New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

hollow grinding

Posts

Re: hollow grinding

#26

Re: Squareness and Camber

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

Thanks very much for the information on the SE-77!

If anyone else considering, they're $66 + free shipping from Amazon. Didn't find at LV, although they do carry quite a bit of Tormek stuff.

Wiley

Re: hollow grinding

#27

Re: Squareness and Camber

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Yes, If one has a precise square setting on the Tormek.

The new SE-77 Tormek jig will reproduce cambers. (And correct out of squareness.)

I did a little You Tube clip on this. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCQg_yua727tzXh1t6BFLjEQ/feed

However unless there are significant chips in an edge, grinding right to it, uses up more metal than necessary.


Hi David

Just to be clear on this - since I do not recommend that one grind to the edge of a blade if doing so freehand - using the Tormek guide, which is on both my Tormek and my 8" grinder (with the CBN wheel), the grind is dead straight and with a smooth edge. The wire is no more than a wire off a 1000 grit waterstone. It is very fine. The Tormek guide makes this possible. I do not use the 1000 grit stone at this point. It is not necessary. In other words, there is no more loss of steel with this method than if one were honing a secondary bevel with a 1000 stone. Since I freehand, there is possibly less loss than using a honing guide since I do not add a secondary bevel, but hone directly on the hollow.

The other side of the 8" grinder is set up with a 80 grit CBN wheel, and here grinding is freehanded - and slightly short of the edge.

The guide I have is the older SE-76, which has proved to be excellent. I did see your review of the new model, the SE-77, and I may purchase it because of the comprehensive demonstration you did. Good job! I am not sure if I want to use it for cambering - this is so easy to do by hand (yes, I know that you mentioned in the review that the guide makes this replicatable). I like that the bolt at the one side is movable, and the blade is supported more evenly. Again, this is great in theory, but in practice I have not had a problem with a blade grinding out of square.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hollow grinding

#28

Re: Squareness and Camber

David Charlesworth

Derek,

Your set up sounds wonderful!

I do occasionally get minutely out of square results from the excellent SE-76, which mystify me.

Usually I blame heavy handed students who may not have used the wheel surface evenly......

I am very pleased to be able to grind different cambers. It takes me about 60 strokes on an 800g stone to create a modest camber on a new blade.

Best wishes,

David

Re: hollow grinding

#29

Re: Squareness and Camber

Chuck Bjorgen

David and Derek -- In addition to the cambering feature on the SE-77 Tormek jig, I've learned that the ability to slide the left hand knob over to meet the left edge of the blade to be sharpened is a big improvement. I've always believed that over tightening the left knob on the SE-76 (and previous models) was the cause of skewed blades, particularly on narrow chisels. Even now, though, I keep a couple small machinest's squares handy to check my progress.

I've used the cambering feature on a couple of no. 5 Stanleys and it works fine but one does lose the "square edge" feature to camber. Nevertheless I'm a believer in this jig on my nearly 20-year-old green Tormek.

Re: hollow grinding

#30

Re: Squareness and Camber

TomD

You make a sound point about jigs Derek, but this is the hand tool forum (where jigs are totally fair play, planes are jigs) where hand skills are an objective. Putting a square on the end of a piece of steel is like the thing you learn in the first few seconds of using a grinder. So it should not be a concern freehand either. For on thing, if you know how to float the bevel it is the bevel that is guiding, not the edge. so grinding past the edge is not a big deal. I think the main issue I had was that I didn't want to waste material, which I never have. If one makes tools, or just welds stuff together that needs prep on a grinder, it is child's play to learn square. As Frank Klausz said "unless you are very beginner" you can saw the square cuts on the tails without any marks. But I can see that people don't want to mess around with the necessary practice on expensive tools.

Re: hollow grinding

#31

Re:Camber

TomD

How fine can one go with the camber on that jig. Jack type camber is no biggie by hand. But Odate went down that sensible wormhole of trying to grind in a few thou, as one would want for finishing, but the comitement was more than I was prepared for.

The thing with all these training wheels are that 70 bucks is not so bad, but piece by piece you are spending what a non-crap grinder would cost on something that is so crap it needs multiple training wheels. It is like going to some non-handtool forum and hearing how this guy needs a Shopbot so he can put an edge on a 6 foot board, and you are sitting there screaming at the computer, "get a handplane".

Re: hollow grinding

#32

Re: Squareness and Camber

TomD

I'm not worried about "wasting metal". My thought on that is that generally I am not using this approach on masterpiece tools, in the old days if I chipped my Japanese tools it was penance on the 600 grit. But these days I would cut it out on the 2x72. That said, I hand sharpen Japanese tools almost exclusively. Anything else is just a commodity, and I can easily make something like a plane blade, out of O1 that I keep around. This is basic stuff not all that clever. So I have the luxury of blowing it out if I want to. I don't waste material because that is not what I want, but I don't baby it. The point of power is power.

When I started out buying my stuff in the 70s there just wasn't good stuff available. I think as late as the 90s I emailed Leonard Lee and said that they didn't have a pro saw, chisel, or plane in the place, to which he answered with the polite versions of "we are already on it". So I bought what I could and I have multiples of everything, as better stuff became available. You don't need to do that today, but people often buy multiples anyway out of curiosity.

What comes next is one to two sets of everything from within what my dad accumulated. The boomers are next, and that is going to be one heck of an estate sale. The younger kids may or not decide to give up manscapping and twiter for woodworking, but it isn't looking too convincing. I think we will be knee deep in tools, and the quaint idea of waste will be the least of our concerns.

