Re: Why the other way might make sense
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
In that case, maybe we should try to convince Rob Lee to manufacture a dual gauge with real knives instead of wheels. 
Hi William
I have the Veritas dual gauge. The way I use it is as a dual single gauge. That is, I score one line, then score the other - not both at the same time. The wheel gauges are excellent across the grain, but leave a fine and rather faint line on end grain hardwood. They may do better on softwood, but I do not work with it much.
The best gauge I have used is a Kinshiro (which was a kind gift from Wiley several years ago) ..

(Kinshiro on the right)
You can see the opposing bevels. This gauge cuts a thin, deep line.
The downside of the Kinshiro is that it is difficult to adjust for a matching offset mortice. The blades cannot be secured while the fence is moved.
The Veritas dual gauge is capable of doing this ... but the lines are too faint in the hardwoods I use. I think that the pin type gauges are actually better for this task.
To overcome this, I built a mortice gauge that uses knives (with opposing bevels) along the lines of a Kinshiro, but where the fence could be moved without losing a setting. The basis of this was a set of fixed knives that could be changed for a specific mortice chisel (1/4", 5/16", 3/8").

The knives sit in a cassette like this ...

Do you like I could interest Lee Valley in this? 
The necessity for deep gauge lines is much less if you are using hard, even grained woods, but with something soft like walnut (or pine
), it becomes more important. Not all Oz woods are as well behaved as your jarrah or other eucalypts. I'm sure you've worked with she oak and silky oak, with their drastic density differences.
I am not following you .. since that is the opposite to what I experience. The woods I use are hard: Jarrah is hard (and some examples are harder than others) and She-Oak is harder still. The wheel gauge lines hardly show up on the endgrain. A cutting gauge is essential.
Regards from Perth
Derek