New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

hollow grinding

Posts

hollow grinding

#1

hollow grinding

Bruce Mack

I just purchased a DeWalt 6 inch grinder and ran it to see there was no excessive vibration. It's good, so the next purchase will be the CBN wheel from Tools for Working Wood. I've read the 2008 article on grinding by Joel Moskowitz (FWW) and just watched a good video with Garrett Hack. Problem, of course, is I've never done it myself. I have a couple of chisels I'm willing to sacrifice, but I like my plane irons too much to ruin them. Garrett free-hands a sweet hollow on a plane iron. I'm thinking I'd rather apply a thin wooden edge transversely on the face of the iron with tape, to act as a guide bar on my to and fro sweep. I'll be $200+ into this with the grinder and the wheel and would rather not buy a Veritas grinding jig right now, but maybe I'm too cheap and the jig is the right tool. Your thoughts? Thanks.

Re: hollow grinding

#2

Re: hollow grinding *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

I have also left information on Joel's blog as below.

I posted information about CBN wheels for flat woodworkers on my website about 18 months ago. My curiosity about CBN was sparked by turners, who have been using these wheels for yonks, and so I was puzzled that I had not read anything in this area by flat woodworkers. This turned to amazement when I took the plunge and purchased a wheel. I wrote the article on my website (link below) because I consider that these wheels are a complete game changer.

The grit I recommend is 180 for general use. One can add a 80 grit if doing much restoration grinding. The higher grit wheels (250 and 350) are for turners.

The hollow grinds created by the CBN wheel are uniform and smooth, and the coolness which which it runs enables grinding close to the edge of the blade (it rarely gets hotter than warm). This clean hollow facilitates easy and quick (freehand) sharpening. I have often argued that the best sharpening system begins with a hollow grind that maximises all that follows. CBN really delivers here. Further, the wheels last nearly forever (I know some that are going for 20 years), and require minimal upkeep. They do not require dressing, so settings do not alter.

The wheels may be used for all hardened steel. I have used them, without any signs of loading, on O1, A2, PM-V11, M2, M4, D2 and CPM-3V.

I like the idea of the crowned wheels sold by Joel at TFWW. These were not available when I purchased mine, which are square/straight. My set up combines the guide from the Tormek, which favours the flat wheel (care needed to set it up accurately), as well as freehand grinding (where the crowned wheels are preferred).


Regards from Perth

Derek


The Ultimate Grinding-Sharpening Set Up?

Re: hollow grinding

#3

Re: hollow grinding

Bruce Mack

Thanks Derek. Your article introduced me to CBN. Joel's wheels are 60 and 80 grit. Do you think the 80 too aggressive for touch-up sharpening? The price is attractive.

Re: hollow grinding

#4

Re: hollow grinding

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

80 grit is not too coarse, however one of the advantages of CBN is that you can grind cool on a higher grit. I grind to the edge of the blade, raising a very fine wire edge (about as much as I would off a 1000 grit waterstone - essentially, the CBN is replacing the 1000 stone at this stage). It is possible to create a microbevel using a 6000 grit stone and then go on to a 13000. The higher grit CBN makes this easier to do, since the surface/edge it leaves is lower in serrations than off a 80 grit.

This is the same strategy I used with the Tormek (which I would maintain at 220 grit), and I have not experienced an edge chipping in the 10 years since I bought that grinder. The heat from a white wheel, even on a half-speed grinder, forced a different strategy, which was stopping a few mm short of the edge.

If you are disinclined to grind this far, stopping short of the edge, then the 80 grit will be fine.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hollow grinding

#5

Re: hollow grinding

GolfSteve in Calgary

Bruce, Derek mentioned a crowned wheel. The crown is essential for easy freehand grinding. Like fettling your planes or tuning up your tablesaw, there are two things I feel are necessary for easy, stressless freehand grinding:

1. You need a decent tool rest. Many of the better grinders come with a decent tool rest (eg. my 8 or 10" delta grinder), but some of them are junk. The rest should be smooth - so that that tool slides along the rest, it should be parallel and square to the wheel. Personally I recommend a Wolverine tool rest, but I've used lots of grinders with the stock rest.