Re: hollow grinding

#33

followup

Bruce Mack

I got the white J grade wheel on Friday. As Bill said, it's a little too hard but it's what the supplier had. I put the tool rests and spark suppressors on the DeWalt grinder and bolted it to a sturdy wooden table already holding my disc sander. The new wheel had considerable run out which I first attributed to the plastic bushings no matter how I rotated them. Consequently the tool rest and indeed the whole table vibrated. The vibration continued after I used the Norton silicon carbide stone conditioner, and even after I removed the white wheel and replaced the original wheel. I conclude that my initial impression of acceptable vibration stemmed from my assessment before I secured the grinder to the table. There must be a harmonic resonance now. I can't say if the wobble is from the motor or the flange/washer assembly, but I'm not inclined to pursue this. I'll return the grinder on Monday and think about the replacement because despite all the above I successfully reground an old chisel and reduced the angle from ~30 to 25 degrees. As you all assured me, the hollow made hand sharpening a cinch!

Re: hollow grinding

#34

Glad to here your success story

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think more people would hollow grind if they knew how easy it is to learn. Frequent dressing of your wheel will compensate for the harder bond. The idea is to expose sharp grits. Sharp grits mill shavings. The shavings take heat away with them (known as sparks!).

Dull grits plow across the tool creating heat that is not carried away by the milled chip.

Re: hollow grinding

#35

Try this....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

On an inexpensive grinder I bought some time ago I had to put a rubber piece between the grinder and steel table to reduce vibration. If your grinder was a bargain see if you can dampen the vibration to make it useful.

Re: hollow grinding

#36

Balance the wheels.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

Try this before returning the grinder ...

Make a pencil mark on the outside edge of the washer and a corresponding line on the wheel. Then rotate the wheel about 10 degrees, and start up the grinder. Does the vibration increase or decrease? Repeat this until you get the minimum vibration.

Of course, some grinders are not going to improve as the spindle is off centre, not then wheel.

The CBN wheels are all individually balanced at the factory, and spin without vibration. My wheels take over 8 minutes to come to a stop after switch off.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hollow grinding

#37

one other thing

Bruce Mack

I have a spare anti-fatigue mat I can cut to size if needed. However as the plastic reducing bushings that come with the wheel (Norton, but I expect the same is true with all brands) are shoddy, I have ordered 2 press-fit drill bushings I.D. 1/2" and O.D. 1" to replace them, hoping this will reduce the wobble. I will also try Derek's suggestion of incremental rotation.

Re: hollow grinding

#38

Re: Why not to grind to the edge

Charlie

Bill is right.

You get the edge to the shape you want on stones (chisel, plane iron, etc.) and then grind back behind that shaped edge never destroying it, never grinding up to it unless it's hopelessly snicked. It's much easier to finesse a shape on stones -- just that right amount of curve, etc. than on a grinder. And once done, never need be done again unless the edge gets a profound amount of damage from something. Of course afterwards the shape is maintained when honing (or even slightly adjusted as necessary), which is when freehand honing pays its dividends.

Re: hollow grinding

#39

Re: Why not to grind to the edge

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I'd like to comment on one aspect of Derek's method (and maybe GolfSteve's) of grinding to a new edge: when this is done, the lower wear bevel is 100% removed. For sure. Which to me is crucial. And I agree with Derek you can then go straight to a fine stone, and without worrying whether you're leaving traces of the wear bevel by going too fine too soon.

However, equally good arguments have been made on the other side, so I don't think there is a One True Way :) . It's all good.

Indeed, some strive for a dead flat bevel (no grinding), and they're right too. There are Japanese carpenters who will grade your skill quickly by how flat your bevels are.

Hmmm, what was my point now :) ?

Wiley

Re: hollow grinding

#40

Re: Antivibration mats *LINK*

Hank Knight

This stuff works great. I had a little vibration with my bench grinder that was troublesome. I put a piece of this antivibration mat under the base of the machine and it dampened the vibration completely. The grinder runs smooh as silk now and the vibration doesnt "print out" in the grind like it did before the mat.


Antivibration mat

Re: hollow grinding

#41

Re: Another source

William Duffield

Mouse pads also work. Back in the good old days, they used to make them from wet suit material. So, a search for these alternates might save you some money. I also use pads under my scroll saw and belt sander.

Re: hollow grinding

#42

the best I could do....

Bruce Mack

With the steel hubs and a set of aftermarket flanges, and incremental rotation, and a piece of anti-fatigue mat, the vibration is a lot better but not eliminated. The tools on the lower shelf of the table don't shimmy, and I don't flinch. I expected too much precision from a 24 pound machine spinning a disc of compressed sand. I'm happy with the results and will use it on all my plane irons. Thanks everyone.

Re: hollow grinding

#43

The importance of "good enough"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the end it seems you have accommodated the important lesson of "good enough", a valuable concept for those motivated to get on with building something. There is little in my shop that is perfect, myself being the prime example. But I have come to live with it in the interest of doing something.

Re: hollow grinding

#44

Re: Balance the wheels. - Oneway

TomD

I have the oneway wheel balancer, it allow you to balance a wheel in a similar way that car wheels are balanced. It seems like overkill in the while I have had, it, but that might be because I used it on my 1800 rpm unit which has heavier wheels but 1/4th the speed related energy.