regimen and solved the problem. I added 3 micron diamonds on a CI plate as the final step before the strop - problem solved. I get great edges now on my A2 chisels and plane irons without completely trashing my sharpening regimen and starting over. You might want to see if the addition of one or two diamond steps to your current sharpening regimen will accomplish your goal rather than going to diamonds completely. It's less disruptive and a lot less expensive.

Re: diamond paste question

#24

Re: diamond paste question

TomD

I am having my best result using hard leather over mahogany. It isn't sinking the paste, I have used very little over the several years I have been at it. I don't sharpen with this stuff since it is slow compared to power, I refresh edges constantly with the stuff. Leather has proven ideal. I have amazing cast iron as I was briefly in tight with a guy who restored machine tools professionally until he retired. But the leather suits my needs. I have several source of goo, but so far am working my way slowly through a tube from LV. I got their three grits, and I think I am using the middle one. I wouldn't get held up looking for idea cast. You can try a little on the bottom of a plane to see if you like it.

Re: diamond paste question

#25

Re: diamond paste question

Bruce Mack

Thanks Hank and Tom. I've tried and liked waterstones. The Shaptons I have are spritz-and-use, so not inconvenient but for the occasional need to flatten and precautions to avoid rust on tools. For a while I thought that Spyderco ceramics might substitute, but unlike Derek I cannot get the edge I want on plane irons. The Veritas plates are easy to use and ready to go under waxed paper. I use 2 grits, 7 and 1 micron after doing the initial post grinding prep on a medium or fine diamond stone. The renewal sequence is just 7 - 1 - strop.

Cast iron is unnecessary but I want to try it and wonder if I can get the edge I want without stropping. Bill's plates have made it possible. All this is frivolous and less important than just about everything, but it's fun.