New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Any Ece Primus plane owners?

Posts

Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#1

Any Ece Primus plane owners?

Joseph Piotrowski

I'm looking at picking up a smother and a joiner plane.used. Any special care it tips on setting them up. I been restoring, using some of the old school wooden planes. They old tap with a hammer kind.

These look a little more advanced with the mechanical adjuster. In just wondering if they are good for a beginner hand tool user. Any information on the care, usage and maintenence would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks,

Joe

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#2

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

Neal in SC

I have their smoother and jointer. I seldom use them, altho they can be made to work well. My problem is that their mechanical adjuster is complicated and takes a lot longer to get the blade out to sharpen and back in. Thus, I end up using them past the point where I know I should resharpen. So I grab a plane that is less fussy to maintain. I don't think I'd recommend one for a beginner - or anyone else for that matter. HTH Neal

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#3

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

Hank Knight

I also have a Primus jointer and smoother (must be a South Carolina thing). Like Neal, I seldom use them for the same reasons his sit on the shelf: the fiddly, tedious mechanism, especially on the smoothr, makes them difficult to sharpen. Except for that, I like the smoother a lot - it works great when properly sharpened and set up. Google Primus reform smoother set up. There's an article on the internet about setting up the smoother to keep the iron from slipping out of adjustment. It's not as straightforward as you might think and the article explains he proper set-up clearly.

I find the jointer impossibly big and clumsy to use. Mine sits on the shelf and has been there for years. I've thought about selling it; but it was my father's, so I guess I'll hang on to it for sentimental reasons. The first time I tried to use it, I discovered that the sole had a nice bow in it. The plane had sat on my shelf, and I guess my father's shelf, unused for a very long time with tension on the adjustment mechanism. I don't know if the tension caused the plane to bow, but I suspect it did. With some work on my tailed jointer and my Stanley 607, I got it flat again and it works fine - at least it did the last time I used it. I leave it now with the adjustment mechanism relaxed and it has stayed flat.

My $.02. Good luck with your planes.

Hank

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#4

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

Bruce Mack

Not quite what you asked, but I have a hammer-adjusted ECE smoother. For reasons I can't determine I have never gotten it to plane well. It seems well built and of course is hardly used. Maybe like the sword in the stone, it needs the right hand. If you'd like it, just send me your address to the e-mail address in my profile.

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#5

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

Joe shelton

I'm not in SC, but I am a Gamecock, and I agree with Neal and Hank. When I get the smoother fettled and use it, it is a terrific tool. I'm just too lazy to do that, and decided not to get the big one.

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#6

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

TomD

I have two smoothers, and a jack, I don't use them much either, but that is not a knock on the planes, I have always mostly used my own planes, but over 35 years or so, I buy the odd other plane to try something new out. So there are a lot of planes around at any one time.

There is no such thing as planes that are more advanced or better than the wedge kind, that was the apex of development, nothing since is better. But the mechanical adjustments work very well, and the ECE planes are amazing devices, wholly better than the Bailey style over her. It is always worth considering that the Germans still have an apprenticeship system, people over there who charge for woodwork are all at a higher initial level than anything you see over here. I was walking down the road in Bremen at one point and a shop was being refitted and the whole thing was full of every piece of gear Inca made, as it is all portable. Similar idea today would be the excellence of Festool. So these are the planes they use, they are good enough for anything you may need them for.

I have a slightly off assessment, because at that time I replace the blades in every western plane I got with Blue Steel Japanese plane blades, which makes them super charged. For one thing one doesn't need to resharpen as often.

I have to agree they are a little fiddly, that is just a manipulation deal. The way the blades are retained is very well designed, rather than the clumsy and bulky lever cap, the blade is adjusted for depth and firmness to the body by a spling loaded T that fits through a slot in the blade assembly. The strust on this unit is paraller to the sole and to the rear. Since the bed is angled this creates a vector up the bed angle, so the dept adjust works on this T. It is an excellent system, except when you go to take it apart, you need to back off both knobs just so and rotate the T in the right direction. This is awkward when first attempted, so it is the kind of deal you want to practice in front of the TV for a while until it become neat and second nature.