I used the Veritas (aluminum) rest years ago, but it was not very good. It flexes too much, the aluminum is sticky, and the 90 degree doohickey had too much slop in it, and getting the rest adjusted to exactly 90 degrees to the wheel is frustrating.

2. You need to put a slight crown (concave profile) on the wheel - not very much of a crown; about 0.5 mm - what you want is your iron to only touch the centre half of the wheel's width.

Without the crown - i.e., with a flat wheel, you must align the iron at exactly 90 degrees to the wheel in order to grind a the iron square, and it is easy to dig the corners of you iron into the wheel, overheating those corners.

However, with a crown, you can bring the iron onto a wheel at a slight angle, and slide the iron from side to side, and you carefully grind the iron square. Note that I said you grind the iron square. Because you can bring the iron in at a slight angle, you can choose how much you grind in which areas in order to end up with a square iron. It's very easy.

The grinding method I was taught by Rob Cosman:

1. Crown the grinding wheel.

2. Relax.

3. Relax again; this should not be stressful.

4. Place the iron on the rest, and slowly slide the iron forward until the centre of the iron contacts the wheel.

5. Slide the iron to the right until the iron stops grinding. Careful to not overheat the corner. Retract the iron away from the wheel as you approach the corner of the iron.

6. Bring the iron back onto the tool rest, and slide forward so that the centre of the iron contacts the wheel again. Slide to the left this time.

... by making the initial contact between the wheel and the iron at the centre of the iron, you minimize the tendency to overheat the exposed corner of the iron. Overheating is easy to do if you start grinding at one corner and proceed to the other corner...

7. Slide back and forth a few times, then check that you are grinding square. Selectively grind more where required.

8. If the iron gets too hot to touch near the cutting surface, back off and let it cool.

9. Use light pressure and relax.

Hollow grinding is so easy using this method that I will re-grind an iron every 2 or 3 sharpenings, as a fresh hollow grind makes freehand sharpening a breeze.

I would try this method with your existing wheel before buying any more stuff. Personally I would spend the money on a better tool rest rather than the fancy wheel.

Re: hollow grinding

#6

Agree with every detail

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have about 10 years experience hollow grinding chisels and plane blades on an aluminum oxide wheel of proper hardness. I have successfully taught many to do it and it takes just a few minutes to do so. Everyone has been successful.

I agree with everything said, especially the rest. I too use the Wolverine. The LV is too wiggly. You must have a good rest for this task. When I teach grinding I refer to the procedure as "touch and go" like practice landings on an airfield.

What do you hope to improve by buying the expensive wheel, as opposed to a $30 aluminum oxide wheel? Personally, I don't think the benefits to me are worth the extra expense.

Re: hollow grinding

#7

Re: hollow grinding

Bruce Mack

Thank you again Derek. Steve - you are a teacher. I printed your response to take to the shop with me. Bill - I thought the CBN would be least likely to burn my blades, given my status as a first-time driver, but I will first use the wheel(s) that came with the grinder. I have 3 unprepped Aldi chisels to try first.

Re: hollow grinding

#8

Re: hollow grinding

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The wheel that came with your grinder may be useless for this task. I have an Article in the Articles section on grinder wheel selection. Of upmost importance, the wheel must have a soft bond to mitigate heating.

Using the proper wheel I grind on a 7" grinder at 3400 rpm 120 grit wheel with no danger of burning, in my hands. Technique and wheel selection is the key to not heating.

Re: hollow grinding

#9

Not a bad video

GolfSteve in Calgary

Not a bad video. He uses the Veritas rest, and I don't get the iron so hot that I need to dip in water.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GB-Pa73Snp4

Another tip is that when you have ground to a wire edge, the sparks start to fly over the top of the iron instead of under the iron. That's when you know you're done grinding.

