New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Steam or wet bending of white oak

Posts

Steam or wet bending of white oak

#1

Steam or wet bending of white oak

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm trimming out the current remodel, which is a room converted, badly, from porch after World War II. There are, of course (as in, old house/of course), slight flooring height differences between the room and the adjacent rooms, and I'm installing white oak thresholds stained and varnished to match or at least be happy with the flooring colors (it's an 1895 house, so I choose details that will look like they fit - exterior thresholds are better than the usual interior stuff for this application), and installed with screws and plugs. The thresholds are roughly 4-1/2" wide, 5/8" at their thickest, tapering off at each side. The adjacent floors are higher than the room's floor, by about 3/8" in both cases (except see below), so I'm putting 3/8" oak reversible base down as a shim on the low side.

One of the adjacent rooms disagrees with the room in question as to what is level, by 1/4" over 32". I'm planing the oak shim and a filler piece to be 3/8" in the room, twisting to "level" with the dining room floor. The threshold will then twist by the same 1/4" over its length. I can try just forcing it down with the screws, but I'm wondering whether I should make things easier (theoretically easier...) by either steaming or soaking the threshold and clamping it in the twisted state while it cools. This would involve making up a form, so there's extra work involved.

I'm sure I'd get some springback, but the screws should take care of that.

If this seems feasible, I've got two choices for heat:

a) I can put it in the hot tub (104 degrees Fahrenheit) for an appropriate period, or

b) I can make up some kind of steam box.

The first choice is much faster, but I don't know how hot water affects white oak and whether it's as effective as steam.

I've never done any steam/hot bending, so I'm approaching this from a state of nearly complete ignorance, and will appreciate advice from the collective wise folk here.

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

#2

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Unless I got lost in the blizzard of numbers you are twisting a 3/8" piece of lumber just a piddly 1/4"? I once took an inch of twist out of a 15/16" table top with a few table top fasteners. I did do it over the course of a month. In your case, just screw it. That is a trivial amount to twist.

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

#3

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'd try what Bill suggests and just give screw it down. If it doesn't work, try the approach that Bill Thomas suggested, just as effective but more work. You can twist the board that much with just hand pressure.

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

#4

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

TomD

Another option would be to kerf the underside of the threshold piece with plunge cuts from a chopsaw, or you can use the wall and a regular skill saw. You get the back of the piece out with rung like cuts, but when it is pressed down you still have solid support from the pieces that remain under the threshold, and you don't have the kerfs showing from the sides.

On the actual question, for future reference, steam is to be preferred. It's a weird world:

1) In theory you shouldn't be able to bend wood by putting it in bath water. What is needed is heat in the steam heat range, penetrating the wood, and softening the lignin. Water won't do that. Dry heat is just as good as wet heat, but dry heat is hard to control without scorching, or cracking the wood, at times. But then lots of people use water to bend stuff. I think what they are doing is softening the fiber in the wood, not the "glue", this is not a great thing, but works in certain situations, the problem is that the weakened fibers may not be able to take much bend. Another problem is that you will have a very wet piece of wood to dry out.

2) In theory you shouldn't be able to steam bend kiln dried wood, though I don't notice it stopping people.

3) As mentioned the ideal is something very hot (or gaseous ammonia), once the pieces get beyond a certain thickness you pretty much need steam.

Instead of a mold you could simply use go-bars to hold the threshold to the floor. To counter springback you could add a couple of shims to raise the ends, and a few to support the quarters, then when it dries you should be able to keep in place by the frames on the sides or some discrete outboard screws or nails.

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

#5

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

Frank House

There should be no problem in hand planing a piece of wood so that the surfaces are out of parallel by a controlled amount.

It is also practical to hand "plane" pieces moderately out of flat, either smoothly curved or "in wind" i.e. twisted (most of us struggle from time to time to avoid doing this).

It can be useful to regard a jack plane as a large spokeshave capable of producing mildly curved surfaces (remember grain direction while working!). A block plane can produce quite steeply curved surfaces. Allow some extra thickness when you start. A cardboard template ot two might help, or just work near where it is to be installed, and keep testing.

Another option would be rasps or shallow gouges, if you have them (or wish to add them to your toolkit), followed by sanding.

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

#6

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

Joe shelton

Tom is correct about the central importance of heat in bending without damage and getting a sufficiently permanent bend. I think he over-emphasizes steam. I regularly bend gunstocks using IR lamps as the heat source, and control the heat distribution with cotton wrap and oil.

Also, Frank has the simple solution: "backing out" the hidden sides of trim is a longstanding technique that lessen any strain on your fasteners.

Hope you'll tell us what you did, after it's done, and how it worked...

Re: Steam or wet bending of white oak

#7

Yes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've been hand planing the stock that will rest under the threshold, and agree that it's easy enough to plane the twist into the stock.