So on the question of whether these are tools for beginners, well there is nothing high end about the skills required to use them. I have never really had any trouble with the wedges, but people do find them tricky, this is not that. In use you get superb adjustments, zero backlash on adjustments, zero interference with the chip escapement that no other plane can claim, and you get the efficiency advantages of a wooden plane, it's light weight and low friction. I am not a fan of the look of the smoothers, but the horn arrangement is very comfortable and very usable in push or pull. So really the only downside is the tricky manipulation of parts during disassembly, it isn't hard on the hands like some planes. It is like starting a chainsaw, you sorta need to have read the starting instructions, and follow a procedure. If you take a few minutes to familiarize yourself it should go smoothly. It isn't an expert woodworker thing, just a mechanism.

The only thing really against them is will you be happy with them. If you follow the mags, blogs, videos, etc... These are not the tools you will see. They might be better but will you feel the need to make another purchase later? Even Franz Klausz gave them up because they were not the planes his students had. The videos I found on Youtube were in German.

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#7

Excellent analysis!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Tom's analysis is outstanding.

Couple of details i would add, speaking of the reform smoother, the one with the adjuster. It has a 48mm iron, about 1-7/8" wide, which in my opinion is about ideal for temperate hardwoods. I also like the 49-50 degree bedding--you can go for either tight mouth or close chipbreaker to control tearout. The lignum sole on mine has not moved nor worn in 10-15 years. The bedding can't move on you, because the blade rests on standoff metal studs up top. It's quality.

Yeah, the mechanism is fiddly, but effective. And the adjuster is much finer, more precise, and no backlash.

As Tom said, there is really nothing against this plane, and much for it. But as he also said, it puts you outside the cultural mainstream in the US, and so you would always wonder if you shoulda got the LN or the LV plane--until finally you do.

I use mine. Why? It has the quality of being 'handy'. It doesn't care if it is coming or going--I pull as much as I push. it's smooth on wood due to the lignum. You can make a superfine adjust very easily and quickly.

It's an excellent plane, but not an easy recommendation, as an LN or LV would be.

Wiley

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#8

thank you all

Joseph Piotrowski

for the heads ups on what you guys like or don't. some great info

seam like it's just getting a few and trying them and learn the tool. since my experience is limited with hand planes, i'll learn something for sure.

i'm not paying a lot for these and it's more for the experience to see what out there and what i want to use. i just don;t want to turn them into decorations when setting them up.

worst case is a have some nice looking planes and people will think i know what i'm doing! :)

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#9

Re: thank you all

TomD

If they are cheap and in good condition, which is often the case, then I would get them, they are great planes, and maybe they will influence your subsequent purchases in the direction of wooden planes, which is generally a not bad direction.

One thing is that they are planes that use breakers, which is the current trend also.

As I may have mentioned, if the sole is flat the jointer is an excellent plane to have around, wooden jointers are great tools and not too many new ones are made.

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#10

Re: thank you all

TomD

There used to be another German plane company that got rolled into ECE. They made a smoother that had adjustable bed angle, among it's other features. I would have liked to have tried that one...

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#11

Re: thank you all

Joseph Piotrowski

i acquired a few planes now of the ece type thanks to Bruce and ebay :)

. they do get bid up on ebay but they are still 50 pct or cheaper if you watch. still way more expense than the old woodies. but they are beautiful looking planes.

i clearly see they have advanced the wooden plane a great deal from the 1800's.

i still crawling here, learning to sharpen and setup the planes but look forward to when i can do some basic skills. using the wooden planes appeals greatly to me for several reasons. aesthetically of course :) but its much easier for me to tune up a wooden plane. another strong factor is my garage is basically unheated( i'm going to get some heat soon) handling cold metal isn't as nice as grabbing the wood bodies.

lots of playing around for the next month or so but sooner or later i'll be making something with my new skills.

Re: Any Ece Primus plane owners?

#12

Re: thank you all

TomD

I have the cold workshop problem also. Woodies are good for that. There really aren't any downsides, and when you get to more complicated types the wood planes are on the top of the pyramid with no competition.

Proceed as you see fit, but it shouldn't really take more than about 30 minutes to get a functional plane sharp and working. Which isn't a boast, that would be nearer to the fact I can make either the plane or the iron in that time... Just don't let the general preciousness of the field get you down.