Re: hollow grinding

#10

Why not to grind to the edge

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I never get close to burning so this problem is never a concern. What is a concern is winding up with an edge that is either not straight or not 90 degrees to the side. Once I get the edge straight and 90 I don't want to risk getting it otherwise for it takes a lot of screwing around to fix. Hence I never grind to the edge. I want to preserve the original edge going into the edge refining step with a finer, and slower, grit/abrasive format.

Re: hollow grinding

#11

Re: Why not to grind to the edge

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, grinding to the edge is very doable on the Tormek because the blade rides in a guide. This ensures a straight edge. The is no need for a coarse stone to first straighten the edge before proceeding to higher grits.

I use the same Tormek guide on my 8" grinder. This has the added benefit of a 180 grit CBN wheel. The result is a straight and fine hollow.

This is a PM-V11 chisel blade straight off the grinder ..


This is the edge after an Ultra Fine Spyderco ...


That edge will not require another grind for many sharpenings. I hone directly on the hollow, and the microbevel is so small that one can work directly with higher grits.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hollow grinding

#12

Those more frugal.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

......will find that any grinder and an appropriate wheel and a stable purchased or home made rest will suffice for hollow grinding if you don't grind to the edge. Grinding just short of the edge hardly slows the following step. That said if I had the equipment to reliably grind away the edge I might do so.

The secret to it all is a LIGHT touch. I barely touch the wheel when grinding. Even with this light touch my worry is taking off too much stuff, not overheating.

Re: hollow grinding

#13

Re: Agree with every detail

TomD

An undeniable advantage would be less airborn stone dust. Cooler grinding is not necessary if you know what you are doing, but if you have the cash, why not? The ability to grind carbide, if they will do it is worthwhile in a life in a shop.

Re: hollow grinding

#14

Re: hollow grinding

TomD

Technique and maybe grinder selection is the key to not heating. I use both 3600 at my dad's and 1750 x 8 in my shop for over 30 years. I use soft, original, whatever, never a problem. If I will need to grind where I think burning is a problem, because it isn't normally, I do the following: I don't wear gloves for safety and because I can feel the heat coming on. I keep a little water handy, and dip the tool in it so a film is visible. I grind until the film is gone. If you have a feel for it you can grind a little longer. When the film is gone I dip and repeat. Eventually a large tool with a lot of work to be done may get hot, I dip it and put it aside. And grind something else. For regular sharpening you will only need to dip a time or two. Any sensible person can't burn the most fragile tool doing this.

You don't need a crowned wheel for freehand, used flat wheels and freehand for 30 some years. Used teh Raffan technique. He stacked two fingers on top of those useless little rests that come on the grinder, pivot tool over that. Like woodturning in reverse.

If you want to spend money on a pro level tool get a 2x72 belt grinder and quit playing at it. Solves all problems.

Re: hollow grinding

#15

Re: Those more frugal.....

TomD

I think you can grind super accurately if you just try. I agree with a light touch at times, the basic skill is to have the edge engaged and floating on the stone with full speed running under it. Then apply whatever power. What you don't want is to stab away at it. You need reference, and the reference is the tool floating on the wheel. I just eyeball square. It is like any other hand tool thing, you can't do it unless you try. Training wheels are for kid's bikes. Grinding precision stuff like planer blades and endmills is probably mostly a machine thing. But plain bevels, even drills are a freehand thing. Look at good knife work, this stuff we do is child's play. If you want to learn to grind learn how knifemakers do it. There are some good videos on youtube, but a lot of the seminal stuff is now buried years back. I noticed going through this time some interesting work done in home shops to make specilized cutlery factory tools, so the amateurs are moving through, or even jumping the base skills.

When I have a blank, the first thing I do is burn on half the flat. Then I float it and check for square. The I square it by eye, and check it. If it needs a slight correction that goes in. Then I push for the bevel angle, check it, correct it if required. Then I blow off the rest of the material to 1/16th and a piece is ready for the forge.

It is like a lot of other stuff, if you don't take a firm cut you don't get engaged and you get worse accuracy. In wood turning it is a lot easier to swoop a clean medium cut, that just picking at the surface.

Of course for a slight edge refresh, you scale back most of these steps.

Re: hollow grinding

#16

Re: MRIs

TomD

If you grind steel, you either need extreme protections, or you need an x-ray prior to an MRI. You can't always tell you have metal in your eye, it may be very painful, or it might just feel like a little grit. You can deny you grind metal and take your chances.

Re: hollow grinding

#17

Re: Those more frugal.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

......will find that any grinder and an appropriate wheel and a stable purchased or home made rest will suffice for hollow grinding if you don't grind to the edge. Grinding just short of the edge hardly slows the following step. That said if I had the equipment to reliably grind away the edge I might do so.

The secret to it all is a LIGHT touch. I barely touch the wheel when grinding. Even with this light touch my worry is taking off too much stuff, not overheating.

I agree Bill. Over the years, before I could afford a Tormek, I'd tried them all - belt sanders, high- and half speed grinders, wet grinders, hand powered grinder, and no grinder. I think that it is essential that one learns to freehand everything and anything. I now use both, freehand and a jig, because I can with the first and because the second is even better.

But it must be said, hollow grinding can be done very successfully with rudimentary equipment. Just learn to use it. A light touch above all else.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hollow grinding

#18

Squareness and Camber

David Charlesworth

Squareness and camber are both lost if one grinds to or beyond the edge.

Renewing these can be laborious, and are not necessary if one leaves a sliver of the previous honing.

The only reason I can see for grinding past an edge would be a large chip, which I hope happens very infrequently in the furniture making workshop!

best wishes,

David

Re: hollow grinding

#19

Re: Those more frugal.....

Bruce Mack

All this good stuff and me without my white aluminum oxide wheel. It arrives on Monday. I'm going cheap to start.

Re: hollow grinding

#20

Re: Those more frugal.....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've had a white aluminum stone, 120 grit, on my 3450 grinder for about 30 years. Works fine for me. Not buying something new all the time works even better.

Re: hollow grinding

#21

Re: Squareness and Camber

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Squareness and camber are both lost if one grinds to or beyond the edge.

David, not if using the Tormek. Freehanding .. yes, I agree.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: hollow grinding

#22

White is meaningless

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is critical is the bond hardness not the stone color. I have a white wheel that even I can't successfully grind on without burning. It is too hard.

Maybe you lucked out and got a soft bond wheel.

Re: hollow grinding

#23

Re: White is meaningless

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't know if it's hard or soft bond, but it has taught me to use a light touch and watch the heat of the blade.

Re: hollow grinding

#24

Easy to know if the label is intact

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For example on a wheel I grabbed from my shelf the label says:

32A-46-KVBE

The particle composition is 32A, an aluminum oxide

The particle size is 46 grit

The bonding material is KVBE. The "K" is the bond hardness. K is moderately hard. This wheel will hold its shape well but not readily shed grits to expose new fresh cutting surfaces. For plane blade grinding I prefer an "H" or "J" bond. I don't know what the "VBE" stands for.

One can compensate for a too hard bond by frequent wheel dressing.

Re: hollow grinding

#25

Re: Squareness and Camber

David Charlesworth

Yes, If one has a precise square setting on the Tormek.

The new SE-77 Tormek jig will reproduce cambers. (And correct out of squareness.)

I did a little You Tube clip on this. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCQg_yua727tzXh1t6BFLjEQ/feed

However unless there are significant chips in an edge, grinding right to it, uses up more metal than necessary.

best wishes,

David